• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

My Hero Academia General Discussion Thread #18

because theyre treated like footsoldiers in the final war that even Burnin can beat
I don’t recall Burnin beating them solo.
There’s only 2 heroes capable of soloing them that we’ve seen. Endeavor and Mirko. For everyone else it takes at least a dozen or they have very clear nerfs (one of them was missing super regeneration)
 
Why do people find it so hard to believe High End Nomu are relative to All Might?
I'm not saying they should or shouldn't be, but weakened All Might can change the weather with a punch or send his opponents flying into the sky. The High End Nomu were never given a hugely impacting strength feat that was reminiscent of weakened All Might's most impressive moments.
 
Last edited:
Still. It's wild that the Nomus weren't dropping corpses everywhere on the battlefield. In the first war they were actually taking out heroes, but in the second one they were literally turned into background fodder.

Should have made them all fight Deku. Would have been far more believable for a reason for delay than the 4'11 yandere pulling 45% Deku through a portal and then somehow not getting one shotted.

Also why Deku with float has worse travel speed than All Might. All Might just jumped across Japan like nothing.

I swear the stalling stuff was really the worst written part of the war.
 
I'm not saying they should or shouldn't be, but weakened All Might can change the weather with a punch or send his opponents flying into the sky. The High End Nomu were never given a hugely impacting strength feat they was reminiscent of weakened All Might's most impressive moments.
I can understand this thought process.
Horikoshi really did just stop with the whole air show from super strength at some point in time, huh?
Obv he can’t have characters producing superduper shockwaves all the time but outside of movies and the final punch. Nobody ever feels as strong as weakened All Might.
No way Shigaraki couldn’t wave his hand and bust out the coffin in the sky.
To this day I still see people contemplate on whether Deku or Tomura were on All Might’s level lol.
So the HEN are basically that times 10.
 
Are we having the same Nomu debate AGAIN?
MHA thread the last few weeks be like:

Still. It's wild that the Nomus weren't dropping corpses everywhere on the battlefield. In the first war they were actually taking out heroes, but in the second one they were literally turned into background fodder.

Should have made them all fight Deku. Would have been far more believable for a reason for delay than the 4'11 yandere pulling 45% Deku through a portal and then somehow not getting one shotted.
If that happened there would be big “hype moments and aura” complaints lobbied towards the arc. I think the Nomu became less relevant cos they’re honestly kinda boring character wise (besides Hood and Kurogiri). Still would’ve been nice to see them in more fights, but not really a big deal. Also maybe Toga is just 45% Deku level. I mean, she was apparently a massive threat to the heroes with Sadman’s Death Parade, Hawks and Endeavour included 🤷‍♂️
Also why Deku with float has worse travel speed than All Might. All Might just jumped across Japan like nothing.
Wasn’t that feat only in Vigilantes? He never did anything like that in the main series. Even then, it feels like the Anime buffed that feat anyway. In the manga it fits with Deku travelling 200km in a relatively short timeframe.
I swear the stalling stuff was really the worst written part of the war.
I wouldn’t call Toga vs Deku stalling. It’s important for both Toga and Uraraka’s arcs and sets up their final confrontation.
 
Last edited:
If that happened there would be big “hype moments and aura” complaints lobbied towards the arc. I think the Nomu became less relevant cos they’re honestly kinda boring character wise (besides Hood and Kurogiri). Still would’ve been nice to see them in more fights, but not really a big deal. Also maybe Toga is just 45% Deku level. I mean, she was apparently a massive threat to the heroes with Sadman’s Death Parade, Hawks and Endeavour included 🤷‍♂️
Not really. One of the biggest complains about the war is how disneyfied it was and how much plot armor the heores side has so if anything, this makes the WAR look like a War.
Wasn’t that feat only in Vigilantes? He never did anything like that in the main series. Even then, it feels like the Anime buffed that feat anyway. In the manga it fits with Deku travelling 200km in a relatively short timeframe.
Not really. In the main series he jumps around everywhere when he has the power. Even Shiggy himself jumps across Jaku in a single leap just in a few seconds.
I wouldn’t call Toga vs Deku stalling. It’s important for both Toga and Uraraka’s arcs and sets up their final confrontation.
Their final confrontation was already setup in the first war when Toga slimed the old woman.
 
