• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Custom Death Battle post-fight analysis workshop

Messages
3,108
Reaction score
3,544
More or less what it says on the tin, in the style of what you could imagine the Death Battle crew doing. I'm also making this as an expansion of both my custom previews thread AND my old end puns thread.

EDIT (for people who want the common equipment):

Order up:

cf285fb32a296056f1921433716aae70f65c87b8.png


(5-Category version):

be3800c13f621922341c72588af13a8eb2f594ac.png


(Who wins? Who loses?)

de7f82e437536770f8168335908822f143d025f9.png


(Winner bar):

29fb36b4be954846db08e99158cfd9d9d0618334.png


Will Edit OP with this post. 1 moment.

Allow me to use Mumkhar vs Zoda as an example:

091471ab6536eda6570a82e9539f1d074bd490fb.png

3d1fac5e145ecbcfd4c946720106145122589508.png

Boomstick: "Wait, face units aren't lactose intolerant, are they? What was that about removed organs?"

Wiz: "...Topic for another time, Boomstick... eh, in what actually matters, while Zoda's level of raw power with the Reactor Might was alarming (MORE than capable of leaving his opponent in a wreckage if given the opportunity), the flexibility of Mechon technology allowed Mumkhar and Metal Face to carve out a win more often than not. We elected to break this down into four categories, starting with Power."

35a804b2ca3b812f831d2d525495a789574a2f4f.png

Boomstick: "Yeah, we weren't joshing when we mentioned how powerful those Reactor Mights are on paper! Ol' Metal may be able to threaten towns and cities, whilst boxing with what remains of the Monado, but Zoda surviving inside that Dark Matter reactor that created a galaxy-spanning blast was insane! Surely that alone would have netted our ice-cream loving purple hulk a win, right?"

CORNER BOX: "While there are versions of this fight that would give Mumkhar the power advantage if allowing for scaling via Project X Zone's interpretation of KOS-MOS from Xenosaga, it's questionable which version of her scaling would be applied here. The viability of Xenosaga III's continuity is shaky enough as is..."

Wiz: "In some circumstances, sure, but the devil is in the details when discussing how that overlaps with other categories such as Speed. Not only do the faced Mechon have the ability to travel the length of the Bionis and Mechonis in a mere few hours, but after the incident outside the Colony 6 mines when Shulk brute-forced Monado I into the face armour (a scenario that is flagrantly unreliable), the repairs were performed by Vanea, who explicitly tipped-off Fiora about light-speed travel being something the Machina can perform with their technology*. Compare this to Zoda's Death Anchor, who without assistance, caps out at around Mach 3... around 273,000x slower."

*CORNER BOX: "It doesn't really make logical sense for Machina scientists like Vanea or Linada to specify 'light speed', if they didn't have access to technology that allowed for that level of speed."

Boomstick: "Oof! But wait, isn't this without the Reactor Mights? Haven't those things been shown to close speed gaps in a jiffy?"

Wiz: "Yes and no. While it's true that the way the Reactor Mights interact with the technology of the F-Zero series allows for interstellar travel, are we really so pernicious enough to imply Zoda could find one of these mediums in the middle of a zero-sum fight? And even if you want to argue that Metal Face's own speed scaling shouldn't be taken so literally, it's still worth noting the lightning he's dodged from Alvis's pet Telethia - a being capable of reading the mind. That, and it's explicitly stated that organic matter could still be found in the Mechon central nerve units, despite the re-configuring of Homs bodies to facilitate the Faces."

Boomstick: "Yep, and this is one of the areas where researching this matchup kinda surprised us, alongside intelligence - where Zoda... is kind of a moron with a Bazooka."

Wiz: "Short-sighted, childish, a constant history of strained or broken relationships with allies, all exemplified by the final fight with Black Shadow, where it took him too long to realize that the bull was holding out on him*. Meanwhile Mumkhar, whilst not exactly some exemplary genius himself, is adept at getting into the heads of people smarter than him, even bragging about his own memory of who is who. Those too eager to engage the Mechon and a likely mob at his beck and call is exactly the kind of fight Mumkhar would excel at, whilst tracks with 40 racers like what Zoda has to deal with have been an... inconsistent endeavour for the purple hulk."

*CORNER BOX: "Notice the number of Reactor Mights in that scene. This, and Black Shadow has worked around power discrepancies similar to this before, simply on a count of the Black Bull's general build and structure."

Boomstick: "And that is where we come to our final category! And not only is the number of hax and resistances at Mumkhar's disposal his final advantage, it even cuts into how much Zoda's raw power really matters, believe it or not!"

Wiz: "The Mechon's ability to decompose living tissue and inflict poison upon a then-unshackled vessel of Zanza in Arglas proves Mumkhar's ability to scam wins he has no business taking, as well as the ability to stun large crowds through his ranged options, making it well within his means to camp out what advantages Zoda may have with the Death Anchor and Reactor Mights. This poison affliction is something that Zoda has basically no answer for, meaning that he'd get worn down in an attempt to swat his opponent out of the sky. By comparison, the only notable thing that Zoda has outside of the Death Anchor is brute force, and an ability to manipulate memories... hardly a factor for Mumkhar in a fight like this, when spiting Dunban seems to be his one drive in life. Hell, Zoda's misuse of his power to implant or revise memories is what got Ryu Suzaku reunited with Haruka in the first place."

Boomstick: "You'd expect the Reactor Mights to do a lot of good here! But unfortunately for Zoda specifically, it's not the first time even one of those snitches has attempted to take him over*. I mean, sure, face units have experienced fatigue before (just look at Fiora), this doesn't apply to Mumkhar by any stretch of the imagination. Hell, MK Ultra over here has had to deal with the defences of Prison Island bypassing what defences he thought he had - and it's only led to him getting back up more pissed off than hurt."

