- 376
- 384
1.) I don't intend on pursuing this point that much further given that it has already been discussed in great detail, I was just pointing out that while his inner essence typically operates on a Low-1A level, it should at its maximum potential vary up to 1A+
2.) At the end of the day it doesn't really matter who is or is not the strongest as they are roughly comparable.
3.) From what we have been shown throughout Marvel Comics history, The Elder Gods did not have a society in the way that The Olympians or Asgaridans did (Utgard is the only exception; however, one can't consider a group of 5 individuals a society), they have all been shown to be cosmically powerful beings with different domains. At the moment, we have yet to see a fodder tier Elder God. While it is not impossible that such a thing exists, it has not been shown. The "weak" Elder Gods were likely devoured by their more powerful siblings or later by The Demogorge if they managed to survive that.
4.) The feat of Gaea's essence being enough for Hercules to temporarily match Chaos King, who had grown so powerful that Multi-Death stopped representing her concept and was in hiding and had also devoured almost all of Multi-Eternity, shows that the major Elder Gods all have feats at the same level as the Utgard Gods. There are also some things with Chthon that back this up such as when he nearly killed Eternity while possessing Quicksilver, given that Eternity mentions this while in Overspace, it may have been his Multi-Eternity form. Chthon is also said to have the power to kill the entirety of The Celestial race. And the artifacts of Gaea, Oshtur, Set, and Chthon form The Four Cornerstones of Creation. All in all the top tier Elder Gods are pretty consistently matched with each other. What we do know is that NONE of The Elder Gods are above The Demogorge and all gods and Elder Gods fear his power. There are some exceptions such as Set when empowered by the age of reptiles was able to fight the Demogorge one on one for eons before being defeated and banished again or Chthon with prep time developing a spell to create his own Demogorge; however, on their own at their base level all of them are below and susceptible to the power of the Demogorge.
Most importantly:
5.) The problem with The Nyx scaling is it doesn't accurately represent how she is depicted. Before getting to that though, Thor does not even have a mechanism for reaching High-1A in the first place. His half Elder God nature caps at 1A+ and he has fought and significantly struggled with 1A+ Elder Gods. There is no possible way for Thor to have a Meta-Qualitative superiority without exceptionally strong logical evidence of such given the magnitude of the tier and its extremely strict requirements. Similarly, there is also no mechanism that that would have augmented Zeus to High-1A either. But neither of those things even matter as the feat regarding Nyx and amped Zeus does not involve the High-1A form of Nyx in the first place. Nyx has many forms: Her regularly seen form inside the universe as a member of various pantheons (typically as a member of the Greek Pantheon), her true form that embodies the darkness that contains The Tiger God and surrounds the fire of The Phoenix Force (we have actually never been shown this form and have only seen elusions and references of its existence throughout the work of Al-Ewing), and finally there is her ascended form having entered The House of Ideas. The problem with her page is that it calls her true nature as the darkness surrounding The Phoenix Force her "full power" key and her state post Zeus defeat her "weakened" key when this is not at all accurate. Her second key represents her true form while the first key is not her "weakened" key but how she is depicted as an in universe entity as a member of the various godly pantheons. She has been part of many pantheons, The Greeks gave her most notable name "Nyx" and while with the Norse pantheon she went by "Nott" and has been part of many others. This is the form that Thor fought, not her uber powerful true form. When in universe, Nyx has been consistently portrayed as vastly superior to sky fathers and while weakened could easily kill Zeus, a skyfather, and tear at the fabric of 616-Eternity itself. During Immortal Thor, we are again shown this in universe manifestation of Nyx that had become more powerful than she was prior to her banishment from The greek Pantheon. Short of being empowered by TOAA itself, the number of things in Marvel that could possibly get Thor to High-1A doesn't even need a full hand to count and as shown is entirely unreasonable in the first place since the Nyx that Thor is stated to be comparable to is not the True Form version.
Her accurate forms are as follows:
The following keys represent different states of Nyx's In Universe Depictions:
Zeus < Weakened In Universe Nyx (This represents Nyx's state post banishment from The Greek Pantheon. This is the state she is in after escaping banishment throughout Avengers No Road Home) <<< Base In Universe Nyx (Before and after being encountered by The Greek Pantheon) [This is in universe form Nyx's natural base power level and is equivalent to when she has all of her "Night Shards". Even when not having all of them, she was capable of "tearing the skin of the universe" {Earth-616 Eternity} ] < Immortal Thor #13 Nyx (It is implied that she caused a second "Endless Night" that increased her power past her base level) ~ Amped Immortal Thor #14 Zeus {While Loki and Word of God states that he is a greater threat than Nyx, this is not really supported by what is shown throughout Immortal Thor #14.) <<< Nyx as seen at the end of Immortal Thor #14 (Nyx is far more powerful than ever before having realized the nature of the realm she is in is perfect for her gaining total mastery and power over it. She states that she will fashion her own entire universe [likely equal to Earth-616 Eternity in scale] within it.)
True Form: The gulf between her in universe form and her true form is so unimaginably massive that it is practically impossible to convey in any form of language without simply repeating the VS Wiki definitions of Meta Qualitative transcendence. In this state she is the literal formless darkness that encompasses the light of the true form Phoenix Force and is the same darkness in which the Phoenix Force's opposite, The Tiger God, stalks it from.
The revised wording along with some additional scans that I suggested in my previous comment accurately reflect the level of Nyx that Thor is comparable to:
I spoke with Eseseso, who added the High 1-A to Nyx's profile, and he clarified the situation with Nyx to me. I've edited Immortal Thor to reflect his and Elephant's feedback. 
