• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Search results for query: *

  1. Moritzva

    Versus Thread Removal Requests (New forum)

    You can paint it as you'd like, Deagon, you said it to me in front of several people. You, yourself, said that you thought bad reasoning wasn't a good enough reason and that profile changes was the primary reason for the thread. This is not correct, and was explained to you. If you want to get...
  2. Moritzva

    Versus Thread Removal Requests (New forum)

    I am not saying Deagon is incompetent. I am saying his opinion (which he has not disputed) is incorrect, which it is. For that reason, his vote holds very little weight. If you want to read the thread and either agree or disagree with me, I have no issue with that. If you think the thread...
  3. Moritzva

    Versus Thread Removal Requests (New forum)

    Potentially. But I have nothing else to say. DMUA put it well: this thread is not about counting votes. A shit argument with a lot of votes is still a shit argument. I have paraphrased your stated opinions on our standards here, taken from discord, and you have not addressed them nor disagreed...
  4. Moritzva

    Versus Thread Removal Requests (New forum)

    You could always simply not comment on it. I don't plan on contributing to the thread's redo because I genuinely do not care about the matchup in any capacity. I am only being a stick in the mud over a flagrant misunderstanding of our rules. If anyone tries to drag me onto the thread itself to...
  5. Moritzva

    Versus Thread Removal Requests (New forum)

    Exactly this. Deagon, you are literally just wrong. I cannot put it in any better words. Please do not comment on threads without actually knowing the standards by which they run. I expect better from a discussion mod.
  6. Moritzva

    Versus Thread Removal Requests (New forum)

    If your reasoning is based on fundamentally not knowing how this thread works—a fact you are not even debating—then it will be overriden.
  7. Moritzva

    Versus Thread Removal Requests (New forum)

    It was not that post specifically, but him telling me that poor, badly explained, unsubstantiated/proofless arguments are not a reason to remove a thread, and implying it should only be done because of profile revisions, is a clear-cut misunderstanding of the thread. My original comment may not...
  8. Moritzva

    Versus Thread Removal Requests (New forum)

    If you fundamentally insist that this thread is something that it isn't, then yes, I will override you. You, yourself, told me that arguments being poor, badly explained, or unsubstantiated by evidence are not reasons to remove a thread. You are wrong. I am not going to debate this with you...
  9. Moritzva

    Versus Thread Removal Requests (New forum)

    Deagon, you went on record to tell me that you did not believe that match being inaccurate or poorly argued was grounds for it to be removed. You quite literally do not know what this thread is for. It has been explained and argued to you. SAO supporters have even said as much on Discord. I'll...
  10. Moritzva

    Rule Violation Reports (New forum)

    I get that a like isn't always agreement, I was just busy that day and didn't feel like making a superfluous comment. Glad I could clarify now.
  11. Moritzva

    Rule Violation Reports (New forum)

    Eugh. First off, I know about both SAO and RWBY, and I have no particular like for each of them. I have not been involved in either of the verses much at all, and I was not on the original thread. I am as close to a knowledgeable, but unbiased party as you can get. I agree with Weekly and I...
  12. Moritzva

    That being said, how this should be indexed on wikis is another matter...and I don't happen to...

    That being said, how this should be indexed on wikis is another matter...and I don't happen to follow any communities with this issue so it's not my problem. I don't disagree with the thread existing, I just also recognize that this wiki has the collective maturity of a middle school lunch room...
    • Moritzva
    • Profile post comment
  13. Moritzva

    Is it ridiculous? If we take the premise that Kubo is obviously portraying a character in a...

    Is it ridiculous? If we take the premise that Kubo is obviously portraying a character in a transphobic light, then surely them saying "No, they are not a woman" can easily be interpreted as more transphobic rhetoric. It is all a part of the same package; as someone who has been deep inside a...
    • Moritzva
    • Profile post comment
  14. Moritzva

    If that was what you meant to say, then that's fine enough, though I will point out that your...

    If that was what you meant to say, then that's fine enough, though I will point out that your post did not make a distinction between the two points. Furthermore, the Yamato situation is very different—and this is, once again, coming from a person who disagrees with Fandom and argued against...
    • Moritzva
    • Profile post comment
  15. Moritzva

    You're not exactly defeating my point about you lacking maturity and tact by immediately...

    You're not exactly defeating my point about you lacking maturity and tact by immediately strawmanning my argument and then saying "Do u not have any shame?" I'm not going to be responding to you further. This is a message for KingTempest, because I have respect for him as a person and I owe it...
    • Moritzva
    • Profile post comment
  16. Moritzva

    For the record, don't take this as me having any ill will or anger towards you. I don't imagine...

    For the record, don't take this as me having any ill will or anger towards you. I don't imagine any of the such and I am not accusing you of anything, though I stand by my original point that your post was naïve.
    • Moritzva
    • Profile post comment
  17. Moritzva

    I'll summarize this quickly for you; I didn't want to continue this discussion on the thread...

