- 16,138
- 10,667
like, wtf.
also, does that logic also applies to IRL profiles here? Because we literally can't assume it
also, does that logic also applies to IRL profiles here? Because we literally can't assume it
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
thats not common sense, thats appealing to fantasy in a wrong scenario, while the wiki says that it is a ''indexing site''Common sense
That's not even a thing, let's take the Lion, you cannot prove that a IRL Lion have a soul, so, Soul Hax should not work in lions, unless it's proven that a IRL lion have a soul, and the problem is, we do have IRL profiles here, and we cannot assume that IRL have soulsSince soul manipulation is an ability, it must be proven that a specific character is immune to it.
my question was mainly directed to it, yeReal world profiles are another case in point.
also, does that logic also applies to IRL profiles here? Because we literally can't assume it
It is more like you can not disprove nor prove a soul can exist in a being or not.thats not common sense, thats appealing to fantasy in a wrong scenario, while the wiki says that it is a ''indexing site''
That's not even a thing, let's take the Lion, you cannot prove that a IRL Lion have a soul, so, Soul Hax should not work in lions, unless it's proven that a IRL lion have a soul, and the problem is, we do have IRL profiles here, and we cannot assume that IRL have souls
So, it cannot be assumed to be a thing, that's just, the logic behind of an indexing siteIt is more like you can not disprove nor prove a soul can exist in a being or not.
it is not proved, it mainly comes from religion stuff and all, but that's also, not proved eitherIn additional to that, the soul concept originated from discussions in philosophy and certain other circles: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soul
To being fair, this is more subjective rather than objective as objectively speaking, we don’t have proof that souls exist yet we also don’t have proof that souls don’t exist as in a way, forms a logical contradiction.So, it cannot be assumed to be a thing, that's just, the logic behind of an indexing site
but what is even the point of assuming it if there is no proof? it should be a thing only in verses that does states that souls exist, because we have no proof of it, meanwhile, burden of proofTo being fair, this is more subjective rather than objective as objectively speaking, we don’t have proof that souls exist yet we also don’t have proof that souls don’t exist as in a way, forms a logical contradiction.
whichAlso you kinda technically make a assumption tbh.
Yeah, we are not sure if they exist or not, that's why it shouldnt be assumed that it exist, because this is an indexing site, well, I can say that a magical elephant with rainbow wings are a thing, despite no proof of it, so, are we going to assume that it exists?"It is not proven that they exist"
Just as it is not proven that they do not exist
The part with the soul not existing or not as the soul is usually treated as something not physical to begin with and more akin to the spiritual side rather than the physical aspects.which
So, these verses works with souls, cool, doesnt means that souls exist in other verse, as you will need to prove it, and my question was mainly to IRL cases, as we do have IRL profiles, how do we treat it then?Because souls are a common concept in fiction, most stories you read might make references to souls, either it be ghosts, people dying or afterlife being a thing, is basically a widespread acceptance that everyone has a soul, either it is right or wrong.
Yeah, we are not sure if they exist or not, that's why it shouldnt be assumed that it exist, because this is an indexing site, well, I can say that a magical elephant with rainbow wings are a thing, despite no proof of it, so, are we going to assume that it exists?
Proving that there is no soul in a character is like proving that he is resistant to something, since soul manipulation is a common abiliy
Common sense in these cases is correct
but i did not made an assumption? I said that it is not proved, because it isntThe part with the soul not existing or not as the soul is usually treated as something not physical to begin with and more akin to the spiritual side rather than the physical aspects.
The assumption that other verses having all beings being soulless is simply not a good idea as you technically have to prove they are in fact actually soulless rather than lifeforms having a soul.So, these verses works with souls, cool, doesnt means that souls exist in other verse, as you will need to prove it
I did not assumed that these verses does not have a soul, I said that souls are not proved in the verse, so, you just can't assume that they have souls, as we have literally nothing that shows that it exist, and funily enough, the whole ''Souls exist'' thing comes from literally tales of thousand years ago, like mythologies, and again, mythologies are not proved eitherThe assumption that other verses having all beings being soulless is simply not a good idea as you technically have to prove they are in fact actually soulless rather than lifeforms having a soul.
I did not said it, I am literally asking about how we treat the IRL profiles, because different than fiction, which I can understand the soul argument there, IRL is IRLAlso you can make the same argument that irl profiles has never once make the assumption they are a soulless being as well tbh.
think you missed the part of the majority of verses agreeing souls are a thing, if it is a widespread concept, it is accepted because majority matters here for the most time, this isn't even a case of "like 10 verses agree on it", you'll have a hard time finding a single fictional work that doesn't have souls unless they are super IRL-ish.So, these verses works with souls, cool, doesnt means that souls exist in other verse, as you will need to prove it, and my question was mainly to IRL cases, as we do have IRL profiles, how do we treat it then?
