• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

The Revenant Marvel Comics Discussion Thread

Isn't Gladiator among the most variable herald-tiers? Doesn't sound like he should be the crutch for such a broad scaling chain. Also, Quasar wasn't confident that his shield could withstand an explosion strong enough to consume a planet.
Oh he isn't the crutch for it, I was just using it as an example. Other Heralds, like Beta Ray Bill, directly scale to him, and BRB does have the same extreme Varies mechanic. As for the planet thing, I think that's just inconsistency inherent to Marvel. We are frequently shown hard limits on power than aren't actual limits, like Thor thinking Hercules would die from falling off a building.
 
I am mostly agreeing with GeneralSol here. Marvel Comics is incredibly inconsistent in terms of power-levels, and routinely lets favoured character with far lesser feats and displayed limits match or outmatch characters with far greater valid feats. 🙏
 
We can't scale from fighting him, but what about statements? If someone is stated to be in the same class of power as Gladiator, would that not be enough?
Gladiator vary based on emotions similar to Hulk. Kinda hard to scale from them. Scaling from them is just by assumption on what power level are they using at the given battle
 
I am mostly agreeing with GeneralSol here. Marvel Comics is incredibly inconsistent in terms of power-levels, and routinely lets favoured character with far lesser feats and displayed limits match or outmatch characters with far greater valid feats. 🙏
What do you think we should do then? I just strongly feel that the 3-C/Low 1-C split is bad and needs to be completely removed. I think that any character currently at 3-C should be upgraded to whatever the new Herald Tier ends up being (Right now I'm thinking High 3-A looks the most consistent) unless they have a very good reason otherwise. I think as long as a character is consistently show to be comparable to Herald Tier characters, then it doesn't matter their own feats.
 
I am not certain honestly, but we all need to stop pretending that this is not a massive problem when attempting to scale this particular verse, and focusing more on individual feats and less on inconsistent scaling for it might be a good idea. 🙏
 
Last edited:
I am not certain honestly, but we all need to stop pretending that this is not a massive problem when attempting to scale this partocular verse, and focusing more on individual feats and less on inconsistent scaling for it might be a good idea. 🙏
I just think we need to make sure its consistent that characters are treated as being on this level. Like merely being able to cause pain to someone with a punch, or send them flying, or not being immediately one-shot, shouldn't be enough to scale. But, as long are there are repeat statements and/or clear feats against characters who are definitely Herald level, I think scaling is fine. For example, Blue Marvel's best feat is like Continent level, but it is extremely consistent and explicit that he is intended to be at Herald levels of power.

For tiering, right now I'm thinking High 3-A is best. There are many feats from a good variety of characters at that level. The Eric Masterson feat is a really good 2-A feat, but unless we find more feats at the level, I fear it may be an outlier.
 
I just think we need to make sure its consistent that characters are treated as being on this level. Like merely being able to cause pain to someone with a punch, or send them flying, or not being immediately one-shot, shouldn't be enough to scale. But, as long are there are repeat statements and/or clear feats against characters who are definitely Herald level, I think scaling is fine. For example, Blue Marvel's best feat is like Continent level, but it is extremely consistent and explicit that he is intended to be at Herald levels of power.

For tiering, right now I'm thinking High 3-A is best. There are many feats from a good variety of characters at that level. The Eric Masterson feat is a really good 2-A feat, but unless we find more feats at the level, I fear it may be an outlier.
Sad as it is to say, High 3-A makes more sense than 2-A.

Honestly we should go back to 3-C ngl
 
Sad as it is to say, High 3-A makes more sense than 2-A.

Honestly we should go back to 3-C ngl
I think High 3-A is more consistent honestly. Genuinely I'm pretty sure there are more High 3-A feats that 3-C ones. But yeah, it's looking like 2-A is a lost cause :(
 
I think High 3-A is more consistent honestly. Genuinely I'm pretty sure there are more High 3-A feats that 3-C ones. But yeah, it's looking like 2-A is a lost cause :(
Even some of the 3-Cs feats should be High 3-A since we currently accept the regular universe as infinite. High 3-A is more consistent. 2-A should be an outlier.
 
