- 5,281
- 3,150
So this one is a bit screwy. I haven't watched a Star Wars thing in awhile, but even then I can recall that the Force is basically everything about the Jedi and the Sith. What matters the most is how these guys use the Force. Ahsoka Tano was a protege of Anakin Skywalker. I only watched The Clone Wars as far as Cartoon Network aired episodes for it, which wouldn't do me any good since Season 7 was aired by Disney.
I do know that Ahsoka dealt with more aggressive Sith like Asajj Ventress and General Grievous. Count Dooku was in the cartoon too, but iirc, he was more disciplined than Asajj and Grievous were.
Why the hell am I bringing that up? Generally one-on-one duels especially between lightsaber users are generally more disciplined than any other form of combat in the Star Wars universe. The only times I really recall things getting dirty during a lightsaber duel were anything having to do with Darth Vader and that one instance in The Clone Wars where a Jedi Knight (I forget who; I just recall that he was red) getting shot down by two B1s while dealing with Grievous.
Momo... Using the UA Beginnings Arc key alone, the students should all have a decent handle of their Quirks: one-trick pony abilities largely based on the physiology of the users. Based on her height and appearance alone, Momo should have a surface area of 1.7 m², which that alone is more than enough for her to pull a lightsaber out of her ass. And yes, I think Momo can legitimately form a lightsaber considering Hacksmith Industries made one and the tech in the MHA universe is more advanced than anything those guys could do. Plus she made a cannon before (which requires ignition to use), so she shouldn't be unused to creating anything thermal. Using the Force is out of the question for obvious reasons, but I think the basic idea of lightsabers being plasma cutters with crystals in them would be more than enough for her. And yes, I brought that up because I think Momo using a lightsaber would be a pretty cool idea, especially with her intelligence section being a thing.
Comparing the two more directly... Ahsoka's AP would be around 491 tons as she is... Just what you would expect from Jedi Knights and those who are comparable. Momo is probably the closest to Deku out of all the ladies in the MHA series in regards to overall viability. At the base, her AP would be 237.72 tons, but can go upwards to one-shotting 711.97 tons with her Quirk. Her durability is pretty stunted, however.
Ahsoka has Class M lifting strength whereas Momo would at best be scaling to this thing: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsar_Cannon
At the same time, with how physics are, Class M is like moving a 9-A projectile 1 meter; what's that gonna do against 8-A projectiles? Not sure how far into the series Momo could ignore LS and just create stuff even when restrained (that argument let Momo win against Ochako) since I only binged up to the Joint Training Arc. That and Ahsoka isn't Darth Vader, so I think LS would be more akin to how Jedi uses it in that they would use the Force to throw stuff around.
The Jedi Mind Trick is a thing too. Thing is Ben Kenobi needed a few suggestions to have someone be on their way. This mofo whose Quirk is the same thing as the Jedi Mind Trick only needed one!: https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Hitoshi_Shinso
Thing is, it's a little hard to truly assess the willpower of anyone from the MHA series since only Deku dealt with that. I think that's more of a matter of opinion than anything else. I do think the possibility is there since Shinso is part of Class 1-B, making it possible that the others of that class at least would be aware of that Quirk. If Momo's willpower can be compared to Deku's, great, that's one thing Ahsoka can't use against Momo. If not, I think the Jedi Mind Trick alone would be GG, even if it is weaker than Shinso's Quirk.
Combat experience... I think Ahsoka is better in that regard. Ahsoka dealt with guys like Cad Bane, one of the best Bounty Hunters who aren't Jango or Boba Fett. I don't think even Tomura Shigaraki is stacking up to that.
I think the thing that really screws with the matchup is the speed. Momo getting a bit off Ahsoka would mean Ahsoka is screwed, but at the same time, Subsonic with Massively Hypersonic combat speed is a bigger gap than Athletic Human with Supersonic combat speed. Equalizing off general speed means Ahsoka outspeeds Momo whereas equalizing solely off combat speed means Ahsoka can't get away from Momo even though their combat speed matches. It's an anomaly I can't get around.
Where do I think this leads up to? Well...
Let's have both combatants start five meters away. The fight would also take place in a Jedi Temple to ensure a more disciplined battle akin to what was displayed in Star Wars itself. Speed is equalized. Oh, and we UA Beginnings Momo and Season 7 Ahsoka.
