Lilybitdun
She/Her- 2,416
- 1,420
I don't like the current ap & speed scaling for AoT so I plan on trying to fix it. This is my first CRT, I'm still pretty new to this so sorry if there's any mistakes ahead of time
Currently the Colossal Titan is given City Block AP based off it's transformation. This is completely wrong since the Colossal Titans' transformation explosion is far more powerful than it's physical stats, this is like scaling Armin's Colossal Titan form off his Large Town and Large Town+ transformations. The Colossal Titan should instead be scaled toSmall Town level At least City Block level+ (Stronger than the Attack Titan from pure size and superior to it's durability which tanked a hit from the Armored Titan), higher far higher, possibly Multi-City Block with Teeth (Bit through the Armored Titan's head), far higher via transforming (Far stronger than his physicals), At most Town level via Instant Form Dissipation. Armin's and Eren's Colossal Titans scales to Bertolt's AP with them being comparable to their AP, with Bertolt's scaling to Armin's durabilty.
There is a 1.42x gap to baseline Small Town, I'm iffy on saying there's enough to argue Eren's Hardening or the size of Rod's & Eren's Founding Titan to cross that gap so I won't include that for now.
There's this accepted calc that puts Mikasa's speed at 12.49 m/s, slightly above baseline Superhuman
The blades are also capable of cutting off chunks of the Colossal Titan, shown here,whose durability should be Small Town level who can tank a hit from the Armored Titan which supports 8-B+ rating
ODM blades are made of Ultrahard Steel which is explicitly stated to be the only material capable of slicing through Titan flesh
In Before The Fall (which is accepted as canon here) Survey Corp members used weapons made of iron bamboo, the inferior precursor to ultrahard steel, with is capable of cutting through Ogre's, a 15m Pure Titan, bone
attackontitan.fandom.com
attackontitan.fandom.com
Scaling Chain: Rod Reiss Durability / Colossal Titan's = ODM blade (Can cut both of them) <Armored Titan's Durability (Blades do nothing to him)<Attack Titan Hardening & Thunderspears (Can shatter Armored Titan's Armor)<War Hammer's Crystallization (Impervious to thunder spears)< Jaw Titan's Jaws & Claws
Bertolt's Colossal Titan was shown biting through the armored titan's neck so it's bite would scale above it's regular ap like we do with the Pure Titans
The thunder spears are shown to oneshot Colossal Titans when hitting their nape & can damage their legs.
And blow up teeth of Eren's Colossal Titan.
The War Hammer's and Annie's Crystalization scale above the Thunderspear with the Jaw Titan's Jaws & Claws capable to damaging War Hammer's Crystalization.
Both the Crystalization and the Jaw Titan's Jaws & Claws should upscale high enough above 2.36 kilotons to cross that ~1.44x gap to Small Town level+.
This is the scaling chain values:
Rod Reiss' Titan Durability / ODM Blade AP: City Block+, possibly Multi-City Block
Armored Titan's Armor: At least City Block+, possibly at least Multi-City Block
Attack Titan Hardening AP & Durability / Thunderspears AP: At least City Block+, possibly at least Multi-City Block
War Hammer & Female Titan's Crystallization: At least City Block+, likely higher, possibly at least Multi-City Block
Jaw Titan's Jaws & Claws: At least City Block+, likely higher, possibly at least Multi-City Block
Supporting evidence of 4m titans being Class 1, 15m titans are already scaled to Class M so it doesn't effect much. Bite force being comparable to body weight could upgrade the Eren's Founding Titan's lifting strength if his mass is calculated. The Colossal Titan was capable of launching a 55 ton 15m titan with a casual kick which could upgrade the Colossal Titan's lifting strength if calculated.
I'm not doing any lifting strength revisions currently, this is just to approve this chart for a later CRT
Scaling:
15m Titan: 729x stronger than a human
15m Titans currently scale to 0.096 tons
Humans: 0.096/729=0.00013168724 tons / 550979.41216j / 0.55097941216mJ (Wall)
Attack Titan: 6561x stronger than a human
Attack Titan's AP: 550979.4121600001*6561= 3614975923.18j / 0.8639999816395794 tons (Building)
Here's a more in-detail version to help explain it better
"As we've seen so far, a 15-meter Titan Eren would be 729 times stronger than a human. At nine times a human's height, his fist would also travel nine times the distance during a punch. In that case, power times distance, or the energy in his punch, would be 729*9, or 6,561 times the energy of a human punch!"
