• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Search results for query: *

  1. Foneybone1

    The Ultimate Annihilator Revision Part 1

    Siiiiiiiiiiiiigh Well...he's not wearing the suit before entering the zone, is wearing it in the zone, and isn't when he leaves. Unless you're asking for specific scans of him actively putting on and taking off the suit, as if that's necessary for the story to convey that the suit he's wearing...
  2. Foneybone1

    The Ultimate Annihilator Revision Part 1

    Sonic's change in personality in issue 52 is likely a result of the suit he follows into the other zone and wore while there. Considering Knothole's temporal zone only encompasses the city, and Rotor's statement about the annihilator creating zones immediately follows talking about it, he's...
  3. Foneybone1

    So...Any Back to the Future fans?...

    Not sure if I'm allowed to shameless plug a game like this, but a guy I know made/is still making a game inspired by BTTF. He also has a discord if anyone wants to make suggestions or keep up with development.
  4. Foneybone1

    Thoughts about The Writer

    A beastiamorph could did beat The Writer.
  5. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    Well I forgot to post this like a week ago. First, putting responses inside quotes is confusing. I meant 236. Sonic and Sally fight in Furville and it's witnessed by the public, ergo 236 not 234. I don't understand why you brought up Sonic 06 when talking about Archie Silver. I ironically...
  6. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic revisions that should have gone through a year ago.

    I'd say leave it open for now, if Shake wants to move it elsewere then we can, but if he wants to just continue it here then we'll just keep it here.
  7. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic revisions that should have gone through a year ago.

    The main conversation atm is mostly just between me and Shake, but he can't respond right away due to college. Due to the size of the OP I didn't want to contact staff until a consensus or impasse was reached. I think, for now at least, it can remain as is.
  8. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic revisions that should have gone through a year ago.

    They appear to only use the green emeralds to transform, and the encyclopedia words it as if they lost their secondary effects after being combined. Even if they did use all 7 colors though, it wouldn't have any bearing on the ones Feist made.
  9. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic revisions that should have gone through a year ago.

    bump
  10. Foneybone1

    The most controversial fight has finally reached a conclusion (kind of). Goku vs. Superman (3-15-50).

    Who's faster? I know speed is equalized, I'm just curious.
  11. Foneybone1

    The most controversial fight has finally reached a conclusion (kind of). Goku vs. Superman (3-15-50).

    Is it 60 votes just for incon? I thought that was all three together. ßÂ░ßÁÿßÁù╦ó
  12. Foneybone1

    The most controversial fight has finally reached a conclusion (kind of). Goku vs. Superman (3-15-50).

