PTJ "Universe"

[Pxnd_013]

At present, the PTJ Universe includes many manhwa series published under PTJ. However, not all of them actually take place in the same shared universe. As a result, the current PTJ Universe page has become somewhat cluttered. Therefore, I created this CRT to remove the series that are not connected to the main continuity, similar to this CRT

The following manhwa will remain on the PTJ Universe page:

• Lookism
These are the main manhwa of the PTJ Universe

• Viral Hit
Hobin, the protagonist of the series, has appeared in Lookism. Taehoon and Hansoo have also appeared in Lookism

• Manager Kim
Characters from Lookism appear in this series, such as Manager Kim, Tom Lee, Gun, Goo, and many others

• Questism
Characters from Lookism appear in this series, such as Johan, Jake, Gun, and the members of Allied

• Dead Mansion
Characters from Lookism and Viral Hit appear in this series, such as Sophia, Eli, Hansoo, and the members of Allied

• Juvenile Offender
Characters from Viral Hit appear in this series, such as Hobin and Taehoon. In addition, Changsoo also appears in Manager Kim

• My life as a loser Ss1-Ss2
Characters from Viral Hit appear in this series, such as Samdak. In addition, Jincheol Park also appears in Manager Kim and Lookism

Therefore, any series that are not included in this list will be removed from the PTJ Universe page

Agree : Pyro9278

Neutral :

Disagree :

 

[Pyro9278]

The CRT is fine and I would be in favor, but normally you should show scans or statements from the author regarding the canonicity of other series because it's not as obvious as just saying which ones are canon or not.

 

[Pxnd_013]

The CRT is fine and I would be in favor, but normally you should show scans or statements from the author regarding the canonicity of other series because it's not as obvious as just saying which ones are canon or not.

I've added more information now.

 

[LegendariumOfLies]

Quick Question: What are we removing from the page then?

 

[Pxnd_013]

Quick Question: What are we removing from the page then?

Remove the series that are not included in the list I provided.

 

[Pyro9278]

Quick Question: What are we removing from the page then?

Mr. Baek, Ulzzang Generation, and Death Row Boy. I can say that the first one has no connection whatsoever to the PTJverse. I don't know about the other two. I haven't even read them yet, so I can't say whether they're canon or not in the PTJverse continuity.

 

[CatLover313]

I agree, unless there's meaningful connection, I don't see why we would put every series made by the company into the verse (We don't really do that for many other verses). Though do we think we might need to define what counts as canon (like is a cameo enough, etc) Or would this be a non-issue

 

[Pyro9278]

I agree, unless there's meaningful connection, I don't see why we would put every series made by the company into the verse (We don't really do that for many other verses). Though do we think we might need to define what counts as canon (like is a cameo enough, etc).

A cameo isn't enough. In Mr. Baek, J High has a cameo, but the story's setting is very different from the Seoul of the current timeline. I think the characters should have more than just a cameo, like the fight between Johan and Taehoon, or Hobin being Lee Yooseung's teacher.

 

[Kachon123]

This makes sense to me.

 

[Powerscalingcat]

Agreed always found it weird that they were on the page despite.. not being a part of the verse