• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

The Revenant Marvel Comics Discussion Thread


Another statement of Nightmare's connection to the Astral Plane, plus SW discusses the belief-focused power of magic

Also, I love how Doctor Doom aura-farms here, bro has been Marvel's best aura farmer for decades now:
ef346975c1cb.png


Does anyone know the sources for these scans?

1, 3
Bump on this, btw
 
I am rather uncomfortable with how some people here seem to look up to a satanically evil character who once blew up an entire populated utopian universe out of petty spite. 🙏
 
I am rather uncomfortable with how some people here seem to look up to a satanically evil character who once blew up an entire populated utopian universe out of petty spite. 🙏
Not really "look up to" as so much as "Love to Hate"/"Evil is Cool".

Same with Cell from DBZ, and Cell was insanely sadistic and monstrous.

Or Hunter J from the Pokemon series.
 
Okay. Thank you for the clarification. 🙏
No problem.

Another good example of a despicable yet cool villain is Abijah Fowler from the (excellent) show "Blue Eye Samurai" (his voice actor absolutely nailed the role, which helps).

Now, Fowler is a sociopathic monster, having been involved in mass human trafficking all across Japan, having murdered dozens of his bastard children and their mothers, and wanting to launch a coup in Japan he cheerfully knows will kill thousands at minimum so that he can turn Japan into a British colony. This is a guy so twisted that he only figures out that Mizu is a woman in disguise from the sounds her bones make when he breaks them.

That said, his combat prowess, cunning, surprising depth to his character (such as being talented in the arts), and his tragic past (lost his family and was forced to eat his sister's kidneys to survive the real-life Irish famine of the early 1600's, which IRL killed 100,000 Irish) make him an incredibly compelling and entertaining character who fans couldn't get enough of.

 
Well, I strongly disagree with the entire fundamental concept of that genuinely evil people can ever truly be "cool", rather than just wanting to appear that way, and my story extensively explored that area. 🙏
 
Cool heavily implies admireable, so I still strongly disagree. True real world evil is completely hollow at its core. Anything else is a marketing distortion. 🙏
 
Cool heavily implies admireable, so I still strongly disagree. True real world evil is completely hollow at its core. Anything else is a marketing distortion. 🙏
Evil people can be admireable in aspects of their being, a merciless general who kills civilians may result cool due to his war tactics and the countries he conquered, the way this person speaks, the ways he dresses, his presence, there are many different aspects of a person can be admireable, doesn't matter if they're evil or good
 
Cool heavily implies admireable, so I still strongly disagree. True real world evil is completely hollow at its core. Anything else is a marketing distortion. 🙏
Literally every marvel character including doctor doom couldn’t possibly be evil by your definition, because there are a very small handful of marvel characters that are completely hollow at their core
 
Well, Marvel Comics is also usually an extreme distortion of how evil fundamentally works in reality according to my experience. Virtually all truly evil people are spiritual nobodies who crave adulation, power, sex, wealth, totalitarian control, and sadistic cruelty to fill the voids within themselves. But since Hitler, Trump, Stalin and the like are vain, fragile, neurotic, and pathetic beings at their cores, who are wholly dependent on enormous marketing to appear as impressive "strongmen", it often doesn't work from a narrative standpoint to set up their types of real world personalities as antagonists in stories to impose a sufficient sense of threat to it.

Regardless, it doesn't seem like we will proceed to any agreement here, so... Did anybody read the new issue of Thor today? I liked it as usual. 🙏
 
Evil people can be admireable in aspects of their being, a merciless general who kills civilians may result cool due to his war tactics and the countries he conquered, the way this person speaks, the ways he dresses, his presence, there are many different aspects of a person can be admireable, doesn't matter if they're evil or good
However, that seems like an extremely amoral, shallow, and simplistic definition of admireable human qualities. 🙏
 
but it is the definition, since what someone finds admireable or a quality or moral changes from person to person
I apologise for my too harsh tone earlier, but as anybody who has read my story knows, I have a major personal issue with when any form of media, culture, or ideology attempts to make genuine evil seem like something admireable, cool, and laudable. 🙏
 
I just found an obscure quite recent YouTube interview with Al Ewing, mainly about his Thor run.

