CJunitilarian
He/Him- 257
- 182
Hi Everyone, this will be my first CRT so please be nice and point out any mistakes made
INTRODUCTION
The current state of Sword Art Online is abysmally bad, like really, really bad. Not pushing to delete the verse even if it's a non-controversial verse, but the verse and all profiles should have an outdated tag, locked down. Took inspiration from this JJK thread and to be honest, SAO is facing the same issues.
1. Massively Outdated Scalings.
The use of outdated calcs like the boulder feat, which was done in 6 years ago and was not re-calculated and used to practically scale almost all Aincrad keys in their respective profiles to 9-A which should be re-calculated among other feats like Asuna's Alicization LS and Kirito swatting a bullet.
2. NO Justifications on Profiles.
Taking a quick glance through these profiles,
2.1 https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Kirito_(Aincrad)
Here in Kirito's AINCRAD profile, taking a quick glance at it, we can see zero justifications for his abilities and with the profile even missing some abilities generally and his AP like i said above using outdated calcs, even the speed part.. and he's the freaking MC.... so if the MC's page is like this, what would the rest be like?
2.2 https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Asuna_(Aincrad)
Same thing here but worse on a different level. At least Kirito's had little justification in AP and Speed, hers has zero justifications for anything, from Abilities to AP to speed to even LS, nothing which is really bad for the so-called "Female Lead" of the show
2.3 https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Yui_(Sword_Art_Online)
This one is absolutely horrendous for a profile with most of her statistics being "unknown" and as usual, zero justification on the profile
These are just some profiles among many profiles which have the same problems as listed above..
3. The threads meant to fix them? Wish there was even one...
Been looking through revision threads and the last SAO related revision thread was 2 years ago and i'm not sure it even got concluded.... No threads to add justifications, No threads to re-evaluate calcs, nothing, and went to the general discussion to ask if the verse was indeed under revision and didn't get a single reply in affirmation or even opposition to that which is actually sad as i am a very big fan of the verse and want the verse to actually "prosper" so to say..
PROPOSAL...
So my proposal is to put the verse on lockdown and to put the outdated template on every profile and the verse page and with the supporters (hopefully, i'll find some) will rework on the verse and every single profile and hopefully introduce more characters in their respective arcs (cause all arcs really lacking characters tbh)
SO TL;DR
1. the verse is using outdated calculations as justifications for feats which should be re-evalauated
2. most if not all profiles are seriously lacking justifications in their power and abilities section
3. there has been no single thread to fix anything in more than 2 years....
4. requesting a lockdown on the verse and the addition of the outdated template to every profile and the verse page
Thank you very much for reading
INTRODUCTION
The current state of Sword Art Online is abysmally bad, like really, really bad. Not pushing to delete the verse even if it's a non-controversial verse, but the verse and all profiles should have an outdated tag, locked down. Took inspiration from this JJK thread and to be honest, SAO is facing the same issues.
1. Massively Outdated Scalings.
The use of outdated calcs like the boulder feat, which was done in 6 years ago and was not re-calculated and used to practically scale almost all Aincrad keys in their respective profiles to 9-A which should be re-calculated among other feats like Asuna's Alicization LS and Kirito swatting a bullet.
2. NO Justifications on Profiles.
Taking a quick glance through these profiles,
2.1 https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Kirito_(Aincrad)
Here in Kirito's AINCRAD profile, taking a quick glance at it, we can see zero justifications for his abilities and with the profile even missing some abilities generally and his AP like i said above using outdated calcs, even the speed part.. and he's the freaking MC.... so if the MC's page is like this, what would the rest be like?
2.2 https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Asuna_(Aincrad)
Same thing here but worse on a different level. At least Kirito's had little justification in AP and Speed, hers has zero justifications for anything, from Abilities to AP to speed to even LS, nothing which is really bad for the so-called "Female Lead" of the show
2.3 https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Yui_(Sword_Art_Online)
This one is absolutely horrendous for a profile with most of her statistics being "unknown" and as usual, zero justification on the profile
These are just some profiles among many profiles which have the same problems as listed above..
3. The threads meant to fix them? Wish there was even one...
Been looking through revision threads and the last SAO related revision thread was 2 years ago and i'm not sure it even got concluded.... No threads to add justifications, No threads to re-evaluate calcs, nothing, and went to the general discussion to ask if the verse was indeed under revision and didn't get a single reply in affirmation or even opposition to that which is actually sad as i am a very big fan of the verse and want the verse to actually "prosper" so to say..
PROPOSAL...
So my proposal is to put the verse on lockdown and to put the outdated template on every profile and the verse page and with the supporters (hopefully, i'll find some) will rework on the verse and every single profile and hopefully introduce more characters in their respective arcs (cause all arcs really lacking characters tbh)
SO TL;DR
1. the verse is using outdated calculations as justifications for feats which should be re-evalauated
2. most if not all profiles are seriously lacking justifications in their power and abilities section
3. there has been no single thread to fix anything in more than 2 years....
4. requesting a lockdown on the verse and the addition of the outdated template to every profile and the verse page
Thank you very much for reading
