• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Arifureta: Black Hole Creation (✔)

Messages
3,570
Reaction score
1,534
The purpose of this thread is to prove that black holes create through GM are real.

Gravity Magic:
WN
Furthermore, gravity magic was something that should be expressed as ‘magic that interfere with the energy of star’, not only gravity, theoretically, it could also interfere with things like earth vein or terrestrial heat, bedrock or magma, it wasn’t impossible to use this magic to purposefully generate earthquake or volcano eruption.
LN
Furthermore, gravity magic was magic that manipulated the planet’s energy. In other words, those who knew it could interfere with a planet’s magnetic field or utilize geothermal energy like magma. It could be used to cause earthquakes or volcanic eruptions as well.
Fandom
Gravity Magic (重じゅう力りょく魔法まほう, Jūryoku Mahō?) grants the user control over gravity. The true power of this magic is the ability to manipulate the planet's energy. It can interfere with a planet's magnetic field or utilize geothermal energy like magma. It can be used to cause earthquakes or volcanic eruptions as well.

GM users:
“In my home world, humanity mastered exceptionally powerful magic. We had researched how to bring the stars under our dominion and channel the natural forces of the world. That should give you an idea of how advanced our civilization was.” Vol 13 p158
and
“The Enlightened was the name for the individuals who understood the true nature of the ancient magic everyone had learned to use. We few escaped the destruction of our star by traveling to a different world." Vol 13 p 162
Here star could be a mistranslation of planet.
Miledi spells

  • Miledi spells:
    • Star of Calamity: An ability which creates a black whirling sphere that swallows anything and everything in the surroundings, pulverizing them from the inside.
    • Obsidian Vortex: The most basic of gravity spells, which allows the caster to create a localized gravitational field and adjust their weight.
    • Spatial Severance: An ability which creates a black hole that absorbs all spells used against her, regardless of their element.
    • Heavensfall: An ability which creates countless tiny black spheres that increase the gravity of whatever Miledi chooses.
    • Inverse Square: An ability which reverses the gravitational pull of anyone she targets.
    • Nether Burst: An ability which traps her targets in a gravity field, which crushes whatever is in it.
    • Onyx Blast: Gravity magic which fires a tiny cannonball of compressed gravity.
    • Whirling Sapphire: A powerful sphere of gravity-compressed fire magic which she shots towards her targets. It explodes with the force of a small sun, creating a huge shockwave.
    • Asura: A spell that creates a wide-area gravity field. With this ability she can envelop the entire island of Andika, and stop it from sinking to the depths of the ocean.
    • Event Horizon: A pseudo-black hole that has enough pressure at its center to crush anything.

    • Black Hole Nova: creates the closest thing to a true singularity, as it pulled an entire alternate dimension into it, and is basically a last-resort, self-sacrificing move.
This was one of her gravity spells, Spatial Severance. She’d created a black hole that absorbed all spells, regardless of their element. Even the knights’ Celestial Flashes couldn’t escape the dark star’s singularity.
celestial flash is a light based spell(Kouki's profile)
Celestial Flash: An attack which emits an intense light from his sword and with a slash is released from the sword, drawing a curve, and bisecting the target in its path.

Don't know if this is helpful, but Mana is a fundamental particle
「If I remember it right, magic power, blessing power, and even the sky dragon power in Grasp Gloria, all will lead to the element (origin) if you follow them back to their root. That was what you said right?」

「That’s right. The sacred tree and great tree――let’s just call of them the world tree. This thing is most likely a natural conversion system.」

The energies that were flowing in each of their respective world were like elementary particle at physics. It seemed they were made from very small grains that were smaller than each of them.

That was “element”. It was the smallest material that became the base of any kind of energy.

And then, the world trees that existed at each world were absorbing those elements from somewhere and converted them into energy that suited each world they were in and released them out. That was Hajime’s theory. Ch 481
――Ultimate gravity magic Black Sky Destitution

Its size was unprecedented. Four of them were formed simultaneously at the east, west, north, and south of the Heaven Tree.

Anything that was in their range, whether the surrounding apparitions in the sky, or the apparitions on the ground 「Even though we’re kneeling!?」, even the divine class got mercilessly sucked in.

The unrivaled suction power that was impossible to escape from devoured the apparitions greedily. Such sight was like a nightmare.

“Black Sky Destitution” was different from the similar gravity magic “Severance Calamity”. It wasn’t a magic to reduce the target into dust using gravitational pressure. It was an annihilation magic. Ch 417
――OoOOOOOOOOOOOO-

As expected from divine beings. The dragon gods endured even after getting swallowed into the “Black Sky Destitutions”. They all roared and unbelievably tore through the ultimate magic from the inside.

From the start they were able to make their large bodies flew in the sky. Naturally they at least had the authority to interfere with gravity.