His punch is 9x a 15m Titan's AP (Hence them doing 729*9), and its 6561x a human's punch
Attack Titan AP: 0.096*9= 0.864 tons (Building)
Human AP: 0.864/6561= 0.00013168724 tons / 550979.41216j / 0.55097941216mJ (Wall)
"Meanwhile, a Titan body is only 81 times more durable than a human body, so what would happen to a 15-meter class Titan getting punched by Eren's Titan is clear as day. Eren would deal 81 times the damage a human punch would deal to another human! Now that's a strong punch!"
See how it says what would happen to a 15m titan when hit by this punch, not what would happen to the Attack Titan. It's not saying Eren's punch is 81x his AP, it's saying his AP is 81x a 15m Titan's Durability
A 15m titan's body is only 81 times stronger than a human
AP to Durability difference: 729/81= 9x
15m Titan AP: 0.00013168724*729= 0.09599999796 tons = 0.096 tons (Small Building)
15m Titan Durability: 0.096/9= 0.01066666666 tons (Small Building)
Rechecking to prove the math is right
Attack Titan AP: 0.01066666666*81= 0.864 tons (Building)
"Eren's fist would also receive nearly 81 times the damage a human fist takes when punching another human. Even boxers wearing gloves to protect their fists can fracture their bones with their own punches. So a full strength, bare fisted punch from a giant monster at 81 times the power..."
"The reason their heads go flying and their hands are destroyed from a punch is because the energy coming from a full 15 meter Titan's full strength punch is unimaginably powerful."
Attack Titan's AP is 81x it's durability:
Attack Titan's Durability: At least 0.69 tons
Attack Titan's AP: 0.69*81= 55.89 tons (City Block+)
Human AP: 55.89/6561= 0.00851851851 tons (Small Building)
This would make even the smallest of Pure Titans at least Small Building level
15m Titan AP: 0.00851851851*729= 6.20999999379 = 6.21 tons (Large Building)
15m Titan Durability: 6.20999999379/81= 0.07666666659 tons (Small Building)
Most Titans Shifters scale to City Block+ while the weaker ones upscales Large Building
Now considering how high these multipliers are it might be a hard-sell but let me make my case
The current AoT human is scaling to 0.324380mJ with Reiner having a durability feat of 0.4845475mJ. Both of these feats are them just merely being able to land with the ODM gear, it should be fine for their durability scale higher than this.The durability for humans via the 15m Titan multiplier is only ~1.7x higher than the former and ~1.137x higher than the latter.
Even the smallest Pure Titans are stronger than soldiers w/o ODM gear and are capable of tearing people apart and one-shotting them. For example, both Carla's & Eren's punches did nothing to the Smiling Titan. A 15m Titan is far stronger than regular pure titans and the first thing Eren does as the Attack Titan is oneshot them. The Attack Titan AP's is already scaled far above his 0.69 tons durability and this new scaling still puts him below the Colossal Titan. The Nine Titans have shown to be vastly superior to both humans and the strongest of Pure Titans; this is excluding Abnormal Titans like Rod Reiss.
Here's the sandbox with the proposed changes: https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User:Lilybitdun/Sandbox
Changes:
Disagree: Huzy (Disagrees with current calc)
Neutral: Raiden38
Disagree:
Neutral:
Disagree:
Disagree:
Neutral:
Disagree:
Neutral:
Disagree: Raiden38, Shadow_x007x (Disagrees with current premise of scaling the blades to titan durability due to Surface Area), Damage3245 (Disagrees due to Surface Area), Huzy
Neutral: Machmatej, Nierre, FinePoint
Disagree: Huzy
Neutral: Raiden38 (Leaning to Agree)
Disagree: Huzy
Neutral:
Let's all have a civil discussion
Downgrades
- Colossal Titan's Physicals
Currently the Colossal Titan is given City Block AP based off it's transformation. This is completely wrong since the Colossal Titans' transformation explosion is far more powerful than it's physical stats, this is like scaling Armin's Colossal Titan form off his Large Town and Large Town+ transformations. The Colossal Titan should instead be scaled to
- Cart Titans' Speed
- Levi's Speed
Upgrades
- Ackerman Speed
There's this accepted calc that puts Mikasa's speed at 12.49 m/s, slightly above baseline Superhuman
- ODM Blade & Thunder Spear AP
The blades are also capable of cutting off chunks of the Colossal Titan, shown here,
ODM blades are made of Ultrahard Steel which is explicitly stated to be the only material capable of slicing through Titan flesh
In Before The Fall (which is accepted as canon here) Survey Corp members used weapons made of iron bamboo, the inferior precursor to ultrahard steel, with is capable of cutting through Ogre's, a 15m Pure Titan, bone
Iron bamboo
Iron bamboo (黒金竹 Kurogane Take?) is a substance once used to craft military weapons and equipment such as the disposable blades of the vertical maneuvering equipment. During later years, it would be slowly phased out and eventually replaced by ultrahard steel.[1]
Iron bamboo (Before the Fall Manga)
Iron bamboo (黒金竹 Kurogane Take?) is a substance once used to craft military weapons and equipment such as the disposable blades of the vertical maneuvering equipment. During later years, it would be slowly phased out[1] and eventually replaced by ultrahard steel.[citation needed] While the exact...
