Playing God | Homelander VS Tighten

[Bruhtelho]

Fight starts in the Metro Man Square

Speed is unequalized

Both start 20 meters apart

Fight ends in Death​

---

"No, no, no. No God. The only man in the sky is me.":14 (Jackof_noTrades068, ShionAH, DavidTPPM, IDK3465, Ruby_R_Dracula, Nonynho, M2u12, ThePrimalHunter, AThe1412, Bruhtelho, CBslayeR, Jaynic1, NikHelton, Doggo)

"This town isn't big enough for two supervillains!":4 (EnderLord8, AyOgUyS, Robo432343, Knifeman29)

Metro Man comes in and cleans up both:1 (Arkansalter2)

​

 

[Bruhtelho]

Stats for Both:

Homelander is superior to 800 Tons of TNT with Class K LS

Tighten is 808.96 Tons of TNT with Class G LS

 

[Robo432343]

Nothing really changed since last time

 

[Bruhtelho]

Nothing really changed since last time

Homelander's AP is a lot higher than it was previously and his profile is much more fleshed out and updated.

 

[Qurbonboev]

Following.
Should be noted that
a)Tighten has x135 reaction time
b)Homelander heat vision is superior temperature wise, but Tighten one has much better direct showings of AP

 

[Bruhtelho]

I could unequalize speed tbf since Tighten would still keep his reaction speed well Homelander would be 3x faster across the board (if i'm correct on Tighten being baseline Hypersonic compared to Homelanders Mach 18

 

[AyOgUyS]

tighten AP stomps, ez W

 

[AThe1412]

tighten AP stomps, ez W

Uh... Have you read anything?

 

[AyOgUyS]

Uh... Have you read anything?

yes, tighten wins easily, h*melander is cooked

 

[Friedoil11]

It might not be that easy, but I think Tighten might win. Yes, Homelander has slightly more abilites (super smell and low regeneration), a lot more resistances than Tighten (which most of them are useless) and is slightly smarter, but I think that Tighten has enough physical strength to win this.

 

[AThe1412]

yes, tighten wins easily, h*melander is cooked

The AP difference is a mere 1%.

 

[AyOgUyS]

The AP difference is a mere 1%.

ahem: H*melander notoriously cannot fight people equal to him to save his life

ez win, H*medlander gets neg diffed

 

[AThe1412]

It might not be that easy, but I think Tighten might win. Yes, Homelander has slightly more abilites (super smell and low regeneration), a lot more resistances than Tighten (which most of them are useless) and is slightly smarter, but I think that Tighten has enough physical strength to win this.

The only advantage Hal has over John is LS, which he doesn't really abuse from what I've seen. Homie's resistance should reduce the effectiveness of Tighten's heat vision, while his would probably cut right through the latter through sheer temperature. There's also the fact that Tighten is a straight up coward who ran away when faced with someone who can actually put up a fight against him. Homie at least tried before dipping, even when he was outnumbered. He also gets stronger when sufficiently angered, which is pretty easy to achieve.

 

[AThe1412]

ahem: H*melander notoriously cannot fight people equal to him to save his life

Neither can Tighten (I know Metro Man should be stronger, but Hal clearly had no way to know the full extent of his power). And what you said is literally untrue because he was still doing well against people like Butcher, Soldier Boy, and Maeve individually. They had to gang up on him and try to have SB neg his power.

 

[AyOgUyS]

Neither can Tighten (I know Metro Man should be stronger, but Hal clearly had no way to know the full extent of his power). And what you said is literally untrue because he was still doing well against people like Butcher, Soldier Boy, and Maeve individually. They had to gang up on him and try to have SB neg his power.

buddy its metro man what do u expect him to do

 

[AThe1412]

buddy its metro man what do u expect him to do

Literally anything other than just running away? For all he knew, he and Metro Man were equals (nobody even knew MM can move at FTL speed). Bro just didn't want to fight someone who can actually hurt him lol. He'll run the moment Homie draws blood.

 

[AyOgUyS]

Literally anything other than just running away? For all he knew, he and Metro Man were equals (nobody even knew MM can move at FTL speed). Bro just didn't want to fight someone who can actually hurt him lol. He'll run the moment Homie draws blood.

yea so we just expect people to risk their lives huh

 

[AThe1412]

yea so we just expect people to risk their lives huh

Are you confirming that he would run away from Homie and not want to risk his life fighting someone who can probably kill him?

 

[AyOgUyS]

Are you confirming that he would run away from Homie and not want to risk his life fighting someone who can probably kill him?

and this would be a loss how? i'm 99% sure we don't even allow forfeits unless it's like mind Control or smth

 

[AThe1412]

and this would be a loss how? i'm 99% sure we don't even allow forfeits unless it's like mind Control or smth

We've had matches where someone won by convincing the other person to give up through sheer charisma (basically just befriending them) or Intimidation (scaring them into surrendering or running away). Combatants are still in character even if they are motivated to fight at first.

 

[DavidTPPM]

Yeah Homelander should bully Hal lol. Hal is a loser bum who would probably lose to an average adult human in a fight with equal AP while John fought actual trained soldiers like SB, Maeve, and Butcher.

