• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Sans (Undertale) VS Oersted (Live A Live)

5,977
4,195
The BGM is mine.
Rule:
1. Sans is 10-B physically, 9-A with Telekinesis while Oersted is in his Oersted key (At least 8-C).
2. Speed is equalized and Oersted has accessed to all his optional equipment.
3. The fight takes place in The Last Corrdor.

Vote:
Sans: 2 (FarerPurple, FantaRin_The_First)
Oersted: 1 (ObsidianCrusader)
Inconclusive: 0
 
Last edited:
since AP is kinda useless here, i'll say sans has a reaction speed advantage and a possible LS advantage (unknown vs 25)

got not clue about Oersted, so im unsure what he starts with, but sans starts with throwing his hand down putting his opponent into a sea of bones.

just off of profile, from what it sounds like most of Oersted haxes either require them hit their opponent or is a AOE(?) so im not sure how useful most of his haxes are.
 
since AP is kinda useless here, i'll say sans has a reaction speed advantage and a possible LS advantage (unknown vs 25)

got not clue about Oersted, so im unsure what he starts with, but sans starts with throwing his hand down putting his opponent into a sea of bones.

just off of profile, from what it sounds like most of Oersted haxes either require them hit their opponent or is a AOE(?) so im not sure how useful most of his haxes are.
Oersted is a playable character so I assume that he starts with anything he could use. Moon Down is a short-range attack, Hexaflange requires him to face his back to opponent, Death's Trail needs some preparation time. Oersted has long-range attacks, but they do not induce some negative effect to the enemy.
 
Oersted is a playable character so I assume that he starts with anything he could use. Moon Down is a short-range attack, Hexaflange requires him to face his back to opponent, Death's Trail needs some preparation time. Oersted has long-range attacks, but they do not induce some negative effect to the enemy.
is there any chance he could hit any of those negative effect moves? from the sounds of it thats his best shot on winning this, or he's just going to be harrassed with bones and blasters until he dies.
 
is there any chance he could hit any of those negative effect moves? from the sounds of it thats his best shot on winning this, or he's just going to be harrassed with bones and blasters until he dies.
I think Oersted could destroy Sans in one hit because Oersted is physically much stronger than Sans. Since Oersted technically defeated Straybow, who "Most of his techniques have a long range and an area of effect." and "can also has attacks that can create field tiles and inflict status effects."
 
I think Oersted could destroy Sans in one hit because Oersted is physically much stronger than Sans. Since Oersted technically defeated Straybow, who "Most of his techniques have a long range and an area of effect." and "can also has attacks that can create field tiles and inflict status effects."
yeah sans is one shot to hell and back, but the chances of them hitting him are near to none considering his reaction speed advantage, sans is going to be keeping his distance and slowly killing Oersted while he dodges attacks.

they either have to outlast sans or somehow get him by surprise and kill him.
 
Finally, a person said a thing about Oersted!

Sans' 9-A telekinesis is probs going to do little to no actual damage towards Oersted but will, at least, keep him pinned and more vulnerable to his danmaku spam of bones and blasters. It seems like Oersted's moves require a few seconds to activate, and it doesn't like his moves aren't going to be canceled if he is hit once during the charging period, but Sans' durability bypassing soul-hax danmaku is going to make it hellish further strengthened by Sans' superior reaction time over Oersted which makes it unlikely for Sans to get hit by a surprise attack and die; nor can I see Oersted outlasting Sans, so...

I vote for Sans.
 
yeah sans is one shot to hell and back, but the chances of them hitting him are near to none considering his reaction speed advantage, sans is going to be keeping his distance and slowly killing Oersted while he dodges attacks.

they either have to outlast sans or somehow get him by surprise and kill him.
Finally, a person said a thing about Oersted!

Sans' 9-A telekinesis is probs going to do little to no actual damage towards Oersted but will, at least, keep him pinned and more vulnerable to his danmaku spam of bones and blasters. It seems like Oersted's moves require a few seconds to activate, and it doesn't like his moves aren't going to be canceled if he is hit once during the charging period, but Sans' durability bypassing soul-hax danmaku is going to make it hellish further strengthened by Sans' superior reaction time over Oersted which makes it unlikely for Sans to get hit by a surprise attack and die; nor can I see Oersted outlasting Sans, so...

I vote for Sans.
It should be noted that Oersted has accessed to all optional equipment.
 
Last edited:
It should be noted that Oersted has accessed to all optional equipment.
most of it seems dodgeable, and its one time use, so not really a game-changer there. and even if the attacks threw him off, he's able to dodge in his sleep, it isn't out of the question he could dodge some that take him off guard.
 
most of it seems dodgeable, and its one time use, so not really a game-changer there. and even if the attacks threw him off, he's able to dodge in his sleep, it isn't out of the question he could dodge some that take him off guard.
Then I'd like to know who you are voting to.
 
funny skeleton man.
Finally, a person said a thing about Oersted!

Sans' 9-A telekinesis is probs going to do little to no actual damage towards Oersted but will, at least, keep him pinned and more vulnerable to his danmaku spam of bones and blasters. It seems like Oersted's moves require a few seconds to activate, and it doesn't like his moves aren't going to be canceled if he is hit once during the charging period, but Sans' durability bypassing soul-hax danmaku is going to make it hellish further strengthened by Sans' superior reaction time over Oersted which makes it unlikely for Sans to get hit by a surprise attack and die; nor can I see Oersted outlasting Sans, so...

I vote for Sans.
Both counted.

Oersted: When I become the Demon, I'll have a Multiversial nuke and you'll never live.
 
Do we treat Undertale soul hax as being a one-shot on people that don't resist?

Just wanna say that Oersted's AoE moves that don't require charge time (I think encage + some optional equipment moves) will be more than enough to take care of Sans due to the obvious immense AP gap. But being an RPG protagonist, it's not clear what he would do.
 
Do we treat Undertale soul hax as being a one-shot on people that don't resist?
No. but that doesn't really matter here since sans nearly insta kills people with soul resistance anyways.

no one in the verse except omega flowey one shot with magic, but he did it through sheer AP than actual haxs.
 
Uhm, hello! I hope I'm not too late. Kinda just made an account to reply to this. (Also wrote a few battles on the Death Battle Fanon wiki, if that gives any credibility.)
Most of Sans' strength comes from his ability to dodge out of the way of incoming attacks, but, as seen when facing LVL 19 Frisk, this isn't necessarily a guaranteed dodge; merely superhuman...err...super...monster? That said...what about Razor Sonic? With multiple slashes, one is bound to hit Sans the same way Frisk struck him.
I will admit though, in the same vein Sans' Karmic Retribution is designed specifically to counter a Genocidal Frisk, it would actually work just as well against Oersted (Assuming we're using only his human form, AND after wiping out all of Lucretia. If he hasn't committed his genocide yet...I don't think KR would actually help him at all, making Sans basically just do chip damage the whole time.)

Anyway, what I'm saying is...I vote Oersted. He most definitely has the tools available to him to land a decisive blow before Karmic Retribution eats away at him.
 
aight uh...
Most of Sans' strength comes from his ability to dodge out of the way of incoming attacks, but, as seen when facing LVL 19 Frisk, this isn't necessarily a guaranteed dodge;
the only time you ever hit him is by breaking game mechanics to hit him off guard, and since we throw game mechanics out the window, he should be fine dodging.
I will admit though, in the same vein Sans' Karmic Retribution is designed specifically to counter a Genocidal Frisk, it would actually work just as well against Oersted (Assuming we're using only his human form, AND after wiping out all of Lucretia. If he hasn't committed his genocide yet...I don't think KR would actually help him at all, making Sans basically just do chip damage the whole time.)
KR is just soul poison, it works regardless on someone and KR only makes up like, 20-30% of sans' damage, he'll still do a shit ton of damage without KR if he didn't have it.
 
I'm not so sure what backing there is for either of those claims.

I do see what point you're trying to make with the dodging aspect to some degree. But it is still you pressing the Fight button, the same button you've been using the whole battle. While the second strike is technically out of your control, and done by Chara as the fanbase believes, I don't see how this in any way makes Sans' dodging unconditional rather than just...having above-average agility, and I still believe a Razor Sonic or two would be able to get at least a single hit in, since a single hit is all it takes.

