• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Star Wars Discussion Thread Canon/Legends- Episode VI Return of the Threadi

Yeah like, Vader when he's not used to his body and hasn't made his own lightsaber style yet
You can make an argument he does significantly better against ESB Vader than Luke did as well since Luke wasn't getting completely stomped since Vader actually had to try somewhat in that fight and he didn't no hit run it. I've also heard that there's a statement of ESB Luke being stronger than Obi-Wan in Vader's opinion but I've not been able to find it.
 
I got bad understanding of what Post Mustafar meant. post rebels it is then
Not gonna lie, that Vader probably just stalemates Kylo or barely wins by the skin of his teeth. He's weaker than he is in ESB though he's just as skilled but Kylo is an unpredictable mess of a fighter with a totally unique lightsaber that's at least somewhat decent at preventing the strat of just sliding your blade down the enemy's until it hits the hilt like what Obi-Wan did to Grievous and as established, he would beat ESB Luke who canonically gives the second strongest version of Vader a decent fight before he loses.
 
Not gonna lie, that Vader probably just stalemates Kylo or barely wins by the skin of his teeth. He's weaker than he is in ESB though he's just as skilled but Kylo is an unpredictable mess of a fighter with a totally unique lightsaber that's at least somewhat decent at preventing the strat of just sliding your blade down the enemy's until it hits the hilt like what Obi-Wan did to Grievous and as established, he would beat ESB Luke who canonically gives the second strongest version of Vader a decent fight before he loses.
if there's still a chance of Kylo Ren losing then I'm still doin this
 
Not gonna lie, that Vader probably just stalemates Kylo or barely wins by the skin of his teeth. He's weaker than he is in ESB though he's just as skilled but Kylo is an unpredictable mess of a fighter with a totally unique lightsaber that's at least somewhat decent at preventing the strat of just sliding your blade down the enemy's until it hits the hilt like what Obi-Wan did to Grievous and as established, he would beat ESB Luke who canonically gives the second strongest version of Vader a decent fight before he loses.
Kylo has direct statements placing him above vader, this isnt close sadly.
 
So, the one place you can actually use a lightsaber and the force on the accursed thing?
Yeah. I personally think its really fun that the same comic hypes this up as a Vader+ feat because Vader didn't kill this same Zillo Beast before when Kylo just kind of cheats, albeit in an insanely risky way.
 
Hey, i'm really lazy in creating Paz Vizsla's profile rn so lemme show y'all what i got so i may put into a CRT

Din Djarin/Mando rework, basically rewrote some small parts and made a complete revamp of references and PnA (including the addition of another key)

Grogu small rework

Tarre "the G O A T" Vizsla's profile

The Armorer's profile

Few questions:

Ayo, no images?
man, i suck A S S at doing this, and were told elsewhere that if i get an ok with the profile first and then ask someone to put images there

What else is there to work on?
Paz Vizsla probably deserves a profile, I'm just doing a lot rn and not sure if it would be much other than "scaling from Din Djarin", Bo-Katan for sure should get her profile created

What about Sabine Wren (who has a profile)? Or Bo-Katan herself, why nothing got worked on?
Both (and any other i forgor to mention) appear on media i don't dominate so i won't work on them rn

What about Moff Gideon?
Didn't see anything to work on.
 
:

Ayo, no images?
man, i suck A S S at doing this, and were told elsewhere that if i get an ok with the profile first and then ask someone to put images there
weird. I never needed to get an okay before I add imgs to my sandboxs. unless I'm misreading
 
Feats>Statements.

And trust me, Kylo "Tantrum" Ren don't got feats for shit.
Denying the narrative put forth is crazy work, ngl, also this sentiment has no basis, they should be treated equally and evaluated to the full extent.

Kylo also doesn't lack in feats but whatever.
 
If you want to argue this, run into a sandbox and rework Kylo's bad profile...

Hehe, whatever you say...
No I don't, that's why I haven't to begin with, I'm merely questioning your reasoning exclusively.

I guarantee i've read far far more Canon than you, I think I'm aware of what I'm talking about lol.
 
No I don't, that's why I haven't to begin with, I'm merely questioning your reasoning exclusively.

I guarantee i've read far far more Canon than you, I think I'm aware of what I'm talking about lol.
I know my way around Kylo. I just prefer to not talk about him because the sequel trilogy was two thirds dogshit. Vader's scaling is blatantly better, unless you want to show me Kylo crushing a man's brain?
 
