• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Search results for query: *

  1. Planck69

    Black Hole Reaches Infinity (BFDI)

    Seems fine to me.
  2. Planck69

    Black Clover : Demon King 5C Upgrade

    I'll close this now.
  3. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    This is very speculative to begin with (we have no idea how much power the ritual gives at all or if it even divides itself), never mind we don't know how strong the Fell God is itself beyond being weaker than Marika. I think it's too flimsy for a potentially rating in all honesty.
  4. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    I am aware of this but them borrowing from the power of their god isn't outright confirmation that they become fully comparable to the Fell God that Marika killed. The sentence itself implies that this is something the Fire Giants can just do and I don't think it needs to be explained why that'd...
  5. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    I don't have a problem with him being above Weakened Radhan. But putting him at the level of the gods and Elden Beast is where I draw issue from. And yeah, bosses being fought after each other being stronger is fine in moderation but we shouldn't let it go too far.
  6. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    4-A Fire Giant is eeeh. Didn't Marika kill their Fell God? And its pretty narratively clear that he's not meant to be like, the strongest Fire Giant around or on the level of Marika.
  7. Planck69

    Guilty Gear Scaling Revision (Part 2.75): Universal Will & Dragon Install Sol Scaling

    Closing this.
  8. Planck69

    Guilty Gear Scaling Revision (Part 2.75): Universal Will & Dragon Install Sol Scaling

    Looks good to me.
  9. Planck69

    Black Clover : Demon King 5C Upgrade

    Clover makes sense to me, this does sound like circular scaling.
  10. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    Yeah, def no for Weapon Mastery.
  11. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    Vibes. In all seriousness, I can see her scaling being "Shouldn't be overwhelmingly weaker than her sister's prime" or smth.
  12. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    At worst, they could be given some scaling off of creating storms. Phase-to-phase can work honestly. Marika was aware of the Rot yet even that didn't spook her as much as Messmer's serpent did. I did hear that Miyazaki called him an Empyrean in an interview but don't take my word for it at all...
  13. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    Missed opportunity to not fight Malarkey, Bow of Messmer.
  14. Planck69

    Power Page Revision Round 3: Radioactively Bad Categorization

    Agreed.
  15. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    Yeah, this is exactly what happens. Dunno how anything else could be inferred. In any case, I personally think Malenia downscales but not really by anything meaningful. The gap itself is pretty small if it exists.
  16. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    Do we have any scaling for the Divine Beast Dancing Lions? We only really know that Messmer low-diffed a bunch of them.
  17. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    Shattering to present time being 5,000 years makes more sense to me, ngl. I feel like Placidusax's reign was far earlier.
  18. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

  19. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

  20. Planck69

    Doctor Who Minor CRT

    Changes look good to me.
  21. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

  22. Planck69

    The Dread Tiering System Revisions

    I'm alright with most of your response there but the Striking Strength discussion is something I'll leave to you two. Also, I don't really mind 1-A being labelled Transcendent but I won't go to bat for it. It's really whatever to me. I do hold the opinion that we shouldn't nitpick specific...
  23. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    Gloam Eyed Queen is so weird cause what do you mean there was an Empyrean with a cult of god killers, who once held Destined Death, and we don't know their names or what they looked like at all. I could buy her being exiled to the Land of Shadows even so the fact we never fight her is weird.
  24. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    Commander Gaius being an albinauric makes me understand Gideon more and more.
  25. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    I like that but that's not even a footnote in the game.
  26. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    After , this wouldn't even suck as much tbh.
  27. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    Wild how we got a whole area dedicated to death and Spiritgraves but not one mention of the Outer God of the Deathbirds.
  28. Planck69

    Elden Ring's Top Tier should be straight High 4-C and not just "possibly".

    To me at least, it seems clear that the term "star" isn't a one-size fits all and can mean both regular stars or meteors/cosmic creatures depending on use. In the context of Radhan's feat, the "constellations" being anything else would take proof of such a thing rather than otherwise, since it...
  29. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    Greater Will and Frenzy Flame have always been equal opposites in my eyes. One created all separated beings and the other can return all of them to one. So I'm not quite sure of it being above time when the other isn't. Also, how do we treat the Land of Shadows? It seems to be a separate...
  30. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    Speaking of Placidusax, do you think the use of Miquella's needle implies that the Outer Gods are restricted to this timeline? Since even the Frenzy Flame can be countered outside of time.
  31. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    The more I think about our old Infinite speed standards the funnier they were. If they were still around Tarnished, Placidusax and most top tiers would be Infinite speed.
  32. Planck69

    Type 4 Acausality: Too Much For Too Little (2)

    Glass does bring up good points there. Of course, comparatively blatant anti-feats or counters should be considered but by that base logic of the power, manipulating the standard causality that a character doesn't exist under shouldn't affect them. At most, I'd suggest just being a bit more...
  33. Planck69

    Bans and Vandalism

    Your suggestion seems fine with me.
  34. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    By the way, how do we treat non-stated boss resistances? Like, the final DLC boss can be hit by Messmer's flame no problem of course. Is that game mech or soul resistance for them?
  35. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    I mean, yeah. Gojo's Infinity might stop that but let's face it, if that's the last obstacle then you've basically soloed the verse. Also, do we count harming Spirit Summons as Soul Manipulation (specifically Destruction) or nah.
  36. Planck69

    Quantum Manipulation: A Broken Relic of Old

    Yeah, it can go.
  37. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    So far that's; Soul Manipulation Fire Manipulation Shapeshifting Weapon Creation Animal Manipulation Teleportation(?) At the very least, his fire innately having that property would make him dangerous.
  38. Planck69

    Elden Ring General Discussion

    I saw an item description that implies Messmer's flame has soul destruction, which is pretty interesting. Edit: Yeah, the Hefty Furnace Pot, made with an ember of Messmer. Craftable item prepared using a capacious cracked pot. Imbued with a hex of the furnace. Throw at an enemy to create a...
  39. Planck69

    Conceptual manip Type 2 and Abstract Existence Type 2 for Han Jee-Han (The Gamer)

    Seems fine.
  40. Planck69

    Removing Power of the Verse from Verse pages

    I don't mind removing relative descriptions like, "X is a very powerful/weak verse" from the section. The section itself is fine aside from that and I'd prefer we just have some ground rules for what is to be explained there (current tiers, some common abilities etc.). I'm fine with the Scaling...
Back
Top