Captain America (Marvel) vs King Bradley (Fullmetal Alchemist)

[HeroicDefender97]

Battle of the Super Soldiers

Who wins and why?

 

[Kowt]

King Bradley wins

 

[HeroicDefender97]

King Bradley wins

Explain?

 

[Kowt]

From what I've seen I think Bradley is faster as well as being a better fighter with no morals. He can kill Cap easily.

This is only my opinion.

 

[HeroicDefender97]

From what I've seen I think Bradley is faster as well as being a better fighter with no morals. He can kill Cap easily.
This is only my opinion.

Oh no

No way is he a better fighter considering that Cap is one of the top tier martial artists in the Marvel universe... In terms of swords maybe, but not h2h

And faster?--- last I checked on their profiles here. Captain America is Massively Hypersonic while Bradley is only Supersonic. But even then him being faster doesn't mean he would automatically win against Cap easily.

 

[LordAizenSama]

if you knew about the speed difference why'd u make this thread

 

[Kowt]

MHS Cap is an outlier or PIS. Bradley could slice bullets easily while sometime Cap couldn't dodge or block them all. Also Bradley is much more durable and capable of reading his opponent's movement.

 

[HeroicDefender97]

if you knew about the speed difference why'd u make this thread

Because there are still multiple forums that claim Bradley would take the victory. So I wanted to see if I can get different opinions on this fight.

 

[Angellerator]

Captain America. Youth and the inability to feel fatigue is one hell of a combination. Although I do think king Bradley õ©Ç who Dual Wields if I remember correctly õ©Ç would be able to suppress Captain America to a certain degree, forcing him to rely on the durability of his shield and his reflexes + speed to evade attacks. However, I think that as time goes on Captain America will start to gain the upperhand in a longer and drawn out battle, and eventually manage to counter-attack with his shield. I think, anyway.

 

[HeroicDefender97]

MHS Cap is an outlier or PIS. Bradley could slice bullets easily while sometime Cap couldn't dodge or block them all. Also Bradley is much more durable and capable of reading his opponent's movement.

"Capable of reading his opponent's movements."

You do realize that Bradley's eye cannot see through solid objects such as Cap's shield right?

Which results to Cap constantly stonewalling his attacks and surprise attacking him

 

[HeroicDefender97]

Captain America. Youth and the inability to feel fatigue is one hell of a combination. Although I do think king Bradley õ©Ç who Dual Wields if I remember correctly õ©Ç would be able to suppress Captain America to a certain degree, forcing him to rely on the durability of his shield and his reflexes + speed to evade attacks. However, I think that as time goes on Captain America will start to gain the upperhand in a longer and drawn out battle, and eventually manage to counter-attack with his shield. I think, anyway.

Bradley can tire out slowly while Cap does not

So Cap certainly has him beat in stamina

 

[Kowt]

This is one on one fight. Cap might not be able to do that. Bradley would blitz Cap.

 

[HeroicDefender97]

This is one on one fight. Cap might not be able to do that. Bradley would blitz Cap.

One on one fights are normally a speciality for Cap

Do you seriously believe that he always depends on his teamates?

 

[Kowt]

Bradley defeated a bunch of soldiers easily. Even without his god eye he was still beating Scar who has deconstruction power. Cap on his own might not be able to beat the guy who's equal to or above Black Panther.

 

[HeroicDefender97]

Bradley defeated a bunch of soldiers easily. Even without his god eye he was still beating Scar who has deconstruction power. Cap on his own might not be able to beat the guy who's equal to or above Black Panther.

I have no doubts that Cap would handle Bradley just fine

I do admit however if he tried fighting the other Homunculuses on his own. He'd be dead lol

 

[MangoDice]

This is bordering into a spite match

Captain America has incredible superhuman reflexes and physical capability, but that's nothing a guy like Bradley hasn't faced in his own universe. He's handled chimera and humunculai alike as if they were little more than worms in the dirt.

While Cap has his impenetrable shield, he himself is very much susceptible to physical damage. Having the ultimate defense isn't everything. Just ask the first incarnation of Greed. While he couldn't cut through the shield directly, the main function of Bradley's eye was finding weaknesses in his opponents defense.

Cap has the edge in stamina, but that only comes into play assuming he could last long enough to wear Bradley down. That just wouldn't happen.We're talking about a guy who was fast enough to close great distance, literally run up ladders and run down the likes of tanks and various other vehicles.

The power of his ultimate eye is considerable but even without it he boasts super human abilities at the ripe age of 60. He's run down and obliterated roof jumping assassins from regions like Xing and even cut tank rounds in half as they flew towards him mid- air. The feats he has demonstrated are just far-more impressive than that of Captain America.

No offense to cap by any stetch at all. He is a very capable and resourceful fighter in his own right. It isn't a matter of him being weak as much as it is a matter of Bradley being overpowered. The dude is so much more than his ultimate eye.

