• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

The Revenant Marvel Comics Discussion Thread

Can we axe the Storm run from the main cosmology?

like we do for DeMatteis and main but DeMatteis case is less extreme as Storm at this point
That's lowkey what we've all agreed on.

And even though we're probably gonna remerge Demattis, ain't no way Oyadele is gonna get remerged at this point
 
The most simple of questions would be how exactly do the events in the comic work.

Oblivion was guarding the universe from Black Winters, yet those can also affect Land of Queen of Nevers and WHR, Eternity travelling to the House of Ideas when Defenders Beyond happened specifically because he couldn't.

It would be "You told numerous times that you limited the scope of the Storm story to be in a single universe. Yet you also included countless of higher realms, like White Hot Room, House of Ideas, and the Land of the Never Queen. How does it work? Did Hadad attacked those higher realms after all or was those still... in a single Universal scope as well?"

I asked Twig to ask him that on X, but I am not sure if it was a fruitful endeavour.
Don't forget about TOAA, and whether or not they represent the universal or multiversal versions?

And how Black Winter was so weak when in its first appearance just one was a multiversal threat?
Yes, especially as it had been clearly established that there was only one Black Winter and that it destroyed the 6th iteration of the Marvel multiverse. Why was that inexplicably retconned, and why the need to constantly degrade Thor in order to wank Storm, instead of letting her stand on her own?

And will the current multiversal crisis storyline ever be resolved, or is the Storm comicbook handwaved as outside of regular continuity now? And who was Storm's daughter's father?

I would appreciate if somebody can write as polite versions as possible for all of our questions and send them to the Q&A before the deadline ends on June 5, 2026. 🙏
 
Yes, especially as it had been clearly established that there was only one Black Winter and that it destroyed the 6th iteration of the Marvel multiverse. Why was that inexplicably retconned, and why the need to constantly degrade Thor in order to wank Storm, instead of letting her stand on her own?

And will the current multiversal crisis storyline ever be resolved, or is the Storm comicbook handwaved as outside of regular continuity now? And who was Storm's daughter's father?

I would appreciate if somebody can write as polite versions as possible for all of our questions and send them to the Q&A before the deadline ends on June 5, 2026. 🙏
Eh... something tells me they're not gonna be polite about any of this...
 
We need to reword it carefully, or we won't receive any answers. 🙏
 
Anyways, Godzilla Infinity Road is done and... they got one more in them!

Godzilla vs the Multiverse 22 of July. Fun, fun, fun.
 
Godzilla vs the Multiverse
geto-suguru-geto.gif
 
Anyways, Godzilla Infinity Road is done and... they got one more in them!

Godzilla vs the Multiverse 22 of July. Fun, fun, fun.
Can't wait for another 6 issues of
Godzilla shows up
New foe fights him for 2 pages
Godzilla proceeds to kick the shit out of new foe
Characters make shocked faces
Repeat

The Godzilla vs Thor book was good because it had actual back and forth but this entire storyline has just been the exact same thing happening over and over and over again. It's so boring.
 
We need to reword it carefully, or we won't receive any answers. 🙏
So are any of you willing to help out with writing our list of politely worded questions please, and is anybody willing to submit them afterwards (You should do so as anynymously as possible)? Our available submission time is quickly running out.🙏

 
Last edited:
Well, the Hulk is at least normally not portrayed as anywhere near as evil as quite a lot of the X-Men, and even the "nicer" X-Men characters tend to be perfectly fine with having Mystique, Apocalypse, and similar downright satanic characters as team members, and to let them roam free to continue to commit atrocities just because they are mutants, and tribalism apparently gives almost everybody a free pass for them. 🙏
They also allowed Tarn to run rampant until Magneto killed him, as well as Mister Sinister, a sociopathic mad doctor who worked with Josef Mengele.
 
So are any of you willing to help out with writing our list of politely worded questions please, and is anybody willing to submit them afterwards (You should do so as anynymously as possible)? Our available submission time is quickly running out.🙏

What actual questions are we actually as a community interested in, specifically?
 
The most simple of questions would be how exactly do the events in the comic work.

Oblivion was guarding the universe from Black Winters, yet those can also affect Land of Queen of Nevers and WHR, Eternity travelling to the House of Ideas when Defenders Beyond happened specifically because he couldn't.

It would be "You told numerous times that you limited the scope of the Storm story to be in a single universe. Yet you also included countless of higher realms, like White Hot Room, House of Ideas, and the Land of the Never Queen. How does it work? Did Hadad attacked those higher realms after all or was those still... in a single Universal scope as well?"

I asked Twig to ask him that on X, but I am not sure if it was a fruitful endeavour.
Don't forget about TOAA, and whether or not they represent the universal or multiversal versions?

And how Black Winter was so weak when in its first appearance just one was a multiversal threat?
Yes, especially as it had been clearly established that there was only one Black Winter and that it destroyed the 6th iteration of the Marvel multiverse. Why was that inexplicably retconned, and why the need to constantly degrade Thor in order to wank Storm, instead of letting her stand on her own?

And will the current multiversal crisis storyline ever be resolved, or is the Storm comicbook handwaved as outside of regular continuity now? And who was Storm's daughter's father?