In addition, right after all the “Black Sky Destitutions” vanished, the dragon gods also vanished from view. Right after that, they appeared once more above Yue. It seemed they could also interfere with space. Ch 417
5 meters in diameter:
「Here it is created, the star of disaster that swallow all creation――”KokutenkyuuBlack Sky Destitution”-!!」

The star of disaster was enlarged explosively. It was the secret technique of gravity magic to annihilate everything by swallowing them, the trump card of lord.

「Kyaah!?」

『Impossible-!?』

A scream broke out from Hinata while agitation surged from the elderly nobleman.

It couldn’t be helped. The earth was getting sucked up with violent momentum. The sparking black sphere with diameter of five meter was swallowing them up.

The earth was getting sucked up toward the sky as though gravity didn’t exist. That sight was just like a joke. It was as though heaven and earth had been overturned. Ch 410

――Coolness depth Level VI

What it brought about was clones in number that increased by one digit. The total number was ten thousand. The amount of lord could be mistaken as a new dark cloud as they rushed through the sky.

And then,

「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」「Kokutenkyuu!!」

The sky was completely covered by the secret technique black hole.

「NOwaaah――――!?」

「Etemp-saa―――n!?」

「Retreat retreaat! We’re going back to the grounddd」

Etemp almost got sucked in before Shia caught her midway. They retreated from the sky together with Kaori. Even the divine spirits were retreating from the battlefield in panic. Rune and Cino also almost turned into lost fairies before Enti protected them while yelling 「Stupidddd! Give a warning at least before you do something like thattt!」 in anger. Ch 424
The black asterism of destruction. They were sparking as they slowly rotated at the sky, swallowing the “shadow” further to the center. The scene looked like a black galaxy. Ch 424
Could black holes merge?
“Kokutenkyuu” that numbered like the stars in the sky due to ten thousand of lords gathered at the center. They all fused and formed a gigantic star of disaster.

The cleansing pure white light covered the whole Japan. The light also flowed from the foot of the mountain to the peak, making the sacred mountain “Fuji” to shine.

「Sleep for ten thousand years more!!」

『Lend the eight ears of Saoshika to all the gods, asking them to listen and eat!!』

The lord extended one hand toward the gigantic “Kokutenkyuu”. He spread open his five fingers――and closed them in a crushing gesture.

The star shrunk right away. The “Dragon’s shadow” was completely annihilated without even any death throes. Ch 424
Here, here and here
BH planetary feat?
The Holy princinct is a pocket reality created by Ehit and consist of multiple dimensions.

1)These dimensions are separated:
When he reached the end of the corridor, Hajime touched the multicolored wall that seemed to be the end of this space. Ripples spread outward from the spot that he touched, and his hand slid into the colored wall. It looked like that spot did connect to somewhere else. And judging by his compass, their distance to Yue was the same on either side of the barrier. Vol 12 p45

2)Separate timeflow?
Unfortunately, the compass wasn’t able to give Hajime a clear picture of what was on the other side. In fact, it almost felt like wherever it was connected to was changing in real time, which was why he’d thrown a space-warping grenade over just in case. It was a new type of grenade that twisted the space around it into a whirlpool and crushed anything caught in it. It was extremely lethal while also being perfectly silent. Vol 12 p45

3)Space or borders between dimensions ?
The transition between places was dizzying. A kaleidoscope of colors assailed the group from all sides, making them feel drunk. There was also a disgusting sensation of something slippery brushing against their skin. Fortunately, the whole experience lasted only a few seconds. Vol 12 p46
A second later, the flesh beast’s tentacles shot out toward the two of them. Their ends were tapered and sharp enough to pierce through flesh. Yue pulled away from Hajime’s neck and stuck her hand outtoward the tentacles. The space in front of her warped, tearing open a hole to another dimension. The tentacles passed through the hole and were immediately destroyed.

Yue had opened a portal to another disintegrating section of the Sanctuary and let thembe destroyed along with it. Normally, that would have taken a lot of mana, but as the Sanctuary was falling apart, the borders between dimensions were quite thin and she was able to do it efficiently. Vol 13 p225

4)These dimensions differ in size:
“This is the fourth zone we have passed through. Is Ehit toying with us?” Tio asked with a frown.

“He might be. This is his domain, after all. He probably gets to choose where we get transported.”

After passing through the portal atop the clock tower, Hajime and the others had passed through three other zones. The first had been a dimension where the ground and the sky were flipped, and gravity was inconsistent. The objects inside that dimension had seemed to fall in all different directions. The second zone had been a museum of sorts. It had been an underground labyrinth with busts and statues at every corner. The statues were of humans, demons, beastmen, dwarves, and giants, as well as monsters and creatures Hajime had never seen before. The third zone had been a library. There was no sky or ground to speak of, just an endless expanse of white filled with bookshelves. The books were seemingly written in every language under the sun and bound in all sorts of unique ways.

“Is that why all the enemies we ran into were super annoying? Because he’s messing with us?” Shea asked, clapping her hands together in realization.