How anyone thinks this is a remotely close match is beyond me.

Bradley wins this one in nearly every scenario.

 

[HeroicDefender97]

This is bordering into a spite match
Captain America has incredible superhuman reflexes and physical capability, but that's nothing a guy like Bradley hasn't faced in his own universe. He's handled chimera and humunculai alike as if they were little more than worms in the dirt.

While Cap has his impenetrable shield, he himself is very much susceptible to physical damage. Having the ultimate defense isn't everything. Just ask the first incarnation of Greed. While he couldn't cut through the shield directly, the main function of Bradley's eye was finding weaknesses in his opponents defense.

Cap has the edge in stamina, but that only comes into play assuming he could last long enough to wear Bradley down. That just wouldn't happen.We're talking about a guy who was fast enough to close great distance, literally run up ladders and run down the likes of tanks and various other vehicles.

The power of his ultimate eye is considerable but even without it he boasts super human abilities at the ripe age of 60. He's run down and obliterated roof jumping assassins from regions like Xing and even cut tank rounds in half as they flew towards him mid- air. The feats he has demonstrated are just far-more impressive than that of Captain America.

No offense to cap by any stetch at all. He is a very capable and resourceful fighter in his own right. It isn't a matter of him being weak as much as it is a matter of Bradley being overpowered. The dude is so much more than his ultimate eye.

How anyone thinks this is a remotely close match is beyond me.

Bradley wins this one in nearly every scenario.

That's because Greed has an easily exploitable weakness. He can heal or harden himself, but he can't do both. A weakness that Bradley took the advantage off. Cap is a whole another story.

And did you not read Bradley's bio on the official Fullmetal Alchemist wiki?--- It clearly states that his Ultimate eye cannot see through solid object like Cap's shield which makes him vulnerable to surprise attacks.

http://fma.wikia.com/wiki/Wrath

 

[MangoDice]

This is bordering into a spite match
Captain America has incredible superhuman reflexes and physical capability, but that's nothing a guy like Bradley hasn't faced in his own universe. He's handled chimera and humunculai alike as if they were little more than worms in the dirt.

While Cap has his impenetrable shield, he himself is very much susceptible to physical damage. Having the ultimate defense isn't everything. Just ask the first incarnation of Greed. While he couldn't cut through the shield directly, the main function of Bradley's eye was finding weaknesses in his opponents defense.

Cap has the edge in stamina, but that only comes into play assuming he could last long enough to wear Bradley down. That just wouldn't happen.We're talking about a guy who was fast enough to close great distance, literally run up ladders and run down the likes of tanks and various other vehicles.

The power of his ultimate eye is considerable but even without it he boasts super human abilities at the ripe age of 60. He's run down and obliterated roof jumping assassins from regions like Xing and even cut tank rounds in half as they flew towards him mid- air. The feats he has demonstrated are just far-more impressive than that of Captain America.

No offense to cap by any stetch at all. He is a very capable and resourceful fighter in his own right. It isn't a matter of him being weak as much as it is a matter of Bradley being overpowered. The dude is so much more than his ultimate eye.

How anyone thinks this is a remotely close match is beyond me.

Bradley wins this one in nearly every scenario.

That's because Greed has an easily exploitable weakness. He can heal or harden himself, but he can't do both. A weakness that Bradley took the advantage off. Cap is a whole another story.
And did you not read Bradley's bio on the official Fullmetal Alchemist wiki?--- It clearly states that his Ultimate eye cannot see through solid object like Cap's shield which makes him vulnerable to surprise attacks.

http://fma.wikia.com/wiki/Wrath

Bradley was one of the only people in FMA to handle greed is handily as he did. He was an incredibly formidable fighter in his own right, but not without his weaknesses; as is the case with most anyone else. It wasn't easily exploitable; Bradley simply made it appear that way. That is what he does. That is my point. He would do the same thing to Captain America that he did countless others.

I don't need to view the quote. I know the episode the wiki was referencing. Bradley was taken by surprise in a split moment attack of opportunity coming from a guy who had to removed a sword bradley had left within him after stabbing him. Even then, he had to hide his attack behind the all but dead corpse of Lan Fan's grandfather, impaling and killing him in the process.

Let's not compare that to a shield that can hardly cover a guy's upper body. This isn't a tower shield we're talking about. Cap isn't a string bean.It's a big dude hiding behind a relatively small shield. There's a reason the shield makes up such a crucial part of his offense.It was ever intended to be used in the way you're describing it.

Even then Bradley is described as carving a way for himself in battlefield full of bullets,vehicles and explosives with only his swords. Do you raelly think such a thing would be possible were it as simple as masking ones moves behind a shield? A guy litterally had to give his life in order to just ensure a surprise attack on the guy. Taking him by surprise doesn't come easily. He's not going to just stand there dumbfounded while this guy attempts to close the distance.

