- 1,902
- 409
- Thread starter
- #441
I've finished.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
DCAU - Superman Revisions
- Thread starter PapiSavitar5025
- Start date
- 1,902
- 409
- Thread starter
- #443
See if John wants some more input before closing.
Oh yeah Ant, I just wanted to ask something real quick. How do you decide which end of Calcs to use when given High, Mid, or Low-ends?
- 3,082
- 1,646
I'd like to keep this open so that getting input on the mega thread is easier.
- 165,058
- 71,911
Okay.
I don't decide that, our calc group members do. However, I suppose that they are evaluated on a case-by-case basis depending on which results that seem more warranted.
- 165,058
- 71,911
Okay. No problem. You can link to your new thread here after you have posted it.
- 1,902
- 409
- Thread starter
- #447
How are things coming along?
- 3,082
- 1,646
Slow
- 3,082
- 1,646
DCAU: Superman redirects a meteor
vsbattles.fandom.com
Here, though it hasn't been accepted yet it might be iffy to use.
So I'm still working on the draft but there are issues with these calcs that need immediate attention.
The top one uses a comet from a later episode (Little Girl Lost Part 2) instead of the Promethians meteor.
- 3,082
- 1,646
The calc currently on Superman's profile is incorrect given what I mentioned. It will need to be reevaluated.
- 165,058
- 71,911
Okay.
@Damage3245 @Spinosaurus75DinosaurFan @Armorchompy @Migue79
Would you be willing to re-evaluate these calculations please?
DCAU: Superman redirects a meteor
vsbattles.fandom.com
The Prometheon Meteor KE
vsbattles.fandom.com
- 1,902
- 409
- Thread starter
- #454
Bump
- 1,902
- 409
- Thread starter
- #455
Oh yeah, I forgot there was a short discussion (but generally agreed upon) that Superman had SoL Heat Vision thanks to it reflecting off mirrors, being comparable to Green Lantern Rings, and all that.
Would that be a fine addition to add or should we discuss it?
- 3,082
- 1,646
I'm rounding up everything, just like I said
This is rather important.Okay.
@Damage3245 @Spinosaurus75DinosaurFan @Armorchompy @Migue79
Would you be willing to re-evaluate these calculations please?
DCAU: Superman redirects a meteor
The Prometheon Meteor KE
- 165,058
- 71,911
It seems fine to me at least, but more input is obviously much preferable.
- 165,058
- 71,911
@Spinosaurus75DinosaurFan @Mr._Bambu @Therefir @DMUA @DemonGodMitchAubin @Jasonsith @Wokistan @ArmorchompyOkay.
@Damage3245 @Spinosaurus75DinosaurFan @Armorchompy @Migue79
Would you be willing to re-evaluate these calculations please?
DCAU: Superman redirects a meteor
The Prometheon Meteor KE
Would any of you be willing to handle this? Tell us here if you accept please.
- 165,058
- 71,911
In the meantime, can you specify what you think is wrong with the above-linked calculations, @JohnConquest1 ?
- 1,902
- 409
- Thread starter
- #460
Bump.
- 3,082
- 1,646
One of the images used as a basis for superman moving the asteroid, the image at the very top of the linked blog, is taken from an entirely different episode (Little Girl Lost Part 2) from the Promethian feat. At the end of said different episode Superman redirects a portion of a comet. Supergirl destroys the other section
- 165,058
- 71,911
Okay. That seems to make sense, but since most of our calc group members very unfortunately seem to usually ignore my notification messages to them, I think that you may have to ask for input via our calculation evaluation requests thread instead.
You can link to both the two calculations and the following post in this thread there if you wish.
You can link to both the two calculations and the following post in this thread there if you wish.
- 1,902
- 409
- Thread starter
- #463
Bump.
- 165,058
- 71,911
Has anybody here done this yet? You can mention that I sent you in conjunction if you wish.
- 3,082
- 1,646
Like I said when making the draft, spread a bit thin personally.
- 1,902
- 409
- Thread starter
- #467
Sorry this is completely irrelevant but I am absolutely terrible at navigating the site.
Do you have the link to the thread where I can request a feat calculation?
- 165,058
- 71,911
See here:
vsbattles.com
Calculation Evaluations (New forum)
This thread is intended for users to link to new blog post calculations, to relay them to the community, and have them evaluated by the calculation group, without contacting the members individually. To evaluate important off-site calculations, preferably copy them to blog posts in this wiki...
- 1,902
- 409
- Thread starter
- #469
I know it's been a while, but how's this going?
- 3,082
- 1,646
Juggling other things. Don't really have the time to focus on it myself.
- 165,058
- 71,911
@JohnConquest1 @PapiSavitar5025
Can you explain exactly what needs to be done here in a sufficiently elaborate manner please?