In the upside-down world, they’d been assailed by a flock of pyramid-shaped inorganic automatons that had been made of some unknown material. They’d been able to control gravity and had moved in a tight formation like fighterplanes. Though in the end, Hajime had blown them all to bits with his Agni Orkans. In the museum world, they’d been attacked by the statues, as everyone had been expecting. Hajime had blown them all to bits too with his Agni Orkans. In the library, the books had cast magic at the party and summoned monsters. And so, Hajime had carried out the biggest book burning in history with his Agni Orkans. Vol 12 p162
There is other dimensions:
The sea of clouds had finally parted, and as it dissipated, the area below it finally became visible. However, the sky below was distorted, as if everyone was looking at it through a fish-eye lens. And far below that distorted space was a familiar sight. Suzu and the others could see a fortress sitting in the middle of a flat plain...with thousands upon thousands of people fighting against an army of apostles. But then, the distortion suddenly vanished, and other distortions appeared elsewhere in the sky in multiple places. They showed the dimensions Shea and the others had passed through, as well as other areas they didn’t recognize.

The ominous rumbling grew stronger, and the distortions that connected to other dimensions started appearing and disappearing more quickly and more frequently than ever. Vol 12 p283
The distortion connect them to other dimensions and to the ouside world.

5)Ehit throne room(the center):
With Shea’s and Tio’s words of encouragement ringing in his ears, Hajime allowed the pillar of white light to whisk him away. He sped through a kaleidoscope of rainbow-patterned space, then arrived in a world of pure white. It was impossible to tell how far it stretched. He couldn’t see any walls or ceiling or even the ground. Everything everywhere was white, and though he could feel his feet touching something when he looked down, it looked no different from anything else.

If this was Ehit’s throne room, it was a fitting one indeed.

“Welcome to the heart of my Sanctuary." Vol 13 p139
Ehit could adjust its size:
As soon as he reached Hajime’s height, the altar below began to get farther away. It was as if the two of them had suddenly shot up much higher into the air. In truth, though, it was the ground that had gotten farther away, for Ehitruje had expanded the amount of space in this dimension. Vol 13 p142

6)Void:
Shea and the other glanced around, instantly wary. They could see cracks forming in the sky, and it looked like the entire dimension was starting to fall apart. Furthermore the islands that had been damaged in the fight were unable to withstand the dimensional earthquake and started crumbling.

Shea and the others hurriedly took out their Skyboard and rose into the air.

Looking down, Suzu exclaimed, "I-Is that...the ground?!"

The sea of clouds had finally parted, and a it dissipated, the area below it finally became visible. However, the sky below was distorted, as if everyone was looking at it through a fish-eye lens. And far below that distorted space was a familiar sight. Suzu and the others could see a fortress sitting in the middle of a flat plain...with thousands upon thousands of people fighting against an army of apostles. But then, the distortion suddenly vanished, and other distortions appeared elsewhere in the sky in multiple places. They showed dimensions Shea and the others had passed through, as well as other area they didn't recognize.

The ominous rumbling grew stronger, and the distortions that connected to other dimensions started appearing and disappearing more quickly and more frequently than ever.

"I bet this is Hajime-san's doing. He must have started fighting Ehit!"

"Indeed. This Sanctuary is a creation of Ehit's, so it stands to reason that he had the most influence over this space. If it has become this unstable, then it's quite likely that Ehit is being driven into a corner."

Of course, Tio had no proof to back up her conjecture. This dimension might have been simply dissolving because Ehit had begun enacting the final stage of his plan to destroy this world. However, no one thought that was the case for even a moment. Everyone smiled, certain that Shea and Tio were right.

"We better hurry, then, or we'll miss the whole fight," Shizuku replied.

"Yeah! Let's get out of here and meet up with Nagumo-Kun" Suzu said with a nod, and everyone started heading toward the obelisk. The island it had been on had crumbled away, so now it was simply a pure-white pillar floating in the air.

Shea was still a little woozy, so she needed to lean on Shizuku's shoulder and ride on her skyboard but she nevertheless reached out to touch the obilisk without hesitation.

"Hm?"

However, nothing happened when Shea touched the obelisk. When Hajime had last checked his compass, it definitely been pointing to this obelisk, and the portals that Shea and the others had gone through on their way here hadn't required any special activation rules.

Puzzled, Shea touched the obelisk again. Shizuku, Suzu, Tio, Ryutarou, and Kouki all tried as well, but again nothing happened.

"Why?!" Shea shouted, slapping the obelisk over and over.

"It may have something to do with why this dimension has become so unstable. There are more obelisk on the other islands. Let us see if an of them still work," Tio said, though she had a bad feeling they might be trapped here. Still, they all split up to try the other obelisks in the distance.

Unfortunately, none of the activated. And to make matters worse, the cracks in the sky were getting so big that they were breaking apart pieces of the sky...and there was nothing but darkness beyond those shattered segments. If you stared at them long enough, they looked like nothing more than black walls, but as test, Shizuku tried throwing a pebble at one of them.

"Looks like anything that goes in disintegrates," Shizuku said. The stone had turn to dust and vanished as soon as it had hit the blackness.

