Rurero Migishita CRT

[Tllmbrg]

This chick should have information analysis
She can tell the number of bullets inside a gun of the shape of it and how it's held, someone like Baki Hanama gets it of telling someone does Judo of their stance so there's no reason she shouldn't

 

[Agnaa]

I feel like Information Analysis shouldn't be given out for all feats of "Figured out something about someone or some object".

idk the greater context of Baki, but Rurero doesn't have anything implying some extrasensory perception to gain that information, and she says that she can figure out that sort of thing as "she's a professional", with the world of Zaregoto containing many varieties of combat-oriented and non-combat-oriented professional killers. These both imply to me that in her case it was from intelligence.

Hence why I made the profile the way I did.

 

[Tllmbrg]

I feel like Information Analysis shouldn't be given out for all feats of "Figured out something about someone or some object".

idk the greater context of Baki, but Rurero doesn't have anything implying some extrasensory perception to gain that information, and she says that she can figure out that sort of thing as "she's a professional", with the world of Zaregoto containing many varieties of combat-oriented and non-combat-oriented professional killers. These both imply to me that in her case it was from intelligence.

I mean shouldn't the wording on Information Analysis as a whole be changed then?
I don't see with how the page is currently worded this sort of feats can't double as both, just means she has limited Information Analysis

 

[Agnaa]

Maybe it should be. It's barely been changed since its creation in 2017 and it really shows.

I feel like that sort of thing should be given for information gained through powers/extrasensory perception.

 

[Tllmbrg]

Maybe it should be. It's barely been changed since its creation in 2017 and it really shows.

I feel like that sort of thing should be given for information gained through powers/extrasensory perception.

Or we can have the dreaded idea of Types for Information Analysis with 1 being for feats like this who;e 2 is supernatural information analysis

 

[Agnaa]

Oh whoops, I forgot to add another thought to my last post.

I could also see an argument for broader information analysis, even without an extrasensory element, but I feel like it should be pretty broad to be that. If we're giving it for a character figuring out how many bullets a gun has left, I feel like it'd end up being given for every single deduction a character makes from their perception, which is way too broad imo.

 

[Tllmbrg]

I could also see an argument for broader information analysis, even without an extrasensory element, but I feel like it should be pretty broad to be that. If we're giving it for a character figuring out how many bullets a gun has left, I feel like it'd end up being given for every single deduction a character makes from their perception, which is way too broad imo.

I mean, this's a high end feat so we can specify that it's something that has to be near BS level deduction wise ig
Maybe have it defined as something that a regular human could no reasonably find out unless specifically told what to do

 

[Wokistan]

I also disagree with this being information analysis, it's just being perceptive enough to recognize a difference in mass. People like soldiers and cops who work around guns a ton can get to the point of being able to just tell stuff like who's concealed carrying via how they present themselves, extrapolate info from a shooter's stance and how they hold their weapon, etc. That doesn't make them all have a special info getting power.

 

[Tllmbrg]

Ig fair enough
What about re-wording information analysis page as a whole then and possibly have types of IA?