As for Karmic Retribution, I suppose I meant that more in the vein of describing both aspects of Sans' damage gimmicks. No other character in the game can ignore invincibility frames, and likewise, no other character has Karmic Retribution in their arsenal. True, it could be influenced by some second secret technique, or ability unique to Sans specifically, and not his brother or his King, but, even if just going off inference alone, it's more than likely it's just a secondary effect of Karmic Retribution. ... ...Not that me elaborating on that matters none, considering the mechanics and nuances of Karmic Retribution wasn't exactly my main point to begin with.
 
I'm not so sure what backing there is for either of those claims.
the only time your able to hit him, and KR is never said to base off LV nor bad acts, as thats not the definition of Karma, if it means such.
I do see what point you're trying to make with the dodging aspect to some degree. But it is still you pressing the Fight button, the same button you've been using the whole battle. While the second strike is technically out of your control, and done by Chara as the fanbase believes, I don't see how this in any way makes Sans' dodging unconditional rather than just...having above-average agility, and I still believe a Razor Sonic or two would be able to get at least a single hit in, since a single hit is all it takes.
pressing a button is game mechanics. and yes, the second attack at the end of sans' fight was done by chara, along with the cuts that kill asgore and flowey.

dodging attacks from a time traveler that knows what your going to do next is him being an agility machine AND good a dodging. two little razor blades are not going to put down sans, thats just down playing his stamina and his dodging.
 
About that...it's not "two little razor blades."


It's two storms of razor blades.
Even Sans' in-battle description reads "Can't keep dodging forever. Keep attacking," and while I'm not sure what the consensus for Frisk on this particular site is, they're just an ordinary human child aside from their Determination setting them aside from the other six fallen humans. Oersted meanwhile has actual battlefield experience, and is thus more familiar to combat-experience overall, including agile opponents.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying Sans' agility won't prove a formidable obstacle to Oersted, but as you said with me downplaying his stamina and dodging (As for stamina, Sans gets tired out from fighting, while Oersted scales two simultaneous mountains on-top of his battles with demons, polar bears, and miscellaneous fantasy monsters, so Stamina isn't much of a factor in Sans' favor) I ask that you don't downplay what Oersted, even in his human form, is capable of. Especially since he's fully capable of great dodging feats as well; to which I present Straybow's "Amber Storm" spell, which Oersted can dodge. Not guaranteed-consistently, but is still fully capable of.

 
It's two storms of razor blades.
Even Sans' in-battle description reads "Can't keep dodging forever. Keep attacking," and while I'm not sure what the consensus for Frisk on this particular site is, they're just an ordinary human child aside from their Determination setting them aside from the other six fallen humans. Oersted meanwhile has actual battlefield experience, and is thus more familiar to combat-experience overall, including agile opponents.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying Sans' agility won't prove a formidable obstacle to Oersted, but as you said with me downplaying his stamina and dodging (As for stamina, Sans gets tired out from fighting, while Oersted scales two simultaneous mountains on-top of his battles with demons, polar bears, and miscellaneous fantasy monsters, so Stamina isn't much of a factor in Sans' favor) I ask that you don't downplay what Oersted, even in his human form, is capable of. Especially since he's fully capable of great dodging feats as well; to which I present Straybow's "Amber Storm" spell, which Oersted can dodge. Not guaranteed-consistently, but is still fully capable of.
Frisk is able to defeat Asgore, King of the monsters who fight in the human monster war and SURVIVED. they aren't a normal ass human, as humans in undertale aren't regular humans, they're superhumans. they dwarf Small building level characters. saying frisk is just some kid without any combat experience is plain ignorant. hell, those razor blade attacks can, get this. teleported away from him. he can teleport himself, other people, and attacks themselves to get out of the way of the attack. im not down playing him, im saying that the fact he gets ******* owned by soul manipulation as people who DO resist it die in seconds against him, he'll die even faster here.
 
Addressing what you said on Asgore, a very important detail to note is that Asgore doesn't want to fight you. He's a broken man who realizes everything he's doing is wrong, but he's already six SOULs deep at this point, he can't give up. No matter how you slice it, the Asgore you face in the Neutral Route is NOT Asgore at his peak potential. As for Asgore surviving the war, you need to remember they lost the war by surrender not by decimation. Asgore's survival of the war is a moot point, considering he was the commander and likely the one to issue the surrender in the first place.

There's never any indication as to whether or not the humans in Undertale are stronger than their real-life equivalent, or if they're just strong in perspective to the monsters themselves, as the only source of info on this was written by monsters.

And no, saying Frisk has no combat experience is not ignorant. They are LVL 1 with no EXP. Therefore, they have never been in a real life-or-death fight, much less won one, prior to the events of Undertale.

And again, there's no evidence to support this. Sans has never teleported an attack away from him. His dodging in-battle is not teleportation, it's just side-stepping, and is in no way a get-out-of-jail-free-card, and even in this case, his teleportation is never used in-battle. Now, for context, this is Sans getting serious. He knows nothing he does is going to matter in the end, but the original human Chara will bring about the apocalypse (Or Armageddon in the case of Oersted.) This is the time for Sans to pull out all the stops, and he DOES so in his very first attack, claiming it to be his strongest. Even when pulling out all the stops we don't see real teleportation the entire time. Otherwise he could just teleport you directly into an unescapable sea of bones which IS something he can create, because he does so if Frisk attempts to spare him.
My point to this is, there are too many variables and making rash assumptions only leads to inaccuracy. I'm sure you've been reading this and have already been typing your reply addressing my skepticism of Sans' teleportation, but my evidence in this point lay solely in uncertainty and variability, just as your assumptions on Sans' limits are. Do you see my point?
TL;DR for this specific point, even when going all-out, Sans doesn't use teleportation in-battle, and can still be hit and killed. Thus it can be fairly believed that his teleportation is not applicable to actual combat-scenarios, and ESPECIALLY not to teleport Oersted's Razor Wind away from him like you claim.

By Soul-Manipulation, you mean Karmic Retribution and his telekinesis, right? Oersted's genocide of Lucretia actually puts him on fairly-even standing with Frisk/Chara, and I've already stated how his agility and combat-versatility exceed that of the Fallen Human's. As for the telekinesis, Oersted have any way of specifically countering it, but...neither does Frisk. And Frisk is still capable of dodging Sans' attacks regardless. Heck, with Oersted's ability to dodge multiple simultaneous lightning-strikes, I'd go as far as to say Oersted would almost definitely dodge every one of Sans' attacks, and certainly wouldn't lower his guard for "Feign Spare" attack.
 
Addressing what you said on Asgore, a very important detail to note is that Asgore doesn't want to fight you. He's a broken man who realizes everything he's doing is wrong, but he's already six SOULs deep at this point, he can't give up. No matter how you slice it, the Asgore you face in the Neutral Route is NOT Asgore at his peak potential. As for Asgore surviving the war, you need to remember they lost the war by surrender not by decimation. Asgore's survival of the war is a moot point, considering he was the commander and likely the one to issue the surrender in the first place.
oh you need more examples?

defeated undyne, captain of the royal guard.

Held their ground vs Photoshop flowey until the souls let frisk damage him.

