The Afton Gauntlet (Games VS Novel VS FF VS Movie VS TJOC)

[Comiphorous]

The Afton Gauntlet​

All five versions of William Afton must fight to see who's the strongest of them all. Each version of him is assumed to be in their strongest incarnation if they have such.

Battle takes place in a maze decorated with Fazbear Entertainment memorabilia, none have line of sight and are all aware of each other and have a vague understanding of eachother's capablilities and appearance. They are fully in character and if viable in character are capable of working together to win, but will ultimately want to win (in a team or not)

Profiles;

William Afton (Games)

William Afton is the overarching main antagonist of the Five Nights at Freddy's video game series. While most of his past is unknown, William was a standout in robotics, and opened a family entertainment restaurant known as Fredbear's Family Diner with the help of his business partner, Henry...

vsbattles.fandom.com

William Afton (Book Trilogy)

William Afton is the main antagonist of the FNaF Silver Eyes trilogy. Unlike his game canon counterpart, this William Afton survived having the springlocks fail (presumably on multiple occasions). He also became Springtrap after being "killed" by Charlie in The Silver Eyes, unlike the original...

vsbattles.fandom.com

William Afton (Fazbear Frights)

William Afton, also known as The Man in Room 1280, is the the overarching antagonist of the Fazbear Frights series. He is the co-founder of Freddy Fazbear's Pizza and notorious serial child murderer who had worn the spring bonnie costume. After being springlocked within his costume and being...

vsbattles.fandom.com

William Afton (Movie)

William Afton, also known as the Yellow Rabbit or by his fake identity, Steve Raglan, is the main antagonist of the Five Nights at Freddy's movie, based on video game franchise of the same name. He is a associate of Fazbear Entertainment, the manipulative and abusive father of Vanessa Shelly...

vsbattles.fandom.com

Ignited Springtrap

Ignited Springtrap is the main antagonist of the spin-off game The Joy of Creation: Halloween Edition. He is an enraged spirit imprisoned inside Fazbear's Fright which attempts to kill anyone who enters the building, to hold the remaining spirits inside the building with him. Tier: At least 9-C...

vsbattles.fandom.com

and when the smoke clears and we have found a winner, maybe i'll write a fanfic about the fight.

 

[Ruby_R_Dracula]

I think Springtrap kinda stomps all of them

 

[Comiphorous]

I think Springtrap kinda stomps all of them

this is true.

 

[DaReaperMan]

So, from weakest to strongest, and I'm not including The Agony because that's ******* stupid, it wouldn't even fit in the place.

5. Movie. Yeah this should be no suprise to anyone, he's the least haxed, second least intelligent, least survivable, and is middling in SI, compared to two guys who doesn't have the ability and the other who barely has it.

4. Ignited. Plain and simple, he's the weakest one with long-acting hax that gets incapped in one good hit. Oh, and since it's basically just a rage monster with little to go to make it seem sentient, it will never get any alliance. The difference is Movie is liable to get targeted first.

3. Games. Ah, the most controversial Afton to date. He's tied for the most survivable, and he's the first one to have any shot at any alliance being the one approaching others with it, but he's also baseline 9-B, 3x weaker than FF, and... well 15 Kilojoules compared to 5 Megajoules is not a fair fight. Also, he REALLY doesn't use a lot of hax.

2. Fazbear Frights. If this was Agony, he'd be #1 based off sheer AP alone. But that's dumb. So he's the most haxed, and has comparable survivability to Games, and as for any alliances... well that's why he's not #1. This man has a need to hurt people, so he'd be hurting people. which means...

1. Novels. Low-tier Remnant, lol. All right so why does this bozo win with the most odds? Well, it's simple: Sheer ******* stats and skill. Frights Afton might have hax, but that hax doesn't mean much when it can't someone with good Immortality type 2, and he can't physically harm him cause 5 Megajoules is an insurmountable advantage. Did I mention this guy casually dispatched a police officer in melee and only didn't get the other one because he had like 4 people behind him? None of the other guys here have the ability to straight up fight worth a damn. Novels Afton does. He'd also be the most easy one to ally with, while he's got pride he's not a monster who needs to hurt people or is fueled by rage, so if Games or Movie approached him for an alliance, it'd probably work out. He's also the most intelligent here for what it's worth when compared to those four bozos.

And if this was Agony discard the rest, it's a 9-A 15 foot tall metal rabbit that keeps on getting bigger. It'd be like if you did a Dwarf battle royale but gave Malakai The Spirit of Grungni, it just ceases being about the characters at that point.

