- 5,914
- 4,597
I can’t see anything either
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Demon King & Arthur Pendragon`s Creation feats
- Thread starter Igneel
- Start date
- Status
- 6,643
- 3,540
Dead link
- 5,914
- 4,597
- 545
- 108
Nah, it's not a cloud, the negative energy spreading on the ground disappears on the horizon, clouds do the same. It's really blurry, so should we use the manga? Also im not pointing the clouds zoom in on the image
- 5,605
- 1,659
what episode is this btw? feels like i missed that part
- 5,914
- 4,597
Épisode 12 season 2 iirc
- 545
- 108
- 5,914
- 4,597
Ngl it itches me a bit that these threads always turn out being inactive when a consensus is found about them being agreed on.
You are an admin, supposed to moderate and help VSBW fludify the immense flow of unanswered threads.
You admitted your bias but ended up not giving your vote which blocked us for weeks now.
So, do you agree with this thread ?
- 34,549
- 34,979
I'm neutral on the topic currently. It's better for me to give no vote than risk a vote that could be affected by bias. I'd have to devote more time than I can afford to currently to investigate it further.
- 5,914
- 4,597
So let me rewind everything:
-You know that Arthur created the dimension
-You have different stated timeframes
-You know it follows the criteria
-You admitted your own bias and said that you would stop talking about said criteria cause it’s not the place for it.
But you don’t want to vote because you are neutral and don’t have time to write « I agree with […] timeframe »
You don’t need to be investigating everything was sent in this thread and you often buy loads of time to comment on CRTs that you disagree with NNT upgrades so ig you will be able to do the inverse.
- 34,549
- 34,979
Being neutral isn't against the rules, is it? Until I have the time and interest to get involved with revising the verse, voting on the thread isn't warranted yet. I don't "know" that the suggested timeframes are correct yet, or if the size of the realms is accurate.
- 5,914
- 4,597
It’s not, but being neutral out of pure bias is we need your approval and you know it.
Sure, 4kota happens 16 years after NNT it’s impossible to find a lower end than this do you agree with it ?
Here is Arthur’s brother dimension having a starry sky.
Here is Anfwynn dimension having a starry sky.
The author also gently answered my question in the Q&A and stated that some dimensions holds starry skies and others endless night.
You can ask me if you need more informations.
- 34,549
- 34,979
Your question? You mean you sent in a question to Nakaba Suzuki?
Demon_Lord18
He/Him- 2,890
- 1,375
- 5,914
- 4,597
Yeah he answered it in his q&a
- 34,549
- 34,979
Well, that's not admissable. We have strict rules about contacting and sending questions to creators like that.
Demon_Lord18
He/Him- 2,890
- 1,375
The email is sent to the editor, who then selects and forwards it to Nakaba. No rules are being broken. It's worth noting that this was something the author himself requested to be implemented. I'm certain this rule doesn't apply to the NNT Q&A
Bossbrosish
He/Him- 2,945
- 927
Doesn't this still go against the rules since it's still the editor who send it to the author? I don't think it's usable in the slightest.
"In addition, the statements they give to appease users are often contradictory to the feats in the stories of the works they have written. Thus, it is frowned upon to bother them over these topics."
- 545
- 108
There is no contradiction. We already know that there are starry skies in some dimensions, and in one episode, Anna asks again, "Is the starry sky still visible in Camelot?" In response (I can't remember to whom) a sentence like "Yes, the starry sky behind the endless night" is made. Nothing is said in this question-answer that doesn't exist in the series.
Demon_Lord18
He/Him- 2,890
- 1,375
Bossbrosish
He/Him- 2,945
- 927
All I'm saying is that contacting the Editor to get an answer from the creator of NNT and 4KOA shouldn't be used or considered.
Even so, it clearly goes against the rules of contacting creators and authors of Vs Battle Wiki. It doesn't matter if it doesn't contradict anything, the rules are clear.
Bossbrosish
He/Him- 2,945
- 927
Alright, so I found this comment from Aggna in this thread: https://vsbattles.com/threads/rewording-wog-rules.179458/#post-7087906 (I'm on my phone and can't edit links for some reason so I'll just leave the link)
What Agnaa said: "When it's a WoG not asked by a member of our community, it's preferred if it's from an official Q&A, not leading, and has a rather elaborate/serious response. It doesn't need all of these, and this sort of thing should be judged on a case-by-case basis.
