Smaug vs Harry Potter characters

[TheVividen]

Smaug flies over the Ministry of Magic as the Order of the Phoenix is fighting Voldemort's forces. He sees the wizards as tasty treats and decides to attack all of them at once. Who wins?

Smaug: 4 OotP: 0

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Smaug https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Harry_Potter_(verse)

 

[MasterOfArda]

Scales bounce every spell. The wizards are tasty treats.

 

[Meosos]

Most spells are useless and just bounce from Smaugs skin. Not sure about Fiendfyre, but even an army of aurors would be useless against Smaug. He roasts them, onless they teleport away. Seems like a stomp.

 

[ZacharyGrossman273]

Smaug is 7-B, Voldemort is 8-B, Smaug solos HP with ease.

 

[MasterOfArda]

Bump

 

[TheVividen]

Bump

 

[TheVividen]

Bumpity-bump

 

[RoyGundam]

does Avada Kedavra negate durability ? It's technically Death Manipulation right ? Also Basilisk petrification and death manipulation. And Death Eater soul manipulation. Smaug doesn't take HP verse, but if it's just a bunch of wizards - then he easily wins

 

[MasterOfArda]

does Avada Kedavra negate durability ? It's technically Death Manipulation right ? Also Basilisk petrification and death manipulation. And Death Eater soul manipulation. Smaug doesn't take HP verse, but if it's just a bunch of wizards - then he easily wins

Avada Kedavra bounces off scales and the like, Basilisks would do as much damage to smaug as the wizards, and death eaters don't have soul manipulation.

 

[RoyGundam]

Why do you assume that Avada Kedavra would bounce off of scales ? Sure, it was never used against any dragon in Harry Potter, but it is still classified as Death Manipulation and does ignore conventional durability.

Basilisks kill by eye contact. Straight up Death Manipulation. Even indirect eye contact causes petrification.

Sorry, I meant Dementors, not Death Eaters. Dementors ca suck out your soul and eat it. Clear-cut soul manipulation. I believe there are even more powerful beasts in the new movie.

Short answer, no - Smaug doesn't take Harry Potter verse by himself

 

[MasterOfArda]

Harry Potter wizards would have the same problem as Samug with Basilisks.

Other similar spells bounce off dragons. Why would Avada Kedavra work?

Dementos can't keep up with Samug.

Short answer: Samug easily solos harry potter verse

 

[RoyGundam]

Harry Potter wizards would have the same problem as Samug with Basilisks.
Other similar spells bounce off dragons. Why would Avada Kedavra work?

Dementos can't keep up with Samug.

Short answer: Samug easily solos harry potter verse

so ? Smaug still dies at the first instance of eye contact with a Basilisk. Besides, Parselmouths ca control all snakes - including Basilisks

Avada Kedavra is not most spells - Other spells can be defended against by using defensive spells like Protego, Avada Kedavra can't be blocked or parried.

There are thousands of dementors - they can also fly and have a passive AoE effect as well.

Stop with the downplay

 

[ZacharyGrossman273]

Isn't Death from Harry potter 8-A?

 

[TheVividen]

Actually Avada Kedavra can be blocked. It's been deflected by animated statues before; anything tough enough physically, it seems, just has passive magic resistance to HP spells.

 

[TheVividen]

Just to clarify I'm not saying Smaug would solo HP, but he would do better against their "all-catchers" than some people would say.

 

[MasterOfArda]

Harry Potter wizards would have the same problem as Samug with Basilisks.
Other similar spells bounce off dragons. Why would Avada Kedavra work?

Dementos can't keep up with Samug.

Short answer: Samug easily solos harry potter verse

so ? Smaug still dies at the first instance of eye contact with a Basilisk. Besides, Parselmouths ca control all snakes - including Basilisks
Avada Kedavra is not most spells - Other spells can be defended against by using defensive spells like Protego, Avada Kedavra can't be blocked or parried.

There are thousands of dementors - they can also fly and have a passive AoE effect as well.

Stop with the downplay

Where will they find a basilisk

As the vividen said.

But they are increadiably slow.

 

[RoyGundam]

Actually Avada Kedavra can be blocked. It's been deflected by animated statues before; anything tough enough physically, it seems, just has passive magic resistance to HP spells.

Animated statues are not living creatures, it works on living creatures only and kills without leaving any marks. It is still Death Manip. but the strength of the spell depends on the skills of the caster. Crouch Jr said that all of his students could cast Avada Kedavra on him and nothing would happen. Most Death Eaters and Voldemort can casually kill people. It's debatable if Voldemort could kill a dragon using Avada Kedavra, but multiple Stunning spells could keep a Dragon under control (they were not trying to kill it). A large number of Avada Kedavras could very well kill Smaug - especially if Voldemort and Dumbledore are there in the mix (Dumbledore had the most powerful wand)

 

[MasterOfArda]

Actually Avada Kedavra can be blocked. It's been deflected by animated statues before; anything tough enough physically, it seems, just has passive magic resistance to HP spells.

Animated statues are not living creatures, it works on living creatures only and kills without leaving any marks. It is still Death Manip. but the strength of the spell depends on the skills of the caster. Crouch Jr said that all of his students could cast Avada Kedavra on him and nothing would happen. Most Death Eaters and Voldemort can casually kill people. It's debatable if Voldemort could kill a dragon using Avada Kedavra, but multiple Stunning spells could keep a Dragon under control (they were not trying to kill it). A large number of Avada Kedavras could very well kill Smaug - especially if Voldemort and Dumbledore are there in the mix (Dumbledore had the most powerful wand)

But what does that wand do?

 

[Czuczian11]

Whole HP universe is actualy muggles as well. Few Imperio on most powerfull countries govement head figures would make usage of nukes possible. But aside from that (it's very unlikely to happen). Smaug has no way to destroy Dementors. Not like it's NLF but they are Amoral and are unable to die basically (as they are unliving by default but not undead) and as far as i can remember Smaug can't seal anything. I doubt they can suck Smaug's soul alone but if all of them combined their power it's possible imo. Also i think wizards could entrap Smaug eventually in one of their poket-dimmension esque thing eventually. And do not foget that Smaug was killed by human with crossbow.

 

[MasterOfArda]

First off, that weakness is nigh impossible to hit.

Second, having real countries here defeats the point of Samug versus HP verse.

Finally, we don't actaully know the mechanics of dementors.

As far as we know they are not intangible.

 

[TheVividen]

Maybe my scenario was a little confusing. This isn't supposed to be Smaug vs HP verse, it's Smaug vs the Order of the Phoenix and the elite Death Eaters that were present at the Ministry during the end of the fifth book.

 

[MasterOfArda]

Okay.

Stomp.

 

[TheVividen]

Bump

 

[MasterOfArda]

Its a stomp.

 

[TheVividen]

So far Smaug: 4 Wizards and witches: 0 Will this get to 7?

 

[TheVividen]

Bump

 

[MasterOfArda]

You do realize it's a stomp right?

 

[TheVividen]

It can still be debated. Bumpity-bump.

 

[MrKingOfNegativity]

As a counter to the 'Basilisks making eye-contact' argument, what are they going to do against Smaug if he decides to just roast them from the air? 'Supersonic+ to High Hypersonic flight speed' means he'll be moving faster than eyes can track.

On-Topic: Potterverse has no chance. Reasons have already been given as to why.