I'm not saying they should or shouldn't be, but weakened All Might can change the weather with a punch or send his opponents flying into the sky. The High End Nomu were never given a hugely impacting strength feat that was reminiscent of weakened All Might's most impressive moments.
Same reason why so many people think Izuku is still at 45% during the Final War. (Even though he visually has better feats.)

Izuku and Shigaraki didn't feel like All Might and All For One. That's why so many people online don't believe they're at or above Prime All Might's level.

Incomplete/Complete Shigaraki never even did what All Might does in the Final Exam, while he was wearing weights that slowed him down.

(Let's downgrade All Might to Class 1, since 765 kg was enough to noticeably affect him.)
 
Not really. One of the biggest complains about the war is how disneyfied it was and how much plot armor the heores side has so if anything, this makes the WAR look like a War.
Almost every new gen gets the Disney complaints, that doesn’t really mean anything. JJK was killing characters left and right in its final arc and still got Disney complaints. It was always going to get those complaints, adding in a scene of Deku fighting nameless blob enemies doesn’t achieve anything other than pad out the arc with meaningless filler. I would have liked to see them fighting the other students a bit more though, give Sato’s bum-ass something to do.
Not really. In the main series he jumps around everywhere when he has the power. Even Shiggy himself jumps across Jaku in a single leap just in a few seconds.
Deku travels 200 Km in a short period of time as well during this arc. There’s not really a contradiction with the main series.
Their final confrontation was already setup in the first war when Toga slimed the old woman.
True, but this doesn't allow for Toga to have a final interaction with Deku. It’s this moment that truly sends her off the deep end as a villain, forsaking her feelings in pursuit of her friends goals (a parallel to Uraraka’s own burying of her feelings).
 
Almost every new gen gets the Disney complaints
Fp32OjwX0AAZxF1.jpg
 
JJK only got disney complaints at the tail end where Higaruma and Nobara come back.

Also giving Deku a fight against multiple high tiers is kinda needed. Reminder that he had no fights since Nagant.
 
JJK only got disney complaints at the tail end where Higaruma and Nobara come back.
That still isn’t a good reason to call it disneyfied when Choso and Sukuna, the only ones who could share in Yuji’s experience of immortality, both die along with Yuji’s own mentor. And let’s not forget that it happened to Modulo as well, people just shut up about that cos the CSM ending wasn’t long after.
Also giving Deku a fight against multiple high tiers is kinda needed. Reminder that he had no fights since Nagant.
That fight was important for his character though. It proved that his philosophy of trying to save villains was not in vain and could work. What does a fight against multiple High-ends do other than provide hype and aura, and drag out the story?
 
Same reason why so many people think Izuku is still at 45% during the Final War. (Even though he visually has better feats.)
This is partly because of his dogshit travel speed. 45% is the last base percentage fans saw him use so it's not unreasonable for them to assume it.


Izuku and Shigaraki didn't feel like All Might and All For One. That's why so many people online don't believe they're at or above Prime All Might's level.
Which is ironic because strictly in terms of the manga, Raid War Deku and Tomura had better visual feats.
Deku's Texas Smash is bigger than AFO/AM fist clash or the USoS iirc.
 
That still isn’t a good reason to call it disneyfied when Choso and Sukuna, the only ones who could share in Yuji’s experience of immortality, both die along with Yuji’s own mentor. And let’s not forget that it happened to Modulo as well, people just shut up about that cos the CSM ending wasn’t long after.

That fight was important for his character though. It proved that his philosophy of trying to save villains was not in vain and could work. What does a fight against multiple High-ends do other than provide hype and aura, and drag out the story?
I never said nagant fight wasn't important. I was point out the sheer void of Deku fights.