Cool? it doesnt means that it existsMajority of the people in the world believe in souls / are still religious.
Yeah, I also asked about it before, iirc, why do we assume it? I can even understand about Mind if people treats Minds as Brain or whatever"why do we assume everyone to have concept"
"Why do we assume everyone to have a mind"
"Why do we assume everyone to Life force"
At the same time, we have no evidence it doesn’t exist irl since the soul is being treated as non physical and thereby make it impossible for it to exist or not exist to begin with.Cool? it doesnt means that it exists
And? I do belive that a magical pink elephant with rainbow wings exist, does it means that it exist? As I said, there is no evidence to it, so, why do we assume that it would work?Um, it exist to majority of the human population.
thats a reverse burden of proof, which just doesnt worksAt the same time, we have no evidence it doesn’t exist irl since the soul is being treated as non physical and thereby make it impossible for it to exist or not exist to begin with.
It does when quite frankly we have no reason to deny or accept the existence of the soul because the lack of evidence rather than just purely burden of proof to begin with.thats a reverse burden of proof, which just doesnt works
Wait 3000 years, science probably will shift greatlythats not common sense, thats appealing to fantasy in a wrong scenario, while the wiki says that it is a ''indexing site''
That's not even a thing, let's take the Lion, you cannot prove that a IRL Lion have a soul, so, Soul Hax should not work in lions, unless it's proven that a IRL lion have a soul, and the problem is, we do have IRL profiles here, and we cannot assume that IRL have souls
Tbf, Tier 2 and Tier 1 did came from the scientific theories that involved the multiverses and other things.****, the entire Tier 1 is almost purely assumption
if we have no reason to assume that something exist, why are we assuming that it does works in verses that NEVER stated that these things exists are real? look, Atoms exist, we can proof it, so, Atom Manipulation (matter hax) can work, however, Concepts, we have no proofs that concepts exist, so, Conceptual Hax is literally a fantasy, at least for now, unless someone proves it existenceIt does when quite frankly we have no reason to deny or accept the existence of a soul because the lack of evidence rather than just purely burden of proof to begin with.
why is it related? does something exist just because majority of humanity or a single person of humanity belives in?Your not the majority of humanity
what they think doesnt even matter, as they have 0 proofs of their claimsBut we are necessarily correct and majority of people would think we are wrong.
So, we are assuming that a thing that is not proven and is mainly from fantasy of thousand years ago are real because people wants it to be real?This, again, isn’t a factual debate, it’s entirely based in opinion.
Assumption is Assumption, so, lols, and I do belive in common sense, but only when the sense is common, such as if someone loses the head, they die, thats a common sense and also proved, but hey.99% of that thread is because the dude doesn't accept things like common sense or standard assumptions
NothingIf we have no proof that it exists and it doesn't, what are we going to do?
actually, MHA works with life essence, souls of previous heroes or whatever helping them, like what happens to one for all ability, so, it's safe that these things exist in MHA, so, Deku cannot have immunity to soul manip based in these things, but if we take a verse that is totally a human verse, assuming that souls exist is literally reversing the burden of proof"Deku has immunity to soul manipulation because that concept wasn't explored in the manga", but then someone else says "But at the same time it's never been proven that souls don't exist"; it's simply a cycle without an acceptable assumption
until it, not proved, I legit have no idea of why it is the standard assumptionWait 3000 years, science probably will shift greatly
it does comes from math/physic stuff, well, the verses with tier 1 are literally STATED to have these higher dimensions, so, as they stated in the verse, it does exist, I don't see how this is the case of souls****, the entire Tier 1 is almost purely assumption
thats actually, the best thing that we have currentlyTrying to disprove or prove things based on IRL science is a bad thing
Tier 1 comes from mathematical models from Set TheoryTbf, Tier 2 and Tier 1 did came from the scientific theories that involved the multiverses and other things.
Not entirely as there are scientific theories and all the stuff.Last I checked tier 1 is entirely based around mathematics now. Unlike the mystic nonsense it used to be
so concept hax shouldn't work on verses without concept hax? please do not try to downgrade/upgrade verses based on irl theories unless they are proven to apply without a doubt, don't even touch irlConcepts, we have no proofs that concepts exist, so, Conceptual Hax is literally a fantasy, at least for now, unless someone proves it existence