Here are the profiles:
Momo's Profile
Ahsoka's Profile
Who takes this?
Momo: 0
Ahsoka: 0
Inconclusive: 0
And yes, I still think Momo with a lightsaber would be cool.
I do know that Ahsoka dealt with more aggressive Sith like Asajj Ventress and General Grievous. Count Dooku was in the cartoon too, but iirc, he was more disciplined than Asajj and Grievous were.
Why the hell am I bringing that up? Generally one-on-one duels especially between lightsaber users are generally more disciplined than any other form of combat in the Star Wars universe. The only times I really recall things getting dirty during a lightsaber duel were anything having to do with Darth Vader and that one instance in The Clone Wars where a Jedi Knight (I forget who; I just recall that he was red) getting shot down by two B1s while dealing with Grievous.
Momo... Using the UA Beginnings Arc key alone, the students should all have a decent handle of their Quirks: one-trick pony abilities largely based on the physiology of the users. Based on her height and appearance alone, Momo should have a surface area of 1.7 m², which that alone is more than enough for her to pull a lightsaber out of her ass. And yes, I think Momo can legitimately form a lightsaber considering Hacksmith Industries made one and the tech in the MHA universe is more advanced than anything those guys could do. Plus she made a cannon before (which requires ignition to use), so she shouldn't be unused to creating anything thermal. Using the Force is out of the question for obvious reasons, but I think the basic idea of lightsabers being plasma cutters with crystals in them would be more than enough for her. And yes, I brought that up because I think Momo using a lightsaber would be a pretty cool idea, especially with her intelligence section being a thing.
Comparing the two more directly... Ahsoka's AP would be around 491 tons as she is... Just what you would expect from Jedi Knights and those who are comparable. Momo is probably the closest to Deku out of all the ladies in the MHA series in regards to overall viability. At the base, her AP would be 237.72 tons, but can go upwards to one-shotting 711.97 tons with her Quirk. Her durability is pretty stunted, however.
Ahsoka has Class M lifting strength whereas Momo would at best be scaling to this thing: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsar_Cannon
At the same time, with how physics are, Class M is like moving a 9-A projectile 1 meter; what's that gonna do against 8-A projectiles? Not sure how far into the series Momo could ignore LS and just create stuff even when restrained (that argument let Momo win against Ochako) since I only binged up to the Joint Training Arc. That and Ahsoka isn't Darth Vader, so I think LS would be more akin to how Jedi uses it in that they would use the Force to throw stuff around.
The Jedi Mind Trick is a thing too. Thing is Ben Kenobi needed a few suggestions to have someone be on their way. This mofo whose Quirk is the same thing as the Jedi Mind Trick only needed one!: https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Hitoshi_Shinso
Thing is, it's a little hard to truly assess the willpower of anyone from the MHA series since only Deku dealt with that. I think that's more of a matter of opinion than anything else. I do think the possibility is there since Shinso is part of Class 1-B, making it possible that the others of that class at least would be aware of that Quirk. If Momo's willpower can be compared to Deku's, great, that's one thing Ahsoka can't use against Momo. If not, I think the Jedi Mind Trick alone would be GG, even if it is weaker than Shinso's Quirk.
Combat experience... I think Ahsoka is better in that regard. Ahsoka dealt with guys like Cad Bane, one of the best Bounty Hunters who aren't Jango or Boba Fett. I don't think even Tomura Shigaraki is stacking up to that.
I think the thing that really screws with the matchup is the speed. Momo getting a bit off Ahsoka would mean Ahsoka is screwed, but at the same time, Subsonic with Massively Hypersonic combat speed is a bigger gap than Athletic Human with Supersonic combat speed. Equalizing off general speed means Ahsoka outspeeds Momo whereas equalizing solely off combat speed means Ahsoka can't get away from Momo even though their combat speed matches. It's an anomaly I can't get around.
Where do I think this leads up to? Well...
Let's have both combatants start five meters away. The fight would also take place in a Jedi Temple to ensure a more disciplined battle akin to what was displayed in Star Wars itself. Speed is equalized. Oh, and we UA Beginnings Momo and Season 7 Ahsoka.
Here are the profiles:
Momo's Profile
Ahsoka's Profile
Who takes this?
Momo: 0
Ahsoka: 0
Inconclusive: 0
And yes, I still think Momo with a lightsaber would be cool.