"This doesn't look too good..."

"I doubt we're somehow special and won't get obliterated if we try to enter..."

"What about the obelisk we used to get in here?" Suzu suggested, and everyone hurriedly headed back there.

Right now, they were more worried about their immediate survival than catching up to Hajime. Even if backtracking lost them time, escaping this dimension was their top priority.

while they hurried back to their starting obelisk, the dimension's destruction started accelerating. It was like a cage slowly constricting around them. Floating islands were swallowed up and destroyed one after the other. The group had to take several detours when the space right in front of the cracked and shattered, exposing only blackness, but eventually, they made it to the obelisk that led back to the abandoned ruins. But unfortunately, that one didn't activate either.

"Oh no...we can't even go back..." Kouki said in a voice tinged with despair. A distortion near the obelisk showed Shea and the others the abandoned ruins they'd come from. It seemed that dimension was also falling apart. It wasn't just here, then. No the entirety of the Sanctuary was crumbling. Vol 12 p283
「So this is something like Noah’s ark huh.」

In the first place they were the people of god. Their magic technology was astounding. The research that they carried out with mad desperation while the danger of destruction was approaching showed astonishing great strides.

A colony of treasure warehouse with miniscule size of grains of sand that numbered in the tens of thousands.

The other dimension that each grain possessed was unified internally to create this vast isolated space.

Even if half of their number was destroyed, there would be no effect to the contained world. At the inside, it was possible to create anything that one wished for by transmuting every kind of mineral particles that were stored inside.

Generation of air and soil, propagation of plants and animals, the technology to preserve them for eternity with time stasis.

The function of reading the information from outside and storing it.

Ability of autonomic movement, camouflage ability by interfering with wind and heat and light, ability to turn into mirage.

And then,

「The function to control all functions and protect the lives inside, me──Eto Shin(Eternal Protector)」Eternal Artifact Ch 3
It was unknown how long they stayed like that. The one who broke the silence first was Eto Shin.

「……I had continued to think within a slowed flow of time.

「About what?」

「Why didn’t the people wish to continue to live. Why, wasn’t I unable to make the people wish to continue to live.」Eternal Artifact Ch 4
Just wanted to mention that Miledi was slowing the destruction of the Holy Princinct or atleast one of its dimensions.
“Oh, umm...come on, guys, why’re you getting all sappy on me?! I can’t even think of what to say! Anyway, get out of here. I really can’t hold this place together for much longer!” Vol 13 p 239

Miledi smiled to herself, and a second later, her sky-blue mana flared out. Cracks appeared in her golem’s smiley-faced mask and her metal body started fading away from the edges, as if it was disintegrating.

Sparks ran down the body of the golem that had been made with all the knowledge and abilities at the seven greatest Liberators’ disposal, and a giant black sphere appeared above it. Just then, Miledi felt as though she sensed another person’s presence, so she looked up. Vol 13 p240

The swelling black sphere started swallowing everything up. The white room, all of the dimensions it was linked to, the cracks and holes that opened up into empty voids, all of it. It was like a true black hole.

Miledi’s golem was destroyed along with everything else, but her soul glowed brilliantly for one last moment, and she shouted with all her might the words that finally signaled the end of her long, solitary journey.

“I’m back, guys!”

A second later, the Sanctuary and everything in it vanished without a trace.

The dark crimson pall that had hung over all of Tortus inverted itself and started to fall apart. The air creaked and groaned as cracks spread beyond the layer of crimson and started extending up, down, left, right, and in all other directions. It wasn’t just the crimson pall that was falling apart, it seemed, but the entire world. Vol 13 p240

A second later, the mana was sucked back into the Sanctuary, presumably converging on the point where Hajime and Yue were. Then, a pitiful scream echoed throughout the entire world, and though it wasn’t ear-splittingly loud or anything, everyone all across Tortus definitely heard it. And at the same time, a streak of platinum light with dark black miasma swirling inside it rose out of the Sanctuary.

In that moment, everyone was absolutely certain that the light was the lifeblood of a god, spilling out from him. The platinum light dispersed into nothing, and silence returned to the world.

A few seconds later, the destruction of the world stopped spreading and instead turned back inward toward the center of the Sanctuary. It was almost as if it was being sucked in by a powerful black hole.

Once all the cracks were gone from the world, the Sanctuary vanished. Its destruction wasn’t accompanied by an explosion or a shock wave, but instead just silence and a brief ripple of light made up of seven distinct colors.

The bright golden yellow of noon, sunset orange, moonlight silver, verdant green, earthy brown, the obsidian of a night sky, and finally, an all-encompassing tinge of sky blue. As that seven-colored light spread outward, it erased the crimson pall that had settled over the world, returning proper color to the sky.

