- 274
- 160
Last edited:
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Fate Ninja verse slime Ninja
- Thread starter Napoleonic01
- Start date
- 274
- 160
- Thread starter
- #3
I don't know my bad.... new at this
- 11,285
- 10,140
can we do sandbox vs sandbox
- 584
- 654
AP-wise, Souei has an edge, but it wouldn’t help him bypass Taira no Kagekiyo’s fate manipulation.
Well, it seems like this would end in a stalemate anyway. I might wait for the supporters to clarify how many people her resistance scales to.
Also I hate when they don't mention the specific types of the ability, nevermind mind the first one is a sandbox.
Well, it seems like this would end in a stalemate anyway. I might wait for the supporters to clarify how many people her resistance scales to.
- 584
- 654
Sanbox ? Loool
- 839
- 384
Should Fate characters even be used in Vs matches in general right now?
XSOULOFCINDERX
They/Them- 26,478
- 12,381
Probably not since that hot mess is still being cleaned up.
- 11,285
- 10,140
I have 2 fate characters that are ready to be published and are up to date if yall want to use it.
- 839
- 384
And those two are?
Arkansalter2
He/Him- 8,185
- 2,639
Sandboxes are not allowed to be used in versus matches.
- 11,285
- 10,140
Altria Pendragon (Honkai: Star Rail)
Saber (セイバー Seibā?) is a playable character in Honkai: Star Rail. Saber is the Saber-class Servant of the Trailblazer summoned during the Penacony Holy Grail War. Her real name is Altria Pendragon, also known as King Arthur. She is the King of Knights who once ruled the kingdom of Britain. Tier...
vsbattles.fandom.com
EMIYA (Honkai: Star Rail)
Archer is a playable character in Honkai: Star Rail. Archer is the Archer-class Servant of Aventurine summoned during the Penacony Holy Grail War. His real name is EMIYA and he is dedicated to protecting his planet as a Heroic Spirit and Counter Guardian. Tier: Low 1-C, higher with Unlimited...
vsbattles.fandom.com
- 274
- 160
- Thread starter
- #14
NiceAltria Pendragon (Honkai: Star Rail)
Saber (セイバー Seibā?) is a playable character in Honkai: Star Rail. Saber is the Saber-class Servant of the Trailblazer summoned during the Penacony Holy Grail War. Her real name is Altria Pendragon, also known as King Arthur. She is the King of Knights who once ruled the kingdom of Britain. Tier...
EMIYA (Honkai: Star Rail)
Archer is a playable character in Honkai: Star Rail. Archer is the Archer-class Servant of Aventurine summoned during the Penacony Holy Grail War. His real name is EMIYA and he is dedicated to protecting his planet as a Heroic Spirit and Counter Guardian. Tier: Low 1-C, higher with Unlimited...
- 11,285
- 10,140
Archer Vs Saitama fr
- 839
- 384
So they would retain their stuff from Fate huh. Also wouldn't they also gain Imaginary Energy since everyone in HSR now has it through being pathstriders? Also I feel the Holy Shroud would be resistance to Conceptual Manipulation
- 11,285
- 10,140
They’re not pathstrides
Weaknesses: Her body wasn't constructed from magical energy for the Penacony Holy Grail War. As a Heroic Spirit from a completely unknown realm, she isn't able to draw power from "fame" or Mystics in the Honkai Star Rail universe and are at a disadvantage against Penacony's Heroic Spirits and Pathstriders who are buffed by the world's power. The Honkai Star Rail universe has almost no magical energy and her master does not use magic to supply her.
- 11,285
- 10,140
Oh yeah btw their hsr counterparts are specifically from post Fate/Stay Night. That’s why they retain their abilities.
- 52,607
- 46,838
No.
These are being deleted BTW for breaking crossover standardsAltria Pendragon (Honkai: Star Rail)
Saber (セイバー Seibā?) is a playable character in Honkai: Star Rail. Saber is the Saber-class Servant of the Trailblazer summoned during the Penacony Holy Grail War. Her real name is Altria Pendragon, also known as King Arthur. She is the King of Knights who once ruled the kingdom of Britain. Tier...
EMIYA (Honkai: Star Rail)
Archer is a playable character in Honkai: Star Rail. Archer is the Archer-class Servant of Aventurine summoned during the Penacony Holy Grail War. His real name is EMIYA and he is dedicated to protecting his planet as a Heroic Spirit and Counter Guardian. Tier: Low 1-C, higher with Unlimited...
- 11,285
- 10,140
What crossover standard was broken
- 52,607
- 46,838
Check profile deletions, I'm just the messenger
Also, if you really want to include things from Fate on that profile, wait until someone reworks Servant Physiology, because that page is hot dogshit.
