Aleph doesn't scale to Kuzuryu in his Low 1-C key.
The strongest characters that Kazuya and Alpeh scale to in their Low 1-C keys are Nebiros and Michael respectively, who should be roughly comparable to each other.
Why is Michael comparable to Michael?
There are no objects that are purely 2D in our 3D world.
It is. It's called being 5th or 6th dimensional, which the Archangels are.
Why is Belial comparable to Michael?
Beelzebub occupies a similar position to Metatron but is significantly stronger than him before devil survivor
Beelzebub, who in Nocturne is capable of transforming into his humanoid form, thus implying those two aspects of himself are reunited, is still stated to be weaker than Metatron.
So I was wrong, it was the other way round.
I literally do not know how I can explain it in a more simple manner.
Any human with sufficient willpower can utilize the RE/AD.
That wouldn't apply to every fight, just a few. Flynn in his fight against Sanat increased his power and gained more actions, something that doesn't happen in every boss fight for him, proving its not something that's always being used. His spiritual power increasing substantially isn't quantifiable, same goes for that Sanat thing
Ok, name all the instances that aren't also using the wild card's power or the Demonica's reactive evolution
No. There are multiple examples in the scans I already posted that don't fall into either category.
The first one is from Yu who was using the power of the wild card, the Yosuke example is because of a Persona user's power to gain strength from bonds, Maruki's one is literally for a god tier of the verse that wouldn't scale to Kazuya and Aleph, the rest are for persona powers neither of them have. The Jonathan feat is when he utilises so much magnetite his body starts to transform, something neither of them have done. The accelerated development against Enlil was again, a Persona ability and something like that only ever happened when they got erased. The SMT If... feat is good but its not like it means he grows strong enough to one shot characters who are able to kill him before that within the span of 1 fight
I'm not going argue with you about abilities that are already accepted because you don't personally agree with them. While RE/AD works more literally with Persona users, since they are directly amped by their bonds and willpowers, as proven by Flynn and Jonathan's feats, the general principle of humans becoming more powerful with stronger emotions should still be applicable to Kazuya and Aleph. Walter's feat in particular isn't simply him channeling more energy through his body either, it's his willpower and bonds that allowed him to awaken to his magnetite and mutate his body in the first place. Aleph and Kazuya are relatively comparable in these keys as well, so neither of them are going to be one-shotting each other in the beginning of the fight.
From the Sanat fight, we know that their RE/AD can extend up to 1-A from Low 1-C.
That's not using the power of bonds, that's his resolve to fight allowing him to awaken all that, and Aleph and Kazuya have never done something on that level, so why would you assume it happens here? Where does it say he jumps from low 1-C to 1-A in that fight? Flynn was already surviving attacks from Sanat before that happened. And if he did grow from low 1-C to 1-A, that's like the only instance where it happened, prove aleph and flynn will use it to that same extent in this fight
You're implying the two are mutually exclusive when they're not.
There are multiple examples of various people growing stronger through intense emotion and/or their connection to others. It's an ability intrinsic to any human with sufficient willpower. Aleph and Kazuya should also be comparable to Flynn as fellow Messiah figures.
Sanat is used as the justification for Flynn's 1-A rating, with the former being the first 1-A Demon the latter fought. And Flynn's RE/AD feat wasn't just what was shown in the scans, but rather the entire fight itself. Rapid growth in a short period of time, such as a Low 1-C character taking down a 1-A demon, is attributed to that RE/AD.
Ultimately, the burden of proof is on you to prove they wouldn't be able to do so. It's been established and accepted by the wiki that humans in Megami Tensei are capable of growing stronger by significant amounts through shear will alone. Aleph and Kazuya are both Messiah figures, and should thus be comparable to Flynn in regards to abilities.
Quantify their skill feats. "Most skilled in YHVH's army" is too vague. You'd need real skill feats like "is an expert at aimdodging and predicting enemy attacks, good at aiming"
Michael managed to defeat Lucifer strategically:
How do you think he defeated him? "Defeated strategically" doesn't tell me much. None of the Gabriel intelligence feats are that useful for a fight
Strategically...He managed to outsmart Lucifer in combat and trap the fallen angel into Hell.
She (and by extension the rest of the Archangels) should still be superior to the likes of other deities who are connected to the concepts of warfare. The Archangels are leading figures in an endless battle between the forces of Law and Chaos --the latter of which includes the Red Rider, who is the personification of war.
