• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Search results for query: *

  1. Mr. Bambu

    Rule Violation Reports (New forum)

    I consider Tilted's comments significantly more dire of the two, but he also isn't on the Warning Tracker yet so I'll settle for a warning. Topaz has two warnings there and has had other discussions that didn't quite make it. That said, this particular instance seems tame- haughty, perhaps...
  2. Mr. Bambu

    Removal of God of War's "Type 1 Concept Manipulation"

    Entirely forgot about this. It's been several days since the last comment prior to Firestorm's, it seems likely Ultima isn't coming. If he is (or if someone else is), he can just re-open it. Even with Firestorm's vote, the voting is significantly weighed enough towards Disagree to close...
  3. Mr. Bambu

    💀 I see your sins

    💀 I see your sins
    • Mr. Bambu
    • Profile post comment
  4. Mr. Bambu

    18 years in gulag

    18 years in gulag
    • Mr. Bambu
    • Profile post comment
  5. Mr. Bambu

    Minor Maou Gakuin rework

    💀💀💀 🗣️🗣️ ‼️ ‼️ Yeah anyways I dunno what you want from this question. I reaffirm: doesn't sufficiently counteract already provided evidence ‼️
  6. Mr. Bambu

    Minor Maou Gakuin rework

    (Also this appears to be one of those very fast moving threads, which I suppose I should have foreseen as an anime thing; don't expect me to reply rapidly to each message, as in spite of what wiki activity says, it is a lying bastard and I am not actively online currently)
  7. Mr. Bambu

    Minor Maou Gakuin rework

    It's not the bit directed at me, but still I feel compelled to state that the last bit is pure semantics. You can't heal an arm that isn't there and neither can you heal something that is dead: nevertheless, if it isn't passive, we would not call it Regeneration. We would call it Healing. That...
  8. Mr. Bambu

    Minor Maou Gakuin rework

    The argument is that the spell has to be cast before hand, as a sort of precaution that only activates upon the conditions being met (in this case, dying to High-Godly damage). This argument is not mutually exclusive to the text provided: in fact, the phrasing of "automatically activated" seems...
  9. Mr. Bambu

    You've got 90 seconds (I'm at work, may respond later)

    You've got 90 seconds (I'm at work, may respond later)
    • Mr. Bambu
    • Profile post comment
  10. Mr. Bambu

    Minor Maou Gakuin rework

    Could you post that argument here?
  11. Mr. Bambu

    Rule Violation Reports (New forum)

    Vaguely recall they were reported a week or two ago, seem to recall there being more evidence mentioned at the time but I don't recall it being brought forward. At the time it was pointed out that they weren't on the warning tracker, but that wasn't indicative of there not being precedent...
  12. Mr. Bambu

    Minor Maou Gakuin rework

    After a certain point, healing and resurrection are nigh identical, it just depends on whether the character it is applied to can be considered fully "dead", really. I'm fine with Resurrection, the point lay in semantics and thus doesn't interest me.
  13. Mr. Bambu

    Minor Maou Gakuin rework

    I feel like there's not much interpretation, but I mean "not passive". Most healing abilities in fiction would be defined as Healing, then. Not Regeneration. We're not changing how the ability works, we're just giving it a more accurate moniker: this isn't Regeneration. I'm not familiar with...
  14. Mr. Bambu

    Minor Maou Gakuin rework

    Was asked to comment, seems clear enough. If it's a spell that actively needs to be used, it's Healing and should be listed as such. As with everything, it should be elaborated upon in the profile to explain the specifics as necessary.
  15. Mr. Bambu

    The SCP Mass Exodus

    Because it was mentioned in the suggestion. And... I guess? But it is resoundingly fan-made content. As fan-made as it gets, really. I'm not familiar with the "substance" requirements you guys are working on behind closed doors, that one just bore mentioning.
  16. Mr. Bambu

    A insectophobe flower made of metal fights a metal hungry insect thing(BFDI vs D&D)(1-0-2)

    so the win condition is biting her at specifically her neck, then I mean, still feel that's super unlikely, but I guess. Shall I also ignore the "thousands of duplicates" bit of the physiology page? The Immortality seems easily ignored given it relies on external facilities. Incon, then...
  17. Mr. Bambu

    A insectophobe flower made of metal fights a metal hungry insect thing(BFDI vs D&D)(1-0-2)

    would she really die from a small amount of damage like that? It's not like the single bite would crumble her entire structure, it just means that the Rust Monster can do more damage against metal even if it has greater durability. It doesn't spread, is my point.
  18. Mr. Bambu

