X-Man Tier Upgrade

[Cmotany84]

Hello. First time posting on here. I want to make the case that X-man's tier should be upgraded.

1. It has been stated on numerous occasion that he's, at the very least, equal to full potential Cable, who is listed at 4-B.

(Cable #29, Vol 1, pg 29)

2. He has the same powers and morphology as Age of Apocalypse Jean Grey:

(X-Factor #22, Vol 3, pg 27-28)

The same Jean Grey who prevented an entire timeline from being erased:

(X-Men: Age of Apocaplypse #6, pg 7)

3. It was stated that he has enough power to devour a universe:

(X-Man #70, pg 21)

This is the same type of reasoning used to justify Trigon's ranking, who sated that 1/10th of his power was enough to destroy the universe.

4. Finally, he's been compared to Franklin Richards at least twice:

(X-Man #59, pg 20)

(X-Men: The Complete Onslaught Epic, Part 4, pg 75)

So, based on this, I believe that X-man's ranking should be upgraded to 4-B/Likely Low 2-C.

Also, I apologize for not posting links or photos. I tried numerous times, but I was not allowed. Listing the referecnes was the best I could do. All the info can be viewed on ***************.

 

[Cmotany84]

Bump

 

[Cmotany84]

Wanted to post a better/stronger argument:

1. It has been stated on numerous occasion that he's, at the very least, equal to full potential Cable, who is listed at 4-B.

2. He has the same powers and morphology as Age of Apocalypse Jean Grey:

http://***************.to/Comic/X-Factor-2006/Issue-22?id=40900#27

http://***************.to/Comic/X-Factor-2006/Issue-22?id=40900#28

The same Jean Grey who prevented an entire timeline from being erased:

http://***************.to/Comic/Age-of-Apocalypse-2005/Issue-6?id=54494&readType=0#7

3. It was stated that he has enough power to devour a universe:

http://***************.to/Comic/X-Man/Issue-70?id=60496&readType=0#21

This is the same type of reasoning used to justify Trigon's ranking ( Can destroy a universe with but 1/10 of his power ) as well as Doctor Fate, who Defeated two beings that supposedly threatened the multiversal balance.

4. Finally, he's been compared to Franklin Richards at least twice:

http://***************.to/Comic/X-Men-The-Complete-Onslaught-Epic/TPB-4?id=88991#75

http://***************.to/Comic/X-Man/Issue-59?id=60465#20

So, based on this, I believe that X-man's ranking should be upgraded to 4-B/Likely Low 2-C.

 

[Antvasima]

I suppose that "At least 4-B, possibly potentially Low 2-C" seems to make sense, but you should ask Matthew Schroeder and Sandman31 to comment here via their message walls.

 

[Sandman31]

4-B looks good, about Low 2-C, he's got a lot of statement but doesnt have feats to back them up

 

[Cmotany84]

Right. Thanks for agreeing on the 4-B. As fo the 2-C ranking, I knew the lack of feats would be an issue, that's why I was hoping adding "potentially" or "likely" would help.

 

[Antvasima]

@Sandman31

Would you be willing to upgrade his profile to 4-B?

 

[Sandman31]

I think he could be "4-B, possibly higher"

 

[Antvasima]

Okay, that seems fine.

 

[Cmotany84]

Thanks guys!

 

[Antvasima]

No problem. Perhaps we should close this thread?

 

[Cmotany84]

Absolutely

 

[Antvasima]

Okay.