Fought Asriel Dreemurr.

kills thousands of innocents within a few hours, many of which also being royal guards.

that's being unskilled? sounds like frisk has a hefty amount of skill under their belt. and then sans completely obliterates them despite all that.
There's never any indication as to whether or not the humans in Undertale are stronger than their real-life equivalent, or if they're just strong in perspective to the monsters themselves, as the only source of info on this was written by monsters.
... what. that's quite literally a PLOT POINT. they write about it because its TRUE. Monsters <<<<<< Humans. we literally calculated that a human would be City Block level. they are FAR FAR superior to them.
And again, there's no evidence to support this. Sans has never teleported an attack away from him. His dodging in-battle is not teleportation, it's just side-stepping, and is in no way a get-out-of-jail-free-card, and even in this case, his teleportation is never used in-battle. Now, for context, this is Sans getting serious. He knows nothing he does is going to matter in the end, but the original human Chara will bring about the apocalypse (Or Armageddon in the case of Oersted.) This is the time for Sans to pull out all the stops, and he DOES so in his very first attack, claiming it to be his strongest. Even when pulling out all the stops we don't see real teleportation the entire time. Otherwise he could just teleport you directly into an unescapable sea of bones which IS something he can create, because he does so if Frisk attempts to spare him.
My point to this is, there are too many variables and making rash assumptions only leads to inaccuracy. I'm sure you've been reading this and have already been typing your reply addressing my skepticism of Sans' teleportation, but my evidence in this point lay solely in uncertainty and variability, just as your assumptions on Sans' limits are. Do you see my point?
TL;DR for this specific point, even when going all-out, Sans doesn't use teleportation in-battle, and can still be hit and killed. Thus it can be fairly believed that his teleportation is not applicable to actual combat-scenarios, and ESPECIALLY not to teleport Oersted's Razor Wind away from him like you claim.
did you play the game? his entire phase 2 is revolved around him rapidly teleporting YOU, ATTACKS, AND HIMSELF to throw you off. he does it so many times its a miracle you somehow missed it.
By Soul-Manipulation, you mean Karmic Retribution and his telekinesis, right? Oersted's genocide of Lucretia actually puts him on fairly-even standing with Frisk/Chara, and I've already stated how his agility and combat-versatility exceed that of the Fallen Human's. As for the telekinesis, Oersted have any way of specifically countering it, but...neither does Frisk. And Frisk is still capable of dodging Sans' attacks regardless. Heck, with Oersted's ability to dodge multiple simultaneous lightning-strikes, I'd go as far as to say Oersted would almost definitely dodge every one of Sans' attacks, and certainly wouldn't lower his guard for "Feign Spare" attack.
No??? soul manipulation as in... all of his attacks. they target the soul... they ignore durability. and are you really trying to tell me Oersted is supposed to be universal+? sorry, they are nowhere comparable to chara. sans attacks will almost one-shot him due to him being able to kill someone who DOES resist his attacks within seconds. he slips up once, which he will since he's never delt with soul magic before... will kill him.
 
If I needed more examples, then that renders your argument about Asgore surviving the humans irrelevant. And Frisk didn't "Fight" Asriel Dreemurr. They survived Asriel Dreemurr, who, I might add, was only toying with Frisk to begin with. It was a game, and he wasn't going all out, so using Asriel's fight as an example is not applicable to Sans and his matchup against Oersted. Although this does lead well into your next point.

And that is...I think you misunderstood what I was saying. I'm not questioning that humans are stronger than monsters, it's something I even cited for you. What I'm questioning is where on the SCALE, the humans are. Yes, they could be superhuman and monsters are as strong as a real-life human in comparison, OR they could be as strong as real-life humans, while monsters are massively sub-human. (And I don't mean that in a mean way.) I think the latter is more likely since, what best to compare humans to...than humans?
As for City-Block level, I have to say that, again, without proper evidence to where this scale actually is, City-Block level is highballing it to the maximum, but it's not locked there. If I had to make an analogy, it's like beads on an Abacus. For the sake of simplicity and fairness, I'm assuming the beads are directly in the middle...which makes Undertale humans as strong as real-life humans, and a monster significantly weaker than that. Although, if I'm to be fair, looking back at the quote I cited: "It would take the SOUL of nearly every monster... ... just to equal the power of a single human SOUL." It does mention humans specifically. So there is the possibility that humans are a special case, considering the magic that composes monsters as opposed to the flesh and bone that compose humans. And THIS...is not something that can be proven, so, it's not a factor you can have definite faith in.

And did you miss what I said? I was not questioning that he can teleport the player and himself. I'm questioning whether he can teleport the player's attacks. Every time Frisk attacks, all that gets in their way is Sans dodging. Not being teleported mid-swing. You still haven't given me a definitive answer to that. I don't care if he can teleport the player and himself, what I'm concerned with is whether or not, as you said, he can teleport the Razor Wind attack, or any of Oersted's attacks or wind spells. But while on the topic of his 2nd phase, I ask you to remember...he gets killed during his second phase. So, it doesn't change anything.

Considering Frisk's armor does mitigate damage from other monsters against their SOUL, that means Sans' ability to ignore Defense is solely thanks to Karmic Retribution. As for Frisk, no...Frisk WOULD be able to resist Sans' attacks, if Sans' attack was any more than one. Sans gives off the illusion of ignoring defense, via his ability to remove invincibility frames. My point there is that there's no reason Oersted should be different than Frisk in that regard.
Whether or not Oersted is comparable to Chara is a moot point. (Demon King Odio does exceed Chara's abilities, due to Armageddon being a multiverse-destroying attack, but we're restricting Oersted to his human-form in this fight, so that's an irrelevant point, hence why I'm not suggesting Oersted just use Cancel Ray or High Speed Gel Bullet, which ABSOLUTELY would shut down Sans immediately.) What makes Chara capable of destroying timelines is her DETERMINATION being reflected in Frisk, allowing her to take control, which is only something that comes into play in a magic-monster-based setting. But this isn't Oersted vs Chara (Chara vs Odio would be a better matchup on that end anyway). This is Oersted vs Sans. Although I see your point, so, I should elaborate. When I refer to "Frisk/Chara," I specifically mean the "merged" version of them, meaning Frisk on the Genocide Route. I don't actually mean the timeline-destroying Chara.
Anyway, it sounds like, in the end, your argument hinges on Oersted not understanding soul magic and panicking because of it. Well, I know usually, the consensus is that characters will have no prior knowledge of each other, so Oersted's ability to see through time and space to understand the history and motivations of each of the Live a Live protagonists might be off-limits in that regard. That said, after wiping out Lucretia, you should know, he has a dungeon full of the trapped spirits of his world; including Straybow, Alicia, the King, Knights, Soldiers. And his demons appear in this dungeon, meaning he IS aware of it, and to some degree he IS familiar with SOULs and their properties. Not enough to control Sans' SOUL, I don't believe, but just enough that he won't be thrown off-guard like you seem to believe he will. Pair that with his agility and reaction-times being superior to Frisk's and your belief of him "slipping-up" becomes more than a little unlikely, and likelihood is what determines a victor in these close-result matches.


One more thing, and though this isn't relevant to the match-up...Just wanted to say...Thank you. I always enjoy having a civil, healthy debate like this. Though we have differing opinions, I hope you don't take that personally. Just thought I'd say that so you wouldn't get the wrong idea. ^-^
 
Last edited:
that entire paragraph is quite literally way too ******* long to read, and skimmed it, so to paraphrase your points AND debunk them;

If I needed more examples, then that renders your argument about Asgore surviving the humans irrelevant. hey survived Asriel Dreemurr. and he wasn't going all out, so using Asriel's fight as an example is not applicable to Sans and his matchup against Oersted. Although this does lead well into your next point.
asgore having the skill to stomp a young undyne, drag out the human monster war somehow and match frisk who defeated someone who DEFEATED HIM. thats irrelevant? thats you ignoring points, which i despise.
where on the SCALE, the humans are. Yes, they could be superhuman and monsters are as strong as a real-life human in comparison, OR they could be as strong as real-life humans, while monsters are massively sub-human. (And I don't mean that in a mean way.) I think the latter is more likely since, what best to compare humans to...than humans?
100,000 monsters = 1 human. majority of monsters are Small building level. thats where they are.
As for City-Block level, I have to say that, again, without proper evidence to where this scale actually is, City-Block level is highballing it to the maximum, but it's not locked there. If I had to make an analogy, it's like beads on an Abacus. For the sake of simplicity and fairness, I'm assuming the beads are directly in the middle...which makes Undertale humans as strong as real-life humans, and a monster significantly weaker than that. Although, if I'm to be fair, looking back at the quote I cited: "It would take the SOUL of nearly every monster... ... just to equal the power of a single human SOUL." It does mention humans specifically. So there is the possibility that humans are a special case, considering the magic that composes monsters as opposed to the flesh and bone that compose humans. And THIS...is not something that can be proven, so, it's not a factor you can have definite faith in.
i cant even paraphrase this since this makes no ******* sense. but heres the human calc.
I'm questioning whether he can teleport the player's attacks. You still haven't given me a definitive answer to that. I don't care if he can teleport the player and himself, what I'm concerned with is whether or not, as you said, he can teleport the Razor Wind attack, or any of Oersted's attacks or wind spells. But while on the topic of his 2nd phase, I ask you to remember...he gets killed during his second phase. So, it doesn't change anything.

