• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Whitebeard Earthquake Calcs

Status
Not open for further replies.

We actually do not see directly beneath Marineford, what we see is a cylinder of water around Marineford with 0 indication of what’s beneath. There’s no evidence or reason to assume that a massive stone structure far denser than water would magically float as opposed to being just built on an island. As far as your previous comment, WB could’ve just tilted the entire island, not like that’s out of his realm of power.
 
Yeah, no.
When WB splits MF, dudes fall straight to water. There's no ground underneath, just water.
Screenshot_2.png
 
When WB splits MF, dudes fall straight to water. There's no ground underneath, just water.

Water would fill in the crack in Marineford.
 
Gimme a few hours
The Whitebeard Pirates were able to sail under Marineford and travel+stay below the island.
vaOY6wF.jpg
oEbUn7u.jpg


When WB first shows up, he sets off 2 Tsunamis. 1 of them peeling off the ground of Marineford, showing that Marineford has a part under it that can be lifted by water.
WFww8VO.jpg


Shima Yurashi shows that Marineford is floating on water
Q1TBKI5.jpg
mjP5ss5.jpg


Aokiji Freezing the Water UNDER MARINEFORD produced Ice directly under the land, which is impossible if the island wasn't on top of water
9ALcSAh.jpg
7FFnlS0.jpg


Gura Gura users were capable of sinking the island
6UHp017.jpg
QZ6YJ8g.jpg
CDDkqYA.jpg

So yeah. Marineford is floating on water
 
Last edited:
The Whitebeard Pirates were able to sail under Marineford and travel+stay below the island.
One-Piece---Digital-Colored-Comics---c0551-(v056)---p177-%5BColored-Council%5D.jpg
One-Piece---Digital-Colored-Comics---c0566-(v058)---p058-%5BColored-Council%5D.jpg


When WB first shows up, he sets off 2 Tsunamis. 1 of them peeling off the ground of Marineford, showing that Marineford has a part under it that can be lifted by water.
One-Piece---Digital-Colored-Comics---c0552-(v057)---p008-%5BColored-Council%5D.jpg

Shima Yurashi shows that Marineford is floating on water
One-Piece---Digital-Colored-Comics---c0564-(v058)---p026-%5BColored-Council%5D.jpg
One-Piece---Digital-Colored-Comics---c0579-(v059)---p081-%5BColored-Council%5D.jpg


Aokiji Freezing the Water UNDER MARINEFORD produced Ice directly under the land, which is impossible if the island wasn't on top of water

One-Piece---Digital-Colored-Comics---c0565-(v058)---p039-%5BColored-Council%5D.jpg
One-Piece---Digital-Colored-Comics---c0575-(v059)---p023-%5BColored-Council%5D.jpg


Gura Gura users were capable of sinking the island
One-Piece---Digital-Colored-Comics---c0573-(v058)---p150-%5BColored-Council%5D.jpg
One-Piece---Digital-Colored-Comics---c0578-(v059)---p064-%5BColored-Council%5D.jpg
One-Piece---Digital-Colored-Comics---c0578-(v059)---p066-%5BColored-Council%5D.jpg

So yeah. Marineford is floating on water
Idk if you formatted this weird or it's an issue on my end, but all I see are censored links (a bunch of *)
 
The Whitebeard Pirates were able to sail under Marineford and travel+stay below the island.
vaOY6wF.jpg
oEbUn7u.jpg


When WB first shows up, he sets off 2 Tsunamis. 1 of them peeling off the ground of Marineford, showing that Marineford has a part under it that can be lifted by water.
WFww8VO.jpg


Shima Yurashi shows that Marineford is floating on water
Q1TBKI5.jpg
mjP5ss5.jpg


Aokiji Freezing the Water UNDER MARINEFORD produced Ice directly under the land, which is impossible if the island wasn't on top of water
9ALcSAh.jpg
7FFnlS0.jpg


Gura Gura users were capable of sinking the island
6UHp017.jpg
QZ6YJ8g.jpg
CDDkqYA.jpg

So yeah. Marineford is floating on water
1) First point doesn’t work because MF has an open port (shaped like a crescent moon), so they don’t need to have access directly under MF to pop up in the port like that.

2) That is less of water peeling off MF like a sticker and is likely more of WB quake causing some tectonic shifting on the sea floor which not only explains the ground elevation shift but explains the Tsunami as well, considering “sea quakes” are a frequent cause of Tsunamis.