Like, I think if someone not from our community asks "Can this character use this ability to heal?" and the author provides a 5 paragraph answer explaining that they can, but also detailing all the limitations that come with that, we should treat that seriously. Even though one could argue that it's leading/powerscaling-related."
Since Makai is a member and was the one who asked the question, I don't think it's usable in the slightest based on what Agnaa said here.
What Agnaa said: "When it's a WoG not asked by a member of our community, it's preferred if it's from an official Q&A, not leading, and has a rather elaborate/serious response. It doesn't need all of these, and this sort of thing should be judged on a case-by-case basis.
Like, I think if someone not from our community asks "Can this character use this ability to heal?" and the author provides a 5 paragraph answer explaining that they can, but also detailing all the limitations that come with that, we should treat that seriously. Even though one could argue that it's leading/powerscaling-related."
Since Makai is a member and was the one who asked the question, I don't think it's usable in the slightest based on what Agnaa said here.
- 545
- 108
No. Battleboarding questions are prohibited here. It is stated that normal questions that do not harass or disturb the author can be asked.
Demon_Lord18
He/Him- 2,890
- 1,375
This is not against the rules.
Asking the author questions through official channels is not against the rules.
Nakaba gives us a detailed explanation of the question, saying that it is possible to see in some places and not in others, he doesn't just say "yes", and we also have visual evidence.
- 5,914
- 4,597
Well, Nakaba posts Q&A corners where fans can ask him random questions it’s not something I asked randomly.
We went formal mode and he responded in the manga
- 5,914
- 4,597
It’s not contradictory since he shows starry skies in Neo Camelot
- 5,914
- 4,597
I didn’t ask the editor, Nakaba makes special corners on his website etc… and tell us to ask some questions that he will randomly answer.
His q&a are perfectly canon and usable
It doesn’t in this case it’s the author that ask us to post questions.
Anyway this goes along the showings of the manga we already know there are some starry skies
- 5,914
- 4,597
Y’all dislike NNT so bad you dodge the evidence and focus on bs that’s crazy.
- 5,914
- 4,597
So, I sent the evidence do you agree with the thread ?
- 34,549
- 34,979
I've done some rereading. At the moment I think it is better to wait for further clarification on Arthur's ability and the nature of Camelot. From what we've been told, whenever Arthur creates something in Camelot he is snatching material from the real-world for it, so it's not just Arthur's raw power being involved in the creation process here. If it is being shown that whole stars are disappearing from the real world, or we get more information about the true size of Camelot, then I'd be more confident on the conclusion but right now it's not clear to me that Arthur is creating or manipulating whole stars or that the dimension of Camelot is that big if it is dependent on taking material from the real world.
- 5,914
- 4,597
He takes parts of britannia in order to recreate memories of the loved ones.
Explain the creation and presence of multiple starry skies inside of Neo Camelot.
We know the size of the realm stop dodging the evidence
Last edited:
- 5,493
- 4,752
- 5,914
- 4,597
So, since every counter argument was refuted is there a consensus ?
- 34,549
- 34,979
At the moment it doesn't seem like any other staff member has commented on the thread, so I recommend contacting some and asking for their evaluations.
- 5,493
- 4,752
Wait what argument was refuted. I know the Q&A stuff was considered Battleboarding but there is Manga evidence of stars being present in the dimensions
- 5,914
- 4,597
The counter argument of Arthur taking things from Britannia was refuted nothing left counters the OP
- 34,549
- 34,979
I don't think that was refuted; nothing about the scan that was posted above changed what I said. Pellegarde just repeats the information that land is being taken from Britannia to fuel what is being created in Camelot.
- 5,914
- 4,597
Neo Camelot is the eternal kingdom, a place where you can find your deceased loved ones due to Arthur using parts of Britannia in order to simulate life with their memories.
He only takes parts of britannia to trigger this memory manip not cause he does not have the power to create it.
Even if we reached an agreement about Thetis statement, it would only concern Britannia and it’s Land not whole entire 4-A structures that he would need to create.
Edit: btw if we follow the statement about things in Camelot being eternal and not withering it shows Chaos Magic is what gives it it’s properties and hold the structure together (we already have statements about Chaos Magic being what makes the ships etc… fly)
- Status
