There’s not proof that all Nature energy is the same either.
but considering how we’re told that the Shinju absorb the unique biology to further evolve an Otsutsuki you can definitely make the case that each planet shouldn’t be automatically “evolving” ones chakra in the exact same way.
Bro nature energy is nature energy.
Are we now creating a difference that doesn't exist anywhere in the manga?
The Rinnegan were called the eyes of the Six Paths by Shinobi that were unfamiliar with Otsutsuki lore
The Rinnegan was called "eye of the six paths" by Ma and Pa who are very familiar with Otsutsuki lore from the Great Toad Sage who was close to Hagoromo.
.
Realistically they are a mutated eye that they develop in the process of evolution after eating Shinju.
We know this bc we see the Rinnegan patterns on each Shinju we’ve see and have seen the Rinnegan on pretty much every Otsutsuki we’ve seen.
The Rinnegan is the biological eye of the Ten Tails fueled by its chakra. When the Juubi's chakra was separated from its body, the rinnegan disappeared and it became the empty husk "Gedo Mazo"
The Otsutsuki inherit the rinnegan by consuming a chakra fruit which contains the genetic info and chakra of the ten tails as well
The idea that Chakra Fruits take in the biological information of the planet they’re on isn’t fan theory.
If every planet has different Biology then naturally its contents will differ.
And if its contents differ then it’s easier to argue that it shouldn’t automatically birth the same abilities.
No. You see how we have to keep on making up stuff. There is nowhere in the manga that states different content means different abilities.
The different abilities (shinjutsu) is a function of the Otsutsuki evolution which is a ladder towards godhood and culminates in the Otsutsuki having the same set of Shinjutsu once they reach godhood.
Shibai didn't consume the same genetic info in his chakra fruits, yet has the same set of shinjutsu the other Otsutsuki have achieved.
You'll need explicit statements to make that assumption that the powers they awaken has something to do with content of each chakra fruit. The Otsutsuki themselves develop their own unique abilities, yes, but saying it has something to do with the content of the chakra fruit would require explicit statements.
Nature energies abilities already vary from animal variant to animal variant (with some similarities) so it’s not unfounded that different “nature” can invoke different properties into their Senjutsu/chakra.
They vary due to different genetic profiles and mind of each animal, not different nature energy. However they are collectively have almost the same set of abilities in the same specie.
Even the individual Bijuu, all pieces of the same Senjutsu chakra, all grew with completely different abilities tied to their being despite all coming from the exact same place.
Hagoromo created the bijuu and gave them individuality (unique body and mind), so therefore different abilities.
Why would being able to recognize that a being is completely made of Senjutsu automatically mean that there isn’t a difference?
We’ve seen regular Senjutsu users able to sense Six Paths Senjutsu and recognize it despite their differences.
Also why would this even matter? They don’t have to be uniquely sensed to have different properties or grant different abilities.
I'm giving you an example of how chakra is similar even when they are a different specie of the Ten Tails because you have been alluding to different genetics means completely different chakra.
Ten Tails chakra is Ten Tails chakra. There is a shared similarity of Ten Tails chakra.
There isn’t proof that they possess either, and if you have to make that distinction then that just goes to show that there are abilities that the Earth Shinju unlocked for its cast that none of the other Otsutsuki have demonstrated.
If they provably don’t have Six Paths Senjutsu then why would they have Six Paths chakra? When all Six Paths chakra users gained their chakra from Six Paths Senjutsu.
The proof just isn’t there and especially with recent staff CRTs pertaining to this kind of topic, we’re just not giving abilities to ppl that haven’t demonstrated them, that require a charitable train of logic to argue for.
Different abilities is not always a function of different chakra, my guy.
Individual genetics and unique minds play a role in giving different abilities to chakra. For instance, the Uchiha collectively have Uchiha chakra but get different abilities from the mangekyou.
Now the only reason why I don't give Otsutsuki the six paths senjutsu is that it requires direct proof that they utilize sage techniques, and I have to have seen a direct visual proof just like how we have seen with the rinnegan.
Kaguya has the benefit of the doubt because she fused with the Juubi, and has shown techs like TSB.
However, six paths chakra is not a technique. Six Paths chakra is Hagoromo's term for the chakra from his mother, who became the Shinju. We have direct statements of Hagoromo stating he acquired his unique chakra from his mother. Not all six paths chakra will create six paths senjutsu, just like not all six paths chakra will create the rinnegan.
The proof that Otsutsuki get the same chakra from the chakra fruit is the fact they awaken the same shinjutsu. If you take your argument at 100%, then Shibai would have had a complete different set of Shinjutsu since he did not consume the same genetic info that Kaguya or the rest of Otsutsuki have consumed.
Further proof is Momoshiki awakening rinnegan which is six paths power derived from six paths chakra. But one does not need to awaken rinnegan or six paths senjutsu transformation to have six paths chakra proven by Kakashi and Obito both using it without having acquired rinnegan or six paths senjutsu.
Therefore any innate ability from just having the six paths chakra should be granted to Otsutsuki
.