• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Sherlock Holmes (BBC) vs Roman Bridger (Scream)

Messages
380
Reaction score
77
Rules:

1 - Both are 9-C

2 - Speed equalized

3 - Fight takes place in Stu House

4 - Both will have prior knowledge of each other


The Detective:

The Director:

He-directs.webp
tumblr-lrzd4l-Qg-RV1qfu9ibo1-r1-640.jpg

(Geez, these images are horrible)
 
Cool match

Sherlock seems to be the better fighter. As well as higher LS and stamina

Sherlock also has a whip and sword listed as standard equipment, which are better than knives

... he also has firearms that might make this a stomp. You need to give Roman his optional equipment to access his gun.
 
he also has firearms that might make this a stomp. You need to give Roman his optional equipment to access his gun.
Although true. He does need his gun to make this even... But by the look of things it seems Roman can handle himself just fine against guns using a bullet proof vest and being able to recover quickly.
 
Sherlock has the AP advantage, the Staima advantage and the LS advantage. And Sherlock is a much better fighter.

And because Sherlock has prior knowledge of Roman, he uses his Analytical Prediction ability to anticipate Roman's actions and gain a huge advantage.

Also Sherlock has better stealth feats.

I vote DETECTIVE
 
Sherlock has the AP advantage, the Staima advantage and the LS advantage. And Sherlock is a much better fighter.
Sherlock also appears to be a far more capable fighter than Roman giving him a better edge In combat aside from these stated advantages. Put me down for Mr No Shit.

And because Sherlock has prior knowledge of Roman, he uses his Analytical Prediction ability to anticipate
Prior knowledge of Roman seems like a big big issue.. it lowers any wincon he has which makes me curious... It'd be a stomp if Roman has not a single wincon available that ignores whatever Sherlock can do.
Also, is Sherlock's ANPR combat applicable? It doesn't seem to be based on how the profile describes it.... It seems more of Info Analysis and Data Analysis to predict future outcome of human behavior as any Detective would have in their department. Is it combat ANPR tho? That's what I'm asking.
 
Also, is Sherlock's ANPR combat applicable? It doesn't seem to be based on how the profile describes it.... It seems more of Info Analysis and Data Analysis to predict future outcome of human behavior as any Detective would have in their department. Is it combat ANPR tho? That's what I'm asking.
Yes, Sherlock's ANPR is definitely combat applicable. His intelligence allows him to mentally simulate entire scenarios before they unfold.
For instance, in the case of the planned parliament bombing, he deduces the exact location of the bomb by simulating the explosion in shorts time and logically tracing it back. In The Lying Detective, he accurately predicts every event before it even begins.

With prior knowledge of Roman, He can do the same at the start of combat, effectively simulating how the entire fight will play out.
 
Yes, Sherlock's ANPR is definitely combat applicable. His intelligence allows him to mentally simulate entire scenarios before they unfold.
For instance, in the case of the planned parliament bombing, he deduces the exact location of the bomb by simulating the explosion in shorts time and logically tracing it back. In The Lying Detective, he accurately predicts every event before it even begins.

With prior knowledge of Roman, He can do the same at the start of combat, effectively simulating how the entire fight will play out.
Rather interesting. Idk, I'm starting to believe Roman is at his wits end here, as if he's getting stomped solely by this ability of Sherlock. Combat is seeking death as he's fighting against a already overall superior opponent with guns. There isn't really much Roman can do with prior knowledge.. and even if he had prep time, he's still getting cooked and sizzled by ANPR with Sherlock outpredicting the actions he's able to commit with the knowledge he has of Roman.
 
Although true. He does need his gun to make this even... But by the look of things it seems Roman can handle himself just fine against guns using a bullet proof vest and being able to recover quickly.
Sherlock shoots him on the head ig

I honestly leaning Sherlock, so I'm voting him
 
Back
Top