He can teleport other people and things but suddenly is stumped on a bunch of razor blades? yeah thats makes no sense. and boohoo he ******* died in phase 2 thats the point of a boss fight. they die. sans can teleport attacks, he's shown it with his own, and he's shown to teleport other people, so he can teleport other objects.

Considering Frisk's armor does mitigate damage from other monsters against their SOUL, that means Sans' ability to ignore Defense is solely thanks to Karmic Retribution. As for Frisk, no...Frisk WOULD be able to resist Sans' attacks, if Sans' attack was any more than one. Sans gives off the illusion of ignoring defense, via his ability to remove invincibility frames. My point there is that there's no reason Oersted should be different than Frisk in that regard.
all of this has been debunked before. don't come in here spouting shit you don't know what your talking about. the reason armor works is because some armor is made of magic and FRISK RESISTS SOUL MANIPULATION. Frisk takes magic as physical hits, making armor work. sans negates durability period, if you have a problem with that, make a CRT. the rest of this is a bunch of shit doesn't mean anything to me. Why would he not be bothered by the fact his soul was just obliterated in less than 4 seconds? your entire paragraph is just spouting shit we already know is debunked, or has nothing to do with the match.
 
You can't seriously be trying to use the fact that Asgore "stomped" a child monster as a feat of strength, are you? Undyne is strong, especially compared to other monsters, sure; but you only meet Undyne after her training with Asgore's completed, and she's already among the strongest monsters in the Underground. Dragging out the Human Monster war is also no better. Not only do we not have any indication how long the war lasted, there WERE no human casualties, meaning any kinda prolonged conflict would have had to occur by either guerilla tactics, or shields of meat; that is not strength. And again, with Undyne, she only defeated him in training. There's no inference here; there's no way Asgore was fighting to kill, or fighting at full-power during training. And being defeated by Frisk is again, not an indicator of Frisk's strength, but rather the depth of Asgore's guilt and desire to be with his family again. This is not me ignoring points; everything I say here is either backed by evidence as stated in-game, or a fair inference based on such evidence. I've no interest in downplaying one character, just to make another look good.

Now, as for your "majority of monsters are Small Building Level," I will admit, that got me thinking. (Even if it's wrong, since, the only indication I can find of this is Undyne lifting a boulder, and she is WELL above the "average" monster.) So, let's take another look at the Waterfall Glyphs I cited earlier. "It would take the SOUL of nearly every monster... ... just to equal the power of a single human SOUL." I realized something upon reading this. It makes no mention of physical strength, rather the strength of a SOUL, which is more magic-based than anything else. So, if human's souls are so much more powerful than monster's SOULs, what does that mean? It means that Undyne's Small Building level feat...is IRRELEVANT to a debate on the power of SOULs!
ace-attorney.gif

This opens up the possibility that humans and monsters are not imbalanced on a physical scale, but on a spiritual scale! Meaning there is no evidence that the physical OR Soul-based power of an Undertale human is any greater than one you might find in real life. Now, before you throw my words back on me about evidence and inference, I say this. There is variability in uncertainty. The possibility does exist that UT-Humans could be superhuman, the high end of my analogous abacus, or they COULD be just regular human-level. If we put this aside for just a second that leaves us with one thing I already touched upon...

I think the latter is more likely since, what best to compare humans to...than humans?

So we have a range of uncertainty AND a clear and fair comparison to work with, meaning the most likely answer...is that Frisk's Physical and Spiritual powers are merely average, human-level if you will, while a monster's Physical powers are similar to a humans, but their Spiritual powers, the ones they actually use to attack you are vastly inferior to a human's average power-level.
Now...since I got my Edgeworth gif, and I'm all in the mood, let me ask. How will you reply? What evidence do you have to immobilize the bead of this abacus and break the Range of Uncertainty?

Now, onto your other points... For what you say about Razor Sonic, I can see how your point would apply...if the Razor Sonic attack WAS just a simple razor-blade. To that, I present this, Razor Sonic's in-game description: "Sword Tech/Chop to bits." Sounds pretty clear...cut...right? Wrong. Let's take a look at the animation again.

256


Do you notice something about it? Multiple strikes occur simultaneously. And with the description I shared, this is specifically listed as "Sword Tech," meaning it IS Oersted himself doing this, and not a magic, disembodied spell he cast. Now, I'll be the first to admit, my math isn't perfect so apologies if I'm wrong here, I'll try not to make too many assumptions, but, assuming Oersted at minimum is moving and slashing faster than the human eye can track, that would put his minimum at 17500 meters per second. Sans is quick, yes, but as seen with Frisk's final blow, his reaction speed isn't NEARLY that fast.
Therefore, I stand my ground that Razor Sonic would ABSOLUTELY be able to hit Sans with at least one of its strikes.

If it's been debunked, why have you not presented this? We're far from out of evidence, and, honestly, I think I've proven my case in more than one of the points available. All of Frisk's armor (except for the temy armor) had been owned by a previous fallen human. I imagine the point that's been made is that each of these items holds some kind of significance, some kind of emotional bond that allows them to resist magic-based attacks, yes? Now, again, Sans' Atk and Def are both 1. And Sans deals damage via Karmic Retribution, dealing 1 point of damage per "tick," and applying the Soul Poison effect you mentioned yesterday. Now, sure, let's go under the assumption that Sans can ignore all forms of armor, and I could see the reasoning for that. Even the Faded Ribbon, (Bandage doesn't grant any Damage Reduction) the least-protective piece of armor, tied with Cloudy Glasses, would make Sans deal zero damage per tick. But...how does this help him fight Oersted? Oersted wiped out Lucretia, meaning his "Love" level should be equal to that of Frisk/Chara. Maybe even better, because literally everyone native to Lucretia is dead, while in Undertale, you were capped at level 19 until you killed Sans. This would give Oersted a similar degree of survivability to Soul Manipulation to Frisk/Chara.

To address your final point, if this stuff has been debunked, why don't you present it? You followed this up by immediately saying "both sides have their evidence burnt out," meaning you don't...really have an argument left, do you? If I wasn't tired from being sick and needed to take a break every now and again, I could do this all day, because most of what you're saying has a flimsy basis to begin with, and supports itself using evidence from other, third-party sources. My logic isn't perfect, there is no such thing, and I've only started really getting into Battle-Writing, research, and debating two months ago. I'm a virtual newbie, so there's got to be cracks in my metaphorical armor. You just need some direct, solid evidence that hasn't been presented yet...

Now, I don't mean to aggravate you, but I'd like to ask you to tone down a bit there, friend. You sound a little angry, and as I've said, this is nothing more than a civil debate. If you need a moment to relax and calm down, by all means, take it. We don't need to continue this debate if you don't want to.
 
... ...Okay, I don't think the gif for Razor Sonic is working, so I'll just link its page again.
 
Y
You can't seriously be trying to use the fact that Asgore "stomped" a child monster as a feat of strength, are you? Undyne is strong, especially compared to other monsters, sure; but you only meet Undyne after her training with Asgore's completed, and she's already among the strongest monsters in the Underground. Dragging out the Human Monster war is also no better. Not only do we not have any indication how long the war lasted, there WERE no human casualties, meaning any kinda prolonged conflict would have had to occur by either guerilla tactics, or shields of meat; that is not strength. And again, with Undyne, she only defeated him in training. There's no inference here; there's no way Asgore was fighting to kill, or fighting at full-power during training. And being defeated by Frisk is again, not an indicator of Frisk's strength, but rather the depth of Asgore's guilt and desire to be with his family again. This is not me ignoring points; everything I say here is either backed by evidence as stated in-game, or a fair inference based on such evidence. I've no interest in downplaying one character, just to make another look good.