It was a beautiful spectacle. Vol 13 p247

Summary of what GM users could create:
  1. Singularity that light and other fundamental particles like mana can't escape.
  2. BH that warp space-time.
  3. BH that expel a form of radiation(mana?).
  4. BH that could absorb world ending destruction.
Calculation (5-A): (credits to Digital_Franz)

Agree: @Lloydblitzed ,@LoudestProcedure ,@ActuallySpaceMan42 ,@DarkDragonMedeus ,@Elizhaa ,@Mr. Bambu(calc accepted) ,@FinePoint ,@Noneless21(besides Kousuke) ,@LuffyRuffy46307

Disagree:

Neutral:
 
Last edited:
In case black holes bending space-time, pocket dimensions are space-time

Eto Shin:
「So this is something like Noah’s ark huh.」

In the first place they were the people of god. Their magic technology was astounding. The research that they carried out with mad desperation while the danger of destruction was approaching showed astonishing great strides.

A colony of treasure warehouse with miniscule size of grains of sand that numbered in the tens of thousands.

The other dimension that each grain possessed was unified internally to create this vast isolated space.

Even if half of their number was destroyed, there would be no effect to the contained world. At the inside, it was possible to create anything that one wished for by transmuting every kind of mineral particles that were stored inside.

Generation of air and soil, propagation of plants and animals, the technology to preserve them for eternity with time stasis.

The function of reading the information from outside and storing it.

Ability of autonomic movement, camouflage ability by interfering with wind and heat and light, ability to turn into mirage.

And then,

「The function to control all functions and protect the lives inside, me──Eto Shin(Eternal Protector)」Eternal Artifact Ch 3

Eto Shin had the function to trace back the past of person, object, and land and read their memory. It was one of its functions to gather information from outside, because it was also shouldering the role as the kingdom’s library by recording and preserving every information. Eternal Artifact Ch 3

It was unknown how long they stayed like that. The one who broke the silence first was Eto Shin.

「……I had continued to think within a slowed flow of time.

「About what?」

「Why didn’t the people wish to continue to live. Why, wasn’t I unable to make the people wish to continue to live.」Eternal Artifact Ch 4
 
Well you would need to get the 5-A thing evaluated by a CGM, but I think its fine considering its described as a "true singularity"
 
@Mr. Bambu

Would you mind helping this poor soul.
I would mind terribly, my wiki time is diminished. But fine. I'll try. I have a lot of other notifications to go through and potentially deal with, but I'll keep the tab open so it can haunt me until I evaluate it.
 
Thanks, but your post is just about follwing the thread. No?
The math is fine. I don't think they're black holes in earnest. The phrasing of a few points of it suggest they produce similar effects but aren't black holes, and the reason black holes yield the values they do is not because they have a pull, but rather because they are extremely condensed mass. The effects produced here seem to just be like. Something that looks like a black hole and sucks things in. That's my take on it.
 
The math is fine. I don't think they're black holes in earnest. The phrasing of a few points of it suggest they produce similar effects but aren't black holes, and the reason black holes yield the values they do is not because they have a pull, but rather because they are extremely condensed mass. The effects produced here seem to just be like. Something that looks like a black hole and sucks things in. That's my take on it.
There is more to them than just having a pull.


1)The logic behind them is Gravity Magic, which manipulate the forces of the planet(or star). These forces include but not limited to gravity, magnet, and vectors.

Gravity magic was discovered by an advanced civilization after reaching the truths/principles of the universe. This civilization was capable of "bringing the stars under their domain"
“In my home world, humanity mastered exceptionally powerful magic. We had researched how to bring the stars under our dominion and channel the natural forces of the world. That should give you an idea of how advanced our civilization was.” Vol 13 p158
And I think "natural forces" is refering to the four fundamental forces. So yeah they manipulate the laws of physics.

2)Gravity Magic users could create singularities that light and other particles can't escape.

3)These BH could warp/absrob/destroy pocket realities(space-time)

4)These BH expel some sort of radiation, but that was a one time thing.

5)These BH condense and erase everything even space.
――Ultimate gravity magic Black Sky Destitution

Its size was unprecedented. Four of them were formed simultaneously at the east, west, north, and south of the Heaven Tree.

Anything that was in their range, whether the surrounding apparitions in the sky, or the apparitions on the ground 「Even though we’re kneeling!?」, even the divine class got mercilessly sucked in.

The unrivaled suction power that was impossible to escape from devoured the apparitions greedily. Such sight was like a nightmare.

“Black Sky Destitution” was different from the similar gravity magic “Severance Calamity”. It wasn’t a magic to reduce the target into dust using gravitational pressure. It was an annihilation magic. Ch 417
6)These BH could absrob a planetary explosion.

7)It was called star on multiple occasions.
 
Whether a 'real' black hole or not, they pretty explicitly say they it acts just like one, so I think it's kind of moot.

Therefore, I agree.
 
Last edited:
But if it erase space and anything it suck into, there shouldnt be any mass to be converted to ap, isn't that kinda moot too
 
That's a pretty good point.
Don't BH compress space? Or atleast are a consequence of it?

(Asked Google)
The process of forming a black hole involves the ultimate compression of matter, which in turn leads to an ultimate compression and distortion of space itself, creating the conditions for a black hole to exist.
 
