Stargate Discussion Thread

[TheAngryOrange]

Indeed

 

[Livingcoffee]

Am I just meant to write replies like this with the stuff?

 

[TheAngryOrange]

More or less. Now ultimately if you have a calc you want approved you need a calc mod to approve it. There is a thread to submit calcs to evaluate. If you have ideas you want to discuss or really anything to discuss, post it here.

 

[Livingcoffee]

More or less. Now ultimately if you have a calc you want approved you need a calc mod to approve it. There is a thread to submit calcs to evaluate. If you have ideas you want to discuss or really anything to discuss, post it here.

The calc I needed doing was an Ori prior crushing the planet with his shield into a black hole, but I have literally no idea what to do. I had someone in my Discord server say it would be small star level and sent this "

1. So the Calc that you referenced about the planet being crushed into a Black hole, then imploding was relatively simple (assuming my Logic is correct)The people squishing the Planet should upscale from the explosion- since by squeezing it theyre maintaining the blast.The Blast would be higher than the Planet’s Durability. Now Assuming it’s earth’s mass, you’d just put it in a basic calculator to calculate the Gravity Binding Energy for a planet the weight of Earth yet the size of 0.89mm (because any smaller and it would’ve collapsed into a black hole).The force needed to Destroy the planet would be 0.6* GM^2/R, where m is mass and r is radius.Assuming a mass of 0.0089m and 5.97210^24kg, you’d get An AP of 1.610^41J, or Low4C Small Star Level (edited)
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
   
2. [23:20]
   The AP of whoever you’re scaling would decently Upscale, since the explosion seems more than enough to destroy the planet (also considering they’re able to crush the planet to a small size, small star level seems reasonable, literally the AP to destroy the earth 800,000,000 times over)"

 

[TheAngryOrange]

You could also try this

Black Hole Feats in Fiction

When it comes to the topic of black holes there are a lot of common misconceptions about their nature and through that also misconceptions about the evaluation of feats involving them. Generally, black holes are often depicted wrong in works of fiction. While a completely correct depiction can...

vsbattles.fandom.com

"To roughly estimate the Attack Potency level one can then compare its mass to either that of the Earth or the Sun, whichever is closer to its mass. If it's x times the mass of the object it is compared to, we estimate that its creation would equal about x times the energy needed to destroy said object, i.e. either x-times baseline planet level for Earth or x-times baseline star level for the Sun."

That was for if you didn't know the mass of the black hole. But since it was a planet squished into a black hole and Kallana is presumably identical to Earth we have a mass making it closer to planet level.

Ultimately, you can consult a calc mod to see if they accept your explanation. You can post the thread in Questions&Answers.

 

[Livingcoffee]

You could also try this

Black Hole Feats in Fiction

When it comes to the topic of black holes there are a lot of common misconceptions about their nature and through that also misconceptions about the evaluation of feats involving them. Generally, black holes are often depicted wrong in works of fiction. While a completely correct depiction can...

vsbattles.fandom.com

"To roughly estimate the Attack Potency level one can then compare its mass to either that of the Earth or the Sun, whichever is closer to its mass. If it's x times the mass of the object it is compared to, we estimate that its creation would equal about x times the energy needed to destroy said object, i.e. either x-times baseline planet level for Earth or x-times baseline star level for the Sun."

That was for if you didn't know the mass of the black hole. But since it was a planet squished into a black hole and Kallana is presumably identical to Earth we have a mass making it closer to planet level.

Ultimately, you can consult a calc mod to see if they accept your explanation. You can post the thread in Questions&Answers.

Where did you get that Kallana is presumably identical to Earth? Cuz if you check the diameter of it, it's smaller then the moon

 

[TheAngryOrange]

Presumption of an earth-like size via earth-like conditions such as gravity. Where did you get the diameter from? Is it from one of the books?

 

[Livingcoffee]

They say the bomb has a radius of 100 miles, and if you use that as a reference,e then you should be able to work out how long the diameter is however because Stargate has always had an issue with scaling, based on what I have done, the planet's diameter could either be 2010 miles or 4600 miles

Presumption of an earth-like size via earth-like conditions such as gravity. Where did you get the diameter from? Is it from one of the books?

 

[Livingcoffee]

 

[TheAngryOrange]

That could work. Just be warned. Smaller planet means smaller AP and given the earth-like conditions you can get away with an earth size.

This would put kallana between the moon (2 k mi diameter) and the earth (8 k mi diameter) in size. I'd estimate small planet AP.