Now, as for your "majority of monsters are Small Building Level," I will admit, that got me thinking. (Even if it's wrong, since, the only indication I can find of this is Undyne lifting a boulder, and she is WELL above the "average" monster.) So, let's take another look at the Waterfall Glyphs I cited earlier. "It would take the SOUL of nearly every monster... ... just to equal the power of a single human SOUL." I realized something upon reading this. It makes no mention of physical strength, rather the strength of a SOUL, which is more magic-based than anything else. So, if human's souls are so much more powerful than monster's SOULs, what does that mean? It means that Undyne's Small Building level feat...is IRRELEVANT to a debate on the power of SOULs!
ace-attorney.gif

This opens up the possibility that humans and monsters are not imbalanced on a physical scale, but on a spiritual scale! Meaning there is no evidence that the physical OR Soul-based power of an Undertale human is any greater than one you might find in real life. Now, before you throw my words back on me about evidence and inference, I say this. There is variability in uncertainty. The possibility does exist that UT-Humans could be superhuman, the high end of my analogous abacus, or they COULD be just regular human-level. If we put this aside for just a second that leaves us with one thing I already touched upon...



So we have a range of uncertainty AND a clear and fair comparison to work with, meaning the most likely answer...is that Frisk's Physical and Spiritual powers are merely average, human-level if you will, while a monster's Physical powers are similar to a humans, but their Spiritual powers, the ones they actually use to attack you are vastly inferior to a human's average power-level.
Now...since I got my Edgeworth gif, and I'm all in the mood, let me ask. How will you reply? What evidence do you have to immobilize the bead of this abacus and break the Range of Uncertainty?

Now, onto your other points... For what you say about Razor Sonic, I can see how your point would apply...if the Razor Sonic attack WAS just a simple razor-blade. To that, I present this, Razor Sonic's in-game description: "Sword Tech/Chop to bits." Sounds pretty clear...cut...right? Wrong. Let's take a look at the animation again.

256


Do you notice something about it? Multiple strikes occur simultaneously. And with the description I shared, this is specifically listed as "Sword Tech," meaning it IS Oersted himself doing this, and not a magic, disembodied spell he cast. Now, I'll be the first to admit, my math isn't perfect so apologies if I'm wrong here, I'll try not to make too many assumptions, but, assuming Oersted at minimum is moving and slashing faster than the human eye can track, that would put his minimum at 17500 meters per second. Sans is quick, yes, but as seen with Frisk's final blow, his reaction speed isn't NEARLY that fast.
Therefore, I stand my ground that Razor Sonic would ABSOLUTELY be able to hit Sans with at least one of its strikes.

If it's been debunked, why have you not presented this? We're far from out of evidence, and, honestly, I think I've proven my case in more than one of the points available. All of Frisk's armor (except for the temy armor) had been owned by a previous fallen human. I imagine the point that's been made is that each of these items holds some kind of significance, some kind of emotional bond that allows them to resist magic-based attacks, yes? Now, again, Sans' Atk and Def are both 1. And Sans deals damage via Karmic Retribution, dealing 1 point of damage per "tick," and applying the Soul Poison effect you mentioned yesterday. Now, sure, let's go under the assumption that Sans can ignore all forms of armor, and I could see the reasoning for that. Even the Faded Ribbon, (Bandage doesn't grant any Damage Reduction) the least-protective piece of armor, tied with Cloudy Glasses, would make Sans deal zero damage per tick. But...how does this help him fight Oersted? Oersted wiped out Lucretia, meaning his "Love" level should be equal to that of Frisk/Chara. Maybe even better, because literally everyone native to Lucretia is dead, while in Undertale, you were capped at level 19 until you killed Sans. This would give Oersted a similar degree of survivability to Soul Manipulation to Frisk/Chara.

To address your final point, if this stuff has been debunked, why don't you present it? You followed this up by immediately saying "both sides have their evidence burnt out," meaning you don't...really have an argument left, do you? If I wasn't tired from being sick and needed to take a break every now and again, I could do this all day, because most of what you're saying has a flimsy basis to begin with, and supports itself using evidence from other, third-party sources. My logic isn't perfect, there is no such thing, and I've only started really getting into Battle-Writing, research, and debating two months ago. I'm a virtual newbie, so there's got to be cracks in my metaphorical armor. You just need some direct, solid evidence that hasn't been presented yet...

Now, I don't mean to aggravate you, but I'd like to ask you to tone down a bit there, friend. You sound a little angry, and as I've said, this is nothing more than a civil debate. If you need a moment to relax and calm down, by all means, take it. We don't need to continue this debate if you don't want to.
You got some stuff wrong because wiki standards but it looks razonable enough anyway
 
... Speed is equalized so unless razor blades is a amp or is far faster than oersted generic slashes it wouldnt make a diference beyond being more atacks
Well, as it just so happens...


This is described in-game as "Sword Tech/Basic Tech." Emphasis on the Basic part. I say this would be a good "standard" for judging speed. As you can see from the animation, it's a fairly simple sword-slash, quite a bit slower than Razor Sonic
 
You got some stuff wrong because wiki standards but it looks razonable enough anyway
"Razonable?" Is that a pun on "Razor Sonic?" Heheh, clever...even if it was unintentional.

That said, I'm curious. What are these "wiki standards?" I would have assumed it's more of a no-frills match. Neutral battleground, no prep-time, no outside help aside from "equipment" characters, that kinda stuff. Am I missing something?
 
Now, as for your "majority of monsters are Small Building Level," I will admit, that got me thinking. (Even if it's wrong, since, the only indication I can find of this is Undyne lifting a boulder, and she is WELL above the "average" monster.) So, let's take another look at the Waterfall Glyphs I cited earlier. "It would take the SOUL of nearly every monster... ... just to equal the power of a single human SOUL." I realized something upon reading this. It makes no mention of physical strength, rather the strength of a SOUL, which is more magic-based than anything else. So, if human's souls are so much more powerful than monster's SOULs, what does that mean? It means that Undyne's Small Building level feat...is IRRELEVANT to a debate on the power of SOULs!
what do you mean? monsters waterfall/hotland up are all small building level... are you even looking at their pages? also, humans lack magic entirely except for the mages that made the barrier, and FRISK THEMSELVES physically amps when their soul gets stronger, making your entire argument flawed.
This opens up the possibility that humans and monsters are not imbalanced on a physical scale, but on a spiritual scale! Meaning there is no evidence that the physical OR Soul-based power of an Undertale human is any greater than one you might find in real life. Now, before you throw my words back on me about evidence and inference, I say this. There is variability in uncertainty. The possibility does exist that UT-Humans could be superhuman, the high end of my analogous abacus, or they COULD be just regular human-level. If we put this aside for just a second that leaves us with one thing I already touched upon...
Alright proved this wrong, moving on.
If it's been debunked, why have you not presented this? We're far from out of evidence, and, honestly, I think I've proven my case in more than one of the points available. All of Frisk's armor (except for the temy armor) had been owned by a previous fallen human. I imagine the point that's been made is that each of these items holds some kind of significance, some kind of emotional bond that allows them to resist magic-based attacks, yes? Now, again, Sans' Atk and Def are both 1. And Sans deals damage via Karmic Retribution, dealing 1 point of damage per "tick," and applying the Soul Poison effect you mentioned yesterday. Now, sure, let's go under the assumption that Sans can ignore all forms of armor, and I could see the reasoning for that. Even the Faded Ribbon, (Bandage doesn't grant any Damage Reduction) the least-protective piece of armor, tied with Cloudy Glasses, would make Sans deal zero damage per tick. But...how does this help him fight Oersted? Oersted wiped out Lucretia, meaning his "Love" level should be equal to that of Frisk/Chara. Maybe even better, because literally everyone native to Lucretia is dead, while in Undertale, you were capped at level 19 until you killed Sans. This would give Oersted a similar degree of survivability to Soul Manipulation to Frisk/Chara.
because it was debunked YEARS AGO, I didn't think I needed to mention something that was basically common knowledge. also, we've gone over this many times

KR ONLY MAKES UP 20% OF SANS' DAMAGE. IF IT WEREN'T THERE HE'D STILL KILL PEOPLE JUST AS FAST.

he deals shit on of damage through ignoring invincibility frames, NOT KR. and yes, he does ignore ALL armor, and does 1 damage regardless what your using.

how does it help him fight Orested? because he MURDERS HIM WITHIN 2 SECONDS WITH HIS ATTACKS. don't mention how much 'love' a character should have, its ******* pointless and plain stupid. and if you wanna go into that department, frisk can die within 2-4 seconds due to his attacks, so he still gets ******.

