• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

The Revenant Marvel Comics Discussion Thread

What I'm suggesting is that she decides to do the duties of the Sorcerer Supreme without caring about the title. But instead she keeps insisting that she is in fact the true Sorcerer Supreme regardless of what the Vishanti thinks. The former lets her do the same things as the latter but without her just making objectively wrong statements that the story keeps trying to treat as valid. It also just makes Wanda look really stupid if her reasoning is that the cloak and eye choosing her is what makes her a valid SS despite the fact that this is coming off of an even where both items didn't choose to leave Doom despite how god awful he was. Yeah I'm sure the personal feelings of those two items are extremely important after we just saw them enable Mr. Fascism himself.
Tbf the Vishanti also enabled Doom without any issue with the war crimes he was committing, so Wanda is right that the Vishanti aren't the best experts of character. Not to mention all the people they sent to their deaths in the WotSS, only to make a ceasefire at the last minute with the Trinity of Ashes.
 
Last edited:
the Vishanti, AKA, how to make cosmic beings seem more incompetent than Shadowlands Elune.

And that woman burned half her main worshippers on Azeroth to death to send them to the winter queen without even ******* checking what the problem with the fake Shadowlands even was.
 
Progress update: I've finished indexing the main Thor titles (nearly 800 issues) and I'm now working my way through his other appearances and special volumes. I am completely convinced that he should not be used for scaling at all unless it's made explicitly clear that he's not holding back whatsoever. The degree that he's above Earth heroes is actually ridiculous.
 
Progress update: I've finished indexing the main Thor titles (nearly 800 issues) and I'm now working my way through his other appearances and special volumes. I am completely convinced that he should not be used for scaling at all unless it's made explicitly clear that he's not holding back whatsoever. The degree that he's above Earth heroes is actually ridiculous.
Well, used to be above Earth's superheroes, except for Doctor Strange and Phoenix. Then Marvel Comics writers and editors managed to invent some kind of headcanon that Thor somehow represented a Nazi patriarchy and began to humiliate and depower him as much as possible, while upgrading quite a lot of other superheroes to irrational degrees in conjunction. 🙏
 
Well, used to be above Earth's superheroes, except for Doctor Strange and Phoenix. Then Marvel Comics writers and editors managed to invent some kind of headcanon that Thor somehow represented a Nazi patriarchy and began to humiliate and depower him as much as possible, while upgrading quite a lot of other superheroes to irrational degrees in conjunction. 🙏
Casual Thor mebbe...
Progress update: I've finished indexing the main Thor titles (nearly 800 issues) and I'm now working my way through his other appearances and special volumes. I am completely convinced that he should not be used for scaling at all unless it's made explicitly clear that he's not holding back whatsoever. The degree that he's above Earth heroes is actually ridiculous.
Make a profile for Modern Loki too~
 
Progress update: I've finished indexing the main Thor titles (nearly 800 issues) and I'm now working my way through his other appearances and special volumes. I am completely convinced that he should not be used for scaling at all unless it's made explicitly clear that he's not holding back whatsoever. The degree that he's above Earth heroes is actually ridiculous.
Fr, my goat's on another level.

You could probably still use his casual showings for scaling tbf. That and Modern Thor's no longer treated as potent as he used to be... but that's more so a symptom of Marvel collapsing any kind of interesting power differentiation.
 
I hear conflicting accounts on if he's cool or not, so, it'd be interesting to see what happens.

His classic profile needs like, a full rework too but hey.
He's definitely interesting, though sometimes I wonder if that's the good kind of interesting or if that's the, "wow, they've done way too much with this character" sort of interesting.
 
Right now my focuses are a bit more P&A, cosmology stuff (mystic and otherwise), and fixing Doom's intelligence section (plus a few other things on his profile)
 
I was about to throw this guy at Ghost Rider but I did the intelligent thing and checked his resistances to be sure, and yep, no chance in hell.
 
Fr, my goat's on another level.

You could probably still use his casual showings for scaling tbf. That and Modern Thor's no longer treated as potent as he used to be... but that's more so a symptom of Marvel collapsing any kind of interesting power differentiation.
The problem is that its kinda arbitrary what counts as "casual." Like baby Thor has a 1-A feat that we treat as being a "peak" feat despite him being, you know, a literal baby.
 
I plan on improving his classic profile in da future
At some point I want to give him stat upgrades. 1-A magic via scaling to Seth and Doctor Strange. Physical stats I'm not sure about though. There are several instances where Loki's physical strength is implied to not be all that far below Thor's, but Thor is posing a big problem for scaling right now.
 