*CORNER BOX: "Keep in mind, this is just one singular Reactor Might, meanwhile the blast from the Dark Matter Reactor is better substantiated by all six of the Reactor Mights being in close proximity."

*CORNER BOX (2): "It's tempting to call a higher-tiered Zoda driven by a Reactor Might an outlier, but in actuality, it's more accurate to just mention that Ryu Suzaku and Falcon have better control over the Reactor Mights than Zoda does, with better training."


Wiz: "All of this means that Zoda does not have consistent access to the closest thing we could call a win condition for him in this fight, at the risk of same dragging on long enough for the power of the Reactor Might recoiling on him. And while it's apt to point out scenarios where Mumkhar has to win that proverbial neutral several times, given the tools at his disposal, it's not unreasonable to imagine him doing so in half of these cases. At Zoda's best, he was certainly a high hurdle for Mumkhar to overcome, but the first Face Mechon's blazing speed, poison inducement and greater tactical acumen led to one race Zoda couldn't bring himself to finish."

Boomstick: "Wipe that scar off your face, Zoda! The podium isn't the claw of the issue!"

Wiz: "The winner is Metal Face."


9ef6497c3205cc95b72fc330903a1e93369d428a.gif
 
Last edited:
Huh, well might as well try sth. Not gonna use all templates tho.

Cell vs Metal Sonic

https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/1303323199286542356/1370149310091624548/DBMatch27-1.png?ex=681e727b&is=681d20fb&hm=3b4e3eb41372a1c94b9ddf6e04c10f30b011712877fc4561958cc40113b7f50a&

Boomstick: Cell might have been Perfect, but Metal was Perfect...er.

Wiz: The full scope of this battle can be seen in three categories; stats, experience and abilities. Lets start with stats.

B: Yeah, base Metal is more impressive than one might think, being able to match Sonic's speed which is comparable to Goku's speed since they both dodged meteors on ships moving at way faster than light, what are the odds. Metal and his shields can also match power of a single Chaos Emerald, that have enough power to obliterate stars. However, Metal probably isn't consistently matching Cell's Solar System destroying power on his own.

W: However, this is not the full potential of either characters.
Popup: Metal Sonic can be argued to be much stronger and faster at base forms, with Sonic restoring spacetime with his speed and possibly matching universe level power as well from Paradox Prism, surpassing standard level Cell.
B: Yeah, while its bit crazy, in both anime and even the manga, there are implications that Cell might be able to destroy the entire universe. A huge leap in power, can Metal at his best match that?

W: Yes he can, as both Metal Overlord and Super Neo Metal are comparable to other users of the 7 Chaos Emeralds, whose powers can not only destroy universes, but destroy timelines as well, affecting past, present and future, such as Solaris and Time Eater.

B: These timeline shenanigans also means that at his peak, Metal can keep pace with power that can alter the past, damn. Even if the Dragon Ball universe is larger than a normal universe, there is no evidence that Cell could destroy timelines.
P: Cell could be stronger via feats from Dragon Ball GT, but even that isn't enough to match full potential of Chaos Emeralds. Likewise any use of spin-offs would allow Metal to get similar levels of power, if not more.
W: So while Cell could match Metal, he couldn't match the full power of the Emeralds, ultimately giving Metal the edge in stats.

B: But Cell definitely has the edge in experience. Having been created from skills of multiple master martial artists, Cell has decades worth of experience in his blood, and he is able to match them in fight well. Metal... kinda is a jobbericus maximus.

W: Even with Metal's copy ability allowing him to match intelligence from opponents, he rarely has managed to out skill opponents without resorting to raw power.
P: Metal's numerous losses outside of Sonic have been result of characters teaming up against them. Metal was shown to be comparable to Shadow in 1v1 fight as well.
B: Now, Sonic himself actually showcases a lot of natural skill that can match experienced foes despite all odds. You'd think that Metal could match that but ahh no, not really. In fact, he keeps losing to Sonic despite the many advantages he should have over him. Metal is simply not him.

W: Experience would help Cell to defeat Metal, if he had abilities that allowed him to counter Metal's raw stats, but Cell doesn't possess abilities to overcome Metal's.

B: Both of them share some abilities like energy blasts , creating shields and using telekinesis, but Cell lacks abilities that would guarantee him a win.

W: Cell's Ki attacks are likely far more destructive than Metal's, but they lack the power to actually overcome Metal's power. Destroying the planet they are on wouldn't quite matter against Metal's Super forms.

B: Cell's Solar Flare and ability to spawn mini-mes also would mostly serve to distract Metal, not be able to surpass him. Worst of all, its actually Metal who would have far better time to match Cell's powers.
P: Martial artists have been shown to be able to mimic techniques by simple witnessing them ever since Dragon Ball. However, even if Cell could copy Chaos Control, Metal himself would not be vulnerable to it thanks to Shadow's biodata.
W: Metal's copycat ability allows him to copy even weirder powers like Shadow's Chaos Control, so Metal would be able to replicate Cell's moves, but that's not even the end of it. Neo Metal's upgraded copy abilities allow him to fully gain strength and intelligence of his opponents.

B: So even if Metal was weaker than Cell, he'd able to copy Cell's powers and even experience to match him. Even if Cell's regeneration is extremely potent, since Metal can copy Cell's Kamehameha, he'd have a surefire way to obliterate him for good. But Metal just has even more abilities as well. Chaos Control allows him to stop time, leaving Cell to be vulnerable to Metal's attacks.

