• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

God of War: Revising Gaia's standing

Status
Not open for further replies.
I made a similar thread the past month, but I have a few more scans now and explanations that I believe would constitute as definitive evidence of what I argued on said thread.

Namely, Gaia from God of War should be rated as being a Conceptual Embodiment and as having Type 2 Abstract Existence. The scans are as below:

Gaia's physical avatar is ripped away in the Titanomachy, and thus she is reduced to an inchoate and completely formless spirit. This spirit is literally described as being "of the earth - the earth", and timeless. Its mere act of waking up causes world-wide effects, with continents cracking and mountain ranges rising. Already starts to sound abstract.

Gaia's spirit herself manifests to Kratos, where she states that she is the ever-present representation of Earth and that she has been with him through all the events of his life. In fact, it is stated that the trees, earth, and rocks are Gaia herself, and that she is there with them:

In an official documentary, the developers state the following about Gaia's standing on God of War:

In other words, Gaia is the earth. She is its quintessential, most perfect representation. Gaia's existence is important and necessary for the continued existence of the world, since she was born as soon as the world was born, if not perhaps even before that ((all of this is literally what the word "quintessential" means). Starts to become even more abstract-sounding.

They also comment around this timestamp that this is what allows Gaia to be the literal narrator of the games and their storyline themselves, without it being a Fourth-Wall break. Because Gaia is literally the Earth itself and thus she can be there with Kratos at all times. David Jaffe comments a bit on this, and Cory Barlog comments on Gaia's "future plans" for Kratos. One might ask what that means?

Kratos uses the power of the Mirrors of Time in order to travel back through time, and he meets Gaia's avatar - more than one thousand years before the events of the game. Gaia recognizes him instantaneously, for she knows of his existence and is aware of her own plan.

This further shows that Gaia is a conceptual representation, and puts the previous statement of time ceasing to have meaning when it comes to Gaia entering her true, non-corporeal form into more context. Gaia, no matter whether it's future or past, is the earth, and thus she knows of absolutely everything that has happened, or will happen in the future.

The only reason why she was not able to know that Kratos would betray her is because Kratos was starting to unlock the Power of Hope from Pandora's Box (in itself the Power of Hope is an abstract power), which allowed him to deceive and go against the powers of the Sisters of Fate, who control fate itself and are aware of everything since they are the ones who actually control what happens. The developers comment on this immunity he gained, saying that Kratos is the only one who will not allow his fate to be mapped out by any deity. It is an interesting documentary to watch for this thread's sake.

Regarding Gaia's birth, it has been a little bit retconned because of Ascension coming out. The official manual for God of War 2 states under Gaia's entry that she was "born from chaos". The word Chaos in God of War has a dual meaning ever since Ascension was released:

1. The first meaning was that Chaos, much like in mythology, was the void of absolute nothingness and disorder that preceded the existence of the concepts, including space and time. It ended up spawning the Primordials.

2. The second meaning is that it is used to refer to the female, mother primordial who embodied Life itself, and pretty much the first being to come out of the Void of Chaos (the one I talked about beforehand).

Either way, however, this would similarly help us denote that Gaia was born from something abstract and that she came to be almost at the dawn of creation, which would support the scans above.

Conclusion
Gaia in God of War is an abstract being, who personifies Earth itself, with her existence being intertwined to the existence of the Earth, and vice-versa (the Earth being intertwined to her existence). So she should be considered both a Type 2 Abstract, and the Conceptual Embodiment of the Earth.

...And no, Gaia did not die at the end of God of War 3. Her physical avatar died. Please don't bring that up.
 
isn't primordials has conceptual manipulation by default ? i think it can be scaled to gaia.

Also why cronos don't have conceptual manipulation ? since he created time it self.


out of topic but i will put this in here: "Kratos actually has resistance to transmutation by resistsing hades' arms"
 
Cronos didn't create the concept of time. He created time. We don't assume every time creator to be conceptual.
 
Also, this would mean that the Primordials would also receive abstract existence and conceptual personifications, since Gaia was heavily implied to have been spawned by them and they preceded her. Which'd mean that:

  • Uranus is the conceptual embodiment of the Heavens (Cosmos/Universe)
  • Thanatos is the conceptual embodiment of Death
  • Chaos is the conceptual embodiment of Life
etc.

Also, some related topics that are worth debating regarding GoW and concepts:

  • Thanatos smiled mockingly to Kratos as he was about to be killed - which could potentially suggest that Thanatos willingly let himself be killed, although that is unlikely.
  • The Blades of Chaos are stated in the novels to be literally imbued with the essence of the Void of Chaos - the same void that spawned the Primordials and all the concepts to begin with, and the blades contain its essence. This could explain why it was able to kill Thanatos. It is imbued with something that preceded his existence and spawned all the fundamental constants. Considering we know the blade's powers adjust depending on the situation, this heavily implies that, under the right circumstances, the blades can destroy abstract things.
 
Emerging out of the Void of Chaos doesn't necessarily suggest being conceptual - Zeus states that Mount Olympus emerged out of said void and the mountain isn't a conceptual or abstract mountain.
 
1. Mount Olympus far preceded the existence of the actual Olympians - it existed since, at minimum, the age of the Titans, as noted in the God of War 2 guidebook entry which claims that Zeus castrated the Titans' control over Olympus. The mountain just grew under the reign of the Olympians.

2. Olympus' height is all about symbolism. It is about how the entire world depends on the Gods' existence and how they literally tower over mortals in every way, with the point that the entire world is covered by the colossal shadow cast by the mountain.
 
Also, why can't the mountain be an abstract mountain? Nothing would suggest otherwise. Athena makes an entire speech at the end of II about how Zeus and Olympus are the things that tie the world together - something that is confirmed, since Zeus' death led to the Greek Pantheon collapsing and fading into today's non-mythological Greece and multiple interviews imply as much

Not only that, we also have the following statement:

  • Remember, as long as Zeus reigns, there is no hope for mankind. Destroy the Flame, Kratos, and the very foundations of Olympus will crumble.
If the Flame of Olympus is destroyed, the foundations of Olympus will crumble. And said Flame of Olympus is a fire which can contain the Abstract Embodiments of Fear and Greed and the Evils, and which spawned Pandora, and etc. Therefore, Olympus is very much an abstract mountain,.
 
Also, the official God of War II lore tells us that Gaia created the concept of Fate/Destiny:

https://cdn.instructables.com/FIQ/9KBQ/FHIK6GZE/FIQ9KBQFHIK6GZE.LARGE.jpg?auto=webp&crop=3:2

While this website has been slightly retconned (namely on the first paragraph, which states Nyx created the universe, which ended up being overridden by the Comics and God of War: Ascension, and that Gaia created Uranus, which was shown not to be the case in Ascension), most of the information is still valid, and as told to us here, Gaia birthed Themis, whose existence marked the existence of a natural order of events and destiny.

So, aside from being the Conceptual Embodiment of the Earth, Gaia would also get Conceptual Manipulation/Creation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top