 

[DaReaperMan]

Side note, if Novels Afton didn't have sheer AP and was instead baseline he'd be 3rd place. There really is a survivability diff between him and the two remnant gods.

 

[Comiphorous]

5. Movie. Yeah this should be no suprise to anyone, he's the least haxed, second least intelligent, least survivable, and is middling in SI, compared to two guys who doesn't have the ability and the other who barely has it.

Poor Movie William, you'll have your moment in the third film.

3. Games. Ah, the most controversial Afton to date. He's tied for the most survivable, and he's the first one to have any shot at any alliance being the one approaching others with it, but he's also baseline 9-B, 3x weaker than FF, and... well 15 Kilojoules compared to 5 Megajoules is not a fair fight. Also, he REALLY doesn't use a lot of hax.

2. Fazbear Frights. If this was Agony, he'd be #1 based off sheer AP alone. But that's dumb. So he's the most haxed, and has comparable survivability to Games, and as for any alliances... well that's why he's not #1. This man has a need to hurt people, so he'd be hurting people. which means...

It's funny to think how these two shared a profile at one point, and he was ******* tier 6 physically for that brief period.

1. Novels. Low-tier Remnant, lol. All right so why does this bozo win with the most odds? Well, it's simple: Sheer ******* stats and skill. Frights Afton might have hax, but that hax doesn't mean much when it can't someone with good Immortality type 2, and he can't physically harm him cause 5 Megajoules is an insurmountable advantage. Did I mention this guy casually dispatched a police officer in melee and only didn't get the other one because he had like 4 people behind him? None of the other guys here have the ability to straight up fight worth a damn. Novels Afton does. He'd also be the most easy one to ally with, while he's got pride he's not a monster who needs to hurt people or is fueled by rage, so if Games or Movie approached him for an alliance, it'd probably work out. He's also the most intelligent here for what it's worth when compared to those four bozos.

Would Fazbear Frights William be able to try and take over novel william's body if he were willing? It's a fairly big thing in the FF (especially specifically for William) for spirits to be able to fight another for control for the vessel.

 

[DaReaperMan]

Poor Movie William, you'll have your moment in the third film.

TBH he's never gonna be top 3 here, Games is too survivable lol

It's funny to think how these two shared a profile at one point, and he was ******* tier 6 physically for that brief period.

Shion was on some hard drugs.

Would Fazbear Frights William be able to try and take over novel william's body if he were willing? It's a fairly big thing in the FF (especially specifically for William) for spirits to be able to fight another for control for the vessel.

That'd require Frights to get sufficiently ******, which... he kinda sorta can't be here. He's not gonna be reduced to beyond where his Immortality can help him. Thus, he gets incapped.

Also I don't recall him ever doing this outside of situations he was forced into it, and frankly his hax would give him #1 if he took alliances, but he wouldn't. Or at least, he'd betray his ally being charitable.

 

[Comiphorous]

TBH he's never gonna be top 3 here, Games is too survivable lol

As long he gets above ******* Ignited Springtrap of all people, i call that a win. I can see him getting an AP feat that puts him in the top three through AP alone though.

Shion was on some hard drugs.

I was tempted to add the storm thing to his final key, but opted not to just cuz it felt like padding for a key that literally only appears for a few pages that never does the storm shit, whether or not it's important to him.

Also I don't recall him ever doing this outside of situations he was forced into it, and frankly his hax would give him #1 if he took alliances, but he wouldn't. Or at least, he'd betray his ally being charitable.

After the fire that left him as the man in room 1280, yeah he didn't make many choices himself, and just used whatever opportunity arose to get himself out his shitty situation. I don't know he could manually try and possess a new vessel. probably not.

I can see him at least temporarily working with some of his other versions if he knew that he wasn't the strongest there. I think he'd difficult to work with considering his mentality, but i definitely can see him trying to get the other two (not ignited cuz he wouldn't listen) to gang up on novels so he didn't die.

 

[DaReaperMan]

As long he gets above ******* Ignited Springtrap of all people, i call that a win. I can see him getting an AP feat that puts him in the top three through AP alone though.

Frankly you could easily swap him and IS, they're pretty comparable but IS has more hax which is why I put him higher.

I was tempted to add the storm thing to his final key, but opted not to just cuz it felt like padding for a key that literally only appears for a few pages that never does the storm shit, whether or not it's important to him.

The storm thing isn't even from Agony so lol

After the fire that left him as the man in room 1280, yeah he didn't make many choices himself, and just used whatever opportunity arose to get himself out his shitty situation. I don't know he could manually try and possess a new vessel. probably not.

