MCU Captain Marvel Change.

[Phirse]

Change to MCU Captain Marvel

Include Absorption as her power is the absorption of light energy.

I know this technically falls under Energy Manipulation however, I think Energy Manipulation is too broad and Absorption should be it's own separate thing.

On a separate note wouldn't this call her flying through Hala's sun and re-ignition feat a into question given that she would have been amped as she did it.

Remove Heat Manipulation as she clearly heats the kettle and therefor the water thru the use of the energy projection from her energy blasts. What constitutes as Heat Manipulation is the direct control of temperature and heat of the environment for any number of purposes, which she doesn't show she has the ability to to. Powers that inadvertently affect the temperature of the environment, such as fire manipulation or ice manipulation, don't count.

General consensus is that the addition is fine but the removal of Heat Manipulation is wrong. You should be able to see this for urself.

 

[ByArrow]

Agree with addition

 

[Phirse]

Agree with addition

I'm going to add something else I just noticed

 

[Emerald]

Generating high heat still falls under heat manipulation

 

[Phirse]

Generating high heat still falls under heat manipulation

While other abilities, such as Fire Manipulation and Ice Manipulation, may affect the temperature of one's surroundings, this ability refers to having direct control of temperature and heat for any number of purposes?

That's what it says on the temperature manipulation page. You can see that she heats up the kettle using her energy projection if u look closely. So generating thru other abilities such as energy projection shouldn't count as temp manipulation. At the very least is should say limited.

 

[Phirse]

I mean if Heat Manipulation just went for anyone who can generate high heat with external accessories such as lasers, then why doesn't Iron man MK 50 have it.

 

[ByArrow]

While other abilities, such as Fire Manipulation and Ice Manipulation, may affect the temperature of one's surroundings, this ability refers to having direct control of temperature and heat for any number of purposes?

That's what it says on the temperature manipulation page. You can see that she heats up the kettle using her energy projection if u look closely. So generating thru other abilities such as energy projection shouldn't count as temp manipulation. At the very least is should say limited.

It count as temp manipulation.

I mean if Heat Manipulation just went for anyone who can generate high heat with external accessories such as lasers, then why doesn't Iron man MK 50 have it.

Iron man’s profile is outdated. He doesn’t have the abilities he should have.

 

[Phirse]

It count as temp manipulation.

That's kinda odd. I hope u understand where I'm coming from because the page for temperature manipulation says that abilities that affect temperature such as fire and ice manip shouldn't count. So maybe they should change it.

 

[ByArrow]

That's kinda odd. I hope u understand where I'm coming from because the page for temperature manipulation says that abilities that affect temperature such as fire and ice manip shouldn't count. So maybe they should change it.

I understand and yes, fire manip and ice manip doesn’t automatically give temp manipulation but energy projection gives if it cause heat.

 

[Lort15]

OP makes sense

While other abilities, such as Fire Manipulation and Ice Manipulation, may affect the temperature of one's surroundings, this ability refers to having direct control of temperature and heat for any number of purposes?

That's what it says on the temperature manipulation page. You can see that she heats up the kettle using her energy projection if u look closely. So generating thru other abilities such as energy projection shouldn't count as temp manipulation. At the very least is should say limited.

about this yeah somehow fire manip or ice manip doesnt give temperature manipulation by default however if you have control over those abilities like can increase and decrease the temp of it, it must be fine to give temperature manipulation and yeah Iron Man must have it as well

 

[Phirse]

OP makes sense

about this yeah somehow fire manip or ice manip doesnt give temperature manipulation by default however if you have control over those abilities like can increase and decrease the temp of it, it must be fine to give temperature manipulation and yeah Iron Man must have it as well

Okay. Should I like send this to a Mod or just wait?

 

[Lort15]

Okay. Should I like send this to a Mod or just wait?

You can ask in their message walls for sure, so why not

 

[Phirse]

You can ask in their message walls for sure, so why not

I also have one more.

Remove limited Electricity Manipulation because she does not generate static electricity. The man in the clip is simply assuming it's static electricty because he doesn't know she's an alien and is looking for the most plausible cause. The "shock" or rather sensation of it is caused by her energy projection

 

[Lort15]

I also have one more.

Remove limited Electricity Manipulation because she does not generate static electricity. The man in the clip is simply assuming it's static electricty because he doesn't know she's an alien and is looking for the most plausible cause. The "shock" or rather sensation of it is caused by her energy projection

it does act like static shock tho i wouldn't mind keeping it

 

[Phirse]

BUMP

 

[Random-Helper323]

Absorption seems okay, heat manipulation should stay.

 

[Phirse]

Absorption seems okay, heat manipulation should stay.

Okay, I'm new here so where should I go from here.

 

[Random-Helper323]

Okay, I'm new here so where should I go from here.

Thread can be applied. Just a few steps to follow:

Use Source Editor if possible.

Follow the same format the page already uses when adding abilities.

There is a summary box at the bottom of the edit screen. Place a link to this thread in that box so staff know that the revisions are approved.

Minor errors in format and such aren't a huge deal for a new member. Staff are happy to help out. Just learn the system as you go.

 

[Hacigeralt]

I agree

 

[Phirse]

I agree

Would u say that this also applies to her suppressed state or no?

I think it should but I did not specify this in my prompt.

 

[Hacigeralt]

Would u say that this also applies to her suppressed state or no?

I think it should but I did not specify this in my prompt.

I think it's valid