Among other things, he also strongly disliked that another writer mischaracterised Thor as supporting Doctor Doom's fascist world takeover (although there have been a lot of deliberate Thor potshot mischaracterisations over the years, including letting him support Hydra's Captain America copy), mentions that overfocus on who is able to kill who power levels as some kind of virtue, to the exclusion of any genuine ethics and story appreciation is inherently somewhat fascistic, and discusses his "Chad Hammer" late stage capitalism parody story (all of which I agree with), but also seems to agree with the Storm writer going on a very extreme "bestest best that ever bestest bestbestbestbestbest!!!!" power trip, which I have personally considered annoying and a double standard, but we cannot agree about everything.



🙏
 
Last edited:
I just found an obscure quite recent YouTube interview with Al Ewing, mainly about his Thor run.

Among other things, he also strongly disliked that another writer mischaracterised Thor as supporting Doctor Doom's fascist world takeover (although there have been a lot of deliberate Thor potshot mischaracterisations over the years, including letting him support Hydra's Captain America copy), mentions that overfocus on who is able to kill who power levels as some kind of virtue, to the exclusion of any genuine ethics and story appreciation is inherently somewhat fascistic, and discusses his "Chad Hammer" late stage capitalism parody story (all of which I agree with), but also seems to agree with the Storm writer going on a very extreme "bestest best that ever bestest bestbestbestbestbest!!!!" power trip, which I have personally considered annoying and a double standard, but we cannot agree about everything.



🙏

It is odd that Thor supported Doom given that Doom harvested Asgardians one time (committing some nasty experiments on them during that time) and tried doing so again in the 2020 series (though in that case Doom actually came in clutch by protecting baby Hela in the past long enough for Thor to arrive).
 
It isn't odd. Many of the Marvel Comics writers evidently truly hate Thor as a concept, and take any chance to depict him in an extremely negative manner that does not make any logical sense historically speaking. Odin has been treated even worse, and seems afflicted with a Sentry-level dual personality disorder at this point because of it. 🙏
 
Last edited:
For what I remember Thor didn't actually supported Doom, he basically said that a King of earth is not a bad idea since Asgard is ruled by a King and it worked for a long time, he then said that based on what he saw that Doom was doing well for the world, at that point they were not aware Doom was harvasting people's energy into powerful magic to change the world. He didn't just said that without first confirming that Doom wasn't mind controlling people, and despite considering himself an Emperor, Doom's rules weren't cruel, he wasn't limiting people's freedom. Ultimately they came to know he was doing a lot of bad behind the scenes which obviously Thor would have changed his mind, although I think he disappeared, I think objectively speaking being capable of seeing good in another political view is not a bad thing.
 
Thor should canonically know that an evil narcissistic egomaniacal tyrant with a history of sacrificing somebody who loved him to demons and turning her into magic skin armor for power, and who blew up an entire utopian universe out of petty spite and jealousy, and likely used mental enslavement magic on the world leaders, and applied draconian death penalties against everybody who broke his laws in the slightest, would not be an ideal ruler of the Earth...

The writer of the story was likely just yet another one in a long line who hates Thor, has somehow rationalised Scandinavia into being a root of evil in the world, rather than one of the most harmless spots, and took an opportunity to undermine and slander him. It has happened quite frequently. 🙏
 
Last edited:
Thor should canonically know that an evil narcissistic egomaniacal tyrant with a history of sacrificing somebody who loved him to demons and turning her into magic skin armor for power, and who blew up an entire utopian universe out of petty spite and jealousy, and likely used mental enslavement magic on the world leaders, would not be an ideal ruler of the Earth.

The writer of the story was likely just yet another one in a long line who hates Thor, has somehow rationalised Scandinavia into being a root of evil in the world, and took an opportunity to undermine and slander him. It has happened quite frequently. 🙏
That seems like an extreme leap in logic to take it...
 