That aside, the moment captain america attempted to mount an offense of his own he'd be picked apart. Bradley is simply too fast. Captain America isn't nearlty fast enough to capitalize on the small advantage conceling his movements underneath his shield the way you're arguing it.Furthermore, one on one combat is his speciality.

It's a piss poor match up heavily favoring Bradley.

 

[HeroicDefender97]

This is bordering into a spite match
Captain America has incredible superhuman reflexes and physical capability, but that's nothing a guy like Bradley hasn't faced in his own universe. He's handled chimera and humunculai alike as if they were little more than worms in the dirt.

While Cap has his impenetrable shield, he himself is very much susceptible to physical damage. Having the ultimate defense isn't everything. Just ask the first incarnation of Greed. While he couldn't cut through the shield directly, the main function of Bradley's eye was finding weaknesses in his opponents defense.

Cap has the edge in stamina, but that only comes into play assuming he could last long enough to wear Bradley down. That just wouldn't happen.We're talking about a guy who was fast enough to close great distance, literally run up ladders and run down the likes of tanks and various other vehicles.

The power of his ultimate eye is considerable but even without it he boasts super human abilities at the ripe age of 60. He's run down and obliterated roof jumping assassins from regions like Xing and even cut tank rounds in half as they flew towards him mid- air. The feats he has demonstrated are just far-more impressive than that of Captain America.

No offense to cap by any stetch at all. He is a very capable and resourceful fighter in his own right. It isn't a matter of him being weak as much as it is a matter of Bradley being overpowered. The dude is so much more than his ultimate eye.

How anyone thinks this is a remotely close match is beyond me.

Bradley wins this one in nearly every scenario.

That's because Greed has an easily exploitable weakness. He can heal or harden himself, but he can't do both. A weakness that Bradley took the advantage off. Cap is a whole another story.
And did you not read Bradley's bio on the official Fullmetal Alchemist wiki?--- It clearly states that his Ultimate eye cannot see through solid object like Cap's shield which makes him vulnerable to surprise attacks.

http://fma.wikia.com/wiki/Wrath

Bradley was one of the only people in FMA to handle greed is handily as he did. He was an incredibly formidable fighter in his own right, but not without his weaknesses; as is the case with most anyone else. It wasn't easily exploitable; Bradley simply made it appear that way. That is what he does. That is my point. He would do the same thing to Captain America that he did countless others.
I don't need to view the quote. I know the episode the wiki was referencing. Bradley was taken by surprise in a split moment attack of opportunity coming from a guy who had to removed a sword bradley had left within him after stabbing him. Even then, he had to hide his attack behind the all but dead corpse of Lan Fan's grandfather, impaling and killing him in the process.

Let's not compare that to a shield that can hardly cover a guy's upper body. This isn't a tower shield we're talking about. Cap isn't a string bean.It's a big dude hiding behind a relatively small shield. There's a reason the shield makes up such a crucial part of his offense.It was ever intended to be used in the way you're describing it.

Even then Bradley is described as carving a way for himself in battlefield full of bullets,vehicles and explosives with only his swords. Do you raelly think such a thing would be possible were it as simple as masking ones moves behind a shield? A guy litterally had to give his life in order to just ensure a surprise attack on the guy. Taking him by surprise doesn't come easily. He's not going to just stand there dumbfounded while this guy attempts to close the distance.

That aside, the moment captain america attempted to mount an offense of his own he'd be picked apart. Bradley is simply too fast. Captain America isn't nearlty fast enough to capitalize on the small advantage conceling his movements underneath his shield the way you're arguing it.Furthermore, one on one combat is his speciality.

It's a piss poor match up heavily favoring Bradley.

Your arugment is just about the same as every other person who has backed Bradley. Still not convincing enough to sway me. ALso no. Greed's weakness was asolutely easily exploitable. Just about anyone else besides Bradley can figure it out.

Bradley fighting Homunculuses and Chimeras you say?--- I'd like to see how he can top Cap by fighting Cosmic beings, Aliens, Mutants, Asgardians etc

Better speed and Ultimate Eye does not guarantee him a win. Its definitely an advantage, but its not guaranteed that he would win.

And I didn't say Bradley is dumb enough to fall for a sucker punch. He is smart alright, but a combatant who is on equal levels as a strategist and tactician as he is can still throw him off balance at any moment.

And really? as if Cap can't himself in a one on one fight because he's also use to fighting single opponents or multiple opponents at once are his speciality like Bradley. You make it sound like he has to rely on his teamates to be effective.

Even if Bradley tries to work around Cap's shield. Cap would still be able to manuever around his sword, dancing in circles with him. Cause he's compensated with this weakness when villains like Baron Zemo attempted to work around his shield or underneath those uncovered areas you mentioned with his sword.

Even without the shield though. Cap would still be a deadly CQC fighter since he can use his enviroment or other various weapons in his surroundings to fight Bradley from different angles. And while Bradley is no stranger to using multiple weapons as well. He tends to prefer swords and knives over anything else.