Question about Luffy’s scale

[ylcknight]

The wiki has Luffy at High 6-A and then higher, higher, and even higher, but his Lifting Strength is Class P? Why not just give him the 5-C AP? Isn’t that pretty much a given considering he was near-death when using the Bajrang Gun? And correct me if I’m wrong, but if Bajrang Gun gives him Class P Lifting Strength, wouldn’t the added density of Armament Haki + the speed at which it falls from the sky easily make that a 5-C attack in destructive capacity alone?

 

[Suigetsuhyugs]

Being higher doesnt mean he goes up to the next tier he could be only 1 joule stronger which is a meaningless number. Lifting strenght and AP are completely different things just because you can lift a iron bar doesnt mean you can destroy it. There is no density of armament haki thats just energy and there is nothing that can calc the weight of an unknown energy. There is a calc for that feat in the wiki its multi continental (6-A), just because it looks like 5-C it doesnt mean it will be.

 

[ylcknight]

Being higher doesnt mean he goes up to the next tier he could be only 1 joule stronger which is a meaningless number. Lifting strenght and AP are completely different things just because you can lift an iron bar doesnt mean you can destroy it. There is no density of armament haki thats just energy and there is nothing that can calc the weight of an unknown energy. There is a calc for that feat in the wiki its multi continental (6-A), just because it looks like 5-C it doesnt mean it will be.

The wiki for Luffy says that there’s a buff of at least 4x due to the Haki density effect. Your iron bar comparison doesn’t work bc it’s not just him lifting something with Class P strength, the object in question is his own fist, he should scale to his own arm. Luffy’s AP should scale to small moon or small asteroid.

 

[Suigetsuhyugs]

The wiki for Luffy says that there’s a buff of at least 4x due to the Haki density effect. Your iron bar comparison doesn’t work bc it’s not just him lifting something with Class P strength, the object in question is his own fist, he should scale to his own arm. Luffy’s AP should scale to small moon or small asteroid.

Its not the haki's density it's the skin density amped by haki which is a gear 4th thing not gear 5. No, being his fist makes no difference, he scales to lifting it and thats it, the AP is something different, just because class P is the same level as small asteroids and moon it doesnt mean he will get tier 5 an asteroid can easily be inferior to a continent heck some asteroids are just a few meters radius. If you see the actual calc the weight of his fist is used to calc the KE and is Multi continental.

 

[Damage3245]

This isn't how AP scaling works, yeah.

 

[Kachon123]

FRA