Not after seeing a pattern of this happening over and over and over for many years, and it was completely out of character for Thor. 🙏
 
Thor should canonically know that an evil narcissistic egomaniacal tyrant with a history of sacrificing somebody who loved him to demons and turning her into magic skin armor for power, and who blew up an entire utopian universe out of petty spite and jealousy, and likely used mental enslavement magic on the world leaders, and applied draconian death penalties against everybody who broke his laws in the slightest, would not be an ideal ruler of the Earth...

The writer of the story was likely just yet another one in a long line who hates Thor, has somehow rationalised Scandinavia into being a root of evil in the world, rather than one of the most harmless spots, and took an opportunity to undermine and slander him. It has happened quite frequently. 🙏
Thor never said Doom was good, only said that Doom was doing good and the things he accomplished in very little time were impressive. As I said before, Thor and the rest of the avengers went to make sure Doom was not using mind manipulation on the world leader, only then did Thor ssaid some good things about what Doom was doing, also the people were happy with the changes, the avengers were against Doom not because he was doing evil but because he did evil in the past and therefore assumed he was doing it again, Thor asked the Avengers to give it a second though before going after Doom.
 
And that was way too stupid and unsympathetic a sentiment to fit for Thor. 🙏
 
the avengers were against Doom not because he was doing evil but because he did evil in the past and therefore assumed he was doing it again
Is this supposed be in Victor's defense? Because honestly the Avengers being against Doom in that context seems pretty reasonable given his track record.

Like if Joseph Stalin somehow rose from the dead tomorrow and opened a soup kitchen you wouldn't exactly assume he has the community's best interests at heart even if he he seemingly hasn't done anything evil yet.
 
Is this supposed be in Victor's defense? Because honestly the Avengers being against Doom in that context seems pretty reasonable given his track record.

Like if Joseph Stalin somehow rose from the dead tomorrow and opened a soup kitchen you wouldn't exactly assume he has the community's best interests at heart even if he he seemingly hasn't done anything evil yet.
I'm not defending him from his acts, he is evil and was sacrificing his own people to archive this which in my opinion is against his whole history.
I'm saying that Thor saw the good that Doom was doing and that's why he asked for the avengers to think if they should really go against Doom, if something I'm defending Thor.
 
And that was way too stupid and unsympathetic a sentiment to fit for Thor. 🙏
So uh... once again, someone is trying to merge MCU and Marvel Comics cosmologies
 
So uh... once again, someone is trying to merge MCU and Marvel Comics cosmologies
Thank you. Planck handled it. 🙏
 
The writer of the story was likely just yet another one in a long line who hates Thor, has somehow rationalised Scandinavia into being a root of evil in the world, rather than one of the most harmless spots, and took an opportunity to undermine and slander him. It has happened quite frequently. 🙏
I think that this was a stupid hasty sentiment of me. I don't think that it is about Scandinavia (I just find it annoying that the single prominent Scandinavian superhero has ended up as a general scapegoat), but I have seen a writer illogically connect Thor with Nazism in an interview (the Nazis completely bastardised religions and mythology from all over the world, not just Viking mythology), and others do seem to inaccurately automatically associate him with the global patriarchy, even though he is very chivalrous and respectful of women when written properly, so that seems to be two major reasons for the neverending attempts to severely negatively distort and thereby slander him, whereas the most extremely corrupt cases, such as Jonathan Hickman and Kieron Gillen seem to take excruciating pleasure in systematically defiling, corrupting, and violating virtually anything kind and noble that they touch into absolutely malevolent, morbid, sadistic, filthy, and amoral dystopian memetic mind cancer, not remotely limited to Thor alone. 🙏
 
Well, the Murewa interview is out, and it was of a far too forced ingratiating nature to dare to feature any of our straightforward questions. In addition, it seems like Murewa is yet another amoral asshole Marvel writer who literally doesn't see anything wrong with annihilating an infinite amount of sentient beings for purely self-serving reasons, and considers himself openminded for thinking that way.

Given this, combined with the extremely power-tripping cosmology-sledgehammering nature of his Storm run, I truly hope that he is never employed by either Marvel Comics or DC Comics ever again, and that the entire story is written off as an imaginary tale that is completely incompatible with the rest of continuity, but with much of the horribly proudly amoral editorial management of Marvel Comics still in place, who knows?

 
Last edited:
Back
Top