• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

TWD Overhaul CRT Part 1

Messages
344
Reaction score
142
The preface

Before I start, I'd like to say why I don't want to scale these feats from Daryl Dixon series to rest of characters.

1. As I said in this thread, I think Daryl should have a separate key for his spin-off
Thread 'TWD return to 9-B? Or something else?' https://vsbattles.com/threads/twd-return-to-9-b-or-something-else.174429/

2. I will also insist on a key (spin-off) for Maggie and Negan. Dead City S2 is coming out soon. So why do I want these characters to have separate keys for the spin-offs? Because these spin-offs are happening or will happen in future seasons at some time interval from main series. characters become more experienced and stronger. Budget for spin-offs is increasing, quality is getting better and number of action scenes is increasing. Directors need to surprise the audience somehow and keep their attention. Accordingly, new types of walkers appear in spin-offs such as: walker king (Dead City), stone walker (The Ones Who Live), or super walkers (Daryl Dixon). More action scenes and fights with main characters. More superhuman level moments. Let's say we get wall level feat from Daryl Dixon season 3 or Dead City season 2, but we won't be able to use them because main series has a bunch of anti-feats in it, although there aren' in new spin-offs. That's not right for me.
Current TWD spin-offs are not like main TWD series. I don't want to scale feats from spin-offs to main series.

So TWD main series needs AP and speed feats

[Attack Potency]

Current TWD Street level+ scaling to high end of breaking bones is not very correct and thread of downgrading has already been raised.

Accepted calcs

(Additionally)

(3:21) Rick busted doors open



(0:06) Beta busted door open

What should require thus much energy

4,5 KJ range for TWD. Who scales?

Beta, Post-Timeskip Daryl, Post and Pre-Timeskip Negan (Post-Timeskip Daryl traded blows with Carver)

(0:52) Post-Timeskip Negan can withstand blows from Carver and Daryl

(3:42)


Pre-Timeskip Negan comporable, if not stronger than his Post-Timeskip version and can harm those, who can harm him (Rick and Negan fights)

continue scaling chain: Rick Grimes Pre CRM, Merle Dixon (traded blows with Daryl and knocked down Rick), Glene (2:56 can harm Merle fight headbutt and withstand his blows)

Abraham (0:30 traded blows with Glenn)

Governor, Shane, Michonne (0:21 can harm Merle, Fight and withstand blows from Governor, (4:15) Knocked out Rick with one blow)

Jesus Paul Rovia, Dwight

(I'm not touching on Carl, Maggie, and Morgan because these profiles need more reworking (adding new keys, abilities). I would like them to be deleted. It was easier for me to create them from scratch with correct stats)

Post CRM Rick should be At least Street level. Since he must be get stronger after CRM training


(0:37) And can harm Pearl Thorne

(1:47) Who survived after massive explosion

[Speed]

Accepted calcs

Characters scales to Peak Human c/r speeds. Who scales: Rick Grimes Pre CRM, Negan Pre Post-Timeskip, Daryl Pre-Timeskip, Shane Walsh, Merle Dixon, Governor, Michonne, Glenn, Abraham

Who scales to At least Peak Human c/r speeds

Jesus Paul Rovia (shown be superior in speeds to Daryl and Rick. In their first meeting, he didn't give his best and didn't want to seriously hurt or kill them. Holding Back Jesus superior to enraged Morgan with bo staff, who should be stronger than his season 3 version, who traded blows with Rick


Post-Timeskip Daryl. Should be superior to his Pre-Timeskip version. Can keep up with Brandon Carver, who shown be massively superior to Negan and Maggie. Also Maggie can keep up with Leah Shaw in combat, who scales to Peak Human speed

Rick should be get stronger after CRM traning

And of course Beta (who can keep up with Post-Timeskip Daryl in combat, while not fighting at full power, because he wanted to find out from Daryl where the alpha's daughter was, not kill him)

Characters, who should scale to At least Peak Human combat and reaction speeds:

Paul Rovia, Post-Timeskip Daryl, Beta, Post CRM Rick

[Lifting Strenght]

Initially, I wanted to donwgrade LS of 90% characters to Athletic Human. But then I remembered Shane's neck breaking feat.

This scales 90% characters (who have profiles) to Peak Human LS

But......... We have goofy ahh anti-feat with vending machine (0:15) (curse the one who was author of this scene)
In defense against this anti-feat, I will say that in this episode Rick and Daryl went to look for supplies and food for Alexandria and as far as I remember they were very short of food and this problem was raised more than once and because of this they had to make a deal with a Hilltop where there was food. Well, Rick and Daryl might have been weakened due to lack of food? (God, it possible to think of a dumber excuse?)