W: Not to mention, Super Neo Metal's invulnerability is a huge boon as well. You need to have special powers to be able to overcome it, but Cell doesn't have abilities to do that. Making Super Neo Metal effectively unaffected by Cell's attacks. Meaning Metal has big advantage in abilities as well.
P: Shadow was able to revert Metal's Super Neo form. However, he utilized Chaos energy and attacked Metal when he was off guard, making it incredibly hard for Cell to mimic that, if he even could copy Chaos energy like that in an actual fight reliably.
W: Cell truly was the perfect warrior of his time, but he simply did not have stats or abilities to match Metal's more powerful Super forms, having more experience and skill simply wasn't enough to overcome that.

B: Metal truly showed what he was made of.

W: The winner is Metal Sonic

CELL
+More powerful than base Metal
+More experienced and skilled
+More destructive energy attacks
-Weaker and slower than Metal's Super forms
-Lacks useful abilities to overcome Metal's own
-Can't bypass Super forms invulnerability

METAL SONIC
+Faster and more powerful with Super forms
+More useful abilities
+Can copy advantages Cell could have
+Super form negates physical damage
-Weaker than Cell at base form
-Has lost despite having statistical odds in his favor
 
I'll give this a try

raiden_vs_2b__metal_gear_rising_vs_nier_automata__by_zelrom_dhqnblj-fullview.jpg



Boomstick: Wha-da-...how did that happen?

Wiz: On the surface and given Raiden's fearsome reputation and weapons, you would think he would take the victory. But if you look deeper, 2B was almost the perfect counter to him.

--Stats--

Boomstick:
Oh, I guess. Remember that metal gear Ray that Raiden blocked and threw? 2B blocked attacks from Engles then wielded its arm as a weapon. The arm alone is already several times the size of a Metal Gear Ray. Remember, to always lift with your legs.

Wiz: That's not even to mention that YoRHa can survive hits from Grun, a machine kaiju over 2 kilometers tall.

Boomstick: But physical strength isn't everything. 2B being stronger isn't going to matter if Raiden can just blitz her.

Wiz: But while Raiden has reacted to raindrops falling putting him around 3% the speed of light...

Boomstick: 2B has reacted to light itself, even out running EMP waves. She really put work in those Glutes.

Wiz: Even the non-combat models can do this. 10H was a healer model. Her pod was hitting her with its arm moments before it fired its laser. Given how short a pod's limb is compared to how thick the laser is-

Boomstick: Everything in this universe is thicc.

Wiz: I...uh....ahhhhh! Anyways, she'd have to have moved more than 10 times faster than light to get out of the way.

--Skill--

Boomstick:
2B was no push over either. You'd think Jack would take the edge. He's been killing trained soldiers as a kid for crying out loud. And nobody taught him how. He taught himself how to fight. And he's been fighting for almost 30 years by this point while 2B is only a few years old.

Wiz: But the same gimmick also helps with 2B's skills since she doesn't have to learn everything like a human does. She can have the knowledge uploaded into her head. But you know someone who did have to learn everything? Adam.

Boomstick: Adam learned how to walk, talk, and fight all moments after he was born because 2B and 9S attacked him. All he needed was to be hit by 2B once and he knew how to dodge her. And he kept growing smarter and develop new powers on the fly. All after he was just born.

Wiz: Raiden was self taught to mastery a few years after being born. Adam was self taught to mastery in seconds after being born.

Boomstick: Some people were just born nerds I guess.

Wiz: And despite them fighting twice and him learning and evolving more thanks to the other YoRHa, Adam could never beat 2B in a fight. And she kills him in a one on one duel. Seriously. That magnificent AI transcends anything we could possibly hope to accomplish. Wasted.

Boomstick: Ugh, talk about nerds.

--Weapons--

Wiz:
But there is one category Raiden can take the edge in. It's arsenal.

Boomstick: Yup. It's kinda hard to match the sword that can split you apart on a subatomic level.

Wiz: That's not to mention weapons like dystopia which generates and intense electromagnetic field. Or even Raiden's EMP grenades. Which pose even more of a threat to 2B because of her vulnerability to intense electromagnetic fields.

Boomstick: That's not even to mention's Raiden's greatest weapon. A pair of chaps that can match 2B's.

Wiz: Just stop.


--Abilities--

Wiz:
But the nail in the coffin was abilities. 2B not only had access to a frankly absurd number of abilities but had a counter to just about everything Raiden could throw at her.

Boomstick: Like her energy shields and energy constructs. No atoms to effect means hitting that thing with a high frequency blade was no different than hitting it with a run of the mill slab of steel. And he had no way of breaking through that thing

Wiz: Or his speed amps. Raiden could increase his speed and perception ten fold with blade and ripper mode. But 2B could match him with overclock. Or counter it with her time dilation field. Or use both and outpace him entirely. And it's not just defensive technology either. While her armament might not be as fearsome as the high frequency blade, they possessed unique qualities that made them troublesome to deal with. Like a laser that can go through solid objects. Or her hacking. While not her go to method, we see she is capable of it.

Boomstick: But 2B has something even BIGGER if all else fails.

Wiz: Don't...

Boomstick: Her big ass...self destruct.

Wiz: sigh

Boomstick: Number 4 took out Mount Ka'ala and fried everything in a 250 km radius. Way more powerful than anything Raiden's ever faced. If 2B really got desperate, she could just blow herself up.

Wiz: You done yet?

Boomstick: Yeah, I think I'm out.

--Conclusion--

Wiz:
Raiden was an extremely dangerous foe but 2B seemingly designed to handle him.

Boomstick: In this battle of the cheeks it was Raiden who got ****ed by 2B.

Wiz: AAAARRRGGGGGHHHH! The winner is 2B. Y-you know that's not even the word that's supposed to be in there.

Boomstick: It is in my head.
 
