• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Reinhard Van Astrea - Proposal for increase

Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Based on some of the things I've read on here, I think people have a pretty good understanding of Reinhard's hax abilities. (aka, the ability to wish for literally any ability or resistance with only a handful of restrictions, and tier 5 reality manipulation with Reid), but I believe that, those aside, the understanding of Reinhard's base power is actually fairly misunderstood. Not without reason, since it's hardly explained and has to be inferred from author statements.

The two I'd like to mention in particular are that "Reinhard could destroy the planet fairly easily", and "Even without all his little tricks, he'd still beat any other character in the setting". Unfortunately, I can't link them since they're in Japanese and I couldn't recognize them even if I found them.

This is due to Reinhard's primary ability, which is shown at the beginning of the anime. When Reinhard is physically weaker than his opponent, he can absorb mana in the area to boost all of his physical stats, which makes using magic impossible in that area. When Reinhard then faces an opponent that this new level of strength is insufficient against, he can boost himself again, increasing the area where magic can't be used and making himself stronger. We know that he can do this based on his fight with Sirius, where he 'boosted' himself twice, and against Regulus, where he jumped from the moon to earth after getting sent there. There is no stated or implied limit to this, aside from the assumption that he can only absorb as much mana as there is to absorb.

Mana in the world of Re:Zero is created by a primordial entity called Od Laguna, which creates souls for all living creatures on the planet, and fills the entire planet with mana that can be drawn on by living creatures and spirits to perform magic. The author has stated that Reinhard's capacity to wish for abilities is due to favoritism from Od Laguna, and the author went so far as to say that Od Laguna would recreate Reinhard if he were to somehow die completely. It can be reasonably inferred then, that if Reinhard were to absorb all mana in the world -which is stated to physically be part of Od Laguna-, he could absorb it in its entirety. This validates the claim that he could destroy the planet fairly easily, as well as the fact that we haven't seen him do so, since this would permanently destroy all magic and make it impossible for new creatures to be born with souls in the setting.

It is also worth noting that this mana absorption would likely work on other power systems. Since his absorption makes it impossible for magic in Re:Zero to be used, it stands to reason that he would make it impossible for most other power systems to function as well.

With all of that, I would like to petition that Reinhard have his tier changed to 5-A. The page is locked, so I can't make the edit myself, and when I mentioned it in the talk page I was directed to the forum.
 
Last edited:
Pretty sure he doesn't "boost" himself via mana, his physical strength is at its peak even without that. Heck the author said it himself that Reinhard would stay as strong he is even without his blessings. He uses that mana to perform his sword attacks or just make people faint in general, though i could see how he could use it offensively but as we havent seen it happening its not possible for now. (also the fact that it just seems out of character and unlikely).
 
His mana absorption isn't from a Divine Protection, though; no more than Subaru's magic is a result of a Divine Protection he has (also, note that the author statement you mentioned I quoted directly, if not word-for-word). Reinhard's mana absorption is due to the way his gate was formed, since all six elements rejected him and he can't use magic.

And I don't see how he uses the mana just to perform sword attacks; it's stated multiple times that he absorbs mana from the area "whenever he fights seriously" meaning that him absorbing mana is similar to another character unleashing their true power or undergoing a transformation.
 
His mana absorption isn't from a Divine Protection, though; no more than Subaru's magic is a result of a Divine Protection he has (also, note that the author statement you mentioned I quoted directly, if not word-for-word). Reinhard's mana absorption is due to the way his gate was formed, since all six elements rejected him and he can't use magic.

And I don't see how he uses the mana just to perform sword attacks; it's stated multiple times that he absorbs mana from the area "whenever he fights seriously" meaning that him absorbing mana is similar to another character unleashing their true power or undergoing a transformation.
That sentence is too vague to be considered dont you think?
For eg. It could mean that he is using his sword style of van astrea which would require mana, or perhaps his dragon reid sword which would also require mana
 
On its own sure, but when you look at his feats, such as jumping from the moon down to the earth, its clear that his speed and durability are drastically increased as well*. A vague statement combined with corroborated evidence is a lot better than using a vague statement alone, such as when the statement "Reinhard will always dodge an attack he has seen before" was used as evidence to apply reactive power level to Reinhard.

*Remember, in his 'base form' (without boosts, since Emilia was healing Subaru), he was on the defensive against Elsa, who is so weak compared to him that he couldn't even draw the Dragon Sword, and she was never able to kill Reinhard even once in Pride IF, where Subaru used her and several other fighters of her level with thousands of different strategies to kill Reinhard. If his base physical power is to the point where he can jump from the moon to the earth without difficulty, then he would have struck Elsa much earlier in that fight.
 
On its own sure, but when you look at his feats, such as jumping from the moon down to the earth, its clear that his speed and durability are drastically increased as well*. A vague statement combined with corroborated evidence is a lot better than using a vague statement alone, such as when the statement "Reinhard will always dodge an attack he has seen before" was used as evidence to apply reactive power level to Reinhard.

*Remember, in his 'base form' (without boosts, since Emilia was healing Subaru), he was on the defensive against Elsa, who is so weak compared to him that he couldn't even draw the Dragon Sword, and she was never able to kill Reinhard even once in Pride IF, where Subaru used her and several other fighters of her level with thousands of different strategies to kill Reinhard. If his base physical power is to the point where he can jump from the moon to the earth without difficulty, then he would have struck Elsa much earlier in that fight.
He has, in his base, no diffed a Cecilus who was clapping Julius with a broken sword. I am pretty sure that debunks it since Julius is much stronger than Elsa
 
He has, in his base, no diffed a Cecilus who was clapping Julius with a broken sword. I am pretty sure that debunks it since Julius is much stronger than Elsa
I haven't read Wrath, but where was it stated that he wasn't draining mana from his surroundings during that fight?
 
Back
Top