GEOM's "erase you on every level of existence"

[SITHISIT]

so whenever I find a fight with him the same argument is

"well the thing is GEOM wiped horus (or whoever it is i follow TES lore not warhammer) on a level that the 13+ dimensional Chaos Gods couldnt bring him back so he should win"

and this is argued with his 3-D form

Either this is a new level of wank I have never seen before or it's missed NLF/PIS. Because a 3-D CANNOT. and please do realize my wording, CANNOT. erase someone on a 13+ dimensional plane without being 13+ dimensional themselves or having higher dimensional manipulation. GEOM without Higher Dimensional Manipulation as 3D being cannot destroy someone on a plane of existence 14 infinities above his plane.

and his 3D ability key does not have

So one of four things

1. this entire moment is said to just be existence erasure and the canvas of existence thing is PIS.

2. GEOM gets HDM

3. and this i highly disagree, we remove his 3D key

4. or i get disagreed on by the entire wiki because random reasons and we allow this to still continue despite lack of higher dimensional manipulation

 

[WeeklyBattles]

His 3-D form erasing Horus to the point where the Chaos Gods couldnt bring him back is 100% legit, ask Azzy about it

 

[Monarch_Laciel]

It's an attack that can kill on higher dimensions. Sure, add it as Higher Dimensional Manipulation. Not that dimensions really even matter in the Warp. Fiction is fiction and can do what it wants.

 

[PaChi2]

voting for 2.

 

[SITHISIT]

"fiction is fiction and it does what it wants lol"

thats a

t

e

r

r

i

b

l

e

argument.


replying to weekly

the point still stands, GEOM cannot erase horus on a 13D plane without Higher Dimensional manipulation which he has not had in his 3D key despite azzy knowing about this feat for months perhaps longer.

and its not like this makes it any better than standard existence erasure, a 3D fighting a 3D does not involve 13D planes and im failing to see how this is any better than just standard existence erasure just with some dimensiontality mixed in.

 

[Monarch_Laciel]

I didn't say "lol" therefore your argument is invalid. Lol

Then add higher dimensional manipulation. It doesn't change anything apart from now having an actual name for the abiltity on the profile

 

[WeeklyBattles]

Then add higher dimensional manipulation

 

[Azathoth_the_Abyssal_Idiot]

I don't really understand the argument, here. Physical GEoM, along with all Psykers, channel the power of the Warp. The Warp is a higher metaphysical plane of existence compared to normal reality. GEoM didn't throat punch Horus or whatever. He completely obliterated his Warp presence on such a scale that the Chaos Gods could not bring him back. Considering 3-D GEoM is basically just a shell for his will (confirmed in Dark Imperium, which is one of Black Library's most recent novels), there isn't really any inconsistency, here.

Just add Higher-Dimensional Manipulation.