My Hero Academia Contradictions

[Therefir]

There are several contradiction regarding the tiers and speed of the verse, for example Stai being only subsonic+, but able to kill several pro heroes, or Kai Chisaki being 8-A, but can be defeated in a single attack by Deku 20%, not only that but Deku withstood his attacks, also the pro heroes should scale from Rappa, who can attacks as fast as bullets.

Talking about the attack potency, the main problem of the tiers is Todoroki, why Todoroki's fire is considered 8-A?, sure he can vaporize his ice wall who cover multiple city blocks, but he can't do it instantly, is like a person who can destroy an entire city but with multiple city block level attacks and over the time, and his ice just cover multiple city blocks, not destroy it, so no one should be scale from him, mostly because his fire isn't 8-A.

 

[Mania568]

well, stain isnt the fastest, he has great reactions and only needs to draw a cut to win the fight, so thats probably why he isnt higher as even lida and deku at a point outsped him, if stain was pro hero speed he would dispach all 3 in a few seconds, his reactions are impressive for his speed though, powers overall dont scale to AP and defense, one can be 8-A in damage and still be taken down from much smaller AP characters this doesnt scale like bleach or dragon ball as AP is always same as durability (i didnt check profiles to reply, for all i know they have same AP and durability on most profiles).

todoroki can defeat 8-A durability opponents, it scales (im assuming) and isnt his fire VERY weak compared to his ice since he never trained it (never saw the manga part, might be missing information here) i dont think his profile would say he is 8-A with fire alone but with both powers.

I do believe some better/proper scaling for MHA are needed, let me know if i got something wrong here.

 

[AidenBrooks999]

Todoroki is 8-A comes from a ACCEPTED calc. And his rating is when using all his power, regardless either ice or fire. Yes, he took sometime to vaporize it, but what? He was supposed to burn Sero in the process too? Of course he took his time.

Chisaki is 8-A for his fight with Deku at 100%. Deku said to be able to defeat him with 20%, but clearly that wasn't the case when Chisaki survived blows from 100% Deku (And in one of them he could regenerate, yet he was "fine")

Only some pro heroes can scale from Rappa, since, well, he blitzed Fatgum, a pro hero.

 

[AidenBrooks999]

What do you want from that feat?

Calculate Pixie-Bob's quirk?

(Tbh, hardly doubt would get anything above 8-C)

 

[Reppuzan]

^This.

There isn't a lot more for me to add.

 

[Therefir]

-Todoroki is 8-A comes from a ACCEPTED calc. And his rating is when using all his power, regardless either ice or fire. Yes, he took sometime to vaporize it, but what? He was supposed to burn Sero in the process too? Of course he took his time.-

If he took his time, how is that 8-A then?

-Chisaki is 8-A for his fight with Deku at 100%. Deku said to be able to defeat him with 20%, but clearly that wasn't the case when Chisaki survived blows from 100% Deku (And in one of them he could regenerate, yet he was "fine")-

...? Of course Chisaki would be able to survive that blows, I was talking about before he fused with Rikiya.

-Only some pro heroes can scale from Rappa, since, well, he blitzed Fatgum, a pro hero.-

I would not be so sure, in the end it was Fatgum who blitz them with a powerful blow.

 

[Therefir]

*snip*

If he is slow, how in his stats he have a S in speed?

 

[Mania568]

if he is that fast how did a lida and 5% deku able to take him by suprise, unless you are saying one of these 2 sources are wrong. the kids arent pro level speeds yet even lida and deku shouldnt be (atleast animewise as i didnt know about that picture or manga).

 

[Reppuzan]

@Mania

Iida explicitly has a Speed Quirk and Deku has One for All. In addition, Stain wasn't paying attention to them.

Besides, when Stain got fully serious, he nearly blitzed Deku.

 

[AidenBrooks999]

1) If he took his time, how is that 8-A then?

2)...? Of course Chisaki would be able to survive that blows, I was talking about before he fused with Rikiya.

3) I would not be so sure, in the end it was Fatgum who blitz them with a powerful blow.

1) Because the calc is from his instantenous Ice Wall

2) Then maybe he needs differents keys? The problem is that there wasn't direct statement of chisaki getting stronger with the fusion, but we can use that

3) He didn't blitz them, Rappa simply statyed there and took it, he even had time to discuss with his partner about the barrier being useless

 

[AidenBrooks999]

If he is slow, how in his stats he have a S in speed?

deku has E in all his physical stats, even though other characters had their stats counted with quirks

 

[Therefir]

Yeah that's weird, maybe are his stats before he gets one for all.

 

[Therefir]

Anyway Stain can kill several pro heroes and Gran Torino stated that Stain wasn't fighting serious against Deku, so I think his speed should be transonic.

 

[RageComment]

I think it should be transonic as well.