I guarantee i've read far far more Canon than you, I think I'm aware of what I'm talking about lol.
Just for your sake I'm gonna give you some advice, don't ever make an argument like this for anything ever as it makes you sound way more whiny than is intended and like you're trying to gate keep. Not saying that's what you're doing but this phrasing is never a good way to go about arguments.
 
I know my way around Kylo. I just prefer to not talk about him because the sequel trilogy was two thirds dogshit. Vader's scaling is blatantly better, unless you want to show me Kylo crushing a man's brain?
Can agree on sequels being beyond dogshit, but whether or not he has crushed someone's brain is situational and shouldn't be indicative of actual power, kylo has direct scaling over vader whether you like it or not.
 
Just for your sake I'm gonna give you some advice, don't ever make an argument like this for anything ever as it makes you sound way more whiny than is intended and like you're trying to gate keep. Not saying that's what you're doing but this phrasing is never a good way to go about arguments.
It's a whiny response to a whiny response, why am I the perpetrator?
 
Can agree on sequels being beyond dogshit, but whether or not he has crushed someone's brain is situational and shouldn't be indicative of actual power, kylo has direct scaling over vader whether you like it or not.
Enjoy those half a dozen anti-feats a movie, pal...
 
As awesome as Tarre is lore wise, does he really need a profile when we have no idea how he fights?
I think it's cool, and from what i got from multiple mods, the wiki is more for categorization sake than for vs matches

So we can have him just because he's awesome and, if needed, we just warn that (un-f***ing-fortunately) we don't know his fighting style

weird. I never needed to get an okay before I add imgs to my sandboxs. unless I'm misreading
its a small misread of yours, yeah
i don't put images because when i try it is dogshit, and i asked (and was given an ok) that i can propose an imageless profile on a CRT and ask someone to do this for me if it gets accepted
 
Ah, also if someone see this as useful to know:
Some stuff (work, gaming and few profiles) are in front of it, but i intend on reforming Yoda's canon profile soon. I'd do it for Grievous too, to get my 3 favorite canon characters, but @Ms.Luzifer has already done a great job :>
 
YESSS, THE THREAD FINALLY FINSIHED

Ah, also if someone see this as useful to know:
Some stuff (work, gaming and few profiles) are in front of it, but i intend on reforming Yoda's canon profile soon. I'd do it for Grievous too, to get my 3 favorite canon characters, but @Ms.Luzifer has already done a great job :>
Grievous is love, Grievous is life
 
Ah, also if someone see this as useful to know:
Some stuff (work, gaming and few profiles) are in front of it, but i intend on reforming Yoda's canon profile soon. I'd do it for Grievous too, to get my 3 favorite canon characters, but @Ms.Luzifer has already done a great job :>
Rework Obi-Wan too lol
 
didn't y'all mention a matchup in the Vader vs Toji thread that included Grievous, but y'all waited for the rework to apply?

who the dude
 
Rework Obi-Wan too lol

negotiator-star-wars.gif



Would be lovely but will take a while before i take on it cuz i for sure will have a f*** ton of material to read for the Yoda one
 
n a matchup in the Vader vs Toji thread that included Grievous, but y'all waited for the rework to apply?
what in the actual f***?
i want to read whatever this is and take whichever drugs someone needed to reach this matchup
 
what in the actual f***?
i want to read whatever this is and take whichever drugs someone needed to reach this matchup
 
didn't y'all mention a matchup in the Vader vs Toji thread that included Grievous, but y'all waited for the rework to apply?

who the dude

Okay, now I remember.
it was Grievous vs Toji....
hmmm should I restrict the Clankers in this matchup since they're now optional equipment?
 
unfortunately no Grievous here until where i read :<

Jokes aside, this can't be fair because how would Toji react to the new Lightsaber temperature, for example?
 
Okay, now I remember.
it was Grievous vs Toji....
hmmm should I restrict the Clankers in this matchup since they're now optional equipment?
Do not put poor Toji against Grievous, skillwise they do not compare in the slightest.
 
Do not put poor Toji against Grievous, skillwise they do not compare in the slightest.
Do it
Okay, now I remember.
it was Grievous vs Toji....
hmmm should I restrict the Clankers in this matchup since they're now optional equipment?
They've always been optional equipment. IG-100 MagnaGuards should be upgraded to 8-A though.
 
Back
Top