Proposal 1
We are downgrading LS almost all characters to Athletic Human except Beta, who shown be have Peak Human LS. One of his feats where he lifted Laura and slammed her against a cell bar, causing her neck broke or crawled out of a grave (0:08)

Post-Timeskip Daryl should have At most Peak Human LS. Since he is weaker than Beta, but he can still push him (3:09 and 4:11)

Proposal 2

We accept my excuse for anti-feat or do we ignore this anti-feat? And 90% of characters have Peak Human LS (via scaling from Shane). Except Beta, who will have At least Peak Human LS (because he is way physically stronger than Daryl and Negan)
--------------
Regardless of that Spin-off Daryl and Codron should have Class 1 LS, since Daryl was able go break neck while being in weakened state (1:20)

SEASON 2. Daryl breaks guy neck with bow (5:08)

Daryl throws man throughs glass several meters away (2:47)

And in general spin-off Daryl is superior to his Post-Timeskip version

[Stamina]

Rick Grimes: Peak Human>>>At least Peak Human

So main feat for Rick's stamina remains how, being pierced by a rebar, he was able to free himself and travel a long distance. I want to dig into it a little bit.

Watch this scenes. They show approximately Rick's complete route after he was wounded.

Rick falls on rebar and pulls himself off it

Rick lost consciousness many times but regained consciousness.

And

3:37 (He was able to broke a wooden plank off a door in weakened state)

He arrives at bridge and shoots dynamite to blow it up. (1:12 he was able to kill walker)

he was pierced by a rebar, pulled himself out, could hold on and mount a horse, lost consciousness many times but regained consciousness, was able to knock out a wooden plank, traveled the some distance, was able to kill one walker and after that he was thrown by a shock wave of bridge explosion and he was still conscious and could move

Additionally. Jadis shot him and threw him off wall of Alexandria. He was held hostage by Jadis and Negan, but after Hilltop and the Kingdom came to the rescue, he could shot without visible signs of pain.
(0:22 2:07 2:19)

If all this is not superhuman stamina then I think that At least Peak Human should be okay

Beta: At least Peak Human>>>Superhuman

Beta may not pay attention to wounds and cuts
3:25

And

1:20

After he fell into the elevator shaft, he survived and was able to function without any medical assistance.

(4:11) During the fall, it could be heard that he hitting walls of shaft several times.

(I'm not using this feat to scale Beta's durability because this fall knocked him out indefinitely. It's better to use this feat for stamina)

Whisperers have a nomadic lifestyle, they are closer to primitive tribes and don't have modern usual amenities.

(0:26 and 1:10) Daryl stabbed two knives into Beta eyes, (note the length of knives) and later Beta smiled as he was eaten by walkers

[Abilities]

Rick Grimes: Rage Power>>>to
Limited Rage Power & Berserk Mode

I realized that current Rick's Rage Power ability is not exactly accurate.

During their stay in locked lab, Shane loses himself, but Rick, who understood that Shane could only make things worse and put his family in even greater danger, manages to overpower him, although in season 2, during their fight, it was shown that Shane is physically stronger than Rick

While, it has been difficult and dangerous for the whole group to be in the prison block

Rick lost himself after his wife died

And after that, he was able to kill Walkers alone in the prison block

Rick spends an unspecified amount of time in prison block killing walkers

When Glenn comes to calm Rick down, Rick attacks him

During Rick's (mad arc), he hears hallucinations. He spent the whole day killing walkers. I can't provide all scenes, but in seasons 3 and 4, there were many moments when even a few people with weapons found it difficult to be in prison blocks, while Rick was able to stay alone and clear prison block durning his berserk state

When Claimers attack Rick, Michonne and Carl. (2:29) One of claimers is about to r*pe Carl and Rick gets into a fight with Joe. But due to the fact that Rick did not eat much (during his travels with Michonne and Carl, they repeatedly had problems with food) and was weakened after being wounded in leg, which he received during the governor's attack on prison, he was overpowered and beaten by Joe. (2:56) But realizing that all his loved ones are in danger, he bites off Joe's throat. And later (3:41) He takes a knife and goes at fat one, despite the fact that claimer is holding Carl hostage and may kill him. Rick starts cutting fat one without noticing Carl

After his lover died and his son got shot

Rick lost it and went to take on hundreds of walkers by himself

After another unsuccessful escape attempt, during which he lost his arm. Rick realizes that he will not be able to escape from CRM and he will never see Michonne and his childrens again, he becomes angry and kills many Walkers>>>setting a record for series of killings of Walkers for whole history of Harvest Point

All of Rick's rage and berserk state appears in critical situations and moments or when he is experiencing strong emotions. And that's why I think Rick should have Limited Rage Power & Berserk Mode
 
Last edited:
I find it difficult to know what exactly is proposed by this CRT, I would ask that a greater effort be made to organize information in the future. As it is, this is sort of sprawling and unfocused.
He kicks a door and it opens. We don't even know if it was locked. Judging by the video it looks like it wasn't.

Slamming doors remains not a feat.

If you can find a way to calc it.

The AP section of this CRT has no meat to it. The feats either aren't feats or aren't calc'd (and I question if they can be calc'd). I would disagree with it all. The explosion thing is an actual feat but it has no value to it.