Wiz: Given how short a pod's limb is compared to how thick the laser is-

Boomstick: Everything in this universe is thicc.

Wiz: I...uh....ahhhhh! Anyways-
c866e65104c7fda515dfd1ca4f9df0fba53de84f.png


I mean this does come off as S3/4 'horny' Boomstick, so I can kinda picture it.

Also, I'm kinda curious how we're making weapons and arsenals two separate things (although this might just me my own analysis philosophy). IMO there's enough overlap between the two to just make it a tied category and not change anything.
 
Anyway, for my next idea (hopefully I'm well enough after this cold), I'm going to try for a non-Xeno MU:

7fa307dae590a52187446adb61fa1e273028c460.png

383cd88380c84ba59ac12da92a2b5e48e73d71d6.png

Boomstick: "When we said 'food items served from behind the counter', a young blonde was not what I had in mind..."

Wiz: "For as much as Chisato's cheeky demeanour and creative thinking would have allowed her to win most fights for her age, the powers of the Kabaneri were just too much for LycoReco's pride and joy to handle. The result was fairly clear cut by these categories, namely ones like Power:"

0fe98d45645efe331fd2e9fff37f938c6d9e16d2.png


Boomstick: "Sure, Chisato was relatively tough, taking a hit from that small Hatchback driven by Majima, or scaling to Takina bursting down that metal side wall. But being frank, that's nothing compared to the power of the Nue and White Blood! Hell, look at what Ikoma could do with that power! And that was before he let the Nue form fully take over."

CORNER BOX: "Mumei's status as a Kabaneri even allows her to take a durability advantage in most cases. That, and it's minor healing factor is not something Chisato's standard arsenal could do much about."

Wiz: "Meaning that, despite Mumei's propensity to grow tired during long, drawn-out fights, she would still win the battle of attrition. And given the Fused Colony that resulted from Biba's experiments - we'd be hard pressed to call this an outlier. Although, while it's indeed true that Mumei takes power, Speed is a little trickier to figure out."

Boomstick: "Guns, Wiz... that's what this boils down to. Sure, Chisato comes from a more sophisticated time, but generally speaking, any discrepancy here is minimal, especially given how creative both characters have been to make up for any shortfalls in their paces."

Wiz: "Needless to say, the safest bet is to say that both tie in Speed. Although some of that can be explained by Chisato's wanton uptake in Experience."

Boomstick: "Despite the narrative falling out, Chisato treats the checkups from Direct Attack like a day in the life! And she happens to be 5 years older than Mumei, who seems largely self-taught despite her con-man of a 'brother'... is that better than being an only child?"

Wiz: "Focus, Boomstick... we already retired that joke. Ahem, regardless, it is worth nothing how Chisato's greater formal training would allow her this one advantage, allowing her to hold out for a time, not to mention her analytical awareness. That said, while this would help her knowledge out in the field... it doesn't strictly help her applied skill and abilities. While both are greater than the sum of their parts, sure, often using their environments to their advantage, Mumei is far more likely to come prepared for the scenarios she's faced with - whereas Chisato... can sometimes be a bit too excitable for her own good. This also overlaps with our final category - Win Conditions."

Boomstick: "Little Chisato is a pacifist at heart, only assuming Majima dead if her friends were in danger, so even if she had something he we could construe as a 'win condition', it isn't immediately obvious. And it'd be especially hard to figure out what the HELL SHE'S SUPPOSED TO DO ABOUT A 100FT FUSED COLONY! SERIOUSLY, HOW THE F**K?!"

Wiz: "And it's not like Chisato could somehow exploit Mumei's tired state to take a win, as narratively, her Fused Colony form came from a version of that same tired state because of the White Blood. Even without Nue or the Fused Colony, Mumei has enough of the tactical acumen to exploit Chisato's artificial heart, or even using the genes of the Kabane to adapt defensively during the fight. Chisato may have been a top runner in this fight, but Mumei's greater Power, tactical fundamentals, and Kabaneri genetics ultimately tripped her up."

Boomstick: "I must have Recoiled from how much I'm coffee-ing up. I didn't realize Chisato had Kabaneri-a chance of winning that one!"

Wiz: "The winner is Mumei Hozumi."

f8ed84f523a06858ff3fa9bb1a207fbd7615222c.gif
 
Anyway, for my next idea (hopefully I'm well enough after this cold), I'm going to try for a non-Xeno MU:

7fa307dae590a52187446adb61fa1e273028c460.png

383cd88380c84ba59ac12da92a2b5e48e73d71d6.png

Boomstick: "When we said 'food items served from behind the counter', a young blonde was not what I had in mind..."

Wiz: "For as much as Chisato's cheeky demeanour and creative thinking would have allowed her to win most fights for her age, the powers of the Kabaneri were just too much for LycoReco's pride and joy to handle. The result was fairly clear cut by these categories, namely ones like Power:"

0fe98d45645efe331fd2e9fff37f938c6d9e16d2.png


Boomstick: "Sure, Chisato was relatively tough, taking a hit from that small Hatchback driven by Majima, or scaling to Takina bursting down that metal side wall. But being frank, that's nothing compared to the power of the Nue and White Blood! Hell, look at what Ikoma could do with that power! And that was before he let the Nue form fully take over."

CORNER BOX: "Mumei's status as a Kabaneri even allows her to take a durability advantage in most cases. That, and it's minor healing factor is not something Chisato's standard arsenal could do much about."

Wiz: "Meaning that, despite Mumei's propensity to grow tired during long, drawn-out fights, she would still win the battle of attrition. And given the Fused Colony that resulted from Biba's experiments - we'd be hard pressed to call this an outlier. Although, while it's indeed true that Mumei takes power, Speed is a little trickier to figure out."

