Rey Skywalker

[Alsotime]

This should be a pretty simple content revision.

I propose changing Rey’s profile name from Rey to Rey Skywalker.

I assume all crt need scans so.

I was browsing her page and I noticed it wasn’t there and I figured why not.

It’s something already acknowledged by her page, and it’s the thing she goes by at the end of the series so I figure it should be added to the actual title of the page similar to Anakin and Luke.


For reference the Star Wars wiki also does the same thing

So theres also that.

 

[DimeUhDozen]

vomits profusely

i... i.... agre-

VOMITS EVEN HARDER.

 

[koopa3144]

Ngl I'm pretty sure you could just requested the profiles name be changed in the All-purpose request thread without the need to make a crt.

 

[Alsotime]

Ngl I'm pretty sure you could just requested the profiles name be changed in the All-purpose request thread without the need to make a crt.

Oh, I uhm, I didn’t know that.

 

[Gonzalo]

No...

 

[AThe1412]

No...

I agree.

 

[Cropfist]

Yeah, there is no reason to add this when it's a controversial spoiler.

 

[Alsotime]

Yeah, there is no reason to add this when it's a controversial spoiler.

Controversy doesn’t really matter when it comes to things that are, if people don’t like that irs her name it doesn’t really matter because it will always be that, if someone doesn’t like Rey I highly doubt they are going to be looking at her page anyway.

Rise of Skywalker came out 5 years ago, there are pages that get updated per chapter, her being named Skywalker isn’t something that reveals much, and it’s going to be stated on her profile anyway so they’d be spoiled anyway.

No...

I agree.

Why is that?

 

[Cropfist]

It's an informal title only used in the last minute of her last appearance. There is no reason to add it over the current name.

 

[IdiosyncraticLawyer]

This is, legitimately what Rey is named, and this anti-accuracy attitude is frustrating.

@Alsotime I am going to have this thread locked. Feel free to post in https://vsbattles.com/threads/all-purpose-request-thread-new-forum.107534/ to request this move.

 

[GarrixianXD]

this anti-accuracy attitude is frustrating.

I honestly understand everyone’s feelings here lol, but reality is often disappointing.

 

[CharlesZaGreat]

This is fine

 

[Snek]

I mean we could do the mature thing. Or we could just call her ma-ray sue or star killer with wars after the word star . In all seriousness this change is fine and calling her a skywalker is what an indexing website should do but still that won't stop me from being mildly annoyed lol .

 

[IdiosyncraticLawyer]

<snip>

Knock it off with the immature bashing. This site is not a place for people to whine about characters they don't like.

 

[LephyrTheRevanchist]

This site is not a place for people to whine about characters they don't like.

are you sure about that?

You're making this more problematic than it needs to be. The guy clearly ain't taking it that seriously.

 

[IdiosyncraticLawyer]

are you sure about that?

You're making this more problematic than it needs to be. The guy clearly ain't taking it that seriously.

I unequivocally dislike accusations of "Mary Sue" towards any character whatsoever because it invites flame wars.

 

[SlendVeny]

I unequivocally dislike accusations of "Mary Sue" towards any character whatsoever because it invites flame wars.

I watched Mortis, said "Anakin is kinda just a Mary Sue here," and was immediately crucified.

Anyway, I agree with this.

 

[LephyrTheRevanchist]

I unequivocally dislike accusations of "Mary Sue" towards any character whatsoever because it invites flame wars.

Notice how it wasn't a problem until you made it into one?

Simply ignore it, my guy. When it starts becoming problematic and inviting flame wars, report and GG.

 

[Snek]

Thanks for the defense anyways I wasn't posting very seriously and am a little suprised by the response when I verbatim called this change the mature thing. I do have issues with the sequels but me suggesting changing her name to starkiller with extra content was just a jest and the ma-ray sue bit was done purely because I appreciate good wordplay.

I thought me saying in all seriousness would make that apparent but I'm clearly at fault for playing too loose and for that I apologize. Agree with the change see ya later.

 

[Nierre]

I thought me saying in all seriousness would make that apparent but I'm clearly at fault for playing too loose and for that I apologize.

u have no reason to apologize, you said it in passing as a joke. he just took it too seriously for no reason lol

 

[Cropfist]

Yeah, it was clearly a joke comment and the overly defensive seething reaction was whiny if anything

 

[IdiosyncraticLawyer]

Notice how it wasn't a problem until you made it into one?

Simply ignore it, my guy. When it starts becoming problematic and inviting flame wars, report and GG.

u have no reason to apologize, you said it in passing as a joke. he just took it too seriously for no reason lol

Yeah, it was clearly a joke comment and the overly defensive seething reaction was whiny if anything

First, I don't appreciate being called "my guy." Second, I'm trying to preempt fights here, and being called "whiny" and "seething" for doing so is also improper.

Thanks for the defense anyways I wasn't posting very seriously and am a little suprised by the response when I verbatim called this change the mature thing. I do have issues with the sequels but me suggesting changing her name to starkiller with extra content was just a jest and the ma-ray sue bit was done purely because I appreciate good wordplay.

I thought me saying in all seriousness would make that apparent but I'm clearly at fault for playing too loose and for that I apologize. Agree with the change see ya later.

It's still a controversial thing to say even if you didn't mean it that way.

 

[Emerald]

I mean we could do the mature thing. Or we could just call her ma-ray sue or star killer with wars after the word star

bro went back in time to 2017 youtube videos

 

[Damage3245]

Snek's comment didn't come across as totally inappropriate "bashing" to me. It's fair to call out a Mary Sue as a Mary Sue and the rest of his comment was actually agreeing with the thread.

But as has been pointed out earlier in the thread this can just be handled on the All-Purpose Request thread and probably doesn't warrant a CRT - so I'll be locking this, especially as the last few comments have just been needless back-and-forth unrelated to the OP.