• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Punches PC

Betcha feel real dumb right about now!
tiUKLP.gif
 
I disagree with scaling intelligence the way OP proposes. Being really good at a bunch of things doesn't mean you can't be outwitted or outdone and X managing to out-hack Ciel doesn't necessarily mean he's comparable in every realm, especially if he doesn't have any EG feats of his own. Same goes for the second guy, you can be equally skillful and competitive without being equally intelligent in every field, and you can trick someone who's smarter than you. Gate's EG seems fine. Similarly I disagree with the stuff that's already being rejected.

I was asked to comment here but that's the point of contention? Judging by the OP seems like everything has enough votes one way or the other.
 
I disagree with scaling intelligence the way OP proposes. Being really good at a bunch of things doesn't mean you can't be outwitted or outdone and X managing to out-hack Ciel doesn't necessarily mean he's comparable in every realm, especially if he doesn't have any EG feats of his own.
X has E.G stuff like being the best Hunter, figuring out how to use the Z-Buster to amp his X-Buster despite it being unanalyzable tech to Gate and basically everyone else (except Ciel), etc.
Same goes for the second guy, you can be equally skillful and competitive without being equally intelligent in every field, and you can trick someone who's smarter than you.
So, only baseline Genius lvl for Axl?
Gate's EG seems fine. Similarly I disagree with the stuff that's already being rejected.
Mind elaborating on why you disagree?
I was asked to comment here but that's the point of contention? Judging by the OP seems like everything has enough votes one way or the other.
Yeah, if the supporters wanna add the abilities, they can.
 
X has E.G stuff like being the best Hunter, figuring out how to use the Z-Buster to amp his X-Buster despite it being unanalyzable tech to Gate and basically everyone else (except Ciel), etc.
I don't really think so. X incorporating the Z-Buster isn't really treated as an intelligence feat, he just pops that on, and being the best maverick hunter isn't necessarily a raw intelligence thing.
So, only baseline Genius lvl for Axl?
I think that's just gifted.
Mind elaborating on why you disagree?
Not really, I just don't really have an input against the current rejections. If you prefer you can list me as neutral I just wanted to make it clear I wasn't approving it.
 
I don't really think so. X incorporating the Z-Buster isn't really treated as an intelligence feat, he just pops that on, and being the best maverick hunter isn't necessarily a raw intelligence thing.
X should be E.G too for the same reason as Zero. since he's using Zero's arm parts to upgrade his own Buster (without a capsule to do any installing for him even), just like Zero upgrading himself w/ the X-Buster.
I think that's just gifted.
"Gifted" is kinda downplay tbh. Axl fights dudes on his lvl or even stronger, plus way more experienced (Red, Sigma, Colonel Redips, etc.) just fine
Not really, I just don't really have an input against the current rejections. If you prefer you can list me as neutral I just wanted to make it clear I wasn't approving it.
Alr
 
X should be E.G too for the same reason as Zero. since he's using Zero's arm parts to upgrade his own Buster (without a capsule to do any installing for him even), just like Zero upgrading himself w/ the X-Buster.
I think that's pretty flimsy reasoning. Being able to tinker with existing tech isn't necessarily EG or even Genius even if it's advanced tech. If you wanna say Genius maybe even though it's kind of a stretch but it's nowhere near EH.
"Gifted" is kinda downplay tbh. Axl fights dudes on his lvl or even stronger, plus way more experienced (Red, Sigma, Colonel Redips, etc.) just fine
Combat skill and intellect aren't directly related. We have plenty of super skilled characters rated way below genius.
 
Back
Top