So, pretty interesting match-up. These two are not only world-renowned heroes, but they've also helped stop slavery!... Sort of.
Anyways, onto the fight.
AP/Dura - Both are actually pretty comparable, the Immortal scales to
649.88 Gigatons, whereas Neo is actually a tad higher; standing comfortably at
858.908 Gigatons of TNT. Giving the latter a
1.3x advantage in terms of pure brute force and durability, so point for Anderson.
Abilities/Hax - Not-so surprisingly, both don't really have game-ending hax they tend to use in character; it's mostly just pure, physical might and martial arts. On that note, Neo no-doubt has the advantage here; not a stompy one, but a notable one overall. He's mastered and been inputted with dozens of different styles, whereas the Immortal was capable of fending off Omni-Man for a time -- impressive given their strength difference, but nothing special when up against The One. What's really gonna keep Immortal going here though is that sick regeneration of his -- arms, organs, you name it; all will come back with time.
The databooks also go on to state that the Immortal has (almost) inexhaustible endurance, and limitless stamina, and while Neo can fight for several minutes against multiple opponents -- unfortunately, he's gonna either have to end things fast or risk gassing himself out.
While the Immortal is very hard to put down, and no-doubt has superior stamina to our action hero, Neo has a vast skill/agility advantage and also a potential one-shot move -- one he doesn't use often, granted -- but Abe Lincoln isn't exactly an Agent; possibly giving him more incentive to
use it; since he won't be making an even more powerful foe this time around. I'll just say this one's a tie.
Lifting Strength - The Immortal, contrary to the profiles (his being incredibly outdated ngl), has the Lifting Strength advantage here vs Neo. The offical Invincible handbook (which the wiki
does use) states
that Abe's capable of lifting 25 tons -- so he'd be about Class 50, compared to Neo's class 25. Solid point for Immortal.
Verdict - So, this match-up is rather interesting, and both have pretty solid advantages. At the end of the day though, I'm gonna give this down to Neo. He has an insane skill and agility advantage, alongside having a one-shot move that the Immortal has
no hope of coming back from, and he's slightly stronger in terms of AP. He's got an answer for pretty much every advantage Immortal has, while all Lincoln can hope for is that he'd gas Neo out and eventually lay him in -- which is very much possible, but not the most-likely verdict in my mind.
His regeneration and endurance get countered if Neo decides to blow him up from within, Immortal's massive LS Advantage gets overcome by Neo's raw skill (if you see his fights, usually when someone gets his hands on them he can quickly slip out or toss them away), and Neo's overall agility means that he'd be able to dance around Immortal like they were at a ball.
Close fight, but going for The One over the Immortal.