    I'll summarize this quickly for you; I didn't want to continue this discussion on the thread itself. See, I do agree that it is entirely possible Giselle is just a very ****** up guy. That is an interpretation that one could make from a position of innocence, yes. However, look at the...
  18. Moritzva

    Giselle is NOT transgender or female (Redux)

    Oh, and if anyone tries to whine and say that this thread was closed because of The Lib Agenda ™️ 1. I don't care about Bleach. I also disagree with Fandom on the Yamato situation and I think that is pretty dumb. 2. What I do care about is when a highly sensitive topic is debated with the...
  19. Moritzva

    Giselle is NOT transgender or female (Redux)

    This is a bad argument. Authors absolutely can write stereotypes or harmful characterizations into their stories. Acting like they can't is just naive, flanderizing groups you dislike in your work has been a thing since essentially the dawn of time. Sure, proving it can be difficult, I'll agree...
  20. Moritzva

    Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

    Denied. It is sort of incredible how next to nobody has even attempted to read the standards, given next to nobody have actually done what the standards ask for at all.
  21. Moritzva

    🌟VSBW Discord Nitro Giveaway 🌟

    gib nitro
  22. Moritzva

    Magic the Gathering: It's 1-A Time

    I'll return to this soon.
  23. Moritzva

    Rule Violation Reports (New forum)

    I fully agree with this, for the record. Weekly’s behavior on the Milly thread is entirely deserving of criticism and scrutiny. That’s about all I have to say on this subject, though. Let‘s try to come to any last conclusions we need to reach, and leave it at that, so we can go on with our...
  24. Moritzva

    Rule Violation Reports (New forum)

    I’ll note that I only said we should consider punishments for future cases, not here. While I definitely think Glass should have exercised better judgement, and I don’t think his actions can be entirely attributed to ignorance, I’d rather we all leave this entire report as a learning experience...
  25. Moritzva

    Rule Violation Reports (New forum)

    I want to make a quick comment on the Weekly situation. To be blunt, a lot of the discord screenshots were taken out of context. Agnaa already analyzed and said this, yes, but this is a problem to me. I do not like the idea that users can go and intentionally take out-of-context, badly framed...
  26. Moritzva

    Smurf hax: Either defining or killing it

    Hence why I suggested another thread, though if we are willing to stop juggling debates on re-defining things and also deleting said thing at the same time, a single large writeup could let us progress from here.
  27. Moritzva

    Smurf hax: Either defining or killing it

    I don't think there's an issue with clearly defining it overall, I'd just like to know whose proposal, exactly, I'd be agreeing to. This is Bob's thread, but Bob's OP doesn't exactly propose much definitively and my stance on his later comments are known. It's late and I don't really want to...
  28. Moritzva

    Smurf hax: Either defining or killing it

    What Bob is suggesting in his more recent posts is not the same as his OP, nor is it the same as what you are suggesting, and has significantly more reach than just affecting smurfs. What you say about his original post being "accurate" is only accurate to the point it is presenting. If we're...
  29. Moritzva

    Smurf hax: Either defining or killing it

    Yeah, no, I get what you mean. If an ability can and is shown in a way such as the theoretical 1-A temperature example, then sure, but I feel like that's a pretty case-by-case scenario that can be argued. Same with the range/targeting issue. The issue I have with this thread is that it insists...
  30. Moritzva

    Smurf hax: Either defining or killing it

    To be fair if a 1-A realm is still operating on common, three-dimension, calculable levels of temperature, that's an entirely different problem lol. It's kind of hard to say "what if someone could raise the temperature of a higher realm" or similar levels since it largely depends on how the...
  31. Moritzva

    Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

    Yes, the team approves your pages.
  32. Moritzva

    Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

    Going back to fact-check what you said, you're definitely telling the truth and we made a judgement too hastily. It is true that we have a no-tolerance policy on this sort of thing, and in most scenarios, we wouldn't allow this sort of thing, as it is extremely suspicious. However, you have made...
  33. Moritzva

    Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

    That's just disguising Low 1-C pages as 2-A with extra steps. It's only Low 1-C, so as said, we'd be willing to hear you out and give it a second chance. This thing aside, things look alright enough. However, we have a no-tolerance policy against this exact behavior for exactly the reasons you...
  34. Moritzva

    Tier 1 & 0 Review Thread

    So, are any characters Low 1-C, or is it just the cosmology?
  35. Moritzva

    Smurf hax: Either defining or killing it

    We have a definition that does describe it. The definition describes it, everyone knows what it is describing. You are the only person I know who has ever seen it any other way, and given you insist on your interpretation despite the entire site and the definition itself disagreeing with you, I...
  36. Moritzva

    Smurf hax: Either defining or killing it

    The current definition is also how it is used. Not possible, as it isn’t even entirely clear what is being voted on.
  37. Moritzva

    Smurf hax: Either defining or killing it

    This has become apparent, though "smurf hax" is little more than higher-dimensional hax on a lower-dimensional character. To be more succinct, this thread is "there is no such thing as higher-dimensional hax, and it's all just range and ap." Which is just, not what Bob's original post was...
  38. Moritzva

    Smurf hax: Either defining or killing it

    No it does not, you quite literally confirmed everything I said. Just because you're making an absolutely absurd point doesn't mean it is a fallacy to point out that it is absurd. Screw off with the "please actually tackle my points, thank you!" shit, Bob, I'm not going to tolerate that. First...
  39. Moritzva

    Smurf hax: Either defining or killing it

    In fact this is such a ridiculous thread to me that I have to comment again to further express my disbelief. A smurf is a lower dimensional character with higher dimensional hax (paraphrased). Bob's suggesting that it isn't treated as any stronger than lower-dimensional hax anymore, to which I...
  40. Moritzva

    Smurf hax: Either defining or killing it

    This is a really stupid conclusion. I really don't know how else to stay it. Removing all smurf hax, just, as a concept, is a pretty ridiculous idea and a big overreaction to some people labeling smurf hax wrongly or using the term a bit too freely. If you are a character who has hax effective...
Back
Top