Boomstick: "Guns, Wiz... that's what this boils down to. Sure, Chisato comes from a more sophisticated time, but generally speaking, any discrepancy here is minimal, especially given how creative both characters have been to make up for any shortfalls in their paces."

Wiz: "Needless to say, the safest bet is to say that both tie in Speed. Although some of that can be explained by Chisato's wanton uptake in Experience."

Boomstick: "Despite the narrative falling out, Chisato treats the checkups from Direct Attack like a day in the life! And she happens to be 5 years older than Mumei, who seems largely self-taught despite her con-man of a 'brother'... is that better than being an only child?"

Wiz: "Focus, Boomstick... we already retired that joke. Ahem, regardless, it is worth nothing how Chisato's greater formal training would allow her this one advantage, allowing her to hold out for a time, not to mention her analytical awareness. That said, while this would help her knowledge out in the field... it doesn't strictly help her applied skill and abilities. While both are greater than the sum of their parts, sure, often using their environments to their advantage, Mumei is far more likely to come prepared for the scenarios she's faced with - whereas Chisato... can sometimes be a bit too excitable for her own good. This also overlaps with our final category - Win Conditions."

Boomstick: "Little Chisato is a pacifist at heart, only assuming Majima dead if her friends were in danger, so even if she had something he we could construe as a 'win condition', it isn't immediately obvious. And it'd be especially hard to figure out what the HELL SHE'S SUPPOSED TO DO ABOUT A 100FT FUSED COLONY! SERIOUSLY, HOW THE F**K?!"

Wiz: "And it's not like Chisato could somehow exploit Mumei's tired state to take a win, as narratively, her Fused Colony form came from a version of that same tired state because of the White Blood. Even without Nue or the Fused Colony, Mumei has enough of the tactical acumen to exploit Chisato's artificial heart, or even using the genes of the Kabane to adapt defensively during the fight. Chisato may have been a top runner in this fight, but Mumei's greater Power, tactical fundamentals, and Kabaneri genetics ultimately tripped her up."

Boomstick: "I must have Recoiled from how much I'm coffee-ing up. I didn't realize Chisato had Kabaneri-a chance of winning that one!"

Wiz: "The winner is Mumei Hozumi."

f8ed84f523a06858ff3fa9bb1a207fbd7615222c.gif
Any chance to drop the format for the pics
 
Might take a crack at one of these for Layton vs Riddler. Any suggestions for categories outside of Intelligence?
 
Might take a crack at one of these for Layton vs Riddler. Any suggestions for categories outside of Intelligence?
Speed, win conditions, and... assistants, maybe?

I'd also throw creativity under that, but that might overlap too much with intelligence.
 
Speed, win conditions, and... assistants, maybe?

I'd also throw creativity under that, but that might overlap too much with intelligence.
Speed would probably get lumped into a general "physical stats" category, though given they should be pretty similar in power and durability, maybe a dedicated speed section is the way to go.

Maybe a skill category, since skill and intelligence should be different enough to qualify for different categories?
 
Also, I'm kinda curious how we're making weapons and arsenals two separate things (although this might just me my own analysis philosophy). IMO there's enough overlap between the two to just make it a tied category and not change anything.
Was kinda grasping at straws. Wanted to give him something.
 
Might take a crack at one of these for Layton vs Riddler. Any suggestions for categories outside of Intelligence?
I don't know how Layton is. But if that's Batman's Riddler then I'm guessing this is a battle of the geniuses.

So I think intelligence could be broken down into two categories that being scientific intelligence and strategic intelligence. Some geniuses will build more powerful traps because their understanding of physics is better. Like the Tony Stark's inventing mechs in a cave.

Then you have strategic intelligence. I'm imagining another Robert Downey Jr character in Holmes where he just lays out how the entire fight is going to go. Which one of them is better at going "I knew you were going to do that!"

The Riddler is an inventor. Sort of. He makes traps and stuff. Maybe compare who makes the more dangerous/powerful stuff.

Then maybe experience. Who has taken down more impressive opponents?
 
I don't know how Layton is. But if that's Batman's Riddler then I'm guessing this is a battle of the geniuses.

So I think intelligence could be broken down into two categories that being scientific intelligence and strategic intelligence. Some geniuses will build more powerful traps because their understanding of physics is better. Like the Tony Stark's inventing mechs in a cave.

Then you have strategic intelligence. I'm imagining another Robert Downey Jr character in Holmes where he just lays out how the entire fight is going to go. Which one of them is better at going "I knew you were going to do that!"

The Riddler is an inventor. Sort of. He makes traps and stuff. Maybe compare who makes the more dangerous/powerful stuff.

Then maybe experience. Who has taken down more impressive opponents?
This is Batman's Riddler, yes.

Not an absolute authority on Riddler, but preliminary research isn't looking good for Edward. The nature of Death Battle forbids prior knowledge or prep time, something which screws over Riddler much more than it does Layton. Throw on the Hint Coins on top of that, of which Layton can carry up to 300 at a time, and Layton should have the intellect advantage pretty solidly in the context of a Death Battle.
 
This is Batman's Riddler, yes.

Not an absolute authority on Riddler, but preliminary research isn't looking good for Edward. The nature of Death Battle forbids prior knowledge or prep time, something which screws over Riddler much more than it does Layton. Throw on the Hint Coins on top of that, of which Layton can carry up to 300 at a time, and Layton should have the intellect advantage pretty solidly in the context of a Death Battle.

Light vs Columbo is a due MU this 'season'. Depends how that's formatted, and if the cast will allow for that.
 
Anyone more knowledgeable on Riddler care to weigh in on his stats? I know that he's frequently portrayed as Batman's inferior in stats and combat skill, so he shouldn't scale to Batman's best feats (at least, not fully).
 
