This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
I have realized this but if Shirou is indeed her Master for this then wouldn't she actually be able to lose via endurance? Since she's unable to keep up with Berserker due to this hindrance.
I feel that the experience difference between the two is a great factor favouriing Melodias as he's probably got an idea on how Saber fights just by basing it out of his past experiences.
Good to know, and wth that I want to also add that a reason with Melodias winning because of Saber's code of honor, which limits a fair number of advantageous moves due to them not being honorable. In-character, Melodias will show a much more hands on approach to this fight, and if he can keep...
I also want to add that Melodias isn't well specified. Is he serious? Can he utilize his treasure? We only get Sealed Melodias which isn't really saying much on his actual capabilities for this fight and I'm really confused which Tier I should use for Melodias because I am new here and I have...
Well I remembered that the Stamina of a Servant is relative to their Master's Mana, which would make Shirou the worst pick having too little for her to even heal much less turn invisible as stated by Saber herself.
So, her stamina is most definitely around a day's worth at best, which would...
I think its highly unfair for people to fight against a Hax on the level of Gil, as you'd need a Hax on the same level as him to even give the match a worthy enough discussion. Like only the first point is possibly Melodias' win, with the other being a complete stomp due to just Hax.
Hmm, in a swordfight its a pretty much equal for both of them but if you let Melodias also fight unarmed then its more than enough to solidify a win for him. Saber's best bet is the use of Invisible Air which can give Saber the range advantage compared to Melodias for as long as Melodias hasn't...
Wait what do you mean by "Sealed"? Is he incapable of using Full counter? Because if he can then its pretty much a win if he can make Saber use it on him.
I don't think using Joseph, a Hamon-user, as reference of the strength of the attack is not a good way to describe the strength of his Hamon, considering that Hamon is capable of more than just shown offensively and defensively in Parts 1 and 2. This is more of stating what Joseph is capable of...
Well Magnus, I will add that Kars' 400 IQ isn't exact, rather its just the assumed number and its more than likely to be limitless, and do remember that Kars has the Hamon which would counter freezing as it is on the same output as the sun's.
And yes Moa, I made an error in the first statement...
That is insane in many aspects, and I can see that she wouldn't use it in such a way. I'll give her that, but "there is no dicussion without argument" in my book and I can still imagine Boros to react fast enough to move a portion of his body away to regenerate it but this will remove his armor...
Though I can still see Boros winning with his intellect and biological superiority. Also isn't Boros' armor capable of tanking a punch from Saitama who intended to end him quickly, evident by Saitama's surprise for him taking the hit. He wouldn't allow Saber to get far so the range advantage of...
That is extremely fast, which makes me wonder why she just doesn't use the thing at the start of every fight like a ridiculously long snipe. Can you cite the line specifying so? I am genuinely curious from where that is stated.
I don't know, I have never seen such an instance that woild confirm the case that she can insta-cast it because from every other depiction shows it charging the blade before performing the strike. If there is an actual example I would like to see that, but as it stands I don't believe that its...
No even then Excalibur is still gonna be a bad move for her, considering that even then the priming for the strike is a very large indicator of her attack and Boros will go in for the strike if she tries. Just saying as people lazily use Excalibur as an excuse for a quick victory and its frankly...
Won't Saber be like standing still casting Excalibur? And wouldn't the attack be easy to dodge because of the priming especially considering Ryuko's speed?
I want to just say this but Boros wins because he's fighting with fists that fly way faster than her swings and that he has two fists. Saber only has one sword. Also, do think that Excalibur needs some priming before she can use it, so Boros will try to quickly deal a blow at her if she tries to...
Well I did say that if she did lose her memories, because I forgot about the quirks connected to her being a special case Heroic spirit, I still believe my points still stand. SoC has way more knowledge and skills in nearly if not every known martial arts and then some. They can find many ways...
I see I made an error but yeah even with that he's pretty much stomping. Seriously, he reacted to Stroheim's UV Ray lasers firing and instantly moved his hands or something to wear the mask. Its... "INHUMAN REACTIONS!"
I feel that SoC wins and not just because of magic. As it is stated, he is the culmination of all Souls of Cinder, AKA EVERY undead that has relit the first flame. Considering that Saber has only lived a regular human's lifespan and losing her memories every resummoning, she is probably...
Kars would win all three cases.
Firstly, Kars absorbs humans instantly, as shown in their debut in the anime when one of them brushed passed a soldier which immediately absorbed his right side. He's got an intellect level of at least 400 IQ and can even be more, but that doesn't matter as the...