Last edited:
If it's erasing the matter then there's technically no mass which means nothing can be calculated.
If anything that's worse than it erasing 'space' since that would be at least abstract enough to ignore probably.
Let's clarify something, by "erasure" I meant this:

1)It's called the ultimate annihilation
――Ultimate gravity magic Black Sky Destitution

Its size was unprecedented. Four of them were formed simultaneously at the east, west, north, and south of the Heaven Tree.

Anything that was in their range, whether the surrounding apparitions in the sky, or the apparitions on the ground 「Even though we’re kneeling!?」, even the divine class got mercilessly sucked in.

The unrivaled suction power that was impossible to escape from devoured the apparitions greedily. Such sight was like a nightmare.

“Black Sky Destitution” was different from the similar gravity magic “Severance Calamity”. It wasn’t a magic to reduce the target into dust using gravitational pressure. It was an annihilation magic. Ch 417

2)Whatever is absorbed can't escape

Don't know how we gonna interpret this, but there is nothing about the black hole lacking mass and there is also the fact that it's so heavy it warp space and light can't escape.

So just matter Annihilation(destruction/obliteration)≠Erasure, and no matter expulsion. Which is a form of erasure, right?

In case you disagree with it there is two types of BH in the verse, one that compress to the limit and one that annihilate.(we could you use either)
 
Let's clarify something, by "erasure" I meant this:

1)It's called the ultimate annihilation


2)Whatever is absorbed can't escape

Don't know how we gonna interpret this, but there is nothing about the black hole lacking mass and there is also the fact that it's so heavy it warp space and light can't escape.

So just matter Annihilation(destruction/obliteration)≠Erasure, and no matter expulsion. Which is a form of erasure, right?

In case you disagree with it there is two types of BH in the verse, one that compress to the limit and one that annihilate.(we could you use either)
your argument stems from the black sky destitution, which explicitly says it erase anything it sucks into, you even said it's a form of erasure smh

and just you know, the only thing that was close to true black hole is the exact Black Sky Destitution that erases anything it sucked into, anything else and the argument falls apart
 
Yes, and I admit that it was a mistake(Annhililation≠erasure)

I called it erasure because it swallow objects, annhililate/obliterate matter with gravity and doesn't spit them back(Like a real BH). And that's it no actual statment of erasure.

Could you post the scan for matter erasure? other than me calling it erasure

And No, there is other examples of BH like Spatial Severance
This was one of her gravity spells, Spatial Severance. She’d created a black hole that absorbed all spells, regardless of their element. Even the knights’ Celestial Flashes couldn’t escape the dark star’s singularity.
 
Last edited:
Yes, and I admit that it was a mistake(Annhililation≠erasure)

I called it erasure because it swallow objects, annhililate/obliterate matter with gravity and doesn't spit them back(Like a real BH). And that's it no actual statment of erasure.

Could you post the scan for matter erasure? other than me calling it erasure

And No, there is other examples of BH like Spatial Severance
Then, why you put in the fact that the some of the black hole can destroy space time? It's literally there at the OP
Summary of what GM users could create:

Singularity that light and other fundamental particles like mana can't escape.
BH that absorb/destroy space-time.
BH that expel a form of radiation(mana?).
BH that could absorb enough energy to destroy the world.
It just create inconsistencies where black hole sucks in something they shouldn't have and all of the sudden they aren't count as real black hole anymore

Also, that's another gripe that I was gonna talk about, do you have any proof that celestial flash count as real light then?

Also also

2)Whatever is absorbed can't escape
I do not see anything that says anything it sucked into can't escape or anything similar, again, if you really think this scan talks about how the highest level magic of Black Hole makes it as if anything it sucks into can't escape anymore, I'd appreciate that you highlight it
 
Then, why you put in the fact that the some of the black hole can destroy space time? It's literally there at the OP

It just create inconsistencies where black hole sucks in something they shouldn't have and all of the sudden they aren't count as real black hole anymore
I'll edit the OP later, but let's make it clear all you have is my statments of matter and spatial erasure. Which is admittedly a mistake on my part.

I admit that some of what I said was wrong and you're still using it as an antifeat.
Also, that's another gripe that I was gonna talk about, do you have any proof that celestial flash count as real light then?
Is Tio breath a real fire? Is ice magic real ice?

Could you provide an evidence for it being otherwise?
I do not see anything that says anything it sucked into can't escape or anything similar, again, if you really think this scan talks about how the highest level magic of Black Hole makes it as if anything it sucks into can't escape anymore, I'd appreciate that you highlight it
Here is the text
──Ultimate gravity magic “Black Sky Devastation”

It was a magic that brought about absolute crushing pressure and annihilation. Even a cheat level magician like Yue was still unable to grasp it completely.

Unlike “Severance Disaster”, that magic wouldn’t spit out anything that it absorbed anymore. It completely annihilated the target. And right now it was falling. Blu-ray SS Eternal Artifact Ch4

Could you post the scan for matter erasure? other than me calling it erasure
Still waiting
 
Is Tio breath a real fire? Is ice magic real ice?