It provides visual confirmation of his growth as a combatant and wielder of One For All alongside setting him and Shigaraki up as Titans in the narrative.

And it utilizes Nomu's well in the story rather than forgetting them.

And it makes AFO look smarter as he uses his strongest pawns to tire out his biggest target.

You are forgetting it's a war arc. Strategy and match ups are a big part of war.
 
It provides visual confirmation of his growth as a combatant and wielder of One For All
That’s the whole point of the Shigaraki fight though. We have a direct point of comparison between the two’s power before and after the Dark Hero - UA Traitor arc (PLW Shiggy vs 45% Deku and Complete Shiggy vs Gearshift Deku) to show that, where the outcomes are different (first fight - heroes kinda win by skin of their teeth before AFO possesses Shiggy and second fight - Deku defeats ShigAFO on his own (after ShigAFO has easily defeated the other heroes) making an utter mockery of him).
alongside setting him and Shigaraki up as Titans in the narrative.
The Star and Stripe and Endeavour fights do that for Shigaraki. It is true that Deku doesn’t really have anything in that regard, but that’s where the Gearshift fight comes in to show us how much stronger he is. That’s a better set up for him being a Titan than him fighting Nomu imo, especially with all the reference to AFO being a perfected Nomu. It’s a classic example of the “Godzilla threshold” trope, the author should refrain from showing the thing that people are waiting for (ie Deku at his strongest) until the moment where it will achieve its greatest effect (ie the fight with the most powerful villain). It’s why horror movies don’t show the monster until the end, it builds hype for how the monster will look like.
And it utilizes Nomu's well in the story rather than forgetting them.
I think the better option for utilising the Nomu more is, again, to see them fight against some of the other students. Like, give Sato something to do, Deku’s got like 4 fights in this arc as is.
And it makes AFO look smarter as he uses his strongest pawns to tire out his biggest target.

You are forgetting it's a war arc. Strategy and match ups are a big part of war.
It’s kinda more of a jumping than a war. It’s called a war arc but that kinda just means there’s gonna be loads of battles. Both parties did have strategy anyway, it’s just that AFO thought that they’d just get there and destroy them in one swoop. He had no idea that they could use Warp Gate as he didn’t know about Monoma’s quirk so he didn’t plan around that. And his sludge warp has a limited range, so he can’t just teleport them willy-nilly. In fact, the reason why the Nomu’s couldn’t all fight Deku was due to the heroes’ strategy.
 
if Sato fought a Nomu, it would make them even more unimpressive.
I honestly wouldn’t care if it made Sato a better character. The Nomu can’t really get any depth as characters (again, besides Kurogiri kinda and maybe Hood), so I’m perfectly okay with just sacrificing their “aura” for lack of a better word, to improve some of the less expanded upon side characters.
most of the UA students were too narratively neglected to believably fight an AM level threat
I mean, Sato did punch out AFO in Shiggy’s weakened body. If him and Ojiro fought hard to take down a Nomu, with flashbacks showing their respective backstories it could make for a decent fight sequence. And I don’t really think the Nomu are that unimpressive anyway, just that the verse’s power creep put a lot of characters up to WAM tier. Hell, Mirko is near PAM tier by the end of the series. I’ve said before, but All Might as of Season 1 is just thought to be stronger than he is due to in verse propaganda and his public persona hiding his true fears.
 
I started watching the anime in different languages, and in the Spanish dub it's mentioned that Shigaraki will destroy the entire planet 😭🙏🏻
 
I started watching the anime in different languages, and in the Spanish dub it's mentioned that Shigaraki will destroy the entire planet 😭🙏🏻
Doesn’t really mean anything for AP unfortunately since Decay is hax. We also know he is limited to Japan for some reason as he says there will be “nothing left except sea and sky”, implying he can’t decay under the ocean from Japan. This implies that he won’t destroy the world in one shot, but rather multiple decays perhaps across different landmasses.
 