The speed section is mostly fine but doesn't provide any reasoning for "Post CRM Rick" to be considered on that level. "He should get stronger" doesn't mean anything.

For LS, Proposal 1 seems fine (the vending machine is, in my opinion, more conceivable as a feat than the breaking of necks; the latter has a more abstract relationship with LS). I want to ask what specific feat Beta has for being Peak Human. I find it unlikely he isn't, but the feats presented don't seem to place him there. I don't agree with scaling Daryl to Beta- he is obviously well inferior. Beta doesn't weigh enough to require Peak Human LS to push him.

Regarding stamina, "at least Peak Human" Rick Grimes is fine. I don't think anyone scales, at least not in the core series.

I think we should classify Rick's rage as either Rage Power or Berserk Mode (the two powers are practically identical, after all). I think Berserk Mode is more accurate, and would support it in an unlimited sense for Rick.
 
I find it difficult to know what exactly is proposed by this CRT, I would ask that a greater effort be made to organize information in the future. As it is, this is sort of sprawling and unfocused.

He kicks a door and it opens. We don't even know if it was locked. Judging by the video it looks like it wasn't.


Slamming doors remains not a feat.


If you can find a way to calc it.

The AP section of this CRT has no meat to it. The feats either aren't feats or aren't calc'd (and I question if they can be calc'd). I would disagree with it all. The explosion thing is an actual feat but it has no value to it.

The speed section is mostly fine but doesn't provide any reasoning for "Post CRM Rick" to be considered on that level. "He should get stronger" doesn't mean anything.

For LS, Proposal 1 seems fine (the vending machine is, in my opinion, more conceivable as a feat than the breaking of necks; the latter has a more abstract relationship with LS). I want to ask what specific feat Beta has for being Peak Human. I find it unlikely he isn't, but the feats presented don't seem to place him there. I don't agree with scaling Daryl to Beta- he is obviously well inferior. Beta doesn't weigh enough to require Peak Human LS to push him.

Regarding stamina, "at least Peak Human" Rick Grimes is fine. I don't think anyone scales, at least not in the core series.

I think we should classify Rick's rage as either Rage Power or Berserk Mode (the two powers are practically identical, after all). I think Berserk Mode is more accurate, and would support it in an unlimited sense for Rick.
About AP. This calcs was accepted. And characters scales to this



Pearl Thorne durability feat was calculated to Small Building level (outlier for TWD)
 
I find it difficult to know what exactly is proposed by this CRT, I would ask that a greater effort be made to organize information in the future. As it is, this is sort of sprawling and unfocused.

He kicks a door and it opens. We don't even know if it was locked. Judging by the video it looks like it wasn't.


Slamming doors remains not a feat.


If you can find a way to calc it.

The AP section of this CRT has no meat to it. The feats either aren't feats or aren't calc'd (and I question if they can be calc'd). I would disagree with it all. The explosion thing is an actual feat but it has no value to it.

The speed section is mostly fine but doesn't provide any reasoning for "Post CRM Rick" to be considered on that level. "He should get stronger" doesn't mean anything.

For LS, Proposal 1 seems fine (the vending machine is, in my opinion, more conceivable as a feat than the breaking of necks; the latter has a more abstract relationship with LS). I want to ask what specific feat Beta has for being Peak Human. I find it unlikely he isn't, but the feats presented don't seem to place him there. I don't agree with scaling Daryl to Beta- he is obviously well inferior. Beta doesn't weigh enough to require Peak Human LS to push him.

Regarding stamina, "at least Peak Human" Rick Grimes is fine. I don't think anyone scales, at least not in the core series.

I think we should classify Rick's rage as either Rage Power or Berserk Mode (the two powers are practically identical, after all). I think Berserk Mode is more accurate, and would support it in an unlimited sense for Rick.
Bump. AP of characters should be scale to this (accepted calcs)


And that about Daryl LS in spin-off? He can break necks and throw man through a glass several meters away (Feats are presented at the end of Lifting Strenght section). Daryl has no LS anti-feats in spin-off. Can only spin-off Daryl and Codron have Class 1 LS?
 
The AP of Beta scaling to these calcs is fine.

Daryl has no LS anti-feats in spin-off. Can only spin-off Daryl and Codron have Class 1 LS?
I'd wager he probably does in fact have some but I'm not familiar. For now I won't sign off on it because the show has demonstrated that it doesn't consider neck breaking to be related to LS. If he lifts something that weighs nearly a metric ton, we can talk.
 
The AP of Beta scaling to these calcs is fine.


I'd wager he probably does in fact have some but I'm not familiar. For now I won't sign off on it because the show has demonstrated that it doesn't consider neck breaking to be related to LS. If he lifts something that weighs nearly a metric ton, we can talk.
Yes, I agree with you. As more seasons 3 and 4 of Daryl Dixon are planned, there could potentially be anti-feats in them. I will point out in Notes on TWD main page that it is not worth scaling characters LS to Peak Human or Class 1 based on the neck breaking in this verse
 
Back
Top