This proves he takes areas locally, since there was one at the party and another at the arc, and it did not happen at the same time , but even if it did, it kills your own argument, because if we play both cutscenes at the same time (thank you for posting them btw, helped a lot), Sonic was trying to attack time eater while Shadow was already teleported to white space.
Time Eater is already accepted to have erased the cosmology. You would need another CRT to debunk this.
Headcanon? It's literally just the order of events shown in the cutscene?
Sonic 4, Sonic speed simulator the game you are using, both shows that bad future is the canon one of Stardust speedway.
Crisis city and stardust bad future are separate from the main universe so, no. They are or were made into alt dimensions.
That doesn’t make sense because the good ending is the canon one, and if you get the good ending then every zone is the good future.
Classic Sonic taking the destruction of the cosmology is currently accepted. That's why Classic Sonic has all these resistances.
So yes, you would need yet another CRT to pass your headcanon.
Retcon, as simple as that + the future in Sonic is constantly changing, so...
Yes but there was nothing to change stardust speedway after CD, Little Planet was off doing its own thing until Sonic 4 and Eggman didn’t interact with it until that game.
Basically what a retcon is.
Yeah and it doesn't make sense for Eggman to recall Crisis city, yet here we are.
I don't understand how this proves your point because it's doing quite the opposite.
It’s not the definitive future, again the good ending in Sonic CD is “every single zone” being in a good future, the good ending is canon. And whether the future changes after that is irrelevant to Gens because the Metal Sonic fight is taking place specifically in the CD era, meaning that the bad future was the alternate at the time.
I think they just didn’t want to program in an entirely new modern version of the good future in Episode 2 for a location you spend about 1 minute in during the game, much easier to reuse the Gens assets. It‘s also irrelevant because what was canon during CD is the important element in context of Gens.
This is true because in the bad ending, Little Planet stays stuck in Never Lake:
That's because the opposition keeps changing arguments everytime they get debunked. Just look at the fact OP doesn't even mention anything he put in his original post, for example. Of course that's exhausting when someone throws everything at a wall to see if it sticks.
That's true, too. Starsprite, for example, has insulted me several times in this one thread.
Define retcon.
Quote me and I will apologize for every letter I ACTUALLY insulted you in, but in return you do the same exact thing because you also insulted me here.
Should be, yes.
A retcon doesn't take place for the convenience of the argument, Star. Do you have an official source that states there was a retcon?
A retcon doesn't have to be a statement when it was shown in 3 seperate games with the sonic lore being consistent on the future constantly changing.
Getting all the time stones automatically makes every zone a good future.
DDM disagreed with the thread for Qawseds reasons
Not really, since we see what actually happened in Sonic 4.
In Sonic CD, the game that’s relevant to generations, getting all the time stones gets a good future in all the zones. What Sonic 4 does is irrelevant.
Wait 24 hours until grace period ends.
Doesn’t matter, if you get a good future for the zone the third act is always in the good version, even during the Metal race.
Not really how it works.