It's kind of a case where he does what he needs to to survive. If he can keep his body and just repair it, he'll do that over time.

I can see him at least temporarily working with some of his other versions if he knew that he wasn't the strongest there. I think he'd difficult to work with considering his mentality, but i definitely can see him trying to get the other two (not ignited cuz he wouldn't listen) to gang up on novels so he didn't die.

But the same can be said for Novels, out of every Afton, he probably likes the sound of his own voice the most, which means interacting with the three who talk would be the most common with him... but I consider an inevitable betrayal to not be an alliance here.

 

[Comiphorous]

But the same can be said for Novels, out of every Afton, he probably likes the sound of his own voice the most, which means interacting with the three who talk would be the most common with him... but I consider an inevitable betrayal to not be an alliance here.

the three aftons ganging up on FF William as he puts them through hallucinations to save his ass cuz he's not his glub shiddo form he pulled out of his ass to get an ez dub here.

 

[Ruby_R_Dracula]

As long he gets above ******* Ignited Springtrap of all people, i call that a win. I can see him getting an AP feat that puts him in the top three through AP alone though.

Theres currently a feat in FNAF 2 that pretty much upgrades the Movie Verse to the point that they would pretty much beat Ig Spring by AP.

Whether it scales to William (well atleast Pre-Springlocked William) is up for discussion (but they do scale to the ogs)

ig there's also a Statement from Golden Freddy about William in the 2nd Movie, but I'm not gonna say it, assuming you haven't watched the movie

 

[Comiphorous]

Theres currently a feat in FNAF 2 that pretty much upgrades the Movie Verse to the point that they would pretty much beat Ig Spring by AP.

Whether it scales to William (well atleast Pre-Springlocked William) is up for discussion (but they do scale to the ogs)

ig there's also a Statement from Golden Freddy about William in the 2nd Movie, but I'm not gonna say it, assuming you haven't watched the movie

Oh no i watched it early. I saw the film before the general public saw it. I have no idea what feat your talking about besides the "TOGETHER, WE ARE FNAF" scene at the end.

 

[Ruby_R_Dracula]

Oh no i watched it early. I saw the film before the general public saw it. I have no idea what feat your talking about besides the WE ARE FNAF scene at the end.

Mangle getting absolutely flunged from Vanessa's Car, and into Toy Freddy, both being unscathed by the feat but deactivated. Moron already made a calc that got around 190000+ Joules but it's getting redone once digital comes


edit: also peak, same, It released 2 days early in my country

 

[Comiphorous]

Mangle getting absolutely flunged from Vanessa's Car, and into Toy Freddy, both being unscathed by the feat but deactivated. Moron already made a calc that got around 190000+ Joules but it's getting redone once digital comes

How the hell does that get that high lmao???

 

[Ruby_R_Dracula]

How the hell does that get that high lmao???

KE ig + Mangle's weight that he calced. if you wanna check, it's currently on the FNAF 2 Movie discussion[/ISPOILER

 

[OrangeFR]

Nah wait we forgetting the LS meta, Silver Eyes William is “Peak Human, likely higher” while games is class 5 and frights is superhuman. They lowkey could LS diff and restrain him/rip him apart.

 

[Perequeliri993]

Nah wait we forgetting the LS meta, Silver Eyes William is “Peak Human, likely higher” while games is class 5 and frights is superhuman. They lowkey could LS diff and restrain him/rip him apart.

Games Will is also the fastest, at around 20 m/s, nearly 2 times more than those who are baseline superhuman, and with 84 m/s reactions.

 

[OrangeFR]

Games Will is also the fastest, at around 20 m/s, nearly 2 times more than those who are baseline superhuman, and with 84 m/s reactions.

Yeah, can’t Games lock tf in and speed + LS meta to victory?

 

[Comiphorous]

Yeah, can’t Games lock tf in and speed + LS meta to victory?

Do we consider springtrap or scraptrap the "strongest version" of games william? If it's scraptrap, he lacks another arm to make use of his LS effectively.

 

[OrangeFR]

Do we consider springtrap or scraptrap the "strongest version" of games william? If it's scraptrap, he lacks another arm to make use of his LS effectively.

We are NOT using Scraptrap for this as long as I walk this earth.

 

[Perequeliri993]

Do we consider springtrap or scraptrap the "strongest version" of games william? If it's scraptrap, he lacks another arm to make use of his LS effectively.

The fact that he lacks an arm makes him the weaker one imo.

 

[Comiphorous]

The fact that he lacks an arm makes him the weaker one imo.

fair enough.