I honestly wouldn’t care if it made Sato a better character.
he wouldnt get any cool points from beating a Nomu if the Nomus themselves arent respectable threats
I mean, Sato did punch out AFO in Shiggy’s weakened body.
literally everyone was farming ShigAFO
with flashbacks showing their respective backstories
they dont have backstories 😭
their flashbacks would just be them as regular civilians living regular lives
 

Show some love to the best twin
 
Last edited:
he wouldnt get any cool points from beating a Nomu if the Nomus themselves arent respectable threats
He’d get more than he does in the current version of the story. Especially if they were all struggling to beat it at first. Have it be an army if you need to.
they dont have backstories 😭
their flashbacks would just be them as regular civilians living regular lives
Give them one then. Or just emphasise his love for his classmates, just give him something.
literally everyone was farming ShigAFO
No one harmed his main body besides Deku, Sato and Ojiro. Not saying that Sato is stronger than all the other heroes there, just that he’s not the weakest of characters in the series and maybe one of the strongest in the Class.
 
This is partly because of his dogshit travel speed. 45% is the last base percentage fans saw him use so it's not unreasonable for them to assume it.
And also, the manga states multiple times that Deku's equipment can't handle 100%. When Deku gets the replica mid-gaunlets from Hatsume, she says they aren't even as good as the ones Deku was using in the Dark hero arc, the same ones AM stated couldn't handle 100%. Plus, the Kudo statement when Deku is flying to the Coffin in the sky. It seems like everyone just kind of ignored all that.
 
And also, the manga states multiple times that Deku's equipment can't handle 100%. When Deku gets the replica mid-gaunlets from Hatsume, she says they aren't even as good as the ones Deku was using in the Dark hero arc, the same ones AM stated couldn't handle 100%. Plus, the Kudo statement when Deku is flying to the Coffin in the sky. It seems like everyone just kind of ignored all that.
The problem with the statements about his equipment is that they're just lies. They tank attacks from Shigaraki constantly and even endure being on Deku when he uses his 120% attacks.
 
Yo r we ever gonna calc how hot endeavours fire is? He destory pure plasma clones with it like years before main story? And heat is comparable to lasers from star n stripes that can vaporize large parts of oceans??
 
And also, the manga states multiple times that Deku's equipment can't handle 100%. When Deku gets the replica mid-gaunlets from Hatsume, she says they aren't even as good as the ones Deku was using in the Dark hero arc, the same ones AM stated couldn't handle 100%. Plus, the Kudo statement when Deku is flying to the Coffin in the sky. It seems like everyone just kind of ignored all that.
Second user filled with shit (least reliable user to take feats from imo) he said you have 5 minute finish this up with gear shift deku used it longer then 5 minutes. 100% then is weird because how is 45% deku able to block prime might shig punches mid air.
 
And also, the manga states multiple times that Deku's equipment can't handle 100%. When Deku gets the replica mid-gaunlets from Hatsume, she says they aren't even as good as the ones Deku was using in the Dark Hero arc, the same ones AM stated couldn't handle 100%. Plus, the Kudo statement when Deku is flying to the Coffin in the sky. It seems like everyone just ignored all that.
Another problem with this is that it’s stated his Quintuple Detroit Smash was weaker than his Fa Jin + Blackwhip kick combo, even though both should push him above 100%, and the gear is fine. Not to mention, when he uses a 120% attack before Quintuple, his gear is fine. On top of that, when he uses Fa Jin + Overdrive, gear is still fine. It really only breaks when he’s losing his Quirks, injured, and using his Overlay form. I don’t think 45% Deku and his gear could be doing all of that without 100. if 45% Deku’s best feat was breaking an incomplete Shigaraki’s jaw.
 
Well I guess Horikoshi simply wasn't thinking about a scenario where Deku's gear breaks because of anything other than his own OFA percentage. Because it would be insanely incompetent writing for all those statements to just be forgotten completely by Hori.

I don't believe 45% from plw is the same as 45% from the Final War. We know the users' base strength stacks with OFA, because otherwise weakened AM wouldn't be a thing, and the concept of 45% from plw being the same strength as 45% from You're Next is hard to believe.
 