Does this mean that Blake going crazy and becoming a psycho murderer was because of Loki? Because that's a retcon I would really like to see.
pPYeRHv.png
 
Because mystical entities are being of the multiverse rather than just the local universe as far as I am aware, and on principle we should not just automatically assume the highest possible interpretation. 🙏
 
To be honest, I do not like the original version of The Sentry at all. 🙏
 
Well, he is a mixture of an uninteresting Gary Stu and Villain Stu, so he is not my cup of tea. I prefer my superheroes as positive ideals to strive towards. 🙏
 
Well, he is a mixture of an uninteresting Gary Stu and Villain Stu, so he is not my cup of tea. I prefer my superheroes as positive ideals to strive towards. 🙏
So do I, but Bob is cool. Later comics simplified him tremendously, but his original portrait was of a struggling man, whose powers also cause an evil force of nature to appear. A hero, who's every good deed being matched by equal or greater destruction. He struggles, and that struggle is interesting.
 

INFERNAL HULK #5
Phillip Kennedy Johnson (W) • Nic Klein (A/C) • VARIANT COVER BY ADAM GORHAM
DOOM HOMAGE VARIANT COVER BY SKAN • VARIANT COVER BY GIUSEPPE CAMUNCOLI
INFERNAL VERSUS ALMIGHTY!
As Infernal Hulk prepares to deal his death blow against Earth, a being of unimaginable power descends from the heavens to save us: the Creator of the Marvel Universe himself! Everything on Earth will change after this shocking, never-before-seen battle for the ages: INFERNAL HULK versus THE ONE ABOVE ALL!

Sigh. Both the Hulk and Storm writers are turning very annoying in the power-tripping fanboyism of their stories. Where are sensible editors when we need them? 🙏
 

INFERNAL HULK #5
Phillip Kennedy Johnson (W) • Nic Klein (A/C) • VARIANT COVER BY ADAM GORHAM
DOOM HOMAGE VARIANT COVER BY SKAN • VARIANT COVER BY GIUSEPPE CAMUNCOLI
INFERNAL VERSUS ALMIGHTY!
As Infernal Hulk prepares to deal his death blow against Earth, a being of unimaginable power descends from the heavens to save us: the Creator of the Marvel Universe himself! Everything on Earth will change after this shocking, never-before-seen battle for the ages: INFERNAL HULK versus THE ONE ABOVE ALL!

Sigh. Both the Hulk and Storm writers are turning very annoying in the power-tripping fanboyism of their stories. Where are sensible editors when we need them? 🙏
I mean... at least Hulk being that powerful is kinda believable? At least based on the character's history (and him apparently being possessed by an eldritch horror). If it was somebody like Spider-Man, than yeah I'd be concerned.
 

INFERNAL HULK #5
Phillip Kennedy Johnson (W) • Nic Klein (A/C) • VARIANT COVER BY ADAM GORHAM
DOOM HOMAGE VARIANT COVER BY SKAN • VARIANT COVER BY GIUSEPPE CAMUNCOLI
INFERNAL VERSUS ALMIGHTY!
As Infernal Hulk prepares to deal his death blow against Earth, a being of unimaginable power descends from the heavens to save us: the Creator of the Marvel Universe himself! Everything on Earth will change after this shocking, never-before-seen battle for the ages: INFERNAL HULK versus THE ONE ABOVE ALL!

Sigh. Both the Hulk and Storm writers are turning very annoying in the power-tripping fanboyism of their stories. Where are sensible editors when we need them? 🙏
One thing we both agree on despite me being a Hulk fan.
 
I mean... at least Hulk being that powerful is kinda believable? At least based on the character's history (and him apparently being possessed by an eldritch horror). If it was somebody like Spider-Man, than yeah I'd be concerned.
It’s not even normal Hulk. He’s being possessed by the Eldest who then gained power by consuming the corpse of the Mother of Horrors. None of this scales to regular Hulk at all.
 
I can’t decide about Thor, but Hulk can remain 1-A...and it’s even possible to make Hulk’s 1-A status stronger and better supported.
Yeah.
But the rest of the profiles… are a disaster… especially Tier 1-A
Thor do have 1-A but those feat can only be performed via his special heritage as an Elder god Asgardian hybrid and Phoenix force type shii. No Heralds scale to this including those who solely scale to Thor.
 
Yeah.