Scaling Chain: Rod Reiss Durability / Colossal Titan's = ODM blade (Can cut both of them) <Armored Titan's Durability (Blades do nothing to him)<Attack Titan Hardening & Thunderspears (Can shatter Armored Titan's Armor)<War Hammer's Crystallization (Impervious to thunder spears)< Jaw Titan's Jaws & Claws
Bertolt's Colossal Titan was shown biting through the armored titan's neck so it's bite would scale above it's regular ap like we do with the Pure Titans
The thunder spears are shown to oneshot Colossal Titans when hitting their nape & can damage their legs.
And blow up teeth of Eren's Colossal Titan.
The War Hammer's and Annie's Crystalization scale above the Thunderspear with the Jaw Titan's Jaws & Claws capable to damaging War Hammer's Crystalization.
This is the scaling chain values:
Rod Reiss' Titan Durability / ODM Blade AP: City Block+, possibly Multi-City Block
Armored Titan's Armor: At least City Block+, possibly at least Multi-City Block
Attack Titan Hardening AP & Durability / Thunderspears AP: At least City Block+, possibly at least Multi-City Block
War Hammer & Female Titan's Crystallization: At least City Block+, likely higher, possibly at least Multi-City Block
Jaw Titan's Jaws & Claws: At least City Block+, likely higher, possibly at least Multi-City Block
- Pure Titan Lifting Strength
Supporting evidence of 4m titans being Class 1, 15m titans are already scaled to Class M so it doesn't effect much. Bite force being comparable to body weight could upgrade the Eren's Founding Titan's lifting strength if his mass is calculated. The Colossal Titan was capable of launching a 55 ton 15m titan with a casual kick which could upgrade the Colossal Titan's lifting strength if calculated.
I'm not doing any lifting strength revisions currently, this is just to approve this chart for a later CRT
- Human to Titan Multiplier
Scaling:
15m Titans currently scale to 0.096 tons
Humans: 0.096/729=0.00013168724 tons / 550979.41216j / 0.55097941216mJ (Wall)
Attack Titan: 6561x stronger than a human
Attack Titan's AP: 550979.4121600001*6561= 3614975923.18j / 0.8639999816395794 tons (Building)
Here's a more in-detail version to help explain it better
"As we've seen so far, a 15-meter Titan Eren would be 729 times stronger than a human. At nine times a human's height, his fist would also travel nine times the distance during a punch. In that case, power times distance, or the energy in his punch, would be 729*9, or 6,561 times the energy of a human punch!"
His punch is 9x a 15m Titan's AP (Hence them doing 729*9), and its 6561x a human's punch
Attack Titan AP: 0.096*9= 0.864 tons (Building)
Human AP: 0.864/6561= 0.00013168724 tons / 550979.41216j / 0.55097941216mJ (Wall)
"Meanwhile, a Titan body is only 81 times more durable than a human body, so what would happen to a 15-meter class Titan getting punched by Eren's Titan is clear as day. Eren would deal 81 times the damage a human punch would deal to another human! Now that's a strong punch!"
A 15m titan's body is only 81 times stronger than a human
AP to Durability difference: 729/81= 9x
15m Titan AP: 0.00013168724*729= 0.09599999796 tons = 0.096 tons (Small Building)
15m Titan Durability: 0.096/9= 0.01066666666 tons (Small Building)
Rechecking to prove the math is right
Attack Titan AP: 0.01066666666*81= 0.864 tons (Building)
"Eren's fist would also receive nearly 81 times the damage a human fist takes when punching another human. Even boxers wearing gloves to protect their fists can fracture their bones with their own punches. So a full strength, bare fisted punch from a giant monster at 81 times the power..."
"The reason their heads go flying and their hands are destroyed from a punch is because the energy coming from a full 15 meter Titan's full strength punch is unimaginably powerful."
