- 286
- 276
Honkai Impact 3rd early game characters are 3-C via scaling from Honkai: Star Rail, this is wrong for a couple of reasons below.
The first and simplest is the fact that there is no scaling between Wendy and HSR, the closest one is Welt mentioning that Trailblazer would be at least S-rank in his world (referencing S-rank valkyries of Schicksal) and as a Herrscher, she should need to be at least comparable to them, the problem is, Wendy has a pretty bad compatibility with her Herrscher Core and worse, she fought against early game trio, with them being B-rank valkyries at the time, which would nullify this scaling as Wendy didn’t manage to get rid of B-rankers, let alone fight a S-ranker.
Another part of the justification mentions a supposed scaling from Durandal's bubble, right from the start there are no scans in the justification which is already a red flag, to give more context this came from this thread in which was just upgrading Elysia and the characters who scale to 4-A and this scaling for the early game characters was added out of the blue, you can even compare it with the previous version, this was deemed vandalism and it wasn’t reverted because we didn’t noticed this 4-A bubble scaling at the time, so it shouldn’t even be there to begin with.
Though, they should scale to these two justifications. Even with the bad compatibility, Wendy still had the power to vaporize several cities, which was calced and accepted as High 6-C. Something that supports this rating is another calculation at 6-C this time made by Avrora, who was only the pseudo-Herrscher of Wind and should therefore be weaker than a Herrscher with a proper core. Just for measure, in this scan it also says that only the 2nd Herrscher (Sirin) had true cores, with the pseudo-Herrschers being only half of her strength as result. So, High 6-C should be fine and consistent for the beginning of game characters.
Bonus:
Not necessarily a downgrade, but when I was reading Honkai: Star Rail pages, I saw several haxes scaling to “Ω”, the vast majority of which have no direct scaling for this and are only scaling because they are powered by the same power source, I don't need to tell you how bloat and redundant this is, since anyone who sees the a realm being mentioned in the justification would deduce that the hax scales to it. Another thing is the misuse of this statistic since even things without AP, like omniscience, precognition, npi, are also being given this, come on man.
TLDR: Honkai Impact 3rd's early trio and Wendy will be downgraded to High 6-C and the non-existent scaling from bubble worlds will be removed from them. Mentions of AP in the P&A should be removed since anyone who reads the justification with a realm or cosmology being there will already know that hax scales to such level.
The first and simplest is the fact that there is no scaling between Wendy and HSR, the closest one is Welt mentioning that Trailblazer would be at least S-rank in his world (referencing S-rank valkyries of Schicksal) and as a Herrscher, she should need to be at least comparable to them, the problem is, Wendy has a pretty bad compatibility with her Herrscher Core and worse, she fought against early game trio, with them being B-rank valkyries at the time, which would nullify this scaling as Wendy didn’t manage to get rid of B-rankers, let alone fight a S-ranker.
Another part of the justification mentions a supposed scaling from Durandal's bubble, right from the start there are no scans in the justification which is already a red flag, to give more context this came from this thread in which was just upgrading Elysia and the characters who scale to 4-A and this scaling for the early game characters was added out of the blue, you can even compare it with the previous version, this was deemed vandalism and it wasn’t reverted because we didn’t noticed this 4-A bubble scaling at the time, so it shouldn’t even be there to begin with.
Though, they should scale to these two justifications. Even with the bad compatibility, Wendy still had the power to vaporize several cities, which was calced and accepted as High 6-C. Something that supports this rating is another calculation at 6-C this time made by Avrora, who was only the pseudo-Herrscher of Wind and should therefore be weaker than a Herrscher with a proper core. Just for measure, in this scan it also says that only the 2nd Herrscher (Sirin) had true cores, with the pseudo-Herrschers being only half of her strength as result. So, High 6-C should be fine and consistent for the beginning of game characters.
Bonus:
Not necessarily a downgrade, but when I was reading Honkai: Star Rail pages, I saw several haxes scaling to “Ω”, the vast majority of which have no direct scaling for this and are only scaling because they are powered by the same power source, I don't need to tell you how bloat and redundant this is, since anyone who sees the a realm being mentioned in the justification would deduce that the hax scales to it. Another thing is the misuse of this statistic since even things without AP, like omniscience, precognition, npi, are also being given this, come on man.
TLDR: Honkai Impact 3rd's early trio and Wendy will be downgraded to High 6-C and the non-existent scaling from bubble worlds will be removed from them. Mentions of AP in the P&A should be removed since anyone who reads the justification with a realm or cosmology being there will already know that hax scales to such level.