Can you explain exactly what needs to be done here in a sufficiently elaborate manner please?
- 1,902
- 409
- Thread starter
- #472
I think for now, in this specific discussion, everything that needed to be discussed has been. JohnConquest was making a large, verse-oriented CRT to tackle all that needs to regarding the DCAU. I think this is free to be closed, if you'd want to.
- 1,902
- 409
- Thread starter
- #474
Yeah, everything's been added that's been accepted.
- 3,082
- 1,646
- 1,902
- 409
- Thread starter
- #477
Right, so I've been looking further into DCAU Superman, believing we haven't covered everything. I just-so happened to be right! I also want to talk about other things first, but I'll save that after I list the new additions.
On this thread (Part 2) and this thread (Part 1) I will be asking you to go to numerous timestamps.
(1:00 - 1:24, Part 2) Superman pushes what seems to be a piece of the moon. The size of it seems to eclipse any other lifting strength feat we have on the profile. If someone could calc this, we may be looking at a serious upgrade.
(1:34 - 1:38, Part 2) Possible Shockwave Manipulation? Superman's stomp rattles the entire building and throws his shooters off-balance. You even see a ripple effect in the ground.
(2:37 - 2:49, Part 2) An addition I actually wanted to add earlier, but Superman shows the ability to Thunderclap here. This is one of two times he ever does it, but he can do it.
(3:36 - 4:06, Part 2) Wind Manipulation. What I would actually consider one of Supes' signature moves, he spins like a tornado and creates an immense gust of wind.
(5:55 - 6:06, Part 2) I know we already have evidence for Fire Manipulation/Explosions, but I think this would be a much better feat to replace the one on the profile with.
(2:59 - 3:26, Part 1) I think this would be a solid speed upgrade for Superman. He's able to push a ship out of the gravitational pull of a Black Hole. With as much FTL statements and feats we have, I think it'd be harmless.
(7:23 - 7:40, Part 1) Alright. Here's where I want to talk about the elephant in the room. Why are we rating a blatant 4-C Feat as Moon Level? Superman out-right takes an explosion heavily damaged and was destroying the Sun. I get it if it's not rated as 4-C outright, but Moon level? The Sun is almost exactly 400x bigger, I don't think any amount of low-balling could put this feat anywhere near that low.
On this thread (Part 2) and this thread (Part 1) I will be asking you to go to numerous timestamps.
(1:00 - 1:24, Part 2) Superman pushes what seems to be a piece of the moon. The size of it seems to eclipse any other lifting strength feat we have on the profile. If someone could calc this, we may be looking at a serious upgrade.
(1:34 - 1:38, Part 2) Possible Shockwave Manipulation? Superman's stomp rattles the entire building and throws his shooters off-balance. You even see a ripple effect in the ground.
(2:37 - 2:49, Part 2) An addition I actually wanted to add earlier, but Superman shows the ability to Thunderclap here. This is one of two times he ever does it, but he can do it.
(3:36 - 4:06, Part 2) Wind Manipulation. What I would actually consider one of Supes' signature moves, he spins like a tornado and creates an immense gust of wind.
(5:55 - 6:06, Part 2) I know we already have evidence for Fire Manipulation/Explosions, but I think this would be a much better feat to replace the one on the profile with.
(2:59 - 3:26, Part 1) I think this would be a solid speed upgrade for Superman. He's able to push a ship out of the gravitational pull of a Black Hole. With as much FTL statements and feats we have, I think it'd be harmless.
(7:23 - 7:40, Part 1) Alright. Here's where I want to talk about the elephant in the room. Why are we rating a blatant 4-C Feat as Moon Level? Superman out-right takes an explosion heavily damaged and was destroying the Sun. I get it if it's not rated as 4-C outright, but Moon level? The Sun is almost exactly 400x bigger, I don't think any amount of low-balling could put this feat anywhere near that low.
Last edited:
- 19,576
- 15,912
There's no such thing at this time frame. Superman intercepts bullets and saves Lois from a big robot.
????
How is taking a volcanic explosion moon level? Also even if this is what you're saying it is, that still wouldn't make Superman consistently Tier 4. He's been injured and knocked out by far worse stuff.
- 19,576
- 15,912
So escaping a Black Hole's pull doesn't require FTL speeds. You only need those speeds if you're beyond the event horizon, which Superman wasn't. In fact, FTL speeds are contradicted in this episode, because both Jax-Ur and Mala were sucked in the black hole can were unable to escape its pull, despite earlier giving Superman a rather difficult fight.
The Emerald Eye feat is the one already listed on his profile for 5-C durability. The eye was also pushing the sun apart with Green Lantern battery energy, which is how the problem was solved at the end, but just reversing the energy to pull the Sun rather than push it out. So I'm not sure if Superman can even scale to it fully in the first place.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