- 11,285
- 10,140
Fate things are included because nasu stated that the saber and archer that appear in the collab are explicitly the same ones from post fate stay night
- 52,607
- 46,838
And a good 85% of the time, Nasu's WoG sucks ass to the point it's been banned to use it. Fair warning.
Also, again, if we went through Servant Physiology and pointed out everything that was wrong with it, it would make the ancient Honkai profiles that got deleted look accurate. It's bad. Don't use Fate profiles for basically anything if you don't want to get deep into the feces.
- 11,285
- 10,140
Tbf the statement is from the interview about the hsr x fate stay night collab and how it was supervised and created. It’s also called the HSR x Fate stay night collab which supports the statement of nasu saying its explicitly post fate stay night characters being used.
To fix the issue. Do I just remove the servant physiology from the profiles until that page gets fixed
- 52,607
- 46,838
Even his interviews are frequently sus as hell
The problem straight up is that fate profiles are not in working order and won't be for over a year at least, and I'm being generous because Artoria is a character with a profile bigger than a stored up yo mama joke so she will naturally take awhile as everyone goes through most larger fate works.
Ebihara
Any/All- 2,109
- 1,651
I agree on this point. nasu isnt always right about his own stories LOL.
- 11,285
- 10,140
This one would still be applicable since it’s legit just him saying what version was used right. It’s backed up by the collab being called HSR X Fate Stay Night. In the HSR story mode it’s also said that they do not exist in HSR’s history and were straight up summoned from the nasuverse. They also use the same attacks. Saber was summoned, and does all of her attacks. Lancer does a thrown Gae Bolg as well, same for Archer tracing Caladbolg II and using unlimited blade works which is all related to their same servant abilities. I don’t see why this would be any other saber and archer other than the stay night ones like Nasu stated.
Do you have any recommendations for what I should do with the profiles since their scaling is pretty much 100% from HSR.
- 52,607
- 46,838
Sandbox them, honestly.
There is a very, VERY small list of profiles that aren't borderline irreconcilable, and Artoria isn't on that list, so copy/pasting her stuff is literally downgrading the quality of your profile.
- 11,285
- 10,140
What about Archer? Also is it possible to just keep the non cooked controversial abilities or just remove the fate stuff and leave a note saying that they’re the exact same ones from stay night but their stay night profiles are currently washed up so their abilities aren’t currently applicable. They should should still have enough information from HSR to work as a profile probably
- 52,607
- 46,838
same deal. Only Gilgamesh and Qin Shi Huang don't have dogshit profiles, and Gil is debatable.
Honestly, you should gather everything they do in HSR and use that stuff for the PnA, add the note sure, but ban of WoG as it is you might still not be able to use it.
- 11,285
- 10,140
Alright. Also pretty sure WoG is usable for stuff like this since it’s being used to clarify what version of a character is being used for a story and not a battle boarding statement and it’s also backed by 3 other things.
Does this sound fine
“The Saber and Archer that appear in the Honkai Star Rail Fate story mode are explicitly the same ones from post Fate Stay Night stated during an interview between Nasu and Shaoji about the Honkai Star Rail X Fate Stay Night collab. The name of the collab is also centered around Fate Stay Night alongside Saber, Archer, and Lancer all using their servant related abilities. They are also stated in the story mode to not exist in the Honkai Star Rail Universe and were summoned directly from the Nasuverse via the Holy Grail. However, their Stay Night profiles are currently heavily outdated and are heavily unreliable so most of their abilities aren’t applicable until they’re up to date.”
- 11,285
- 10,140
Hey both their hsr profiles should be fine now I think?
- 2,506
- 1,882
So, the matter of sanboxes aside, I see no way Taira can win this. There is a massive AP and Dura gap that I don't think her skill can close and even if it did, there is no way she wins the hax battle with Souei having this for attack
And also AE1 on LM and IM2 and Immortality type 5
- 839
- 384
Don't necro old threads. Also Fate characters outside of the Star Rail versions of Artoria Saber and Emiya Archer shouldn't really be used for Vs matches right now
- 2,506
- 1,882
It's not THAT old, plus just wanted to give it a general conclusion as the thread seems more of a general discussion and not a VS one
- 11,285
- 10,140
We love HSR Saber and Archer
- 839
- 384
Speaking of which I did have a matchup Idea involving Archer that I wanted to do, and maybe see if it'll work
- 839
- 384
- 11,285
- 10,140
- 839
- 384
A fellow member of the Astral Express
Similar threads
- Locked
