VS Battles Wiki Forum

Sorry I just saw your post. Are you about to ask if the Persona 3 fanbook is actually canon?

Because I've been trying to question the validity of that fanbook and which particular "Atlus staff" who wrote that.

Yeah, I wanted to know where you put Nyx in comparison to Philemon and Nyar.

Most versus sites such as the OBD and Spacebattles puts her below Philemon and Nyarlathotep. If the fanbook is canon then it's just a huge Unknown, she might be above or below them but we don't have enough info unless the future games makes a reference. If it's not canon then she is going to be below them. OBD and Spacebattles posters seems to reject that fanbook due to contradictions with the established lore in Persona 1 and 2 and the most important part is the identity of the writter of the fanbook is still unknown. If it's not Yuichiro Tanaka, Katsura Hoshino, or Satomi Tadashi I don't think that fanbook would have much credibility behind it.

So far, we have Nyx below them. I thought they were all equal, but most of the revision team agrees Phil and Nyar >

Thanks for the info. Yaldabaoth might even be above Nyx depending if this community will accept the Persona 3 fanbook as canon or not.

Yeah, Yaldabaoth > Nyx has been talked about. But we do count the Club Book as canon. And apparently there's a Part 3 of the Club Book that isn't translated about the Velvet Room and Personas.

I'm going to wait for that to be translated just to check in case it makes any contradictions in the Persona 1 and 2 lore.

Part 3 likely won't be coming for a long time, since the original translator was last seen like 3 years ago. But a friend is gonna buy it and try to have it translated.

Again, thank you for that wonderful info.

Don’t need it.

What?