 

[Livingcoffee]

That could work. Just be warned. Smaller planet means smaller AP and given the earth-like conditions you can get away with an earth size.

This would put kallana between the moon (2 k mi diameter) and the earth (8 k mi diameter) in size. I'd estimate small planet AP.

I think I have got it to planet level AP, as it would take 1.64 x 10^33 N to crush the planet into a black hole, while planet level needs 2.487195084 x 10^32

 

[Livingcoffee]

I think I have got it to planet level AP, as it would take 1.64 x 10^33 N to crush the planet into a black hole, while planet level needs 2.487195084 x 10^32

Actually, it might just be star level but is could mean the solar system all at once as is says the sun and planets

 

[Livingcoffee]

Two Ha'taks are able to make a star go nova

 

[TheAngryOrange]

Do you have the book/chapter/page?

 

[Livingcoffee]

Do you have the book/chapter/page?

It's from a roleplaying game however it is licensed by MGM and I know other verses that use statements from roleplaying books. Stargate SG-1: Living Gods: Stargate System Lords, chapter 2, page 31

Also I misread the statement, one Ha'tak made a star go nova but it happened twice in two different solar systems

 

[Livingcoffee]

Do you have the book/chapter/page?

Just trying to get The Ancients page up but they aren't replying to me anymore

 

[TheAngryOrange]

Give them some time. Things move slowly around here.

I found it. I can now provide a screen cap. Now this can easily be added to the feats. But in terms of getting it to stick to AP, that might be a harder sell. I'll surely ask. But without knowing precisely how, there's no guarantee I can get people to sign off on it.

 

[Livingcoffee]

Give them some time. Things move slowly around here.

I found it. I can now provide a screen cap. Now this can easily be added to the feats. But in terms of getting it to stick to AP, that might be a harder sell. I'll surely ask. But without knowing precisely how, there's no guarantee I can get people to sign off on it.

I'm sure you would be able to work out how much energy it would take to make a star go nova and equate that into AP

 

[Livingcoffee]

Give them some time. Things move slowly around here.

I found it. I can now provide a screen cap. Now this can easily be added to the feats. But in terms of getting it to stick to AP, that might be a harder sell. I'll surely ask. But without knowing precisely how, there's no guarantee I can get people to sign off on it.

What is the main stuff you are focusing on? My main one is The Ancients and then Merlin, Ba'al, Anubis, Todd, Teal'c

 

[TheAngryOrange]

TheAngryOrange/StargateSandbox

vsbattles.fandom.com

TheAngryOrange/StargateSandbox2

vsbattles.fandom.com

The ones closest to finished would be the kull warrior, death glider, and alkesh. relying either on statements or calculations that were already accepted.

As you can see the goa'uld empire, 304, and replicators are still in the works. At least Goa'uld and Replicators are since those would be new pages. The 304 is a change to an existing page.

 

[Livingcoffee]

TheAngryOrange/StargateSandbox

vsbattles.fandom.com

TheAngryOrange/StargateSandbox2

vsbattles.fandom.com

The ones closest to finished would be the kull warrior, death glider, and alkesh. relying either on statements or calculations that were already accepted.

As you can see the goa'uld empire, 304, and replicators are still in the works. At least Goa'uld and Replicators are since those would be new pages. The 304 is a change to an existing page.

For the Kull Warrior you should add, Supernatural will (as they don't feel pain), regeneration (due to the goa'uld), energy absorption and resistance to sleep manipulation, fear manipulation, pain manipulation.

 

[TheAngryOrange]

Just had to make sure that new profiles didn't require CRT. Give the aforementioned profiles a final look over for anything you think should be added. If not, I'll probably add it next week. Reminder this is the kull, death glider, and alkesh.

 

[Livingcoffee]

Just had to make sure that new profiles didn't require CRT. Give the aforementioned profiles a final look over for anything you think should be added. If not, I'll probably add it next week. Reminder this is the kull, death glider, and alkesh.

Any new updates on Stargate stuff?

 

[TheAngryOrange]

I admit I've been slacking. I'll put the kull warrior up soon. Also still need to update the 304 page. And I guess I could put the SG teams up on there. I mean the wiki has Kirk so normal people won't be overshaowed. Give me a bit. I'll swing back to it.

I also intend to make a verse page.

 

[TheAngryOrange]

Any new updates on Stargate stuff?

By the way. Has your calcs for the MK IX been accepted? I want to revise the 304. Or I guess I could see if I can get my calc accepted

TheAngryOrange/StargateSandbox

vsbattles.fandom.com