It’s likely that those quirks don’t produce the type of recoil needed to destroy his gear like 100% does.
Against Lady Nagant Deku uses Fuax 100% and it doesn’t destroy his gear. He also says there’s no recoil from using it.
he mainly uses fa jin to recreate 100% without the drawbacks so it might be because of that
Yeah, this is most likely it. He literally says to All Might during the Dark Hero arc that he can perform attacks on All Might’s level with no recoil. Given how the coffin battle with ShigAFO is supposed to show Deku’s affinity with OFA, it stands to reason that the sequence is portraying him using Fa Jin (and maybe Gearshift) to nullify the recoil of his 100%.
 
I have a question that was ignored yesterday, but I'm curious to see what you all think.

Would it make sense for Deku to receive the Durability Negation hax thanks to Gearshift? I say this because the Quirk is based on controlling the speed of the objects it touches at a cellular level. What does this imply? It implies that if Deku were to decide to set his speed to "0" or become immobile (which is possible depending on the GS's recoil), the enemy's cells would stop. This would imply things like lack of oxygen or heart problems/death due to not pumping any blood, and according to the manga, this Quirk can affect oxygen. (Or at least that's what we saw with Deku, since when he was immobile he was unable to breathe and had to resort to forcing his own movement with Blackwhip)
I'd like to know what you think
 
I have a question that was ignored yesterday, but I'm curious to see what you all think.

Would it make sense for Deku to receive the Durability Negation hax thanks to Gearshift? I say this because the Quirk is based on controlling the speed of the objects it touches at a cellular level. What does this imply? It implies that if Deku were to decide to set his speed to "0" or become immobile (which is possible depending on the GS's recoil), the enemy's cells would stop. This would imply things like lack of oxygen or heart problems/death due to not pumping any blood, and according to the manga, this Quirk can affect oxygen. (Or at least that's what we saw with Deku, since when he was immobile he was unable to breathe and had to resort to forcing his own movement with Blackwhip)
I'd like to know what you think
Gearshift has several gears, the highest being the top gear and the absolute slowest we’ve seen it go was “low gear” which seemed to slow Deku down at best.
I don’t think he can freeze something with it.
Deku hasn’t done it, and I’m sure if he could do it, it probably wouldn’t work like that.
Not enough evidence for this and it’s mostly speculation
 
Gearshift has several gears, the highest being the top gear and the absolute slowest we’ve seen it go was “low gear” which seemed to slow Deku down at best.
I don’t think he can freeze something with it.
Deku hasn’t done it, and I’m sure if he could do it, it probably wouldn’t work like that.
Not enough evidence for this and it’s mostly speculation
izuku used low gear to freeze things at least twice by my memory.

once during the first half of the shigaraki fight when he first used gearhift against him. shigaraki was getting brutally blitzed but could predict the angle of the next attack based on the trajectory of the previous one. izuku used low gear and froze himself in place to prevent shigaraki's hit from landing, and proceeded to pummel him again.

the second time was during the second half of the fight, when izuku used low gear on his own smokescreen to keep it in place and obscure shigaraki's vision while using black whip to abuse danger sense.

there could be another instance that i dont remember, but low gear does indeed slow things down to the point where they're practically completely frozen
 
Last edited:
Gearshift has several gears, the highest being the top gear and the absolute slowest we’ve seen it go was “low gear” which seemed to slow Deku down at best.
I don’t think he can freeze something with it.
Deku hasn’t done it, and I’m sure if he could do it, it probably wouldn’t work like that.
Not enough evidence for this and it’s mostly speculation
Gearshift is just "changing speed while ignoring inertia"; the gears are how Deku uses it, they're not something the Quirk had by default (so to speak). Anyway, if we base it on what that change of speed without inertia is, it should reduce something to 0 or an unmovable level. Furthermore, couldn't he freeze in mid-air when Shigaraki was about to strike him by prediction?
 
Back
Top