Now, I don't mean to aggravate you, but I'd like to ask you to tone down a bit there, friend. You sound a little angry, and as I've said, this is nothing more than a civil debate. If you need a moment to relax and calm down, by all means, take it. We don't need to continue this debate if you don't want to.
i just debate incredibly aggressively. something about a man with a fish pfp screaming about a funny skeleton is ******* hilarious to me. (y) i ain't aggravated,I just debate like I took a suitcase full of coke.

unless its a MG:R thread. then I just shitpost the entire time and derail the thread.
 
i just debate incredibly aggressively. something about a man with a fish pfp screaming about a funny skeleton is ******* hilarious to me. (y) i ain't aggravated,I just debate like I took a suitcase full of coke.
Oh, yeah, hahah. Funny angry fish man, woo! In all seriousness, if I had a nickel for the amount of times someone with a Scout weapon, or anything Scout-related as a profile picture went on a furious, shouting tirade at me over the internet, sincere or not, I'd have enough to commission a Brandon Yates track for this match-up. So I'm sorry if the joke's run a little stale on me.
what do you mean? monsters waterfall/hotland up are all small building level... are you even looking at their pages? also, humans lack magic entirely except for the mages that made the barrier, and FRISK THEMSELVES physically amps when their soul gets stronger, making your entire argument flawed.
Quite the contrary actually. Undyne is both more durable and hits harder than any of the standard non-boss monsters (And Boss Monster is a specific classification of monster, DESIGNED to be stronger than the average, as stated by Gerson.) Regardless of that, looking at the classifications of the standard monsters on this wiki, most of them seem to just be listed at wall-destroying-level or below, not including the Boss Monsters.
Now, for humans, I could see your point. Frisk is not a mage in the traditional sense, and certainly not to the same calibur as the mages who created the barrier, but to that, I present this, a quote from Sans himself, describing Love: "A way of measuring someone's capacity to hurt. The more you kill, the easier it becomes to distance yourself. The more you distance yourself, the less you will hurt. The more easily you can bring yourself to hurt others." Now, I want you to compare this to the damage dealt in the game's routes. Attacking a standard monster deals a standard amount of damage, as expected. Attacking Undyne during her cooking training results in a pitifully low amount. Attacking any of the boss-monsters like Papyrus, Toriel, and Mettaton result in colossal numbers and a one-hit kill. Even Undyne the Undying specifically can take such numbers before dying. What does this mean? My point is, regardless of how determined Frisk is to kill a monster, it can't affect their physical power; it's the power of their SOUL, and thus, magical power that this killing intent influences.
Frisk's physical power doesn't "amp" at all, considering, as I've just pointed out, both attacking AND defending is relevant to the power of Frisk's SOUL, and NOT their physique.

Alright proved this wrong, moving on.
Addressed? Certainly. Proved wrong? Hah...I wouldn't be so sure.

because it was debunked YEARS AGO, I didn't think I needed to mention something that was basically common knowledge. also, we've gone over this many times

KR ONLY MAKES UP 20% OF SANS' DAMAGE. IF IT WEREN'T THERE HE'D STILL KILL PEOPLE JUST AS FAST.

he deals shit on of damage through ignoring invincibility frames, NOT KR. and yes, he does ignore ALL armor, and does 1 damage regardless what your using.

how does it help him fight Orested? because he MURDERS HIM WITHIN 2 SECONDS WITH HIS ATTACKS. don't mention how much 'love' a character should have, its ******* pointless and plain stupid. and if you wanna go into that department, frisk can die within 2-4 seconds due to his attacks, so he still gets ******.
If it's been debunked years ago, then present it, as I've been saying. Everything is variable, especially in a game as vague as Undertale, so you'd be surprised how such "common knowledge" can change.

By 20% you're talking about the poison-effect, yes? I'm considering both the poison effect AND the Invincibility Frame removal to both be aspects of Karmic Retribution for reasons I've stated prior. I'm not denying he can deal damage well, but there's no reason to believe Frisk's SOUL would be weaker or stronger than Oersted's, considering Oersted in the form being used during this battle...Is human.
1200


Murdering within two seconds, eh? Well, as Livinmeme so politely reminded us...Speed is equalized, and even in spite of that, with Oersted's attacking speed varying between a basic slash and being faster than the human eye, this means Sans isn't the one dodging Oersted...Oersted is the one dodging Sans. If Oersted stood motionless, LETTING Sans hit him, yeah, he'd die just as quickly as Frisk does, but Frisk doesn't stand still, do they? No, they're constantly bobbing and weaving, dodging bones and blasters, and Oersted's reaction speed and movement speed exceeds that of Frisk's, thanks in part due to Amber Storm, and his Razor Sonic feat.

Oersted is like nothing Sans has ever faced before, and takes Sans' dodging speed, one of his only two combat advantages, and relegates it to second place.

Now, I trust I've stated my point, so, let's summarize what we know.

OFFENSE: Sans' damage against Oersted is equal to that which he can deal against Frisk/Chara.
DEFENSE:, Sans' low Defense means he dies in one hit all the same.
SPEED: Sans' teleportation ability is unreliable and scarcely-detailed. While he is certainly faster than any other monster as far as we know, it is not quick enough to dodge Frisk's attack at the end of his battle, and with Razor Sonic being composed of more than one slash, it is very likely at least one of these will hit him sooner or later, while Oersted is more than fast enough to evade Sans long enough to land that killing blow.
INTELLIGENCE: This factor mainly depends on where in Oersted's timeline he is. As Odio, he is capable of seeing through time and space, and learn the hero's stories that way, while Sans is knowledgeable of the existence of a Time Traveler, but is not all-knowing. To this end, I would say Oersted and Sans are tied in this, with Sans maybe having a slight edge.
VERSATILITY: This one is fairly clear-cut. Sans' techniques are powerful and deadly-effective, but Karmic Retribution (The Poison and invincibility-negating effects both) is the only skill that gives him any sort of advantage. He can dodge, but Oersted can do this too, and more effectively. Oersted's wider moveset and variety of counters and wind-based spells, as well as the aforementioned Razor Sonic, makes him more versatile overall.

Do you have any objections with any of these points?


And now...back to the thread itself. I will say it again. My vote is wholeheartedly for Oersted, by virtue of having the means to hit Sans, and the agility to ensure he stays alive long enough to deal the killing blow.
 
Oh, yeah, hahah. Funny angry fish man, woo! In all seriousness, if I had a nickel for the amount of times someone with a Scout weapon, or anything Scout-related as a profile picture went on a furious, shouting tirade at me over the internet, sincere or not, I'd have enough to commission a Brandon Yates track for this match-up. So I'm sorry if the joke's run a little stale on me.
My personality is stale it revolves around a TF2 weapon.
Quite the contrary actually. Undyne is both more durable and hits harder than any of the standard non-boss monsters (And Boss Monster is a specific classification of monster, DESIGNED to be stronger than the average, as stated by Gerson.) Regardless of that, looking at the classifications of the standard monsters on this wiki, most of them seem to just be listed at wall-destroying-level or below, not including the Boss Monsters.
Now, for humans, I could see your point. Frisk is not a mage in the traditional sense, and certainly not to the same calibur as the mages who created the barrier, but to that, I present this, a quote from Sans himself, describing Love: "A way of measuring someone's capacity to hurt. The more you kill, the easier it becomes to distance yourself. The more you distance yourself, the less you will hurt. The more easily you can bring yourself to hurt others." Now, I want you to compare this to the damage dealt in the game's routes. Attacking a standard monster deals a standard amount of damage, as expected. Attacking Undyne during her cooking training results in a pitifully low amount. Attacking any of the boss-monsters like Papyrus, Toriel, and Mettaton result in colossal numbers and a one-hit kill. Even Undyne the Undying specifically can take such numbers before dying. What does this mean? My point is, regardless of how determined Frisk is to kill a monster, it can't affect their physical power; it's the power of their SOUL, and thus, magical power that this killing intent influences.
Frisk's physical power doesn't "amp" at all, considering, as I've just pointed out, both attacking AND defending is relevant to the power of Frisk's SOUL, and NOT their physique.
All boss monsters (Toriel, Papyrus, Undyne, Mettaton, Asgore) are Small building level or higher, not sure where you got that from. the only exception to this is sans himself. you seem to miss the fact that monster stats ******* plummet when fighting someone with the desire to kill them, making frisk one shot everyone in the genocide route and do minimal damage in any other route until you start attacking them over and over. frisk has never, and will never use magic in undertale, they get PHYSICALLY stronger from raising their LV, which affects the SOUL. meaning no, their soul does affect how physically strong they are.
Murdering within two seconds, eh? Well, as Livinmeme so politely reminded us...Speed is equalized, and even in spite of that, with Oersted's attacking speed varying between a basic slash and being faster than the human eye, this means Sans isn't the one dodging Oersted...Oersted is the one dodging Sans. If Oersted stood motionless, LETTING Sans hit him, yeah, he'd die just as quickly as Frisk does, but Frisk doesn't stand still, do they? No, they're constantly bobbing and weaving, dodging bones and blasters, and Oersted's reaction speed and movement speed exceeds that of Frisk's, thanks in part due to Amber Storm, and his Razor Sonic feat.
Oh speed is equalized?
"The combat speed of that faster character is assumed to be equalized to the combat speed of the slower character. Every other speed the faster character has is reduced by the same multiplier. This includes the speed of any attacks, projectiles, reactions, perception, flight etc."