This is literally just a trained fighter vs an incel but they can fly

 

[AyOgUyS]

We've had matches where someone won by convincing the other person to give up through sheer charisma (basically just befriending them) or Intimidation (scaring them into surrendering or running away). Combatants are still in character even if they are motivated to fight at first.

well H*melander would still lose via Tighten having apparently far higher reaction time and higher physical stats in all cats

 

[AyOgUyS]

Yeah Homelander should bully Hal lol. Hal is a loser bum who would probably lose to an average adult human in a fight with equal AP while John fought actual trained soldiers like SB, Maeve, and Butcher.

This is literally just a trained fighter vs an incel but they can fly

"Fought"

 

[AThe1412]

"Fought"

What's with the cringe ass reaction? You think he's lying?

 

[AyOgUyS]

What's with the cringe ass reaction? You think he's lying?

well first of all tighten and the two actually good characters are completely different and I still don't see how H*melander is gonna get around Tighten having 100x faster reactions if that's tru

 

[AThe1412]

well first of all tighten and the two actually good characters are completely different and I still don't see how H*melander is gonna get around Tighten having 100x faster reactions if that's tru

Don't start backpedaling. We were discussing AP and skill. I proved that those aren't a problem for Homie. You jump to speed, which OP is planning to unequalize anyway. Tighten having 100x reactions would make it a blitz stomp either way.

 

[DavidTPPM]

"Fought"

Huh? He literally BEAT Soldier Boy in a 1v1 after keeping up with him offscreen for like a minute, then equally traded blows with Butcher, and then did surprisingly well in a 2v1 against both.

John is clearly very proficient in h2h combat while even I'd probably beat the piss out of Hal lmao.

well first of all tighten and the two actually good characters are completely different

Yes the main difference being those 2 are well trained combat proficient soldiers while Hal is a loser bum.

and I still don't see how H*melander is gonna get around Tighten having 100x faster reactions if that's tru

How's that going to help here? He's gonna watch John break his face in slowmo? That might unironically make him give up even faster

 

[AyOgUyS]

Huh? He literally BEAT Soldier Boy in a 1v1 after keeping up with him offscreen for like a minute, then equally traded blows with Butcher, and then did surprisingly well in a 2v1 against both.

soldier boy and butcher do not have 100x faster reactions than h*melander while tighten does

Tighten having 100x reactions would make it a blitz stomp either way.

I don't get ur argument

You jump to speed, which OP is planning to unequalize anyway.

in that case h*melander has faster combat speeds while tighten has faster reactions I think?

 

[DavidTPPM]

soldier boy and butcher do not have 100x faster reactions than h*melander

The argument in question here was about their skill because YOU claimed John can't fight people on his level when in reality everyone else proved you he's actually very skilled.

while tighten does

And like I said all that'd do is let him watch Homelander pummel his face in slow motion.

h*melander

Why do you keep censoring the word Homelander…?

 

[AThe1412]

I don't get ur argument

Homie can't land a hit if Tighten has 100x reaction, which would allow him to just dodge everything and retaliate. Stomp matches can't be added to the profiles.

in that case h*melander has faster combat speeds while tighten has faster reactions I think?

Homelander is faster in everything other than reactions.

 

[AyOgUyS]

The argument in question here was about their skill because YOU claimed John can't fight people on his level when in reality everyone else proved you he's actually very skilled.

being able to fight a master martial artist because you're significantly stronger than them isn't a skill feat b

And like I said all that'd do is let him watch Homelander pummel his face in slow motion.

brother what? reaction speed/time is how long it takes for you to react. if tighten has shorter reactions then he's gonna be able to move before h*melander can, thus he can dodge far easier

 

[AyOgUyS]

Stomp matches can't be added to the profiles.

yippe

Homelander is faster in everything other than reactions.

seems pretty even then

 

[ByArrow]

Does anyone know why Tighten's reaction speed doesn't scale to combat speed? The things written in the profiles seem applicable to combat speed?

 

[DavidTPPM]

being able to fight a master martial artist because you're significantly stronger than them isn't a skill feat b

Yeah and he wasn't significantly stronger. They equally trade blows and clash repeatedly, it's painfully clear that they're comparable in stats.

brother what? reaction speed/time is how long it takes for you to react. if tighten has shorter reactions then he's gonna be able to move before h*melander can, thus he can dodge far easier

Reaction speed at best gives you a short burst of speed at the moment of reaction

Reaction speed is the speed at which a character can react to an event or action. This usually only grants a short movement upon reaction, whereas several movements at the same speed switch it to combat speed.

So at best Hal is dodging one or two blows before he gets brutally beaten by John since he cannot keep up this speed beyond just that one or 2 dodges.

Also you didn't answer why you censor Homelanders name.

 

[ByArrow]

Also you didn't answer why you censor Homelanders name.

He hate him.

 

[DavidTPPM]

He hate him.

That's cringe af ngl

 

[ShionAH]

The GOAT of Humanity, the PROTECTER OF EARTH, REAL American HERO FRA

 

[MochOath]

why are yall arguing skillslop
neither of these guys are skilled enough to skillstomp an average human

 

[AThe1412]

why are yall arguing skillslop
neither of these guys are skilled enough to skillstomp an average human

Because there's still a clear difference between them. Homelander was holding his own against Supes as strong as him but with actual combat training, even when they are more skilled. Meanwhile, Tighten's first move upon seeing someone whom he was presumably equal to (again, he didn't know the full extent of Metro Man's powers. All he knew was that he had Metro Man's powers) was to flee.

 

[Jackof_noTrades068]

An actual skill debate between Homelander and Tighten especially this cannot be real.
So far leaning Homelander. (following)