I would appreciate if somebody can write as polite versions as possible for all of our questions and send them to the Q&A before the deadline ends on June 5, 2026. 🙏
We need to reword it carefully, or we won't receive any answers. 🙏
Well, these are the questions we have had thus far here. 🙏
 
They also allowed Tarn to run rampant until Magneto killed him, as well as Mister Sinister, a sociopathic mad doctor who worked with Josef Mengele.
Yes. The mutants in general are mostly ranging from being presented as major assholes to complete monsters. Not exactly good representations for the concept of people being persecuted by others. 🙏
 
Well, these are the questions we have had thus far here. 🙏
So which of these questions can be worded in a way so they are sufficiently polite to be accepted? And is somebody here willing to reword them in a clearly understood manner please? We only have until tomorrow to submit them. 🙏
 
So which of these questions can be worded in a way so they are sufficiently polite to be accepted? And is somebody here willing to reword them in a clearly understood manner please? We only have until tomorrow to submit them. 🙏
I was gonna ask about the Black Winter thing, but apparently he already clarified that the ones seen in the Storm series were created by Hadad and that the original Black Winter predates those.



Anything else I should try asking?
 
Well, these are the questions we have had thus far here. 🙏
Problem is, while we are giving a ton of shit to him, most of the generic questions are already answered.

Black Winters aren't as strong as prior one, but of the same "race". Hadad was stated to be stronger than Elder Gods, so he can spawn them...

I did send one question personally, but those questions will be chosen by the staff anyways.
 
So are there none of our questions about the story that we can send in, such as about the abrupt cut-off ending, the inconsistencies, and Storm's daughter's father? 🙏
 
So are there none of our questions about the story that we can send in, such as about the abrupt cut-off ending, the inconsistencies, and Storm's daughter's father? 🙏
How much time do we have and which inconsistencies are you talking about specifically?

He naturally won’t spoil anything and… I am pretty sure that Earths Mightiest Mutant is still ongoing 🤔
 
How much time do we have and which inconsistencies are you talking about specifically?
Today is the deadline, so we REALLY need to hurry up here.

And the issues we mentioned above along with any other ones we can remember from our earlier discussions about the cosmology.
He naturally won’t spoil anything and… I am pretty sure that Earths Mightiest Mutant is still ongoing 🤔
No, it has apparently been cancelled as far as we currently know. 🙏
 
I mean, isn't Death planning her massive war against TOAA?
Death is "just" planning to wipe out Eternity and all life within him, because Eternity destroyed her brother Oblivion. 🙏
 
Never mind. I sent in the following questions. 🙏

1) Has the Storm comicbook been cancelled, and if so, will its storyline ever be properly concluded?

2) Some of the deceased characters serving Death have been shown to be perfectly alive in other currently releasing comicbooks. Did the editors not help you out enough in this regard?

3) Will we ever learn the identity of Storm's daughter's father?

4) In Defenders Beyond, Eternity couldn't travel to The House of Ideas, but in your story he could. Please explain your reasoning.

5) Are Storm's stories working on a universal or multiversal scale. It seems unclear at times.

6) It seems like you sometimes make jabs in Thor's direction. Can't Thor and Storm just be allowed to exist in their own rights as equally prominent, valid, virtuous, and powerful characters without the need to outshine each other?
 
They also allowed Tarn to run rampant until Magneto killed him, as well as Mister Sinister, a sociopathic mad doctor who worked with Josef Mengele.
Eh, Sinister made sense tbh. They couldn’t do the resurrection protocols without him and the deal was a seat at the council in exchange for his bio data. Everyone knew he was a snake, they just believed that it was only a matter of time before he made a play that would fail so they could get rid of him. And considering Sinister needed what was essentially a secret reset button that he needed to use many times? Their confidence in being able to deal with him wasn’t exactly misplaced.

Frankly that was the thinking with the amnesty in general. Either someone would genuinely reform and become a good person or they’d inevitably try something and get punished while serving as an example to others. Though its a major theme with the Krakoa era that the Mutants in charge overestimate themselves because they’re high off of their current situation as a nation state full of powerful Mutants which in turn makes them underestimate threats. Hickman went out of his way to make it clear that Magneto and Xavier weren’t actually the kind of people you want in charge, but they’re also the kind of people who think they should be.
 
Last edited:
Never mind. I sent in the following questions. 🙏

1) Has the Storm comicbook been cancelled, and if so, will its storyline ever be properly concluded?

2) Some of the deceased characters serving Death have been shown to be perfectly alive in other currently releasing comicbooks. Did the editors not help you out enough in this regard?

3) Will we ever learn the identity of Storm's daughter's father?

4) In Defenders Beyond, Eternity couldn't travel to The House of Ideas, but in your story he could. Please explain your reasoning.

5) Are Storm's stories working on a universal or multiversal scale. It seems unclear at times.

6) It seems like you sometimes make jabs in Thor's direction. Can't Thor and Storm just be allowed to exist in their own rights as equally prominent, valid, virtuous, and powerful characters without the need to outshine each other?
Nice! Although I do hope you have added more flowery language there. I made up a whole persona XD
 
I find it hilarious that recent What If showcases what would have happened if Sinister wasn’t on Krakoa. Total disaster.

Except the writers also forgot that Enigma puppeteered everyone to reach his creation and simply wouldn’t allow such scenario. Tragic.
 
I find it hilarious that recent What If showcases what would have happened if Sinister wasn’t on Krakoa. Total disaster.
That does seem extremely contrived in terms of being narratively engineered to amorally justify allowing embodiments of absolute evil to run around freely, yes. 🙏
 
Back
Top