sans has a higher reaction speed here, Oersted ain't hitting SHIT. and don't mention Oestered's reaction speed, because it isn't a separate rating meaning his reaction and attack speeds are lower than sans' reaction, meaning he can react to ANYTHING they do. oh and his gaster blasters are also just a bit faster than both of them, so both his attacks and his reaction speeds are superio. and who cares if oestered is dodging? sans has telekinesis and teleportation to throw em off and get easy damage on them.
OFFENSE: Sans' damage against Oersted is equal to that which he can deal against Frisk/Chara.
DEFENSE:, Sans' low Defense means he dies in one hit all the same.
SPEED: Sans' teleportation ability is unreliable and scarcely-detailed. While he is certainly faster than any other monster as far as we know, it is not quick enough to dodge Frisk's attack at the end of his battle, and with Razor Sonic being composed of more than one slash, it is very likely at least one of these will hit him sooner or later, while Oersted is more than fast enough to evade Sans long enough to land that killing blow.
INTELLIGENCE: This factor mainly depends on where in Oersted's timeline he is. As Odio, he is capable of seeing through time and space, and learn the hero's stories that way, while Sans is knowledgeable of the existence of a Time Traveler, but is not all-knowing. To this end, I would say Oersted and Sans are tied in this, with Sans maybe having a slight edge.
VERSATILITY: This one is fairly clear-cut. Sans' techniques are powerful and deadly-effective, but Karmic Retribution (The Poison and invincibility-negating effects both) is the only skill that gives him any sort of advantage. He can dodge, but Oersted can do this too, and more effectively. Oersted's wider moveset and variety of counters and wind-based spells, as well as the aforementioned Razor Sonic, makes him more versatile overall.

Do you have any objections with any of these points?
Offense damage is something sans never takes, he does shit ton of chip damage that negates durability that can kill people who resist his attacks within seconds. defence doesn't matter since he 'lolreacts' to everything they throw at him. intelligence is given to sans regardless, he's a Extraordinary Genius vs someone with High intelligence, it isn't a question. and god ******* dammit, you keep going on about KR, but KR IS ****** USELESS. its just poison that gives him slightly more damage than he'd normally. and his wind based spells are ******* useless since he can react to all of it with his superior reaction speeds in this fight. ]
 
My personality is stale it revolves around a TF2 weapon.
Yeah, I don't recall the fish complaining about being used to bludgeon a clueless newborn Sniper. He seems rather content with his life.

All boss monsters (Toriel, Papyrus, Undyne, Mettaton, Asgore) are Small building level or higher, not sure where you got that from. the only exception to this is sans himself. you seem to miss the fact that monster stats ******* plummet when fighting someone with the desire to kill them, making frisk one shot everyone in the genocide route and do minimal damage in any other route until you start attacking them over and over. frisk has never, and will never use magic in undertale, they get PHYSICALLY stronger from raising their LV, which affects the SOUL. meaning no, their soul does affect how physically strong they are.
I don't think you understand what I'm saying. I'm not arguing the boss monsters aren't small building level, thanks to Undyne's boulder-feat. I'm questioning whether the standard monsters are anywhere near that level.
Ah, that's what I disagree with. It's not the monster's stats that plummet, it's the sheer damage done by Frisk that increases. For example, Snowdrake has 7 Def, while Mettaton NEO has 9 Def. Snowdrake takes an average amount of damage, proportional to Frisk's visible Attack stat in the overworld menu. Mettaton NEO, I don't think I need to tell you, takes significantly more than that. This is a result of Frisk's desire to kill the more consequential monsters, rather than a generic monster. Does this mean that Frisk doesn't want to kill Snowdrake? No, they absolutely do want to kill everyone. But Mettaton NEO ONLY appears in the Genocide Route, and if monster's stats plummeted due to Frisk's desire to kill, then Snowdrake's 7 would be even lower. Therefore, I suggest that it's not the monster's stats that decrease, but rather the direct damage dealt by Frisk that increases.
And this desire to kill, it's not a tangible concept, it's not Frisk's muscles, or the sharpness of their weapon. It's the power of their SOUL that kills the monster they attack. This is ABSOLUTELY magic, or at least some subvariation of magic. There is no indication that leveling up increases their physical capabilities, and even if it did, it doesn't matter, since it's still the SOUL that kills the monsters anyway.

Oh speed is equalized?
"The combat speed of that faster character is assumed to be equalized to the combat speed of the slower character. Every other speed the faster character has is reduced by the same multiplier. This includes the speed of any attacks, projectiles, reactions, perception, flight etc."

sans has a higher reaction speed here, Oersted ain't hitting SHIT. and don't mention Oestered's reaction speed, because it isn't a separate rating meaning his reaction and attack speeds are lower than sans' reaction, meaning he can react to ANYTHING they do. oh and his gaster blasters are also just a bit faster than both of them, so both his attacks and his reaction speeds are superio. and who cares if oestered is dodging? sans has telekinesis and teleportation to throw em off and get easy damage on them.
No, I wouldn't say that at all. In fact, if anything, Oersted's reaction speed has been proven to be GREATER than Sans'. A lightning bolt is 270,000 mph, while the VERY FASTEST a human can move their arm (that being professional baseball pitchers, which is highballing Frisk,) is 100 mph, making Oersted's maximum reaction speed 2700 times greater than Sans' maximum. Now, I don't understand what you mean by "separate rating," when reaction speed is its own category entirely. It isn't an unfair comparison to pit these characters' speeds against each other. And even if this is irrelevant, if reaction speeds are equalized as well, it means Sans is more-or-less incapable of dodging Oersted any more than Oersted can dodge Sans. And with Oersted's superior HP and guaranteed one-hit-kill, this can only mean death for Sans.
And yes, Gaster Blasters do emit laser-beams, and those WOULD be an issue, if Sans' Gaster Blasters didn't linger before firing. This clearly telegraphs when Sans is going to fire it, and with Oersted's superhuman reactions, this renders the Gaster Blaster basically useless. And as seen with Sans' battle itself, Sans CANNOT ATTACK, while manipulating someone with telekinesis. It is possible to get through Sans' assault without taking any damage, prior to his last telekinesis slam attack. And even if Sans could keep Oersted at a distance, Oersted HAS ranged magic in his wind-spells, and, again...our old friend, Razor Sonic. Do I think Oersted wouldn't be caught off-guard at first? No, of course not. But when Sans uses this ability the first time, he's not going to catch him off-guard a second; Oersted is no idiot. He was capable of deciphering the runes at Devil's Peak, just as the mage Straybow had, and unlocked the power of the Demon King. And even if Sans hits him once, how often does he actually kill Frisk in one attack, unless they're standing still and just bumbling through?