The answer is going to depend on which Riddler you want to go with. Some are smarter than others and some are better fighters than others.

I'm not familiar with his comic counterpart. But in movies and cartoons he creates Jigsaw-level traps. Sometimes exploiting things in the environment. Sometimes out of the blue. You just escape by solving the riddle instead of tearing out your eye.

The one that would probably be most impressive would be the Riddler from 2004's The Batman. He was known for creating scifi equipment even beyond Batman's accomplishments. His most impressive invention was a sticker you could put on your forehead that gave you supercomputer level brain power. Demonstrated, a man with it read through a dictionary-thick physics book in minutes, literally just flipping through the pages, and could recall the contents with word for word accuracy. He even created his own I guess you could call it an air vehicle. A small pod. 4 rocket engines. It flew across the city, swooped up Batman, then flew back to him.

Also while many other verse's Riddler traps are room or even building large, The Batman's Riddler often involved the whole city. In a competition with Penguin and Joker to see who could unmask Batman first, Riddler remotely controlled every electronic device (minus Batman's) in the city, turning lights on and off, monitoring security cameras, controlling trains, traffic lights, a drawbridge, and construction equipment.

And on top of all that, he could match fists with the Batman. He still prefers tech-based tricks but he has lasted in battle against Batman.
 
Also while many other verse's Riddler traps are room or even building large, The Batman's Riddler often involved the whole city. In a competition with Penguin and Joker to see who could unmask Batman first, Riddler remotely controlled every electronic device (minus Batman's) in the city, turning lights on and off, monitoring security cameras, controlling trains, traffic lights, a drawbridge, and construction equipment.
Cheers for the input, this was very helpful! This part in particular is intriguing to me, since Layton has solved city-spanning mysteries before. Without spoiling much on Layton, that's kind of a recurring element in the series, especially the original trilogy.

Everything I'm researching about this matchup just makes me like it more.
 
bump

Although I am brainstorming a certain Xeno vs GL MU in the wake of Simon vs Kyle, so stay tuned for that.
 
Not quite the GL MU I was thinking of, but consider it an appetiser for the moment (been a little while since I've been in this thread):

3da08322ba00813b78edd26c609d68139ee06213.png

458713759193acbafc56528a23764759cb1b1038.png


Boomstick: "You call that a murder? Eh, that was pretty... Lin-wristed"

Wiz: "Looking at this matchup across the board was more than decently involved, and while the winner of this bout wasn't all that surprising, the margins were fairly tight. To get one thing out of the way before we address the main categories of this fight, we need to address the nature of the Mims and Disassembly Drones."

Boomstick: "While it's true that both series characters have their own form of Project Phoenix-style immortality, just one round of this would fall under BFR. We wouldn't be able to declare a proper winner if we let this factor distract us."

Wiz: "Therefore, the first 'death', so to speak, is determined by these five categories - beginning with Power. Scaling Lin to Luxaar and the Vita, and N to the likes of Cyn and Uzi's use of the Absolute Solver, there isn't a hellish discrepancy to be found here. What IS interesting, however, are interpretations of both character higher potential from that planetary base, and under what circumstances these could be surmised."

e03b9b246e3209db1cc52070654c4413d4289ff4.png


Boomstick: "Yep! That black hole that Cyn maintained was ultimately a result of the Absolute Solver and similar technology, meanwhile the forces that the Ganglion and Luxaar managed were said to domineer several galaxies! Depending on how you construe both of those facts, Lin WOULD take the edge here... were it not for her alarm at the fact, and the planet bust her species were forced to run from."

Wiz: "Well... that's partly true, there's also the recontextualization of Earth's destruction as an alleged universe bust to consider. That said, when taking into account Elma's behaviour as an unreliable narrator and Void's ignorance, the chances of Lin alone, let alone other crew members of the White Whale and NLA is questionable... not to mention the outlier this would lead to. Meanwhile, N fighting on par with Uzi in the fight against Cyn is much more visibly noticeable - even if N would come out the other end weaker than Lin when taking both peaks at face value. For our purposes, the safest bet is to just say they tie in power."

Boomstick: "Not to worry for our little hen... get it, because they 'Koo'?"

Wiz: "Focus, Boomstick..."

Boomstick: "...Alright, fine... looks like I'll have to be as brisk as her own pace, because as it turns out, she takes Speed pretty handily! Around 3-6 million times faster than light, given the two years the White Whale spent in space, and the Skells that scale to it*. Sure, the rocket that N piloted could achieve something semi-relative to that, but that's with a lot of assumptions about what he was driving, which is... unstable enough as it is, especially when considering the advanced nature of the Skells by comparison."

*CORNER BOX: "Even if you want to make the argument that the White Whale's journey did not span the -exact- same Galaxy or portion of Samaar as what the Ma-non were describing, given the distance between the destroyed earth that the White Whale outran, and where Mira is supposed to be, it's logical to assume these speeds are possible."

Wiz: "With that contemplated, it's unlikely N would be able to so much as catch Lin, especially from the comfort of a Skell. And even if you're thinking that the most speed-focused models such as Hraesvelg isn't something she'd liberally have access to - keep in mind that even the rank-and-file Skells were able to keep ahead of the White Whale, and the forces that could catch up to it. This becomes especially interesting when mulling over our next two categories: Experience and Intelligence."

Boomstick: "To cut a long story short - the technology of JCJenson that the Disassembly Drones run on mean that N would likely take an experience advantage (after all, Lin is only a 13 year-old girl). That SAID, this doesn't strictly translate to smarts... the drones are pretty bull-headed at the best of times, whilst Lin is out here putting food on the table through her know-how about Skells, something a little girl her age isn't generally known for."

