Super Galaxy Bros: Return of the Grand Stars

[IDK3465]

Based on the bronze Grand Star thing Bowser’s definitely not “holding back”, but he also needs time to properly learn that power.

The issue though is that even with that argument Bowser should still be in the Tier 4 range. Even at his weakest in 64, he knew how to use Star power well enough to fight Mario with 8+ Power Stars. Bowser didn’t personally have all the Power Stars on him in 64 and was seemingly just drawing power from the ones under the control of his army, whereas in Galaxy 2 the Grand Star is literally in his body so he’s probably drawing on way more power than he was from a single Power Star in 64. There’s also the question of whether the 4-A calc actually applies to Bowser or not as I don’t think that was proven yet. If it was created by Bowser with the power of the Grand Star then he would be 4-A anyway, so that adds more complications.

Yeah, I agree 100% with those points. I just wanted to bring that up so that if we DO end up confirming Bowser is capable of using the full power of the Grand Star, he'd almost certainly fully scale to it; it's just up in the air right now whether or not that's the case

 

[Dalesean027]

Soo is anyone gonna make a summary of both sides?? So myself and other mods can have everything for a final review

 

[JPTheGamer]

Soo is anyone gonna make a summary of both sides?? So myself and other mods can have everything for a final review

Okay, lemme recap...

The current mod vote is 6-1; three of the mods agree with 4-A Grand Star and the other three agree with the key being brought back. We've been arguing back and forth on whether or not Bowser was using an amount of Grand Star power equal or greater than the black hole feat that was calculated. The most recent argument that was against it all is right here whereas the most recent ones for it are here and there, and there haven't been any more recent arguments against the Grand Star having its energy used at 100% by Bowser.

Now that that's out of the way (hopefully)... What's the final review gonna be?

 

[JPTheGamer]

Soo is anyone gonna make a summary of both sides?? So myself and other mods can have everything for a final review

Bump?

 

[Dalesean027]

haven't forgotten about this fyi just been very busy

 

[JPTheGamer]

haven't forgotten about this fyi just been very busy

Can the changes be applied, then? What's the review?

 

[Dalesean027]

4-A with Grandstars seems fine to me

 

[JPTheGamer]

4-A with Grandstars seems fine to me

Counted. Can the changes be applied now?

 

[Dalesean027]

Sure

 

[JPTheGamer]

Not sure why you think reversing the Burden of Proof is the play here. He's not arguing for your position.

I’d lean towards agree

Sure

Alright, the changes have been added; hopefully, I didn't add anything that was controversial or against the rules.

Now that that's out of the way, may I have someone close this thread, please?