Offense damage is something sans never takes, he does shit ton of chip damage that negates durability that can kill people who resist his attacks within seconds. defence doesn't matter since he 'lolreacts' to everything they throw at him. intelligence is given to sans regardless, he's a Extraordinary Genius vs someone with High intelligence, it isn't a question. and god ******* dammit, you keep going on about KR, but KR IS ****** USELESS. its just poison that gives him slightly more damage than he'd normally. and his wind based spells are ******* useless since he can react to all of it with his superior reaction speeds in this fight. ]
Not the point I was getting at. Sans dies in one hit, we've established this, but Oersted...does not. Frisk is capable of taking more than one of Sans' attacks without dying, and Oersted post-genocide, should reasonably have the same amount of HP as Frisk. Oersted won't last forever, but remember, he only needs to land ONE hit in order to kill Sans, and as I've proven numerous times during this thread, Oersted equals or exceeds Sans' speed, leaving Sans as nothing more than a sitting duck with a pistol in its beak.
"High Intelligence" is low-balling Oersted...and I'm convinced you barely even know who he is, or his role in Live a Live. To summarize what's important, you need to know that he can not only communicate cross-dimensionally, but KNOWS of the heroes' history. Pogo, the Heart of the Mountain Master, Oboro-Maru, Sundown Kid, Masaru, Akira, Cube. These are all people who stared hatred in the eyes and emerged victorious, REFUSING to give into hatred. And Oersted knew about this for each of them, despite living in a different time, and in a different universe. I don't think it's too much of an exaggeration to call this some form of Omniscience, or at least Extraordinary Intelligence, like Sans, who, again, I must remind you, does not know precisely what happens in the other timelines Frisk travels to and from. He doesn't know if he's ever been freed, he doesn't know if Chara erased his world at some point. All he knows is that there is a time-space anomaly, and he correctly INFERS Frisk is the cause of this, my source being his dialogue during his fight.

Now, as for KR, I keep telling you, over and over, I'm counting the poison and the invincibility-nullification both as KR. Not that it matters that much, I suppose, for reasons I've stated earlier in this reply; Oersted can take Sans' attacks for long enough to land a killing blow himself, since Sans' reaction speeds are NOT superior.
 
I don't think you understand what I'm saying. I'm not arguing the boss monsters aren't small building level, thanks to Undyne's boulder-feat. I'm questioning whether the standard monsters are anywhere near that level.
Ah, that's what I disagree with. It's not the monster's stats that plummet, it's the sheer damage done by Frisk that increases. For example, Snowdrake has 7 Def, while Mettaton NEO has 9 Def. Snowdrake takes an average amount of damage, proportional to Frisk's visible Attack stat in the overworld menu. Mettaton NEO, I don't think I need to tell you, takes significantly more than that. This is a result of Frisk's desire to kill the more consequential monsters, rather than a generic monster. Does this mean that Frisk doesn't want to kill Snowdrake? No, they absolutely do want to kill everyone. But Mettaton NEO ONLY appears in the Genocide Route, and if monster's stats plummeted due to Frisk's desire to kill, then Snowdrake's 7 would be even lower. Therefore, I suggest that it's not the monster's stats that decrease, but rather the direct damage dealt by Frisk that increases.
And this desire to kill, it's not a tangible concept, it's not Frisk's muscles, or the sharpness of their weapon. It's the power of their SOUL that kills the monster they attack. This is ABSOLUTELY magic, or at least some subvariation of magic. There is no indication that leveling up increases their physical capabilities, and even if it did, it doesn't matter, since it's still the SOUL that kills the monsters anyway.
actually small building level comes from Mettaton, not undyne. and yes, most if not all hotland monsters are at that level, aswell as some Waterfall and snowdin monsters are at that level aswell. frisk's attack doesn't go up when their's go down, they just slap them as their defence plummets and strangles the life out of all of them. frisk has no magic, never will, and its accepted they never do, and use physical attacks at all times.
No, I wouldn't say that at all. In fact, if anything, Oersted's reaction speed has been proven to be GREATER than Sans'. A lightning bolt is 270,000 mph, while the VERY FASTEST a human can move their arm (that being professional baseball pitchers, which is highballing Frisk,) is 100 mph, making Oersted's maximum reaction speed 2700 times greater than Sans' maximum. Now, I don't understand what you mean by "separate rating," when reaction speed is its own category entirely. It isn't an unfair comparison to pit these characters' speeds against each other. And even if this is irrelevant, if reaction speeds are equalized as well, it means Sans is more-or-less incapable of dodging Oersted any more than Oersted can dodge Sans. And with Oersted's superior HP and guaranteed one-hit-kill, this can only mean death for Sans.
And yes, Gaster Blasters do emit laser-beams, and those WOULD be an issue, if Sans' Gaster Blasters didn't linger before firing. This clearly telegraphs when Sans is going to fire it, and with Oersted's superhuman reactions, this renders the Gaster Blaster basically useless. And as seen with Sans' battle itself, Sans CANNOT ATTACK, while manipulating someone with telekinesis. It is possible to get through Sans' assault without taking any damage, prior to his last telekinesis slam attack. And even if Sans could keep Oersted at a distance, Oersted HAS ranged magic in his wind-spells, and, again...our old friend, Razor Sonic. Do I think Oersted wouldn't be caught off-guard at first? No, of course not. But when Sans uses this ability the first time, he's not going to catch him off-guard a second; Oersted is no idiot. He was capable of deciphering the runes at Devil's Peak, just as the mage Straybow had, and unlocked the power of the Demon King. And even if Sans hits him once, how often does he actually kill Frisk in one attack, unless they're standing still and just bumbling through?
Oestered's reaction speed is not any higher than his base speed, meaning in speed equalized sans' reaction speeds are higher as his reaction speeds are higher than his base speed, gaster blasters have a 'higher' speed, meaning they are faster. all of his spells dont have a seperate rating to his basespeed, meaning sans can react to all of it, including his wind spells, they are useless here.
Not the point I was getting at. Sans dies in one hit, we've established this, but Oersted...does not. Frisk is capable of taking more than one of Sans' attacks without dying, and Oersted post-genocide, should reasonably have the same amount of HP as Frisk. Oersted won't last forever, but remember, he only needs to land ONE hit in order to kill Sans, and as I've proven numerous times during this thread, Oersted equals or exceeds Sans' speed, leaving Sans as nothing more than a sitting duck with a pistol in its beak.
All of this is wrong. Oerested does basically die within a single touch to his attacks as he kills someone who does resist his abilities faster than they can react, dont bring up HP, thats game mechanics. speed equalized makes all of Oersted's attacks Supersonic leaving sans' reaction speed at Supersonic+ (roughly, didn't do the math), meaning he can react to literally everything. so unfortunately sans is not a sitting duck, he's more like a terminator duck.
"High Intelligence" is low-balling Oersted...and I'm convinced you barely even know who he is, or his role in Live a Live. To summarize what's important, you need to know that he can not only communicate cross-dimensionally, but KNOWS of the heroes' history. Pogo, the Heart of the Mountain Master, Oboro-Maru, Sundown Kid, Masaru, Akira, Cube. These are all people who stared hatred in the eyes and emerged victorious, REFUSING to give into hatred. And Oersted knew about this for each of them, despite living in a different time, and in a different universe. I don't think it's too much of an exaggeration to call this some form of Omniscience, or at least Extraordinary Intelligence, like Sans, who, again, I must remind you, does not know precisely what happens in the other timelines Frisk travels to and from. He doesn't know if he's ever been freed, he doesn't know if Chara erased his world at some point. All he knows is that there is a time-space anomaly, and he correctly INFERS Frisk is the cause of this, my source being his dialogue during his fight.

Now, as for KR, I keep telling you, over and over, I'm counting the poison and the invincibility-nullification both as KR. Not that it matters that much, I suppose, for reasons I've stated earlier in this reply; Oersted can take Sans' attacks for long enough to land a killing blow himself, since Sans' reaction speeds are NOT superior.
Im going off of profile, which lists him as 'high' intellegence, if you wish to change that make a crt. also you might want to look at their profiles, since you are seemingly missing a lot of things.

KR is poison damage, its nothing more nothing less. the invincibility-null is just his attacks, NOT kr, kr is the poison, his actual attacks are the IN.
 
Back
Top