Wiz: "And while it's true that the worst of her mistakes are particularly clumsy - she is better than her mistakes at the end of the day. Take, for example, the time she helped develop a superweapon capable of cleaving open Ganglion armour using alternate materials, such which was unfamiliar to most engineers in NLA due to the nature of Mira at the time. Lin not only takes the intelligence advantage, but also our final category: Counters."

Boomstick: "Now, much like Power, you'd expect this category to be relatively well contested, right? What with both having healing factors to fall back on, and other weird tricks... Well, if this matchup was going to surprise us anywhere, it's here, actually! Sure, N has a metric shitton of weapons to throw around, some of which could annoy Lin for a while - but not only are a lot of them bog-standard when getting down to brass tacks, Lin had just the right kind of answers for most of them and more anyway!"

Wiz: "A lot of N's standard kit is stonewalled by arts such as Shield Wall or passives like Stand Strong. But most importantly - the Disassembly Drones' most applicable win condition (the information manipulation and virus uploading) is not only NOT within N's personality to actually use (as the main series does not show him using this kind of thing once despite his cohorts using the same), but Mim technology (despite being electronic), isn't strictly computerized*. Remember: Mims were there explicitly to replicate the nature of the human body to the best of it's ability - and it's literally a key plot point that what runs life on Mira was not the lifehold itself (the lie found out by Elma after the White Whale had long since crashed), but an unknowing force related to Mira itself - with even that interpreted as 'Impure' by Telethia, the Endbringer falling under this umbrella."

*CORNER BOX: "While it is technically true that what fellow users of hacking such as J and Cyn have hacked non-sentient doors before, not only does this not rebuke the idea that N would be unwilling to use the technology - a large proportion of the doors that were hacked into were computerized - unlike what Mims happen to run on."

Boomstick: "I'll say! Not to mention how infamously unstable the Disassembly Drones even are - yet they've been able to resist virus uploading to some extent. Trying to stick that in a near-perfect recreation of the human body created by the condemned of a pissed-off misanthrope and double agent? Forgettaboutit..."

Wiz: "Besides, just because Lin's offensive options weren't as abundant doesn't mean that they weren't there. Not only does the use of a Skell and potential ejection give her a sort of proto-second life, but arts such as Reality Rift and Supershield give her a viable method of disrupting or outright reflecting what few hits N could potentially work in - not that her speed advantage wasn't doing most of that anyway. And with a well-timed Overdrive, it's possible for her to spam these options for far longer than that. Serial Designation N may have hung in there for a fair while, but Lin's blinding speed, gifted intelligence and workable counters eventually sent this worker back to the production line."

Boomstick: "I won't drone on any longer - cos' it looks like Lin had just about Koo the Roost!"

Wiz: "The winner is Lin Lee Koo."


5d3e9b0149886dd38406d9f9ce954ee817cd0b5b.gif
 
you got the template for this?

9ef6497c3205cc95b72fc330903a1e93369d428a.gif

Also how you post the images without issue? you hosting them somewhere without expiring?
 
you got the template for this?

9ef6497c3205cc95b72fc330903a1e93369d428a.gif

Also how you post the images without issue? you hosting them somewhere without expiring?

Winner plate is updated in the OP, and the Door transition is found here:



Both of these depend on whichever editing software you use (just make sure it has a Chroma Keyer setting of some description). To convert the mp4 output to GIF, I recommend ezgif.

To then upload it, you can either:

A) Post it to any channel on Discord (I have a cubbyhole channel in my own server), click 'open in browser', and then use either archive.ph or archive.is (or whatever you prefer) to archive the link it generates, right-click the result, and then post the link into the insert image function.

OR B) Right-click the generated result in ezgif when it's generated/adjusted, and archive that link and do the same.

Shouldn't take you too long. If you're having issues or don't have editing software - DM me the clip you want me to use for your winner, and I'll get it sorted.
 
Ok, took a while to make the categories in photoshop editing, but here is my attempt at this, enjoy it

Boomstick: Rock Howard vs Jin Kazama!

Wiz: The The Wolf's Pedigree vs Lightning of Fate!

Boomstick: He's Wiz and I'm Boomstick.

Wiz: And it's our job to analyze their weapons, armor, and skills to find out who would win... a Death Battle.

maxresdefault.jpg


KO!

Boomstick
: He really lived up to his name of a Fallen Rock...or more accurately...he really died by his name...

Wiz: This match up had a lot to be going through, so in order to make it easier, we will break it down in 5 different categories

5c814b97c1f15aa59d8fa3e881cd26773a819aa2.webp


Strength

Boomstick
: When you look at strength, you would think Jin had more impressive displays of power, having the energy to create dimensions with a solar eclipse inside mixed with the scaling from other characters that are able to do similarly and overpowering levels of power that can create a constellation, as well as various ways to get stronger like empowered by their desire, get his muscles bigger, multiple boosts in his physicals and attacks in combination with the multiplying power of the transformations, Jin should take it with ease right?