Could you provide an evidence for it being otherwise?
Well
Typically, lasers and other light-based attacks are only accepted to really move at the speed of light if they meet, at a minimum, a few of these criteria:The beam behaves in a reasonably realistic way, such as reflecting off non-magical mirrors or refracting and diffusing through liquids and materials.
  • The beam is stated to move at the speed of light by reliable sources.
  • The beam is stated to be composed/consisting of photons or light itself, again by reliable sources.
  • The beam originates from a real source of light, such as the Sun or the flash of a camera.
    • Note that a beam does not automatically qualify for this requirement just by originating from a technological source.
Does Celestial Flash checks at least one of the requirements of this criteria? (it was from this page) If not then I find them iffy to count them as real light.

furthermore, from the very same page:
Furthermore, there are a few criteria which show that a beam is not behaving like realistic light:
  • The beam is shown to move at different speeds in the same material.
  • The beam curves through the air or otherwise doesn't travel in straight lines (with the exception of realistic refraction or deflection).
  • The beam primarily deals damage by means other than heating materials that absorb it.
    • A laser may cause explosions, but only if it rapidly vaporizes some matter, meaning that the target needs to be partially destroyed in the process.
  • The beam is tangible and can be interacted with physically by normal humans, as if it was a solid, liquid or gas. It shouldn't disperse when being hit as a substance would, and should not be redirectable without using a mechanism like refraction.
    • While a laser can in theory push things, through radiation pressure or by causing explosions when vaporizing part of an object, those are niche circumstances and generally a laser should not primarily push things away like a physical projectile would.
So yes, I am asking, does Celestial Flash count as actual light? Not just magical attacks that spew out light? Because this
Celestial Flash: An attack which emits an intense light from his sword and with a slash is released from the sword, drawing a curve, and bisecting the target in its path.
This does not explained if this attack is real light or not, so please elaborate
Still waiting
It's from the same scan that you posted
A second later, the mana was sucked back into the Sanctuary, presumably converging on the point where Hajime and Yue were. Then, a pitiful scream echoed throughout the entire world, and though it wasn’t ear-splittingly loud or anything, everyone all across Tortus definitely heard it. And at the same time, a streak of platinum light with dark black miasma swirling inside it rose out of the Sanctuary.

In that moment, everyone was absolutely certain that the light was the lifeblood of a god, spilling out from him. The platinum light dispersed into nothing, and silence returned to the world.

A few seconds later, the destruction of the world stopped spreading and instead turned back inward toward the center of the Sanctuary. It was almost as if it was being sucked in by a powerful black hole.

Once all the cracks were gone from the world, the Sanctuary vanished. Its destruction wasn’t accompanied by an explosion or a shock wave, but instead just silence and a brief ripple of light made up of seven distinct colors.

The bright golden yellow of noon, sunset orange, moonlight silver, verdant green, earthy brown, the obsidian of a night sky, and finally, an all-encompassing tinge of sky blue. As that seven-colored light spread outward, it erased the crimson pall that had settled over the world, returning proper color to the sky.

It was a beautiful spectacle. Vol 13 p247
The second part where Miledi uses her Black hole and destroyed the Sanctuary, this also erases the space, but given that the Sanctuary was collapsing, I dont know if this is viable so you can refute this if you wanted to. But given that she might also erases the whole Holy Precinct, so with my assumption, this black hole erases spaces

Edit: Actually, now that I think about it
Don't know how we gonna interpret this, but there is nothing about the black hole lacking mass and there is also the fact that it's so heavy it warp space and light can't escape.
Do you have a scan that explicitly said that the black hole someone created became so heavy it distorted space and light?
 
Last edited:
Well

Does Celestial Flash checks at least one of the requirements of this criteria? (it was from this page) If not then I find them iffy to count them as real light.

furthermore, from the very same page:

So yes, I am asking, does Celestial Flash count as actual light? Not just magical attacks that spew out light? Because this

This does not explained if this attack is real light or not, so please elaborate
You haven't provide any antifeat for it. Make a CRT yourself and stop derailing the thread.
It's from the same scan that you posted


The second part where Miledi uses her Black hole and destroyed the Sanctuary, this also erases the space, but given that the Sanctuary was collapsing, I dont know if this is viable so you can refute this if you wanted to. But given that she might also erases the whole Holy Precinct, so with my assumption, this black hole erases spaces
Where does it says "erase space"?

After Ehit death, a the holy sanctuary became unstable which caused a void("black wall") to appear an it started erasing those dimensions.
"It may have something to do with why this dimension has become so unstable. There are more obelisk on the other islands. Let us see if an of them still work," Tio said, though she had a bad feeling they might be trapped here. Still, they all split up to try the other obelisks in the distance.

Unfortunately, none of the activated. And to make matters worse, the cracks in the sky were getting so big that they were breaking apart pieces of the sky...and there was nothing but darkness beyond those shattered segments. If you stared at them long enough, they looked like nothing more than black walls, but as test, Shizuku tried throwing a pebble at one of them.