At some point I want to give him stat upgrades. 1-A magic via scaling to Seth and Doctor Strange. Physical stats I'm not sure about though. There are several instances where Loki's physical strength is implied to not be all that far below Thor's, but Thor is posing a big problem for scaling right now.
You can handle tiering I'm focusing on his P&A, his current P&A section is badly lacking
 
The problem is that its kinda arbitrary what counts as "casual." Like baby Thor has a 1-A feat that we treat as being a "peak" feat despite him being, you know, a literal baby.
Thor’s peak is qualitatively superior to his normal/heavily holding back output, all of the training and aging in the world isn’t going to ever give you a qualitative increase, meaning that if his peak is currently qualitatively superior to his “normal” output then as his peak as a baby would be qualitatively superior to his normal output
 
Fr, my goat's on another level.

You could probably still use his casual showings for scaling tbf. That and Modern Thor's no longer treated as potent as he used to be... but that's more so a symptom of Marvel collapsing any kind of interesting power differentiation.
He actually is another level lol. 1-A at peak is pretty consistent across the hundreds of issues I've indexed
 
Thor’s peak is qualitatively superior to his normal/heavily holding back output, all of the training and aging in the world isn’t going to ever give you a qualitative increase, meaning that if his peak is currently qualitatively superior to his “normal” output then as his peak as a baby would be qualitatively superior to his normal output
Ok, but the writers absolutely were not thinking of it in that way. There is absolutely no chance that any writer working for Marvel ever thought of baby Thor as being "qualitatively superior" to someone like Silver Surfer. That is a concept this wiki has imposed on Marvel. Scaling should be based on in-universe logic, not our rules
 
Ok, but the writers absolutely were not thinking of it in that way. There is absolutely no chance that any writer working for Marvel ever thought of baby Thor as being "qualitatively superior" to someone like Silver Surfer. That is a concept this wiki has imposed on Marvel. Scaling should be based on in-universe logic, not our rules
What the writers were thinking of is irrelevant, we can’t determine what the majority of writers were thinking but we can determine what was shown in the comics, therefore it is more logical to judge stuff by what happened in the comics not what the writers were thinking, and we can’t scale based on in universe rules, different universes have completely incompatible rules because different pieces of fiction have very different ideas about how power in general works, meaning the most effective way to scale characters is to use a single system
 
Maybe hulk’s 5-B end, he resists a good amount of that guy’s Hax and isn’t able to Hax stomp the guy into oblivion
Hulk is literally impossible to kill or properly knock out without 1-A hax. And Gul'dan is lethal incarnate.
 
You mean Mr. High 8-C?

Or maybe 5-B Doctor Doom? I have put some existent thought into this
Well, probably not… Victor is a bit too skilled. Him with tech would be better against… I want to say Illidan, but without magic Illidan is… well… blind.
 
Well, probably not… Victor is a bit too skilled. Him with tech would be better against… I want to say Illidan, but without magic Illidan is… well… blind.
Now you see my problem.

Any magic user who can fight a Marvel Character in melee and expect to not get skill stomped is also 5-B or 7-A, like Illidan, Thrall, or Kil'jaeden. And Kil'jaeden is iffy cause demons are weird and their physiology genuinely has conflicting examples on it. Kil'jaeden without Fel might just ******* explode Warhammer Daemon style. And Thrall might even still be able to cast cause he's all-natural.

And 7-A isn't an option cause the only ****** there is Ghost Rider. Who is busted beyond belief.
 
Last edited:
Now you see my problem.

Any magic user who can fight a Marvel Character in melee and expect to not get skill stomped is also 5-B or 7-A, like Illidan, Thrall, or Kil'jaeden. And Kil'jaeden is iffy cause demons are weird and their physiology genuinely has conflicting examples on it. Kil'jaeden without Fel might just ******* explode Warhammer Daemon style. And Thrall might even still be able to cast cause he's all-natural.

And 7-A isn't an option cause the only ****** there is Ghost Rider. Who is busted beyond belief.
Hmm. Any tier 3s? If any infinite strength statements are by default tier 3 (I think?), then maybe some heralds would do?
 
Hmm. Any tier 3s? If any infinite strength statements are by default tier 3 (I think?), then maybe some heralds would do?
I haven't exactly sorted out Cosmology, but currently the only tier 3s are over time destruction for the burning Legion and environmental destruction for Nozdormu and Murozond... and frankly that's probably 2-B environmental destruction.
 
Back
Top