Wiz: Not quite, considering Rock would scale from characters that would have destroyed the spacetime continuum of our world, which even characters like Geese to whom he should scale from, managed to defeat one of them in combat singlehandedly, making Jin numerous power increases unable to raise him anywhere near these high levels when the gap is so massive in scale, plus characters like Kukri also had a power to create a similar dimension with a star inside just like Jin, so Rock would have been able to handle somebody of this level

Speed

Boomstick
: As far as speed goes, both scale from characters who can react to satellite lasers and even actual light, so they were pretty even in that regard, at least when it comes to their base forms...once Jin utilizes his devil power and transformations, his speed will multiply to the point Rock wont even be able to keep up anymore with him, especially when you take in consideration Jin flight and superior ranged options, making it pretty unfair for Rock

Skill

Wiz
: But their skills in combat were fairly similar on the other hand, both were trained from a young age how to fight by skilled fighters like Terry and Heihachi, both use a mix of different fighting styles they learned, both won their respective martial art tournaments and both of them could defeat characters like Geese and Ogre, whom mastered all fighting styles on Earth! To say one was more skilled then the other was quite difficult, so the best way is to have them at a tie for skill

Abilities

Boomstick
: Thats why we had to take a look at their powers too, Rock had the ability to shoot ki projectiles, as well as use ki in various ways for other moves offensively and defensively, hell as Fallen Rock he could use his ki to telekinetically move others and even stop time itself!

Wiz: Unfortunately, Jin could do most of these as well with his lasers and own telekinesis and even much better in comparison. Same thing in regards to using his ki and other forms of energy like rage and heat, not to mention that...Jin...had a wider variety overall of powers from his devil and kazama powers

Boomstick: Like burning or freezing an opponent, nullifying energy attacks and paralyzing them with his electricity and even control actual lightning, absorbing their soul, becoming invisible, teleporting, going intangible, become invulnerable for short time, purify others and even negate the power of others like he did to the devil gene to himself and Kazuya to become normal humans!

Wiz: And while time stopping sounds like a huge game changer at a first glance...the gap in speed between them would make it too insignificant to matter if he cant use it, especially if Jin can just purify and get rid of his evil blood inherited from Geese genes like with the devil gene....thus winning by another huge edge in this category

Endurance

Wiz
: Which finally brings us down to our final category for their overall endurance....whom could outlast the other first...

Boomstick: Both of them are capable to keep fighting from day till night, however lesser characters then Jin are able to also fight for days, some can last being buried in gravevards for months or sealed underneath a temple to carry on their back without rest for whole decades! The Mishimas by themselves are very persistent son of a guns! Like how Heihachi and Kazuya kept going and going to their last breath inside a f*cking volcano, Kazuya even fought with Akuma shortly after winning the previously against his old man and managed to win that one as well!

Wiz: And when Jin faced Kazuya for their last time, after a fall from space during a raining thunder storm...he proven to his father...that his willpower...was greater....and thats without factoring his fast healing and brain damage levels of regeneration or that the devil gene provides the user with a limitless source of power either, nailing him his third and last category....

7d6602dab2cede2665a9a4d4ef338dbc03277fc1.webp


Wiz: Rock was a very talented and impressive fighter with his superior strength and matching skill against his opponent, but Jin massive speed, abilities and endurance advantages were too much for Rock deal with in the long run...

Boomstick: The fatal fangs of this wolf fury, just couldnt tekken care of these iron fists, from striking their lightning of fate upon their king of fighters...

Wiz: The winner is Jin Kazama

3650b9e0cfa243e793099ad95d72cfada85ca432.gif
 
Still working on the Layton vs Riddler analysis, just got to figure out how to convert it into a Death Battle post analysis. I ultimately settled on the categories of Physical Stats, Gadgets, Intelligence and Mindset.

General breakdown looks like this:

LAYTON:
+Physically stronger and tougher
+More skilled in direct combat
+Doesn't play his trump cards until absolutely necessary, giving Riddler less to work with. By contrast, Riddler will actively self-sabotage the fight by providing Layton with riddles and hints
+Hint Coins can help him best Riddler's tricks and traps...
=...though even without them, his intelligence should be about on par with Riddler's
=Comparable speed
-Far less ruthless

RIDDLER:
+Better gadgets
+Far more ruthless...
-...but mindset means he wouldn't go for the kill immediately
=Comparable speed
=Comparable intelligence
-Far more reliant on prep time and prior knowledge
-Physically weaker

Overall, very close, but I'm inclined to believe Layton should take it.
 
Still working on the Layton vs Riddler analysis, just got to figure out how to convert it into a Death Battle post analysis. I ultimately settled on the categories of Physical Stats, Gadgets, Intelligence and Mindset.

General breakdown looks like this:

LAYTON:
+Physically stronger and tougher
+More skilled in direct combat
+Doesn't play his trump cards until absolutely necessary, giving Riddler less to work with. By contrast, Riddler will actively self-sabotage the fight by providing Layton with riddles and hints
+Hint Coins can help him best Riddler's tricks and traps...
=...though even without them, his intelligence should be about on par with Riddler's
=Comparable speed
-Far less ruthless

RIDDLER:
+Better gadgets
+Far more ruthless...
-...but mindset means he wouldn't go for the kill immediately
=Comparable speed
=Comparable intelligence
-Far more reliant on prep time and prior knowledge
-Physically weaker

Overall, very close, but I'm inclined to believe Layton should take it.
Been a little while. Erstwhile I'm brainstorming an MU with about 7-8 different categories, and I might put it in my own 'Xeno VS' style of categories, so stay tuned for that.

btw @Peter_"Quicksilver"_Maximoff where are you up to on your MU? Or did it skip your mind?
 
Been a little while. Erstwhile I'm brainstorming an MU with about 7-8 different categories, and I might put it in my own 'Xeno VS' style of categories, so stay tuned for that.

btw @Peter_"Quicksilver"_Maximoff where are you up to on your MU? Or did it skip your mind?
Changed my mind on the MU. Going a different route. Plus, life is lifing rn, so i have other things on my mind atm lol
 
Death-Battle-4.png


I'm not good enough with Adobe to use the Category render, and i'm not even that good to making up dialogues for Wiz and Boomstick.

Maybe i will try later with some help of ChatGPT (i know it may be lazy but english its not my native language).
 
Back
Top