- 5,313
- 2,024
OP’s opening post involves both canon and Legend content though.
Belongs to Legends as mentioned by @Epyriel
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STAR WARS - May the Force be with Canon
- Thread starter Phsccarvalho
- Start date
- Status
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #42
Neither of them belong?
Of the two scans that the justification has, one comes from the databank which is canon and the other comes from this canon book.
- 5,313
- 2,024
You have kinda brought up Legend content so I was bring up Legend content to help with that.
- 7,935
- 12,029
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #45
This part is not content added to Legends. It is simply a tab separation.
I said in the CRT that none of the Legends content will change and that the page does not use any of their content and will not be applied to Legends.
- 5,313
- 2,024
Oh alrighty, other than that, I think I agree with the CRT overall including the Transduality part.
Kinda confused myself tbh
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #47
I'm sorry, when I make a long message it kind of ends up like this, but to try to explain it to you.
See this P&A from Obi-Wan's profile?
When I make a canon and a legends tab, I'll move all of this old P&A over to Legends to make sure no legends abilities are lost.
And in the canon tab I'll put the "Link" to the force page along with any extra canonical force powers that the profile has indexed.
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #48
I'm at home so this is for when I get home. Can I create the page without the transduality? (Because DT may take a while to respond and I would like to advance what is already accepted). Or will AE and CM need 3 votes? Because there are 2 agreements and 2 neutrals for these two.
- 12,494
- 16,894
AE and CM does require 3 votes
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #50
Bump
- 14,995
- 10,612
Isn't transduality contradicted by this
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #52
This is legendsIsn't transduality contradicted by this
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #53
Could you ping someone?
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #54
Hey Fine, could you ping@ someone please?
- 7,935
- 12,029
- 5,643
- 4,972
Agree
OrangeFR
Username Only- 1,731
- 1,041
This CRT looks good as is, but I was wondering about how force abilites would be applied. Would every light side force user get all of the abilities on the page for example? It seems like some abilities might not apply to weaker ones.
Maybe instead of only giving a baseline of abilities and then listing additional, stronger powers, usage of the force could be formatted like Remnant in FNAF, where characters are separated by how powerful they are, and abilities are given to characters in each level based on if at least 3 characters of that level have that ability (if something like this actually happened for Star Wars it would probably have to be more than 3). This might be much easier than either linking to the whole page or painstakingly going through everything each character appears in and getting evidence for every ability. The only downside of this is that there will still be exceptions to this (such as the examples for nonstandard force abilities in the Q&A section of the OP), but that could be handled on a case by case basis.
Maybe instead of only giving a baseline of abilities and then listing additional, stronger powers, usage of the force could be formatted like Remnant in FNAF, where characters are separated by how powerful they are, and abilities are given to characters in each level based on if at least 3 characters of that level have that ability (if something like this actually happened for Star Wars it would probably have to be more than 3). This might be much easier than either linking to the whole page or painstakingly going through everything each character appears in and getting evidence for every ability. The only downside of this is that there will still be exceptions to this (such as the examples for nonstandard force abilities in the Q&A section of the OP), but that could be handled on a case by case basis.
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #58
No... I've said this a few times in the CRT. The force powers tab is just a general indexing list of force powers and their explanations. The force sensitive tab is what each character will gain upon being indexed.
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #59
The only ones left out are untrained sensitives (who will not be altered at the moment) and beings that are in the middle ground like Kylo Ren. The next crt will solve Kylo Ren's problem and the problem of normal untrained sensitives I will only do if necessary.
OrangeFR
Username Only- 1,731
- 1,041
Okay, sorry I probably should have taken out the first part cuz the message was mainly about my suggestion. IDK why I kept it in when I knew the answer to that question.
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #61
Many things are basic to sensitives, and at a sufficiently trained level (Jedi/Sith) most powers are the same. Only a few are considered something exclusive like Force Echo and abilities aligned to one side of the force.
And even then, the force is not something of power, of a stronger character being capable of someone weaker.
Although Yoda is "stronger" than Qui-Gon Jinn and can do things like neutralize Force Lighting with his hands, Yoda had to learn from Qui-Gon Jinn how to become a spirit of the force.
Or the Force Lighting itself, which is not about power but how deep someone is in the dark side.
I don't think this kind of formatting would be better than classifying it this way.
TegamiBachi25
He/Him- 1,976
- 606
Canon Palpatine should have force drain since he could drain rey and kylo in ROS. Obviously, canon force drain isn't as powerful as Legends, but he should have it, along with the Canon Son and Father (if they ever get profiles), since both would upscale from being stronger than Palpatine
Maybe add that force drain should be only for Canon Palps, Son, and Father?
Maybe add that force drain should be only for Canon Palps, Son, and Father?
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #63
A canon novel talks about the Siths in general sometimes doing this. But I've already done the CRT and adding anything new will require reconfirmation from the entire staff again.
- 12,494
- 16,894
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #65
I didn't understand.
But if you're wondering about it, here it is. But the novel is like 400 pages long, finding exactly that page will be annoying.
- 12,494
- 16,894
Pg. 164I didn't understand.
But if you're wondering about it, here it is. But the novel is like 400 pages long, finding exactly that page will be annoying.
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #67
Geez, thanks.
I will add this to the sandbox of the next crt.
- 12,494
- 16,894
You can add it here. I accept it directly.
And I can simply: @FinePoint @Theglassman12 @DarkDragonMedeus a simple extra addition. Sith Lords can drain force in canon;
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #69
Ok, I'll add it. In the force powers and siths tab.
Thanks for pinging them, maybe @DarkDragonMedeus and @Theglassman12 will change the neutral vote.
Last edited:
- 34,752
- 42,217
Everything else looks pretty good to me now.
OrangeFR
Username Only- 1,731
- 1,041
Alright then, thanks. That makes sense.
- 21,714
- 13,665
force drain from the sith looks fine to me.
- 9,229
- 5,677
- Thread starter
- #73
With that in mind, everything got 3 votes to be added.
DDM came back to agree on the Nature of Force stuff, and Glass, DDM, and Lephyr agreed on the force drain. This can be closed, I'll apply it.
Thank you for your time, and may the force be with you.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