"Looks like anything that goes in disintegrates," Shizuku said. The stone had turn to dust and vanished as soon as it had hit the blackness.

"This doesn't look too good..."

"I doubt we're somehow special and won't get obliterated if we try to enter..."

"What about the obelisk we used to get in here?" Suzu suggested, and everyone hurriedly headed back there.

Right now, they were more worried about their immediate survival than catching up to Hajime. Even if backtracking lost them time, escaping this dimension was their top priority.

while they hurried back to their starting obelisk, the dimension's destruction started accelerating. It was like a cage slowly constricting around them. Floating islands were swallowed up and destroyed one after the other. The group had to take several detours when the space right in front of the cracked and shattered, exposing only blackness, but eventually, they made it to the obelisk that led back to the abandoned ruins. But unfortunately, that one didn't activate either.

"Oh no...we can't even go back..." Kouki said in a voice tinged with despair. A distortion near the obelisk showed Shea and the others the abandoned ruins they'd come from. It seemed that dimension was also falling apart. It wasn't just here, then. No the entirety of the Sanctuary was crumbling. Vol 12 p283
Edit: Actually, now that I think about it


Do you have a scan that explicitly said that the black hole someone created became so heavy it distorted space and light?
Read the OP, I'm not repeating myself


Could you post the scan for matter and spatial erasure? other than me calling it erasure
Still waiting
 
So after finding out with @expectro2000x about the scans, I decided to concede about the legitimacy of black hole at least for Yue (and by extension, Ehit) and Miledi, but I don't know if Endou should have them

He also said this
Also, please tell watcher that noting the page number is useless with the scans because they change depending of the formatting or version, like in the first scan he says it comes from page 283 but the pdf version I have for example only has 251 pages (with the scan being from page 207-208)
And this'll by my final message in this thread

Side note: finally found the erasing space part
「Here it is created, the star of disaster that swallow all creation――”KokutenkyuuBlack Sky Destitution”-!!」

The star of disaster was enlarged explosively. It was the secret technique of gravity magic to annihilate everything by swallowing them, the trump card of lord.

「Kyaah!?」

『Impossible-!?』

A scream broke out from Hinata while agitation surged from the elderly nobleman.

It couldn’t be helped. The earth was getting sucked up with violent momentum. The sparking black sphere with diameter of five meter was swallowing them up.

The earth was getting sucked up toward the sky as though gravity didn’t exist. That sight was just like a joke. It was as though heaven and earth had been overturned.

Both Hinata and the elderly nobleman were looking up at that in a daze. They didn’t know what would be the fate of the things that got swallowed into there, but their instinct had guessed it.

That was, anything that had been swallowed by that would only vanish.

Mercilessly, without any discrimination. It would swallow anything and everything a nd brought demise. Chapter 410 WN
So yeah, if you still think it isn't meant to be erasing space, then just put me in disagree on Endou part
 
Last edited:
So after finding out with @expectro2000x about the scans, I decided to concede about the legitimacy of black hole at least for Yue (and by extension, Ehit) and Miledi, but I don't know if Endou should have them

He also said this

And this'll by my final message in this thread
(So it's only valid when Expectro says it)

Didnt know about the format thing, but I'll keep those numbers to help me find those scans when I need them.
Side note: finally found the erasing space part


So yeah, if you still think it isn't meant to be erasing space, then just put me in disagree on Endou part
There is no space erasure statment in that scan.

And why doesn't Kousuke qualify? If he is using the same power and he has statment that compare his BH to Miledi's
「「「「「「「「「「「That is a world of interstice without light. The embrace of demise. The birth of a new providence――」」」」」」」」」」」

And so, that thing propagating into the world, which destroyed even the Holy Precincts――the attack of the protector that brought about the dawn.

The main body of the lord made a beautiful turn that was without any meaning, and then along with a really magnificent pose, he spun the last sentence, and let it resound to the world.

「Be swallowed by the infinitude of darkness and perish――Gravity magic ultimate secret art【Kokutenkyuu(black whirling darkness of abyss)】」(TN: Black Heaven Suffering)

At the center of the surging black sparks, a small black sphere manifested.

The sphere was whirling in disorder, and right after that, it swelled up to a size with a diameter of a meter and began to suck anything and everything in the surroundings with a fierce might. No, perhaps it should be said that rather than sucking, it was already twisting the space altogether while compressing it to the center.

――Gravity magic “Black Heaven Suffering”

It was the gravity magic’s secret art that the liberator Miledy Raisen once used in order to save the world.

Compared to what she used, this magic here was a shoddy one where its immatureness was standing out. But, even so, here in this place, it possessed enough strength to destroy this monster that could possibly regenerate and propagate if there was even just a fragment of its cell remaining――it was truly legendary magic. Ch 219
His technique is still "immature", but don't see how that disqualify it. I also believe that was his first time using it which explain the "immature" part.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top