• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Recent content by Soupywolf5

  1. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    Alright, cool. Are the different novels all connected to each other or are they each their own separate thing?
  2. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    I'm not sure how Calv saying the novels aren't official and only a possibility translates to "we can use them for this separate version of the character." You'd need to prove that different versions of the character share all of the same abilities, we don't just assume that by default. I'm not...
  3. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    I read it, I'm just not sure I agree with the interpretation of her answer to the warping question being "he can't warp reality, he can just teleport," (idk, they've mentioned they use a translator for English questions, maybe this is just google translate doing them horrendous) and don't think...
  4. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    Is it really? If she's responding (And knows so) to a question on if Sans can warp reality, then what's the point of bringing up his shortcuts, my point was that her answer is giving a way of crossing distances quickly, right after saying "Sans can't warp," I don't think interpreting her as...
  5. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    First, insane whataboutism, bringing up other verses doesn't mean anything, second what are you actually trying to argue here anymore? The last few posts you've just been trying to use the novels despite admitting in your original post that they shouldn't be used (And looking through the...
  6. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    I’m a little confused, are you agreeing that Dust Sans shouldn’t have Teleportation? I was originally saying that it seems like Calv kind of just ignored the original question, given their answer doesn’t sound like it pertains to reality warping in any way
  7. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    We’re not basing the profile on what Calv might have been thinking when answering, we’re basing it off what the answers actually are You still haven’t provided an actual reason for that exact distance as opposed to any other arbitrary value, attacking him while he’s off-guard or distracted...
  8. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    I mean; I guess? The answer does seem like it's very much their own opinion on his fighting That doesn't really support the interpretation that he's a good fighter though That's in relation to him being a tactician, it doesn't say much on how well he can handle himself when he actually gets...
  9. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    Your blog is arguing that the novels should be treated as separate, anything that exists in the novels should have no bearing on the profile based solely on ask-dusttale Immediately your assumption of 10-20 meters is entirely unfounded, we have no reason to believe he'd attack from that...
  10. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    Well then that’s too bad ig (Is there really nothing else?) Given their answer is “he can't warp, he knows shortcuts” I think they interpreted the “warp” in this question as teleporting (They mention in another post that their English isn’t great) plus I couldn’t find any posts where she...
  11. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    Also on the subject of teleportation & the BIQ stuff. I've been looking through ask-dusttale tumblr (BTW the scan for gravity manipulation looks like a Twitter post, which Calv has said to ignore since they're not official) and Calv has outright said that Sans can't warp (In response to another...
  12. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    If the novels are going to be separate from the Ask-dusttale profile, then they don't matter ok, but you need to actually prove your interpretation here, Subsonic would require a very specific interpretation of the original answer that just isn't very solid The original question says "what if...
  13. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    We can't use this response at all since it was responding to a leading question, which we don't allow, furthermore there isn't even a definitive answer here that a tier could be derived from, Calv saying Sans isn't interested in breaking buildings doesn't in and of itself indicate he's actually...
  14. Soupywolf5

    Dust Sans a remastered

    While I think I'm harsher on fanon-canon scaling than most (My opinion on when it should/can be used is "basically never") the profile's only reasoning for such is just "he should be comparable," so I agree with axing any stats that come from scaling to canon Sans. (And, while it wasn't proposed...
  15. Soupywolf5

    My Hero Academia General Discussion Thread #18

    This would fall under the “hiding calculation” section on the calc stacking page: “Hiding calculations is the practice of trying to avoid calculating a feat in order to be able to use the result in another calculation. In other words it is the practice of trying to fool people into not noticing...
See more
Back
Top