Thor do have 1-A but those feat can only be performed via his special heritage as an Elder god Asgardian hybrid and Phoenix force type shii. No Heralds scale to this including those who solely scale to Thor.
How many 1-A feats does he have? Like all the Yggdrasil ones will be downgraded to High 1-B
 
Why even do all that "who will be the next Sorcerer Supreme" hype if you're just gonna jump to it being Wanda? She's not even the actual Sorcerer Supreme, she just gave that title to herself and told the Vishanti to go screw themselves when they told her to stand down. Even Wong admits that Wanda already rejecting the Vishanti worries him since that's one less check on the Sorcerer Supreme.
AP1GczPyjdzJWl_VJB59XoicnZv11IhC_4ih-bcWG4CQ-_zr7zHurnMGiO4St2euOjHM1pKCMpXYzTmykOoVEAg7CZP962gFS0kAMp-whpq0Trg8bMQ57OM=s0

Her only defense is that the Cloak of Levitation and Eye of Agamotto chose her after she saved them which is an extremely lousy defense. Agamotto is one of the Vishanti. THAT'S LITERALLY ONE OF HIS CREATIONS.
AP1GczPv4Ta3zky1PzXMzFNL2_UYdwMMDaWaOgKdY0knd5FeVdhylidRMYkgpWvxi_LeA03wMCZGFvjyLAmHKV6n1liyNoHS_7o3P_IWlC6SVo5nGY5r9ls=s0


Edit: Just realized it's Orlando writing this. Oh boy I can't wait for the 500th storyline of "cosmic level antagonist says that Wanda is weak/worthless/underserving/whatever and then Wanda says that actually she's super great and then beats them up". It even happens in this very first issue. Can Orlando write literally anything else for Wanda? It's just like when Ewing writes Storm.
AP1GczN-qoC5h8X_L8jaWKhyFsMdZdPRjgd9_sB2az1r7rGEksNsI_4nwRlHa8tatzshksBabW6Rau82pX3Km1tMYy9IfIiE7flHUpYx6E9tEhsbZoCBlZ8=s0
 
Last edited:
Also type moon bros better cook good or Gilgamesh is cooked😭🙏
Oh yeah, and I'm definitely gonna add some stuff from the post to Doom's P&A (like the intelligence/Social Influencing stuff and the ridiculous amount of weapons his standard armor has).

Why even do all that "who will be the next Sorcerer Supreme" hype if you're just gonna jump to it being Wanda? She's not even the actual Sorcerer Supreme, she just gave that title to herself and told the Vishanti to go screw themselves when they told her to stand down. Even Wong admits that Wanda already rejecting the Vishanti worries him since that's one less check on the Sorcerer Supreme.
AP1GczPyjdzJWl_VJB59XoicnZv11IhC_4ih-bcWG4CQ-_zr7zHurnMGiO4St2euOjHM1pKCMpXYzTmykOoVEAg7CZP962gFS0kAMp-whpq0Trg8bMQ57OM=s0

Her only defense is that the Cloak of Levitation and Eye of Agamotto chose her after she saved them which is an extremely lousy defense. Agamotto is one of the Vishanti. THAT'S LITERALLY ONE OF HIS CREATIONS.
AP1GczPv4Ta3zky1PzXMzFNL2_UYdwMMDaWaOgKdY0knd5FeVdhylidRMYkgpWvxi_LeA03wMCZGFvjyLAmHKV6n1liyNoHS_7o3P_IWlC6SVo5nGY5r9ls=s0


Edit: Just realized it's Orlando writing this. Oh boy I can't wait for the 500th storyline of "cosmic level antagonist says that Wanda is weak/worthless/underserving/whatever and then Wanda says that actually she's super great and then beats them up". It even happens in this very first issue. Can Orlando write literally anything else for Wanda? It's just like when Ewing writes Storm.
AP1GczN-qoC5h8X_L8jaWKhyFsMdZdPRjgd9_sB2az1r7rGEksNsI_4nwRlHa8tatzshksBabW6Rau82pX3Km1tMYy9IfIiE7flHUpYx6E9tEhsbZoCBlZ8=s0
Tbf it's hilarious how the Vishanti have antagonized Strange and by extent humanity countless times (the entire War of the Seven Spheres shenanigans with General Strange, turning a blind eye to Doom's crimes and how he tricked Strange to get the title) only to be shocked and angry when a sorcerer supreme has enough of their bs.
 
Tbf it's hilarious how the Vishanti have antagonized Strange and by extent humanity countless times (the entire War of the Seven Spheres shenanigans with General Strange, turning a blind eye to Doom's crimes and how he tricked Strange to get the title) only to be shocked and angry when a sorcerer supreme has enough of their bs.
What makes me hate Vishante even more is then chosing Agatha, what the hell is going on with them, she is more villain than anything else, she is probably more evil than Doom.
 
Back
Top