3) I addressed this early with the post I sent with the link. We don’t actually see directly beneath MF there, we see a cylindrical section with water on the sides. You can’t claim there’s only water below there, cuz the cylinder we see is wider than MF, so the underside of the island can still be concealed and not contradict it being an actual island.

4) Not at all, Aokiji’s ice can simply be so cold that it freezes objects nearby without indirect contact. Furthermore, Aokiji freezing the water around the island would work to drastically lower the surrounding temperature making what I said above not far fetched. Either way, there objectively doesn’t need to be water beneath MF for Aokiji’s ice to freeze it if it’s cold enough (and considering his ice can combat magma, it’s probably cold enough).

5) Sinking MF by destroying the marine base and under water mountain (the island part) that it sits upon would sink it under water.

The fact we see MF has a lot of stone beneath it and is a massive concrete base, and then we see the water around it acts like regular irl water with people being able to swim in it and boats float, it’s too illogical to assume an utterly massive stone structure can float at all. There’s no indication of special properties or mechanisms that would point to a floating stone base that would otherwise realistically sink, it’s far more logical imo to assume MF sits atop an island.
 
1) First point doesn’t work because MF has an open port (shaped like a crescent moon), so they don’t need to have access directly under MF to pop up in the port like that.

2) That is less of water peeling off MF like a sticker and is likely more of WB quake causing some tectonic shifting on the sea floor which not only explains the ground elevation shift but explains the Tsunami as well, considering “sea quakes” are a frequent cause of Tsunamis.

3) I addressed this early with the post I sent with the link. We don’t actually see directly beneath MF there, we see a cylindrical section with water on the sides. You can’t claim there’s only water below there, cuz the cylinder we see is wider than MF, so the underside of the island can still be concealed and not contradict it being an actual island.

4) Not at all, Aokiji’s ice can simply be so cold that it freezes objects nearby without indirect contact. Furthermore, Aokiji freezing the water around the island would work to drastically lower the surrounding temperature making what I said above not far fetched. Either way, there objectively doesn’t need to be water beneath MF for Aokiji’s ice to freeze it if it’s cold enough (and considering his ice can combat magma, it’s probably cold enough).

5) Sinking MF by destroying the marine base and under water mountain (the island part) that it sits upon would sink it under water.

The fact we see MF has a lot of stone beneath it and is a massive concrete base, and then we see the water around it acts like regular irl water with people being able to swim in it and boats float, it’s too illogical to assume an utterly massive stone structure can float at all. There’s no indication of special properties or mechanisms that would point to a floating stone base that would otherwise realistically sink, it’s far more logical imo to assume MF sits atop an island.
1) This isn't the case, as we pretty blatantly see that some ships are in the direction facing the front of the port, which means they need to go through the back of the island

2) This isn't it either. We can blatantly see water under it lifting it up. This isn't the work of tectonic plates shifting, it's the work of the water pushing the island up.
Screen_Shot_2022-07-18_at_4.48.12_PM.png


3) Fair

4) I don't see at all how this tackled the point. It's a bunch of "coulds" and "shoulds".
Aokiji flat out froze the water under the part of the island. This isn't "he skipped part of it". He directly froze under it and froze outside of it.
With your argument he would've ended up freezing over the bay's edges as well, which he didn't from many shots. He froze under that part, which means that the bay has water under where the land is.
Screen_Shot_2022-07-18_at_4.53.17_PM.png


5) I'm sorry but what?
You do realize that isn't Whitebeard's power right? He would need to go under there and destroy it. Everything we see from him tilting it to letting water on, to causing 2 Tsunamis to even splitting it in half. Nothing at all says that he would do that.

This the same planet that has an island like this floating on top of nothing.
unknown.png


The laws of "it should've sunk" don't apply here.
 
1) This isn't the case, as we pretty blatantly see that some ships are in the direction facing the front of the port, which means they need to go through the back of the island

That just means that they would have turned around while underwater.

2) This isn't it either. We can blatantly see water under it lifting it up. This isn't the work of tectonic plates shifting, it's the work of the water pushing the island up.

In that screenshot the water looks like it is to the side of it, not directly underneath it.

This the same planet that has an island like this floating on top of nothing.

Technically speaking that island isn't floating on nothing. It is connected to land.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top