    The SCP Mass Exodus

    I awoke about ten minutes ago to the proposition of a reject wiki. Ovens mentioned allowing things that are pornographic or racist (satirical or otherwise) in fundamental concept, I think that's a truly horrible idea but many of his other inclusions make a lot of sense: Skibidi Toilet (rejected...
  19. Mr. Bambu

    evil, vile match

    evil, vile match
    • Mr. Bambu
    • Profile post comment
  20. Mr. Bambu

    A insectophobe flower made of metal fights a metal hungry insect thing(BFDI vs D&D)(1-0-2)

    this like at best forces an incon, no? this isn't true, by the way. "Weapon Focus" as a feat includes things like Bodily Weaponry. Hence how the weaponless Rust Monster has it and why it's classified as Martial Arts and not Weapon Mastery. It's just good at fighting with its limbs. anyways...
  21. Mr. Bambu

    not particularly, but I might anyways if I think there's something to be said

    not particularly, but I might anyways if I think there's something to be said
    • Mr. Bambu
    • Profile post comment
  22. Mr. Bambu

    The SCP Mass Exodus

    The premise for the mentioned game is that when you lose, your character is raped by monsters. He is an implicit child. I'm against the notion of a sister wiki by default, but I would die on the hill of not allowing that shit.
  23. Mr. Bambu

    It probably won't be a sandbox- they're discussing whether to move it to some copycat wiki...

    It probably won't be a sandbox- they're discussing whether to move it to some copycat wiki willing to host it, or making a separate wiki for their purposes.
    • Mr. Bambu
    • Profile post comment
  24. Mr. Bambu

    The SCP Mass Exodus

    The Holders appears to be more or less a closed canon, with the website since deleted and archived. It should by all accounts be immune to the manipulation that SCP is vulnerable to. RPC is essentially the same case as SCP, just without having reached the same level of severity yet. I would...
  25. Mr. Bambu

    The SCP Mass Exodus

    Could. I don't expect them to be open to lending much manpower on special assistance, but it's feasible that there might already be a solution made up.
  26. Mr. Bambu

    The Death of SCP

    That's good enough to me. I'd support keeping it.
  27. Mr. Bambu

    The SCP Mass Exodus

    So the options are: Off-Fandom wiki, which sacrifices much of the use and ease in comparison with other options An existent copycat wiki that's willing to take them on, with some concerns regarding wiki-specific content and, depending on the activity and nature of the copycat, perhaps some...
  28. Mr. Bambu

    The Death of SCP

    A more tenuous case. RPC has a level of likelihood of reaching the same scenario as SCP (albeit lessened in comparison). If that's the truth of the Holders, I'd be less opposed to it's continued presence.
  29. Mr. Bambu

    The Commoner's Thread: The Death of SCP

    you're a strange, strange little man
  30. Mr. Bambu

    The Death of SCP

    By "updates stopped", do you mean it is a closed canon?
  31. Mr. Bambu

    The Commoner's Thread: The Death of SCP

    Yeah, Madness Combat seems the current likely choice. Specifically the protagonist, Hank Wimbleton.
  32. Mr. Bambu

    The SCP Mass Exodus

    (just gonna interject and say that while I did make VS Debating Wiki in 2016, it's not really "my site" and I haven't actively contributed to it since 2018, when I joined here as CGM; I'm not operating a competitor, however insignificant, to this place- I just own the skeleton of a wiki with...
  33. Mr. Bambu

    The Commoner's Thread: The Death of SCP

    Yeah, my knowledge on RPC is more limited but I've never heard of anything like the SCP situation happening here. Still, it is just as open to the same stuff. If we're codifying into rule something against this situation to begin with, RPC and similar verses would probably be toasted along with it.
  34. Mr. Bambu

    The Death of SCP

    I also considered unlocking, but I'd decided to do a separate thread since there may be different votes given RPC hasn't reached the point of SCP. It's the same exact thing on principle and allowing it in the future, I feel, will at least likely lead to the same point. I see the two as being...
  35. Mr. Bambu

    Same fate, I think. Less notable, probably doesn't have anything akin to what SCP has, but still...

    Same fate, I think. Less notable, probably doesn't have anything akin to what SCP has, but still just as much an issue in theory.
    • Mr. Bambu
    • Profile post comment
  36. Mr. Bambu

    FC/OC formally rejected my request to put it there- I had asked before even posting the deletion...

    FC/OC formally rejected my request to put it there- I had asked before even posting the deletion thread, although they reiterated and explained their position in the thread. I'm not sure we'll call it an official sister wiki. It's not going to be staffed by us formally.
    • Mr. Bambu
    • Profile post comment
  37. Mr. Bambu

    Being discussed here, there is a want to preserve them, yes.

    Being discussed here, there is a want to preserve them, yes.
    • Mr. Bambu
    • Profile post comment
  38. Mr. Bambu

    The Commoner's Thread: The Death of SCP

    I'm sorry you feel that way, then.
  39. Mr. Bambu

    The Commoner's Thread: The Death of SCP

    I don't feel like really anybody did, and if they did they didn't mention it. It appears to me that if anything, the want for SCP writers to be separate has only further cemented the sentiment. Regardless, everyone who said they may want to vote later has the ability to re-open it. We can't just...
  40. Mr. Bambu

    The Death of SCP

    I suppose that's fitting. Theoretically there were staff who voiced an interest in speaking again (or at least that did not commit to a position one way or the other), but it's been quite some time and most are able to re-open it if it's desperately important, anyhow. The decision is fairly...
Back
Top