    I see Supes winning, so I'll vote him. but really I just wanna add to the total vote count
  13. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    My stance is that there is potential evidence that the ring aura is what revived him in issue 50, but there is also evidence that it wasn't necessarily. The OP mostly goes over information told in the comic and encyclopedia that opens up the possibility that Sonic returned from EE the same as...
  14. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    gosh l hope this is formatted right Well, if the consensus is that we are ignoring the Sonic 06 adaptation that has no proof it follows the game events to a tie, I'll move on. Could you elaborate on this? 06 happened, and it happens the way the encyclopedia says, it just retcons itself. It...
  15. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    Okay, this is a lot, but it's time travel so it's complicated. There are four versions of the prime timeline. There's one where Silver never appears in the past, the Freedom Fighters are defeated, and the future is in ruin. When Silver goes back in time for the first time to fix the future, he...
  16. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    Saying that we aren't told Mephelis didn't do the specific thing he needs to do for type 8 to still work, so he definitely could have done it to dismiss what we are told is confirmation bias. (it may also be a self-fulfilling prophecy but I'm not sure) With that same logic, one could make the...
  17. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    yeah, it was crossed out to show it didn't need to be responded to, I just found it funny, that I ended up being correct that my intention would be misconstrued The bigger offense is when Medeus asked what was being proposed, instead of stating your own side of the argument, you attempted to...
  18. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    I'm pretty sure Sonic needing outside assistance to be revived does disprove type 8. Who knew me saying "at risk of coming across as dismissing criticism," would be so relevant? I attempted to change the subject, like I said, to the more prevalent topic. Establishing type 8 in the first place...
  19. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    Where Foney? Where where where where? Are you getting this information? Because the encyclopedia details nothing about Sonic's death. Did you read the rest of that paragraph? Also no, I literaly just explained how I did not give up, go back and read my old reply.
  20. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    You didn't disprove Mephelis, him killing Sonic does work as evidence against type 8. We are given enough details with just the encyclopedia to say Sonic's ring aura didn't revive him. They needed the Chaos Emeralds, if you want to argue that it doesn't specificaly say they used the emeralds...
  21. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    No, you have presented arguments. I could just as easily say I countered all of your arguments; you repeating yourself doesn't mean anything when I've also been repeating myself.
  22. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    No, this should not be closed, we haven't reached any kind of consensus. Cal being the only staff in support doesn't matter when Medeus is the only staff opposed.
  23. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    Can you stop trying to interpret what I'm saying? You are falsely assuming the meaning behind my words and I'm getting tired of telling you "no no no, that's not what I said." You do know that's why I'm asking questions right? I'm not declaring that what I say is what your saying, I'm asking if...
  24. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    Since I just noticed this, Medeus was told all my points were countered with two being said to have been proven false. This is disingenuous as we both presented our ideas and support and neither yielded after much back and forth; all of our points are still relevant.
  25. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    So with no explanation or visual indicator, the reader is supposed to determine that instead of just sending Sonic to the in-between zone directly the way the story implies, the device interfeared with Sonic's ring aura, which at this point can't even pretend to have revival properties? Two...
  26. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    How do you agree that the device sent Sonic to the in-between zone but also say it couldn't have saved Sonic by happenstance?
  27. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    Are you saying the ring aura brought him to some other place/dimention/zone before returning him to Mobius in issue 50? I can't figure out how you believe both of the quoted staements to be true. If you believe you've already answered this I apologize, but can you please answer the question...
  28. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    The walkers brought him into their zone to test him and sent him back, that isn't evidence that the ring can send Sonic between dimentions on its own.
  29. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    These statements are incongruous: "I do agree the device sent Sonic in-between zone" "I don't agree the device had the ability to be the thing responsible of saving Sonic" So again, how is it able to do the former but not the latter?
  30. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    Not very well or else I wouldn't be asking, but how about a different question. How did Sonic get to the in-between zone?
  31. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    How is the device responsible for sending Sonic to the in-between zone but not also able to have saved him?
  32. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    Should we wait for Cal to give his thoughts? At risk of putting words in his mouth, he doesn't seem to agree.
  33. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    I don't think Sonic wasn't hit by the SWATbots, I just don't think he was vaporized by them, he's survived much worse than SWATbots. I agree that it looks like he was vaporized, but like the Superman clip, that's the point. It's supposed to make the reader think the hero's been defeated.
  34. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    My argument isn't that the SWATbots are what sent Sonic to the in-between zone, it's that the human's device, which teleports things through the in-between zone, sent Sonic there when it created the link between their dimentions. Sonic being revived into the in-between zone is inconsistant with...
  35. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    They're pulled through a portal at a point. The device "created a link between dimensions" and Sonic ends up between those dimensions. It makes infinitely more sense for the device to have sent him there than a power that may or may not exist and wasn't even possibly introduced until half a year...
  36. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    How on earth am I being a hypocrite? You're choosing to believe Sonic wasn't teleported by the device because we aren't explicitly told that while also choosing to believe type 8 when we aren't explicitly told that either. In both Sonic Live and issue 50, we're given an explanation for what...
  37. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    We're told that a device is randomly teleporting people through dimensions and Sonic ends up in the same place those teleported things go through. Occam's Razor definitely favors Sonic being sent there by the device over applying an ability that, in addition to also going against Occam's...
  38. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    Are you serious? It's just a coincidence that instead of returning to where he was like in 50, Sonic got sent to the same in-between zone that the human's device was creating portals through? Why does the comic need to explicitly say that the device was the reason he was sent to the in-between...
  39. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    It is a place, a place he was sent when the human's device started making random portals due to an electrical storm.
  40. Foneybone1

    Archie Sonic's Immortality Discussion

    I have already told and showed you that Sonic was teleported by the human's unnamed device. Stop using that quote saying he was vaporized, I have said multiple times that that is from the Sonic News Network not an official source.
Back
Top