Attack Titan's AP is 81x it's durability:
Attack Titan's Durability: At least 0.69 tons
Attack Titan's AP: 0.69*81= 55.89 tons (City Block+)
Human AP: 55.89/6561= 0.00851851851 tons (Small Building)
This would make even the smallest of Pure Titans at least Small Building level
15m Titan AP: 0.00851851851*729= 6.20999999379 = 6.21 tons (Large Building)
15m Titan Durability: 6.20999999379/81= 0.07666666659 tons (Small Building)
Most Titans Shifters scale to City Block+ while the weaker ones upscales Large Building
Now considering how high these multipliers are it might be a hard-sell but let me make my case
Reliability & Consistency
The Science of Attack on Titan book is already the source used for the ODM speed, the lifting strength to withstand ODM, and the durability to survive impacts while using the ODM; including Reiner.The current AoT human is scaling to 0.324380mJ with Reiner having a durability feat of 0.4845475mJ. Both of these feats are them just merely being able to land with the ODM gear, it should be fine for their durability scale higher than this.
Even the smallest Pure Titans are stronger than soldiers w/o ODM gear and are capable of tearing people apart and one-shotting them. For example, both Carla's & Eren's punches did nothing to the Smiling Titan. A 15m Titan is far stronger than regular pure titans and the first thing Eren does as the Attack Titan is oneshot them. The Attack Titan AP's is already scaled far above his 0.69 tons durability and this new scaling still puts him below the Colossal Titan. The Nine Titans have shown to be vastly superior to both humans and the strongest of Pure Titans; this is excluding Abnormal Titans like Rod Reiss.
Here's the sandbox with the proposed changes: https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User:Lilybitdun/Sandbox
Changes:
- Gave Superhuman to Mikasa, Levi, Kenny, and Our Man
- Added accepted Superhuman speed calc to Mikasa
- Downgraded Levi and Kenny's ap in accordance to this accepted thread that has 3 staff approvals that hasn't been added to the profiles yet.
- Upgraded Our Man's durability to at least Small Building level due to comparability to Mikasa and surviving an explosion that killed several of his companions
- Added durability to Kenny's guns for being able to deflect an ODM blade
Made the durability of Bertolt's and Armin's Titan Forms Building+- Added reaction feat of Pieck reacting to the Past Jaw Titans to her profile
- Added durability rating for Falco's Jaw Titan's Armored Face due to it scaling to Porco's
- Upgraded Karl Fritz and Ymir Fritz creations feats to at least Large Town+ level due to the rating coming from it upscaling from the Colossal Titan's transformation AP.
- Added durability value to 15 meter Titans
- Added new AP justifications for Bertolt's Colossal Titan
- Added guidebook stats to AP justifications to Mikasa and Levi
- Added an injured Levi clashing with a past Jaw Titan to his speed justifications
Colossal Titan's Physicals Upgrade
Agree: Shadow_x007x, Machmatej, Nierre, Godernet, FinePointDisagree: Huzy (Disagrees with current calc)
Neutral: Raiden38
Cart Titan's Speed Downgrade
Agree: Apex_Predator_GX, Eficiente, Raiden38, WeeklyBattles, Shadow_x007x, Machmatej, Nierre, Godernet, Huzy, FinePointDisagree:
Neutral:
Levi's Speed Downgrade
Agree: Apex_Predator_GX, Eficiente, Raiden38, WeeklyBattles, Shadow_x007x, Machmatej, Nierre, Godernet, Huzy, FinePointDisagree:
Disagree:
Neutral:
Ackerman Superhuman Speed Upgrade
Agree: Apex_Predator_GX, Eficiente, WeeklyBattles, Shadow_x007x, Machmatej, Nierre, Godernet, Huzy, FinePointDisagree:
Neutral:
ODM Blade AP Upgrade
Agree: Apex_Predator_GX, Eficiente, GodernetDisagree: Raiden38, Shadow_x007x (Disagrees with current premise of scaling the blades to titan durability due to Surface Area), Damage3245 (Disagrees due to Surface Area), Huzy
Neutral: Machmatej, Nierre, FinePoint
Titan Lifting Strength
Agree: Machmatej, Nierre, Godernet, FinePointDisagree: Huzy
Neutral: Raiden38 (Leaning to Agree)
Human to Titan Multiplier
Agree: Apex_Predator_GX, Eficiente, Raiden38, Shadow_x007x, Machmatej, Nierre, Godernet, FinePointDisagree: Huzy
Neutral:
Let's all have a civil discussion
Last edited: